12 ms·
John Carmack is suing ZeniMax
- kar1181 10y agoI feel like there needs to be a sequel or at least epilogue to masters of doom when the dust finally settles on all this.
- teej 10y agoIf you're looking for something in the iterim, noclip produced a documentary on the making of Doom (2016) that's pretty engaging. It briefly discusses the Zenimax lawsuit but doesn't go deep into it.
- eriknstr 10y agoDOOM Resurrected, Part 1 - To Hell & Back (DOOM Documentary) - https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=PS6SBnccxMA https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=PS6SBnccxMA DOOM Resurrected, Part 2 - Designing a First Impression (Doom Documentary) - https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=vsoVQWnSOfM https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=vsoVQWnSOfM DOOM Resurrected, Part 3 - Guns, Guitars & Chess on Mars (Doom Documentary) - https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=r0nOsuaPDeg https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=r0nOsuaPDeg I too recommend these. Noclip also has a bunch of extended interviews that you can find on their channel or in related videos but I haven't seen those so can't comment on whether or not they are worth looking at.
- KPLauritzen 10y agoThe interview with Hugo Martin, the creative director of DOOM, is great - https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=LVLecokaRv4 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=LVLecokaRv4
- kar1181 10y agoThank you so much - love this stuff.
- aresant 10y agoI bet that Zenimax will claim that due to the issues surrounding the Oculus case Carmack failed the covenants required to collect his 50% earn out mentioned in Carmack's complaint. EDIT - Another commentor posted the original complaint and this is exactly why Zenimax is not paying "ZeniMax’s stated basis for its failure to comply with the Convertible Promissory Note is a series of allegations regarding claimed violations of Mr. Carmack’s Employment Agreement and ZeniMax’s alleged intellectual property rights."(1) A jury of "peers" found Oculus at fault in several key areas in Zenimax's last complaint, and Carmack was central in that story. When Zenimax sued Oculus - the VR community responded with overwhelming support for Oculus, casting Zenimax as the greedy corporation trying to get a slice. Zenimax's original complaint - of which a Jury saw enough truth in to award $500m to Zenimax - is more or less as follows: - Zenimax bought ID software for >$100m on June 24, 2009. - Carmack signed up with Zenimax for an earn-out / golden-handcuffs agreement that ended in June of 2013. - Carmack was enthralled with VR. - Carmack found Palmer via an internet forum, reached out to get a rift to try. - Carmack tinkered with the Rift, adding sensors, building calibration, etc. while on the clock / using hardware from zenimax. - Carmack brought a prototype of the Rift working on Doom 3 to E3 with him providing Oculus with their early press. - Zenimax realized the extent to which Carmack was enabling Oculus and worked to negotiate equity with Brendan Iribe. - Oculus sent Zenimax a proposal to discuss a partnership Sept 21, 2012 but never followed up / followed through. - Carmack quit Zenimax the day his contract was up in June 2013, joined Oculus as CTO a few months later and took his 5 best guys with him. - FB bought Oculus March 2014, Zenmix got pissed and sued. When Zenimax responds to this new complaint from Carmack it's a foregone conclusion that they will re-raise this "bad behavior" and likely point to non-competitive clauses attached to the "earn out" as non-performing. I love Carmack and his contributions to our world, I am concerned that Zenimax may out lawyer him. PS - Fun fact - two of Zenimax's board members are Cal Ripken, Jr. (hall of fame baseball player) and Robert S. Trump - brother to our current president. EDIT - Changed first sentence for clarity of my point. (1) https://www.scribd.com/document/341420632/John-Carmack-vs-ZeniMax-Media#from_embed https://www.scribd.com/document/341420632/John-Carmack-vs-Ze...
- pvg 10y agoCarmack is suing them over a compensation issue. None of the '-'s and fun facts appear directly related.
- hayd 10y agoDoes the author even read the article after copying and pasting the press release? > Instead Carmack is suing Zenimax Media for $22.5 million that he says has not been paid to him for the 2009 sale of his game studio, id Software, known for such pioneering video game classics as Doom and Quake. > The lawsuit reveals that ZeniMax Media paid $150 million for the game studio behind such pioneering video gaming classics as Doom and Quake. Subsequent sentences. FFS.
- coolsunglasses 10y agoYou don't usually own 100% of a game studio that is that old when it is sold.
- taspeotis 10y agoI believe GP is complaining about what's in italics - "such pioneering video game classics as Doom and Quake" appears twice in subsequent sentences. (It's redundant.)
- jbreckmckye 10y ago> Subsequent sentences. FFS. You are outraged that the writer missed a duplication (that happened in draft, no doubt) during a copyedit stage? I have some news for you: publishers in 2017 do not enjoy the economic conditions to either give journalists time to polish their work or hire dedicated copyeditors.
- a13n 10y ago
- gpm 10y agoOriginal article which contains a copy of the complaint is available here [0]. Direct link to the complaint here [1]. [0] http://www.dallasnews.com/business/technology/2017/03/09/legal-feud-over-facebook-owned-oculus-has-another-dallas-chapter http://www.dallasnews.com/business/technology/2017/03/09/leg... [1] https://www.scribd.com/document/341420632/John-Carmack-vs-ZeniMax-Media#from_embed https://www.scribd.com/document/341420632/John-Carmack-vs-Ze...
- pmarreck 10y agoHe seems like a stand-up guy to me (not that that implies innocence), so this is of course mostly a misunderstanding from what I can tell (since two well-meaning people can still end up in a lawsuit over misunderstandings)
- jacquesm 10y agoI find it hard to believe that someone as smart and well versed in copyright and patent law as Carmack would not be able to understand the terms of his employment contract.
- tracker1 10y agoBecause you often expect people to actually be reasonable... despite the fine print.
- sunwooz 10y agoAlso, because he's human, and they all unfortunately make dumb mistakes.
- LoSboccacc 10y agoNor that an aqui-hire of a succesful studio like id software would go down unlawyered.
- pmarreck 10y agoWow. I missed the "unlawyered" part. If so, that was dumb.
- erikbye 10y agoWhy do you say he is well-versed in copyright and patent law? He has always been vocally against patents and even threatened to leave id Software back in the day if they started patenting. He is a known proponent for open source and have released a lot of source code for their games. I do not think he is well-versed in this at all, because he basically wants nothing to do with it.
- misty_tech 10y agowow that's interesting.
- danm07 10y agoThese types of things really irritate me. Corporate NDA agreements are total shams. We couldn't hire a P/T contractor because the engineer signed an NDA agreement with his company that pretty much said everything he developed, verbalized, or put to paper -- during work or after -- was IP of that company, irrespective of whether it had anything to do with its products. Even as an employer, I find this an absolute outrage.
- tehlike 10y agoWhat state was this at? I would question its legality/enforcability.
- alextheparrot 10y agoFor anyone searching for a relevant California clause [0]. [0] https://leginfo.legislature.ca.gov/faces/codes_displaySection.xhtml?lawCode=LAB§ionNum=2870 https://leginfo.legislature.ca.gov/faces/codes_displaySectio....
- 824ueirwfjd 10y agothat's not enforceable if it's in California, other states possibly as well...
- z3t4 10y agocreative work is a 24h job. you will get ideas even when you sleep. closing tickets and programming however is not and then such a contract would be outrageous. make sure you are paid for 24h and not 8h. or go home early every day stating that your contract say you can work from home on anything you want.
- danm07 10y agoI get that and at my company, we restrict IP to the realm of our product line, and products developed using our resources. If our business sold sewing machines, I wouldn't expect the guy to hand over his encryption algorithm if he built it at home using his personal laptop.
- rongway 10y ago"serious injury" hah, what a joke
- aligna 10y agoIt's not a joke, it's standard legal verbiage.
- wsc981 10y agoAt least Carmack won't be sued by Jordan Mechner, he dodged a bullet there: https://twitter.com/ID_AA_Carmack/status/837127224675328000 https://twitter.com/ID_AA_Carmack/status/837127224675328000
- ChuckMcM 10y agoI find it interesting that ZeniMax wins 500M from Facebook where Carmack works, and then Carmack sues Zenimax and if he wins gets $22M which one would presume they would use some of the $500M for. It is kind of like getting $22M from your own employer the long way around.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- merraksh 10y agoInstead Carmack is suing Zenimax Media for $22.5 million that he says has not been paid to him for the 2009 sale of his game studio, id Software, known for such pioneering video game classics as Doom and Quake. The lawsuit reveals that ZeniMax Media paid $150 million for the game studio behind such pioneering video gaming classics as Doom and Quake. Off topic, but I'm disappointed in the quality of writing: why repeating "such pioneering video gaming classics as Doom and Quake"? I get the impression that the article was either written in a rush or just mixed up (in a rush) from other sources.
- 6stringmerc 10y agoI thought this was about the Oculus / NDA issue and it very much is not in the legal sense, and I'm not really surprised to find out what the real situation is in this case. As Carmack's musing on Facebook pointed out, he didn't like the outcome but he didn't have any grounding to factually dispute the NDA. So, tough as it may be, they lost. This is about getting what is owed in contracts. Essentially the opposite side of the coin to an NDA (Can vs. Can't Do) and I hope he wins if he is truly being ripped off.
- dsschnau 10y agooff topic: I had no idea John Carmack was so fit!
- kafeltz 10y agohttps://twitter.com/ID_AA_Carmack/status/840231319082754049 https://twitter.com/ID_AA_Carmack/status/840231319082754049