8 ms·
Electricity consumption of Bitcoin: a market-based and technical analysis
- nhaehnle 10y agoIn other words, the Bitcoin network consumes about 5-6 orders of magnitude more electricity than would be required to maintain a similarly-sized ledger using more traditional database techniques. Yes, the feature set is a bit different, but it's difficult to see how Bitcoin can remain competitive in the long run. I guess it can help push down overheads elsewhere in the financial system, so at least that's a good thing. And it's always been a good educational experience.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- mrb 10y ago"it's difficult to see how Bitcoin can remain competitive" Quite the contrary, the fact Bitcoin has been successful & growing for 8 years in spite of using so much energy is proof it is a non-problem. Energy per tx is rapidly decreasing (http://blog.zorinaq.com/bitcoin-mining-is-not-wasteful/ http://blog.zorinaq.com/bitcoin-mining-is-not-wasteful/) so it will only become more and more competitive from now on.
- rspeer 10y agoLet's hope it doesn't! Here's a Fermi problem to show how horrifying the prospect of Bitcoin succeeding is: By this blog post's estimate, Bitcoin currently consumes about 500 MW of power. As others have estimated, Bitcoin processes about 3 transactions per second. The world currently consumes about 2.38 TW of power. If Bitcoin were a commonly-used currency -- if, for example, a billion people in the developed world each made an average of one Bitcoin transaction per day -- then Bitcoin would have to run 4,000 times faster than it currently does, consuming 2 TW of power, which is most of the power in the world.
- mrb 10y agoYou are incorrect. Bitcoin does not "have to" consume more energy to process more transactions. Energy and tx rate are uncorrelated. And the energy cost per transaction is falling. Again, see section 5 of http://blog.zorinaq.com/bitcoin-mining-is-not-wasteful/ http://blog.zorinaq.com/bitcoin-mining-is-not-wasteful/
- rspeer 10y agoSection 5 says "thanks to the transaction rate increasing faster than the network's energy consumption". Is the transaction rate increasing? Two years ago people said it was 7 transactions per second. Now it's 3 per second. It may be that people were making unchecked exaggerations two years ago. But this doesn't look like any sort of increase. If the transaction rate is "quadrupling every 2 years"... why didn't it quadruple over 2 years? An article entitled "Bitcoin Mining is Not Wasteful" on a Bitcoin blog kind of tells you what conclusion it's going to come to. For people who aren't personally invested in Bitcoin, of course Bitcoin mining is wasteful. It is literally made of wasted computation. The fact that it benefits an economy of Bitcoin speculators is of no interest.
- mrb 10y agoYes the tx rate is increasing: https://blockchain.info/charts/n-transactions?daysAverageString=7×pan=all https://blockchain.info/charts/n-transactions?daysAverageStr... It never was 7 tps. 7 is the theoretical maximum (assumes the tx had only 1 input.) In practice Bitcoin never achieves this because the average tx has multiple inputs. "...tells you what conclusion it's going to come to" You have to examine the presented facts, not the messenger. This blog is mine, and I think I present decent evidence that it's not wasteful. You have to look at the whole picture, ie. the Bitcoin economy lead to $1+ billion invested in 729+ companies, etc... Investing x megawatt in a system that produces investments and jobs is hardly a "waste".
- rspeer 10y ago> It never was 7 tps. 7 is the theoretical maximum Wow, you mean Bitcoin fans were prone to exaggeration and unrealistic claims two years ago? I wonder if they still are. Speaking of which, this graph you're showing me definitely has not quadrupled over the last two years. What went wrong? > Investing x megawatt in a system that produces investments and jobs is hardly a "waste". It is if the jobs never produce any actual value. Moving money around is not a good in itself. In fact a lot of Bitcoin companies have moved money in ways that are distinctly bad. Would you be celebrating MtGox as part of the Bitcoin economy if they still existed? Of course whoever is currently holding the money is happy with it. Doesn't mean it's not a waste. People have profited from waste for as long as civilization has existed. (edited out an ad hominem, sorry)
- runeks 10y agoThe point of Bitcoin is to consume as much electricity, roughly, as a block is worth. Consuming this electricity, and using it to calculate a proof of the consumed electricity, means that the blockchain becomes immutable: no one can change the past, because it would require re-doing the proof-of-work. So, out of this -- seemingly meaningless -- activity of burning off energy, arises the trustless property of the Bitcoin blockchain: with digital currencies that use proof-of-stake, or an SQL backend, every participant could -- theoretically -- have mutually agreed on assigning themselves 100x as many currency units, right before you enter and buy $1000 worth. There's no way to prove that this didn't happen, as it takes little effort to change history. This is unacceptable for a digital currency, hence the need for proof-of-work, and Bitcoin.
- ben_w 10y agoOn the one hand, if each coin is worth 1/10th its cost, nobody will mint them. On the other hand, if each coin is worth 10x as much as it cost to make, people make their own and the price collapses. That applies equally to gold coins as bitcoins. I suspect bitcoin is, in its current form, incapable of replacing a major currency, because if it become a dominant currency then someone would beg, borrow, and steal just enough bitcoin to buy just enough compute power to get half of the bitcoin computer pool, from there using their new power to double-spend their way to getting even more computer power (while blocking other transactions that might try to out-bid them), and ultimately using that power to rewrite the consensus reality of the blockchain to say they now own as much as they want to say they own. Even if the bitcoin wiki is correct to expect no rational miner will attempt this, there are plenty of irrational actors when enough money is dangled in front of them, even when it is only a mirage (citation: every lottery).
- mrb 10y ago"if each coin is worth 1/10th its cost, nobody will mint them" No. What will happen is as the miners with the highest mining costs drop out of the network, the difficulty target will decrease and decrease... until people stop dropping out of the network. "people make their own and the price collapses" No, again the difficulty target would adjust to regulate the rate of coin rewards. See https://en.bitcoin.it/wiki/Difficulty https://en.bitcoin.it/wiki/Difficulty
- ballenf 10y agoBitcoin is both the ledger and the printing/minting mechanism and the delivery mechanism (armored cars delivering new bills & coins to banks and picking up and destroying old ones). Factor in those costs and suddenly bitcoin is bargain, energy-wise.
- nhaehnle 10y agoAn SQL database with a simple front-end could be all of those things you named, and much more cheaply than Bitcoin. The real issues lie elsewhere.
- linsen 10y agoThey make the assumption that unprofitable hardware has been retired. But this assumes that the person profiting from the mining is also paying for the electricity.
- foepys 10y ago> But this assumes that the person profiting from the mining is also paying for the electricity. Otherwise it doesn't make sense. You cannot steal electricity forever.
- peter303 10y agoAt one ton of CO2 per megawatt hour, we could be looking at 2 million tons CO2 a year. https://www.eia.gov/tools/faqs/faq.cfm?id=74&t=11 https://www.eia.gov/tools/faqs/faq.cfm?id=74&t=11 100 gallons of gasoline also creates a ton of CO2 for context.
- pmorici 10y agoYou are assuming the mining electricity comes predominately from fossil fuels which couldn't be further from reality. In reality the cheapest power is often in areas where hydroelectric is the dominate power source and miners choose their location based on availability of cheap power. Look at Washington State for example. It's a major producer of hydropower, has the cheapest electric rates in the US, and has a large number of Bitcoin mining facilities. Even in China it holds true that many mining facilities are in areas supplied by hydro electric power.
- mrb 10y agoAuthor here. You are absolutely right. Petroleum- or coal-produced electricity is typically too expensive for miners.
- bitxbitxbitcoin 10y agoThanks for authoring this!
- mrb 10y agoGlad you liked it!
- jankotek 10y agoPetrol is very cheap in Venezuela and some other countries.
- mrb 10y agoIndeed. I know of a medium-size 55nm Bitfury farm in Venezuela. But as others pointed out, most miners are not located in Venezuela. In fact Venezuelan authorities are cracking down on mining farms, and have shut this one down - https://news.bitcoin.com/venezuelan-authorities-weakening-bitcoin-mining-operations/ https://news.bitcoin.com/venezuelan-authorities-weakening-bi...
- canadian_voter 10y agoIn the future bitcoin[1] mining is banned on inhabited planets and instead done on Dyson spheres. [1] It's the future, so neither bitcoin nor internet are capitalized.
- bitxbitxbitcoin 10y agoI knew I couldn't be the only person with this thought. Solar powered Bitcoin mining will eventually be economically viable :).
- vivekd 10y agoif this happens, bitcoin would become valueless. The value of bitcoin comes from the fact that you can't just pump them out, the energy requirements required to solve the calculations required for mining are one of the limits to bitcoin production. Free energy like feasible solar or dyson spears would just be a license to print free digital currency making it worthless.
- aakilfernandes 10y agoThe network recalculates payoffs based on the hashrate. If electricity becomes cheaper, hashrate goes up, and the payoff per hash goes down.
- adrianN 10y agoDyson spheres are not free to construct and the energy they provide is limited.
- n00b101 10y agoI think a rough estimate of the cost of 500MWh/year is $500 million per year. That doesn't include cooling, hardware, real-estate, staff and other operating expenses. I guess the majority of this cost is ultimately paid for by speculators who buy Bitcoins off of the miners.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- hollerith 10y ago$500 million per year is roughly what I get, too, but 500MWh/year is very different from 500MW, which is what I think you meant to write since the OP expresses its conclusion in MW.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- tbihl 10y agoA growing trend is to mine Bitcoin in Venezuela, where the electricity is hugely subsidized, mining can pay better than something like being a doctor, and you can get food sent in from Miami (since your income is in a widely accepted currency.) Good Econtalk on the subject: http://www.econtalk.org/archives/2017/02/jim_epstein_on.html http://www.econtalk.org/archives/2017/02/jim_epstein_on.html
- danblick 10y agoIf you accept that (1) there are economies of scale in Bitcoin mining and (2) miners are rational and will only mine when it is profitable, then doesn't this suggest that large amounts of mining power should become concentrated in the hands of just a few major miners? Doesn't that seriously undermine Bitcoin's validity?
- danblick 10y agoThis article seems to support my suggestion. https://www.cryptocoinsnews.com/declining-profitability-for-new-miners-threatens-bitcoin-decentralization/ https://www.cryptocoinsnews.com/declining-profitability-for-... Quoting the conclusion of the referenced paper: "Each future halving of the Bitcoin block reward will narrow the range of profitable entry for new Bitcoin miners considerably. The stronger relative position of incumbents compared to that of new entrants supports further consolidation of Bitcoin mining. Consequently, the distributed Bitcoin ledger, the blockchain, may become more vulnerable to attack, and its trustless nature may ultimately even be destroyed."
- globuous 10y ago" Once a predetermined number of coins have entered circulation, the incentive can transition entirely to transaction fees and be completely inflation free" - btc whitepaper Transaction fees will take over mined bitcoins once there is non left to mine.
- danblick 10y agoOkay but that does not solve the problem I am concerned about. That doesn't ensure a diverse mining pool. Already it doesn't make sense for me to mine Bitcoin (I don't have access to these ASICs). I think that economic forces will tend to concentrate mining power and that's a problem.