8 ms·
Musk Bets He Can Fix Aussie Power Woes in 100 Days or It’s Free
- jimmcslim 10y agoHaving made these public commitments, Musk and Cannon-Brookes had better deliver on their commitments within '100 days', or they are going to unfortunately pour petrol on the bonfire that is any attempt at rational energy debate in this country. There are enough conservative elements here already making misinformed claims about renewable energy that any failures or compromises, even for good technical reason, will be seized upon.
- adventured 10y agoTesla has previously demonstrated the extremely impressive speed at which they can deploy these systems. I suspect the only problem is likely to potentially be politicians that try to get in the way to intentionally slow it down and cause the referenced negative PR event.
- jnsaff2 10y agoNote how Musk promised 100 days from signing. This seems like a very reasonable bet that the negotiation will take a long time and if things look promising they can start the production early.
- londons_explore 10y agoThis is only the battery capacity of 1000 cars. That about 15% of tesla's car production over that time period. I bet they have sufficient supply chain slack to accommodate that if they need to.
- yellow_viper 10y agosurreal we live in a time when discussions like these are public and on twitter.
- comboy 10y agoIndeed. Sorry for off-topic, but is there anybody reading this who could help me claim a twitter username that is inactive for almost 10 years now? Any hints are welcome. AFAIK twitter doesn't do that officially anymore. It would be really awesome.
- Anderkent 10y agoIsn't the discussion happening in public a good thing?
- wastedhours 10y agoGood, and surreal.
- mirimir 10y agoWhat will be surreal is watching WWIII break out in real time ;)
- adventured 10y agoI know you're mostly joking, but it's not going to happen. There aren't enough powerful countries on the theoretical opposition side to sustain a WW3 engagement. There are only a few consequential military powers today that can seriously attempt to fight a major war outside their own borders while simultaneously enduring opposition: US, Russia, China, Germany, France, UK. All the next tier powers down from that can be trivially crippled, locked down to their own territory and prevented from substantially joining the battle. IE there can be no WW3 until or unless the world changes a lot.
- lefstathiou 10y agoTo add to that, you need a large and consistent oil supply to sustain a war on that scale and it is no accident that the North American, South American and Middle Eastern oil regions are effectively all under US control.
- gonzo41 10y agoFingers crossed this happens. Currently we have a government thats talking up clean coal :(
- posnet 10y agoIt is a sad day when a politician unironically holds up a lump of coal in parliament and pronounces look how clean it it.
- kogepathic 10y agoIt also doesn't make any sense, as a number of studies have shown that renewables employ more people per MWh than fossil fuel energy sources like coal. [0] So if the politicians point is that renewables destroy jobs, the evidence does not support this claim. [0] https://web.stanford.edu/group/emf-research/docs/occasional_papers/OP64.pdf https://web.stanford.edu/group/emf-research/docs/occasional_...
- fennecfoxen 10y ago> renewables employ more people per MWh than fossil fuel energy sources like coal. Anyone who suggests that's a feature, and not a defect, is either a fool or has designs on your wallet.
- kogepathic 10y ago> So if the politicians point is that renewables destroy jobs, the evidence does not support this claim. My point isn't that more people employed = cheaper energy. Obviously that's not how economics works. My point was, if politicians are advocating for building out more fossil fuels because renewables "take away jobs" that argument has been proven false. [0] [0] http://fortune.com/2017/02/21/donald-trump-jobs-coal-mining-solar-energy/ http://fortune.com/2017/02/21/donald-trump-jobs-coal-mining-...
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- roenxi 10y agoIf Australia's power problem can be solved by two billionaires on twitter for $25 million, then it isn't anywhere near as problematic as I've been led to believe. There are enough problems with the grid that any solution needs to be discussed in the context of what problem is being solved. The latest I've seen ( https://www.aemo.com.au/-/media/Files/Gas/National_Planning_and_Forecasting/GSOO/2017/2017-Gas-Statement-of-Opportunities.pdf https://www.aemo.com.au/-/media/Files/Gas/National_Planning_... ) suggests that there is a risk of not being able to produce enough at all, let alone keep the grid stable. My read of that report is that current "Aussie Power Woes" are the ageing generator infrastructure, not grid stabilisation which was a politically interesting but otherwise relatively minor hiccup a few months ago in South Australia. In addition to those two there are cost troubles brewing related to the cost of maintaining infrastructure for power (poles & cables), and energy prices are moving upwards. May or may not be related to generators capacity, I don't know.
- ZeroGravitas 10y agoYour linked report suggests one of the solutions to gas shortage is to build more battery storage: "Alternative generation fuel sources such as biofuels, or technologies such as energy storage, may be viable alternatives to GPG, if cost-effective. These alternatives would help alleviate gas supply shortfalls by reducing gas demand, while still supporting renewable generation integration." Though since one of the other solutions to a gas shortage is to stop shipping so much of it out of the country, it seems the "problem" may well be blown out of proportion.
- sjwright 10y ago$25 million for parts... I suspect global shipping and installation isn't cheap.
- wolfgke 10y ago> $25 million for parts... I suspect global shipping and installation isn't cheap. Shipping via ocean freight (I will avoid the obvious pun) is exceptionally cheap; for example consider the following article from 2016: > https://www.flexport.com/blog/why-are-ocean-freight-rates-so-low/ https://www.flexport.com/blog/why-are-ocean-freight-rates-so...
- SturgeonsLaw 10y ago> Australian Prime Minister Malcolm Turnbull blamed the power cut on the state’s rapid take-up of renewable power So typical of Australian politics. Any event, positive or negative, is used to attempt to score cheap political points. We have no leaders with long term vision. There is no discussion about building Australia's future, only mud slinging at the opposite party. The few large scale nation building projects that commence are gutted once the opposing party is elected, and in the end, the people who lose out the most are the Australian public. "Coal is the future" - Tony Abbott
- mstade 10y agoNot just Australian politics, I'm afraid. :o(
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- zachruss92 10y agoThe can do optimizim here is amazing. There is obviously a bit of PR here, but that's what I've come to respect about Elon Musk. Promise the moon then deliver, literally. If private citizens using technology to solve a nation's crippling issues is awesome.
- drcross 10y agoIt's refreshing in a world thats increasingly in a stranglehold from regulation and restriction that if humans really want to do something on a massive scale that we could potentially pull it off.
- ewood 10y agoAnyone here have deep insight on this? I thought a large part of the problem is the way that the Australian Energy Market Operator (AEMO) is operating the market? Their mandate seems to be to prioritise price over reliability causing artificial shortages when there are not enough bids to form a market for excess load. It appears that there is sufficient capacity in SA but providers are holding out for higher prices or not wanting to meet demand because they are providing higher priced capacity from their operations in other states.
- londons_explore 10y agoIn a properly working market, at the point the power grid fails due to lack of supply, the spot price should be infinitely high. Given that, no sane supplier would refuse to sell given they would be making unlimited profit. Hey, I'd be connecting up my windup flashlight if I got paid $999,999,999 per kilowatt hour. The issue must be a bad market. Either people aren't paying for what they use, there isn't sufficient transmission capacity to have a sufficiently large market to avoid local monopolies, there are price caps or floors, the market isn't fast enough (no automated trading), or new entrants are limited from participating. In a correctly working market, electricity never fails because all people using electricity at the time of the failure would be paying an infinitely high price, and therefore be bankrupt.
- alextheparrot 10y agoMaybe the utility derived from having electricity doesn't make the good actually worth the prices you are saying? A seller makes no money if they price their good so far above market that there is no demand for it, not infinite.
- Callmenorm 10y agoYou're missing his point. Prices steadily go up as demand increases so suppliers bring on more (expensive) capacity to meet. You never get to the failure point unless demand exceeds all possible supply capacity. He just took this argument to the extreme.
- cstross 10y agoMusk quoted $25M for the batteries? I'm guessing that this escapade — if it works — is going to be more productive than $25M in marketing/advertising spend.
- mimo777 10y agoI doubt Australia's power problems have anything to do with technology.
- ehnto 10y agoThat is very arogant, even if I believe he could do it. Australian power issues are endemic to the regions unique requirements, and born out of long term political and economic policy discussions. I am honestly surprised that someone as smart as Elon wouldn't recognise both the crassness of a comment like that, and that he likely doesn't fully understand the political landscape that caused the situation. Good luck getting through the red tape and border crossing negotiations. To say nothing of the near 50 degree weather beating down on old infrastructre that spans thousands of very sparse kilometers. Edit: to clarify, it is arogant because he is stirring an already controversial pot in a country that is frankly none of his business. I am from the state that is enduring the power troubles, and the technology in use is not the core of the issue, it is the artificial market policies dictating the generation of power. Having batteries wouldn't solve that, as having people to pay for the energy generation is the mechanism that is actually broken.
- arbuge 10y agoOne possibility is that he realizes he won't be taken up on the offer, which also means that there's no chance he'll be tested on it. In the meantime, free publicity. His comment is on most major news channels today.
- marktangotango 10y agoIndeed, Musk is a showman. Early in spacex they put a falcon 1 on a trailer and drove it to Washington, D.C. Essentially a privately funded and built ballistic missile, on a trailer, in front of the capital building. That turned some heads. This was before it flew so 2002 or 2003.
- lorenzhs 10y agoFor more on that story, see http://www.thespacereview.com/article/70/1 http://www.thespacereview.com/article/70/1 (article has two pages, link to the second at the very bottom)
- 10y ago
- m23khan 10y agoWhy not take up a better challenge...solving Pakistan's power woes in 1 year :-D
- dkbrk 10y agoThe title does not follow from Elon's actual tweet. He promised to "get the system installed and working 100 days from contract signature". He does not guarantee that such an installation would be a panacea for all "Aussie Power Woes".
- smikhanov 10y agoThe article says he promises to deliver and install a working energy storage system in 100 days, not to fix the "woes". Brilliant PR move though: he just closed a $25M deal on Twitter and used this as a good publicity for himself.
- M_Grey 10y agoMusk is a true and absolute master of PR. He understands what each audience wants to hear, and also understands that his messages to each need to be consistent with each other. He paints himself as a dreamer reaching for the stars, while solving what problems we have on Earth. It's amazing... and the result is that people who would normally be suspicious of him, love him and truly want him to be their hero.
- forgot-my-pw 10y agoFunny, I feel his PR team is probably stressing out all the time.
- M_Grey 10y agoWhy? He talks about going to Mars and people who would normally grimace, swoon because they so want to believe it. If not for his constant PR assault, focus might actually shift from his dreams, to things like how he treats the people who work for him.
- woodandsteel 10y agoPart of the reason people trust him is that he is a tech genius who has done things the experts had agreed were impossible. On the other hand, the Koch brothers attack Musk as a fraud. https://www.theguardian.com/technology/2016/dec/04/elon-musk-trolling-us-conservatives-green-tech https://www.theguardian.com/technology/2016/dec/04/elon-musk... Perhaps you're with them?
- owenversteeg 10y agoI know nothing about the Australian power grid but I do know a fair bit about batteries. The cost of batteries and surrounding hardware here means that on this particular deal Musk is losing money. 100 days isn't a lot of time, and he needs to get about 1% of yearly global li-ion battery production to Australia, build surrounding hardware, AND install it in 3 months. It's definitely doable, and he's not giving out-of-this-world prices, but he is losing money here. It is completely worth it though: a lot of backup battery plants are hilariously overpriced and seeing "oh, this Australian company got 100mWh for $25MM, we paid $100MM for the same" will probably get some people thinking about switching to Tesla. Also worth noting that Tesla's battery costs will drop in the future, so if a utility company asks them in a year from now for the same $250/kWh rates they can probably get them. (Yes, I am 'that battery guy' that makes battery systems and comments on battery stuff a lot here.)
- windexh8er 10y agoAppreciate the insight. For edification who are the other big players Tesla would be ousting here? I'm curious to see if the public play has long term consequences for the competition. The transparency here is great, obviously it forces an interesting conversation for deals that are on the table for others - Musk likely made a bad weekend for some sales oriented folks in that space. And that's great for all of us long term (hopefully).
- schiffern 10y ago>he's not giving out-of-this-world prices, but he is losing money here Note that the quoted price of $250/kWh was given at the pack level (just the Powerpacks).[1] So the total project cost should be expected to exceed $25 million after including shipping, tariffs, site preparation, installation, bidirectional inverters, and interconnection. >build surrounding hardware, AND install it in 3 months The nice thing about the Powerpack is that they need very little surrounding hardware. The units are rated for outdoor installation, and they just forklift into place to a concrete pad. A group of Powerpacks (4-8) shares a common bidi inverter, which is wired to the grid interconnect on site. Done. The obvious thing to do would be to construct a building to house the packs and protect them from the elements, but I'm not sure that makes economic sense. These are exothermic devices when operating, so a big challenge will be cooling and ventilating the building. And if you're making a building just to spend capital and energy to ventilate it, was it really worth it to enclose weatherized equipment? It might make sense in hot climates to put a solar "carport" over the batteries to shade them and reduce cooling load. Tesla has one that's supposed to be cheap to install.[2] I expect the economically "right" answer (open air install, solar canopy, or prefab building) depends on local climate, expected battery duty cycle, and financing. Not to mention factors like your boss saying "100 days or it's free." ;) >he needs to get about 1% of yearly global li-ion battery production to Australia In 2013 Tesla gave global production as 34 GWh of cells.[3] 100 MWh works out to 0.29%, and I don't expect cell production has gone DOWN since 2013. So if you're looking for an order-of-magnitude, 0.1% would be less wrong (in both the multiplicative and the additive sense). The completed Gigafactory is expected to produce 150 GWh/year, so this is only 0.06% of that. Unfortunately I haven't seen reliable numbers about the production volume at present (with about 14% of the planned 13.6 million ft^2 footprint completed, and probably half of that outfitted for production). I naively estimate the Gigafactory is currently producing at about 2% planned final capacity, so 100 MWh represents around 12 days of production. [1] https://twitter.com/elonmusk/status/840096176678420481 https://twitter.com/elonmusk/status/840096176678420481 [2] http://www.solarcity.com/newsroom/press/solarcity%E2%80%99s-new-zs-beam-solar-carport-system-makes-it-faster-cheaper-easier-and-safer http://www.solarcity.com/newsroom/press/solarcity%E2%80%99s-... [3] https://c1cleantechnicacom-wpengine.netdna-ssl.com/files/2014/09/image2.jpg https://c1cleantechnicacom-wpengine.netdna-ssl.com/files/201...
- Taylor_OD 10y agoWe live in an age where multi million dollar government contract deals are happening publicly on Twitter. Amazing.
- will_hughes 10y agoNeither person mentioned in the article are in government.
- CodeSheikh 10y agoMusk wants to capture market. And these days "100 days" is a good term to through around when it comes to meeting expectations and deadlines. But if anyone can do it it is still Elon Musk as of now.
- dghf 10y agoThere's an irritating mix-up between power and energy throughout the article and in the tweets it's sourced from. Cannon-Brookes asks for a 100 MW (power) system; Musk responds with a price of $250 per kWh (energy), based on a >= 100 MWh (again, energy) system. Retail price for electricity in South Australia is on the order of AU$0.30 - AU$0.40 per kWh (~US$0.23 - US$0.30), so it's presumably a typo on Musk's part; but the article repeats and compounds it by talking about Tesla supplying "up to 100 megawatt hours of power". (If I've done my sums right, 100 MWh is about the amount of electricity produced in Australia as a whole every 15 seconds, on average.)
- khana 10y agoI love this guy!