7 ms·
I'm not sure we should be celebrating what's basically an intimidation campaign to shutdown free speech. What they did was trespassing and theft in the service
by empath75 10y ago
I'm not sure we should be celebrating what's basically an intimidation campaign to shutdown free speech. What they did was trespassing and theft in the service of shutting down political speech they disagreed with. It's pretty disgusting.
- RoboPlumber 10y agoWhile this was certainly illegal, I think it's hard to say that it was malicious. This has essentially become a (somewhat one-sided) prank war. If they intended to deplatform or suppress Shia, they could have done something much more mean-spirited than photobomb his video streams and snatch his flag.
- threeseed 10y agoIt's the very definition of malicious. You can't just doxx, trespass and then steal from someone.
- empath75 10y agoIt's funny how anti-doxxing the chan people are when it's directed at them, but they cheerfully do it against their enemies. And let's not forget that along with relatively minor stuff like this, they'll be getting death threats and swatting attempts for the foreseeable future.
- ctrl-j 10y ago> This has essentially become a (somewhat one-sided) prank war. Isn't there another term for a one-sided prank war? I think it's called harassment or something? Combined with theft and vandalism... I can see why they prefer to be anonymous. It's hard to meme from jail.
- RoboPlumber 10y agoI bet you were fun in college. Good-spirited pranks don't warrant jail time.
- bitwize 10y agoYeah, yeah. Tell it to the judge.
- R_haterade 10y agoThis irreverent spirit is exactly why trump won. Compare his campaign messaging with some of the messaging out of the clinton machine and you will see how deep it goes. Consider Trump's 1) Make America Great Again (subtext: we've been letting the establishment make america not-great) 2) Build a wall (subtext: I'm going to do something audacious and unpopular and there's not a damn thing they can do to stop me) Clinton came back with several messages beyond the core "I'm with her" and none of them stuck, because they were the sort of thing you'd hear the teacher's pet say. Nobody likes a teacher's pet--they're no fun at parties.
- ctrl-j 10y ago> Good-spirited pranks don't warrant jail time. Who determines what is "good-spirited"? I've been a part of many prank wars. You know when they stopped being fun and ended up getting people in trouble? When one side stopped enjoying it. I don't think the receiving team in this case is enjoying the prank. Which just makes it mean-spirited and low class. Anon is just being a bag of dicks in this case, which means they either stop, or should get in legal trouble.
- glenstein 10y agoWhen deciding whether or not something is malicious, I don't think "they could have done something even worse" is the standard you judge it by. I think you're definitely right that they could have done worse but I'd argue it's already pretty malicious as it is.
- clubm8 10y agoI wonder if it's legal in that location to shoot someone committing theft under cover of darkness...
- caseysoftware 10y agoTennessee appears to have the concept of "Castle Doctrine" which says that "your home is your castle" and gives you a lot of latitude in what you can do to protect yourself and others but it doesn't extend to property. More the specific requirement is usually the belief that you (or they) are in immediate physical danger. Attacking someone for stealing a flag from your property will probably land you in jail or worse. Ref: http://nashvilleattorneynow.com/criminal-defense/nashville-criminal-lawyers-explain-self-defense-in-tennessee-when-can-i-use-deadly-force-for-protection/ http://nashvilleattorneynow.com/criminal-defense/nashville-c...
- Neliquat 10y agoFormer Tn resident: yiu can shoot them if 1. They are in your house 2. They are threating your life, 3. You can ask them to get off your lawn 3 times then start blasting. I recall a deaf kid got shot for not getting off a lawn once and the guy was found not guilty.
- Vexs 10y agoThat's a bit much. People who go and yell shit in front of a camera, yeah, that's nothing to celebrate. However, random individuals coming together, learning new things, and working towards a common goal that harms pretty much nobody at all except the ego of an actor is something that should be celebrated. Plus, the techniques used are kind of neat. Think to yourself, if this was a nazi flag, would you feel the same way? Furthermore, it's a bit ironic that you bring up an attempt to shut down free speech, when that's exactly what shia did when people started supporting trump on his opposition feed. Freedom of speech is freedom of speech from the government, not individuals, so he's perfectly in his right to do that, but still. And yes, stealing the flag is theft. I can't support or argue for that, but again, would you feel the same if it was a nazi flag? I don't support trump, but calling this endeavor disgusting is disheartening.
- JamilD 10y agoYou can choose to regulate speech on your own property or site (just like HN does). You cannot vandalize someone else's property and infringe on their rights because you don't like what they say. There's no equivalence between the two.
- tscs37 10y agoI don't think this stems from not liking what they had to say, rather doing it just because it's something that can be done.
- derrickdirge 10y agoThat's giving them the benefit of the doubt, to say the least.
- smhost 10y agoIt's the insanity defense for lacking human decency. Pretty hilarious, in a morbid kind of way.
- 10y ago
- hoorayimhelping 10y ago>I'm not sure we should be celebrating what's basically an intimidation campaign to shutdown free speech An actor set up a camera and told people to chant a mantra into it. When people started saying political things he didn't like, he flipped his shit, got pushy and ended up getting arrested. When people started saying racist things (which is protected by the constitution) that he didn't like, he moved locations. That sounds a lot like trying to shutdown free speech.
- carbocation 10y ago>When people started saying racist things (which is protected by the constitution) that he didn't like, he moved locations. That sounds a lot like trying to shutdown free speech. The Constitution doesn't compel private persons to provide a platform for speech they disagree with.
- accountface 10y agoIt's amazing how many people attempt to take the term "free speech" literally and avoid reading the few sentences in the actual amendment that provide context. Free speech is absolutely not the ability to say anything to anyone at any time.
- x1798DE 10y agoFreedom of speech is a general principle and most consider it a bedrock principle of western / modern society. The US constitution provides that it won't be abridged by the government because the constitution is a document that is binding on the government of the United States. Just because it is legal to abridge someone's free speech does not necessarily make it a good idea - people are usually quite wary of platforms who place content-dependent restrictions on the type of speech that is allowed (with some notable exceptions for particularly unpopular opinions). Note that I am not really taking a side on whether the actual theft of the flag was admirable or not here, I just want to make clear that just because it's constitutional for private individuals to do most anything (given that the constitution places almost no restrictions on individuals), that does not mean that the broader concept of freedom of speech only applies to governments.
- zokier 10y ago> What they did was trespassing and theft in the service of shutting down political speech they disagreed with The most fun thing about this is that the whole thing could very possibly not be really politically motivated. Speculating, they would have not been disagreeing with the (message of the) speech but instead just stirring some shit up for "fun". These are not people who support Trump because they think he is a good leader. Instead they enjoy the drama and chaos he creates. Saying that "some people just want to see the world burn" might be bit extreme, but that is essentially the mentality there. Of course that might be also completely bullshit and this was done by actual pro-Trump people. I haven't frequented 4chan lately (thank god), so I don't know what the scene there is these days.
- taneq 10y agoLikewise, I haven't been to that hive of scum and villainy for a while, but as I understand them, this kind of thing is literally for the lulz.
- jccalhoun 10y agoThis is on Heat Street which is kind of like Brietbart-light so it shouldn't be surprising that it takes this spin on things. https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Heat_Street https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Heat_Street
- aaron695 10y agoShia LaBeouf is an performance artist. To call this political speech is pushing it. 4Chans actions is a form of art. And I think there's a form of implied consent going on here. Shia was interacting with the world and it interacted with him. In many ways this is what I see as his aim.