4 ms·
I am not sure why you put the word currency in quotes. There have also been many state issued currencies that have done similar - see Thai Baht, Argentine Peso
by bogomipz 10y ago
I am not sure why you put the word currency in quotes. There have also been many state issued currencies that have done similar - see Thai Baht, Argentine Peso, Russian Ruble, Venezuelan Bolivar etc.
- srssays 10y agoPound sterling...
- dmoy 10y agoWoah wait when did the pound lose 25% of its value due to a SEC ruling?
- srssays 10y agoThere were two separate events, adding up to 25%. The first happened instantly as the Brexit result became known. The second happened on Oct 7 at the opening of trading when there was nobody around who wanted to buy... I find that Bitcoins are an effective hedge against conventional wisdom.
- guiambros 10y agoI wouldn't call Brexit a "minor ruling".
- alexeldeib 10y agoCould be a reference to Brexit? The pound suffered pretty severely after the referendum.
- conanbatt 10y agoTo be fair, sec ruling is a much smaller measure than country-wide referendum on economicy policy
- arthurcolle 10y agoRead about Soros breaking the Bank of England sometime, it's great stuff. Black Wednesday I think is the name of the event in popular culture
- Blahah 10y agoGreat stuff in the sense that one person can directly profit to the tune of a billion dollars, by manipulating currency markets, at the cost of the taxpayers of an entire nation. So, not great stuff at all.
- shitgoose 10y agoHe did not manipulate pound. UK government manipulated it by locking the exchange rate that did not reflect the fundamentals. Pound was doomed, Soros just profited from the crash. So, yes, great stuff - government should pay for its stupidity. Unfortunately they pay with our money...
- Blahah 10y agoHe shorted the pound enough to move the market significantly, and his buyback strategy deliberately prevented any stabilisation. The crash wouldn't have happened or at least wouldn't have been as bad without his involvement.
- shitgoose 10y agohttps://www.youtube.com/watch?v=K_oET45GzMI https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=K_oET45GzMI a good overview of the origins of the crisis. how politicians for their own shortsighted gains made one poor decision after another and led the country into financial crisis.
- nradov 10y agoVolatility isn't the issue. Bitcoin isn't technically a currency because it can't currently be used directly to pay public debts or taxes in any nation state. Bitcoin is just another commodity like copper or crude oil.
- bogomipz 10y agoI understand the quoting now, thanks. I agree with you that its not technically a currency since it's not issued and circulated by a government but I disagree with the OP that it is not ready to be a "store of value" because of a single volatility event. There are many who would argue it is a good store of value since it can't be manipulated by the issuing state's monetary policy or susceptible to the poor fiscal management of the issuing state.
- blunte 10y agoThere have been many volatility events. Given that governments have the ability to practically outlaw it if they choose, that makes it quite risky as a store of value. Several of the major volatility events in the past of bitcoin were related to Chinese government announcements or rumors regarding regulation/legality. Sure one can transfer bitcoin without governmental approval (or against restriction), but that annoying need to convert to and from fiat in order to trade for other goods and services means that the governments still have a great deal of influence over bitcoin.
- bogomipz 10y ago>"There have been many volatility events." Sure but I was speaking to the OPs assertion that this particular event is proof that it is not suitable as a store of value. >"Several of the major volatility events in the past of bitcoin were related to Chinese government announcements or rumors regarding regulation/legality." Right but this is to be expected given that China recently has been the largest market for Bitcoin by volume no? [1] >" but that annoying need to convert to and from fiat in order to trade for other goods and services means that the governments still have a great deal of influence over bitcoin" Is that any more annoying or any more inconvenient than having your hard-earned savings devalued by your government? [1]http://www.coindesk.com/estimating-data-china-real-bitcoin-trading-volumes/ http://www.coindesk.com/estimating-data-china-real-bitcoin-t...