15 ms·
>Bitcoin just went from a high of 1327.1926 to 995.9575 in the blink of an eye. That is a loss of 25% of its value. This announcement does nothing to hurt the
by slg 10y ago
>Bitcoin just went from a high of 1327.1926 to 995.9575 in the blink of an eye.
That is a loss of 25% of its value. This announcement does nothing to hurt the utility of Bitcoin or its application as a medium of exchange. That drop certainly seems like a speculative investment bubble popping.
- baddox 10y agoIt clearly reduces some of the potential future value of Bitcoin, and predictions of future value are baked into the current market price. I guess you could consider that under your definition of "speculative investment bubble," but it really applies to any market price of anything.
- slg 10y agoThe only way it reduces its future potential value is by making it harder to speculate on its future potential value. Nothing about the currency actually changed.
- askmike 10y agoWhile technically nothing changed, the SEC approving an ETF directly tied to bitcoin would have changed how Bitcoin is perceived by a lot of people. > Nothing about the currency actually changed. You can say this about about everything: "while nothing about the pound changed, brexit caused the price to go down."
- slg 10y agoBrexit had real world impact on how the currency would be used in the future and the strength of the economy of the country that stands behind it. The SEC decision does none of that.
- askmike 10y ago> The SEC decision does none of that. That's because Bitcoin isn't directly tied to any economy. But just as Brexit had a real world impact on the pound, the SEC decision had a real world impact on bitcoin: It is directly tied to how people perceive Bitcoin, which is an import aspect just as well.
- baddox 10y agoThe SEC decision very clearly has real world impact on how Bitcoin will be used in the future.
- baddox 10y agoIf an official decision from the agency that regulates financial assets for the most powerful economy in the world doesn't count, then when does "something about a currency actually change"?
- kolinko 10y agoAnything that prevents Bitcoin from: - being a good anonymous currency - being a truly global currency for irreversible online transactions - being a currency that's easily programmable That's the three main use cases for Bitcoin. There are contenders for #1 (Monero, Dash), and for #3 (Ethereum). For #2 it's still the easiest because of the huge network effect behind it. Traditional currencies can't compete with crypto for neither of the space. They are attached to systems that prevent transactions from being anonymous, global, irreversible or programmable.
- rocho 10y agoThere's nothing that prevents Bitcoin from being a good anonymous currency. It simply isn't. Its design allows it to be pseudo-anonymous at best, while Monero, for instance, has anonymity built in. Therefore if one seeks a truly anonymous currency they cannot possibly find it in Bitcoin.
- Analemma_ 10y agoYup. Any "currency" that can plummet in value by 25% because of a minor SEC ruling is not ready to be a store of value.
- Taek 10y agoWell, it can't compete with the USD. But plenty of nations like Venezuela have citizens that would happily take a >25% haircut to escape their governments capital controls. When Greece went bankrupt, life was much easier for anyone with Bitcoin than for anyone without it. As many issues as Bitcoin has today, it has clear use cases.
- sanswork 10y ago>When Greece went bankrupt, life was much easier for anyone with Bitcoin than for anyone without it. How? Bitcoin atms were basically non-existent there and from what I read on /r/bitcoin at the time from Greeks no one there was accepting it in stores.
- drcross 10y agoThere were capital controls restricting more than 100 euro worth of withdrawals from banks per day. Sure it's not helping you if you are buying a coffee but if it's saving parts of your pension that you worked your whole life to earn then it becomes very important.
- sanswork 10y agoThis is a non-answer. >There were capital controls restricting more than 100 euro worth of withdrawals from banks per day. Yes and bitcoin didn't help this since the ways to get cash for your bitcoin involved international transfers which exposed you to those restrictions. >Sure it's not helping you if you are buying a coffee but if it's saving parts of your pension that you worked your whole life to earn then it becomes very important. I'm not sure what this has to do with the question above. Could you expand on it some more?
- mrb 10y ago"That is a loss of 25% of its value" Update as of 11 March 01:44 UTC (4h43m after the SEC decision): BTC fully recovered! It now stands at $1140, which is the level it was trading at just 2 days ago. From 09 March 00:00 UTC to the SEC decision on 10 March 21:01 UTC it gained +12% due purely to speculation ($1140 to $1280) and basically retraced these 12%: http://bitcoincharts.com/charts/bitstampUSD#rg10zig30-minzczsg2017-03-07zeg2017-03-11ztgSzm1g10zm2g25 http://bitcoincharts.com/charts/bitstampUSD#rg10zig30-minzcz... I am impressed. I thought downward trading pressure would have lasted for days/weeks after the SEC rejection.
- koolba 10y agoAlternatively: https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dead_cat_bounce https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dead_cat_bounce
- freework 10y ago> This announcement does nothing to hurt the utility of Bitcoin or its application as a medium of exchange That's what the 1MB blocksize limit is for.
- jamespedwards 10y agoIt is more a reflection of the instant liquidity available on exchanges. A more accurate description would be that the price went from about $1250 pre rejection announcement and has settled at around $1190-$1200.