9 ms·
Crazy Eddie Fraud
- KasianFranks 10y agoI owned a small mobile app public co a while ago for a few years. The things I witnessed ran deep and with most listed companies on most exchanges up and down the food chain. The fraud can go many levels deep and begins to look like a giant complex game, and for crazies out there, Sith Lords https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Patrick_M._Byrne#Campaign_against_naked_shorting_and_analysts https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Patrick_M._Byrne#Campaign_agai... One fun fact I remember is that your share price is not calculated based on shares outstanding. Sure, perceived supply and perceived demand account for a lot but many traders and armchair investors are not aware of this larger detail: The bedrock of your share price is based on available tradeable DTCC-deposited http://www.dtcc.com/ http://www.dtcc.com/ "unchilled" float. It's all in the float and that includes a few private companies out there that determine your float number, including the DTCC and CapitalIQ https://capitaliq.com https://capitaliq.com, which can mean a manipulated or highly inaccurate market cap via your share price which is calculated by your float. And, if a crook has any spies or moles working there, that crook can get a lot done with his buddies which can include stock transfer agents who play a big role here. I got offers like this from time to time. Market makers and institutions will eventually dial your price in based on your float as it's one of the few solid factors they have for determining price. Shorts are all over this too. Large caps have arsenals of CFO's, attorney's and connections that fighting for an accurate unmanipulated float is trivial. "Bigger Stuff" is happening for them although NFLX was known as a "short incinerator" due to their essentially well-engineered low float which helped them maintain a high but volatile share price historically. For mid size and small public co's if you're market cap is manipulated, you can see this when you ask for NOBO reports provided by the DTCC combined with reports from CapitalIQ who control how and when the main DB gets updated with the number of shares used to calculate your float aka number of tradable shares any given day, week or month. Try and get them to make corrections if you can, sometimes you won't be able to, depending on who you know or how well your engineering plan for your float is from the start of structuring your public co.
- gech 10y agoHow would one utilize this to game the market?
- KasianFranks 10y agoWhat you do if you're the one trying to manipulate the company from the outside and on the short side: A company might have a shareholder that needs a new certificate of stock issued because they "lost" their old one. Or it got eaten by sharks or something while you were at the beach, somebody's house burned down, they moved it got lost, cancer. Whatever the case, this happens everyday in the market, people lose certs for all kinds of reasons. If you own a public co, you'll have to work with your current stock transfer agent to get the certs reissued and this is a pain in the ass as affidavits and sometimes insurance bonds need to be issued along with them. These certs might represent e.g. 1 million shares of stock, 50k, 100k but it all accumulates if not taken care of and tracked like a hawk immediately. This might happen 1-3 times per year. Each time this happens, the DTCC needs to finally validate the certs and "put them on deposit" officially approved for trading. Once this is done, if you have not worked with your SEC attorney, stock transfer agent (to get the ledger updated) and the DTCC to make sure there are no hold ups you then make sure CapitalIQ/S&P are holding accurately reflected updates in their DB as most institutions and market makers and some traders just rely on this data to adjust or predict your price in their models. Remember, a price adjustment must come if there is any change in the float. And, you've just witnessed a change in the float as the CEO properly overseeing the process, if you're on top of it, so you then expect to see a corresponding change, more or less, in the price in some reasonable amount of time, say a day or two or immediately if you have some good connections. Now multiply the above by several accumulated share cert reissuances, which is more real-world, then add the fact that not many small cap CEO's are hawkish about that (half of them just let the stock transfer agent take care of everything and call it day, wake up the next day, grab a bag of popcorn and watch their stock trade <- keep this mind. Now add, the critical part, guys on the inside that know this process like the back of their hand. They in fact make money by making sure all this happens "smoothly", they are usually working closely with the stock transfer agents. Next factor shrewd but unscrupulous friends in this guys little network, who might be big shorts of this stock. They call their friend at the transfer agent and throw a monkey wrench into the process knowing that inaccurate float data will then be distributed to OR within CapitalIQ. Prices then will not be accurately reflected and they are now in the money for building a short position in the stock while everyone else including the public thinks it should be valued differently. Unethical Information Arbitrage is happening. Then then call their buddy up at the stock transfer agent and correct a synthetic mistake. Once corrected, the price of the stock must come down, making the short a load of $$$ on the way down because e.g. 20M shares have just been added to the float. This means more supply right. BTW: you want no where near that amount in your float as a small cap. Unless the CEO can correct this or even knows about it, a form of fraud can continue to exist on that company stock. This is just 1 of many examples of how fraud can be structured on the short side. The long side is a bit different but with the same principles of screwing with a public companies cap table based on inside manipulation of the float, by deep insiders, not company insiders. I know this because I had to fight this exact scenario and few others from happening to my company. Being a software engineer also helps quite a bit. I built all kinds of automated monitoring systems for this in particular to monitor the NOBO list and true "short interest" for example. I also use to have bots send certain small Market Maker guys updated news on our company. They hated that because it then bound them to a piece of knowledge that could be traced back to them. I thought it was funny. I eventually stopped that as I thought it was also too aggressive in terms of taking a bite out of fraud that ran against my company. Keep in mind, some CEOs are in collusion here shorting their own stock after going long and just riding the waves of what they consider giant ATMs. You can tell who they are because 99% of the time they have super high floats and know that the public are clueless related to the bad "financial engineering" specific to float structures. Other examples of the above including someone disagreeing with the NAV (Net Asset Value) of the assets within your company. If you legitimately change the NAV of one of your assets such as an LLC that has a JV with a new partner based on some IP or the acquisition of something valuable, then you can negotiate with CapitalIQ/S&P to have them change your float based on shares being issued to the JV or LLC and no longer being part of the public company. This is bit more complex strategy for the CEO to control the float. This process can also be manipulated by being help up a firm being used by some outsider. I had to deal this scenario too. I had some outside shareholders saying one of our NAVs was too low and another saying it was too high and he would not stand for a change in the float so he wanted to get personally involved with communicating with the outside data vendors. Another example relates to "Donkey Kong" but that's different kind of volume manipulation that can help chip away a bloated float altogether. And then there are those that will offer to manipulate the option pool which of course entails them cashing out very soon or immediately, buying all the way up and then shorting all the way down when your float become bloated from all the options being converted to actual tradeable stock and then just sitting out there waterlogging everything for investors and traders that are trying to figure out why your stock does not move up like the others but moves down much greater than the others... messing with options for the CEO while the deal includes the same options for the outside partner is still outright illegal and can land you jail. But I'm pretty sure its still being done. And there's always the good nuclear option of cleaning up the cap table, buying back shares, finding ones no one is using (believe it not yes, unclaimed or those someone may want to give back to the company based on first right of refusal or for tax reasons and then once all rounded up - outright "canceling" a large lot, which can burn a lot of people real quick on the short side and make tons for others on the long side overnight. This is actually perfectly legal with the right intent. This also takes lots of phone calls and negotiation. The bad nuke option is a reverse split, this leads different kind of death spiral for the stock and is encouraged by dealers and brokers some of which know that you won't be able to sustain it. You cut the float in half e.g. and then the price doubles correspondingly overnight. However, most companies are unaware that they being manipulated such that naked shorts keep piling on and worse off than where you started. Naked shorting and other kinds can almost endless add to an inaccurate float number. Lots of details left out but in principle that's how the above works.
- skrebbel 10y agoThis must be the best content marketing I ever read. The author is the convicted felon being written about and he now runs a forensic accounting consultancy.
- bbarn 10y agoThis is his cousin, Sam, the CFO. "Eddie" himself got convicted by testimony from Sam.
- skrebbel 10y agoAccording to Sam's own writing, Eddie might've been the main motivating force of it all, but Sam architected all the details of the fraud.
- sgift 10y agoYou are correct, from the start page of https://whitecollarfraud.com/ https://whitecollarfraud.com/ : Sam Antar is a convicted felon and a former CPA. As the CFO of Crazy Eddie, Mr. Antar helped mastermind one of the largest securities frauds uncovered during the 1980s. Today, Sam Antar is a forensic accountant. His primary work focuses on identifying and investigating public companies engaged in securities fraud by performing an in-depth (deep-dive) forensic analysis. (...)
- csours 10y agoSam also took a plea deal; he is also a felon (but a very nice one from all accounts).
- mirimir 10y agoWhat's funny is how pervasive these games are.
- dredmorbius 10y agoThis needs a backgrounder on what the Crazie Eddie story was, specifically. I'm not familiar with it. The story presumes the reader is. OK, Wikipedia has a pretty good article. And ... I question the ethics of directing traffic to the fraudster himself. https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Crazy_Eddie https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Crazy_Eddie Crazy Eddie was a consumer electronics chain in the Northeastern United States- previously called ERS Electronics ... It was started in 1971 in Brooklyn, New York, by businessmen Eddie and Sam M. Antar. The chain rose to prominence throughout the Tri-State Region as much for its prices as for its memorable radio and television commercials, featuring a frenetic, "crazy" character played by radio DJ Jerry Carroll ... At its peak, Crazy Eddie had 43 stores in four states, and earned more than $300 million in sales.[1] In February 1987, the United States Attorney's Office for the District of New Jersey commenced a federal grand jury investigation into the financial activities of Crazy Eddie. In September of that year, the United States Securities and Exchange Commission initiated an investigation into alleged violations of federal securities laws by certain Crazy Eddie officers and employees. Eddie Antar was eventually charged with a series of crimes. Antar fled to Israel in February 1990, but was returned to the United States in January 1993 to stand trial. His 1993 conviction on fraud charges was overturned, but he eventually pleaded guilty in 1996. In 1997, Antar was sentenced to eight years in prison and was subject to numerous fines. He was released from prison in 1999.[2]
- ourmandave 10y agoThis Crazy Eddie Ad from 1986 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=uCGsqBn9pog https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=uCGsqBn9pog reminds me of Morrie's Wigs from Goodfellas https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=9dwV18I2ngk https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=9dwV18I2ngk I wonder if Eddie inspired the character.
- richardfontana 10y agoArticle on the actor, Jerry Carroll: https://www.nytimes.com/2016/09/13/nyregion/the-public-face-of-crazy-eddie-recalls-the-real-one.html https://www.nytimes.com/2016/09/13/nyregion/the-public-face-...
- 10y ago
- username223 10y agoThe Planet Money episode talking to Sam Antar is a great listen: http://www.npr.org/sections/money/2009/08/into_the_mind_of_a_financial_c.html http://www.npr.org/sections/money/2009/08/into_the_mind_of_a...
- subpixel 10y agoAnother fascinating story is that of the ultra-insular Syrian Jewish community/subculture to which the Antars belong: https://www.nytimes.com/2007/10/14/magazine/14syrians-t.html https://www.nytimes.com/2007/10/14/magazine/14syrians-t.html http://forward.com/news/110943/an-inside-look-at-a-syrian-jewish-enclave/ http://forward.com/news/110943/an-inside-look-at-a-syrian-je...
- jakobegger 10y agoHere's what I don't get: Why is everyone so unconcerned about making themselves complicit in crimes like this? I can understand that you might be able to influence one or two people to become complicit. But it sounds like everyone was taking part in the scheme: everyone in the family, employees at every level, even the auditors contributed a part to the conspiracy. I mean, dozens of people must have been involved in this scheme. Why didn't anybody of them say, hey, I'm not going to be a part of this? I'm going to report this?
- koolba 10y ago> I mean, dozens of people must have been involved in this scheme. Why didn't anybody of them say, hey, I'm not going to be a part of this? I'm going to report this? It two completely different level of effort and involvement. Saying "I'm not going to be a part of this" means you step away and brush your hands clean. Saying "I'm going to report this" requires much more effort. If you personally know someone working there it's even more difficult as you'd be intentionally ratting out your friend/colleague/family.
- AtheistOfFail 10y agoAlso, if you walk away and they get caught, it's likely they'll think it's you anyway.s
- neves 10y agoAnd nobody in your field will hire you anymore.
- HarryHirsch 10y agoHave you never been in a place where the culture stinks? If you go along with everyone, there is potential trouble in the future, but if you go against there is certain trouble now. A reasonable person with a choice will go along and bail as fast as they can (see what Susan Fowler did), but in a family business people don't have that luxury, and that's how the cart gets wedged in the mud.
- kefka 10y ago
- AtheistOfFail 10y ago> I engaged in a calculated plan to subtly distract them with cute Crazy Eddie employees reporting to me. I encouraged my female employees to flirt and get friendly with their young male PMM counterparts and discuss audit issues with them over lunch and dinner on Crazy Eddie’s tab. Human Intelligence at it's core with some Social Engineering thrown in.
- commandertso 10y agoI was a kid on Long Island when Crazy Eddie was big - it was impossible to not know the commercials' tag line by heart - "Crazy Eddie! His prices are in-saaaaane!" I was young enough when all of this went down that I remember being super sad the guy in the commercials was a criminal. And then blown away to learn he was just an actor.
- twic 10y agoI'd only heard of Crazy Eddie via a New York area local historical society, the Beastie Boys, who boasted [1]: I splash on beats like sauce on spaghetti Putting MC's out of business like they're Crazy Eddie And once made an ad for an album in the style of the Crazy Eddie ads: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=3OR8O0u2fDY https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=3OR8O0u2fDY [1] https://genius.com/Beastie-boys-shazam-lyrics https://genius.com/Beastie-boys-shazam-lyrics
- biscuitt 10y agoAs an accountant, 1/3rd of the auditing class I took in college was just reading about how different companies perpetuated fraud. It made an otherwise boring class, pretty fun. I still currently work in public, and a couple of the partners are incredibly jaded because they worked on clients at some point in their careers who were committing fraud.
- spoonie 10y agoDoes this reflect poorly on the auditing industry? Kind of like with the ratings firms during the GFC. It seems that their poor practices have aided and abetted these frauds. Has their behaviour changed?
- pm90 10y agoThis is a good question, and I would like to know the answers as well. Although, seeing that the credit rating agencies that enabled the Great Recession are still in business...it seems unlikely that they have changed anything. The only instance I've heard of an accounting company truly blowing up is probably Arthur Anderson after the Enron scandal.
- gefh 10y agoI believe that a lot of firms had to split their accounting and consulting businesses after Enron, but this article shows the conflict of interest had quietly been there, and been abused, for decades.
- jacquesm 10y ago> After the funds were transferred to Panama, a family member withdrew those funds from Bank Leumi in the form of bank drafts or non-negotiable instruments, to avoid violating disclosure laws on the movement of funds into the country. Bank Leumi figured big time in the crash of iBill, they took the money of a lot of merchants and never paid it out.
- late2part 10y ago"The gullible auditors accepted our silly explanation that our employees had sacrificed many years working at below average wages for the opportunity to be part of what they hoped might become a growing public company." Brilliant line!!! Got stock options?