11 ms·
“Alcohol and caffeine created civilization”
- sametmax 10y agoPeople drink alcohol because it's a social lubricant. Mostly to ease acceptance or improve the chance of sex. And coffee because of fatigue. It's not rocket science. It has not "created civilization", merely compensated civilization flaws.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- bigbugbag 10y agoThis article title is quite the outrageous claim akin to clickbait, claim that's not substantiated in the article content. Actually the content says: "research suggests that alcohol may have helped create civilization itself" which is far from what the titles claims but fails to provide source about this supposed research. Reading this felt like a piece of entertainment based on opinion, much confusion and stuff that does not make much sense: in times before humans could purify water and prepare food but they somehow where able to brew beer, correlation of events made into causal link and so on. How does this kind of crap gets to HN front page ?
- beloch 10y agoThere's nothing new about the "beer theory of civilization", although this article doesn't really explain it very well. Perhaps the most compelling aspect of it is that it explains how we domesticated crops in the first place. Consider the wild antecedent of maize(corn): teosinte. It's basically grass. It's "cobs", if they can truly even be called that, are tiny. You simply couldn't settle down and try to grow this stuff and be able to actually feed yourself. The yield of edible material is just too tiny. You'd spend more calories growing the stuff than you'd get back out of it. It took thousands of years of selective breeding to yield a crop that would make agriculture viable, so how the hell did we do that when there were no farmers? Beer. While it's not practical to settle in one spot and try to grow teosinte for food, it is possible to gather up enough wild teosinte to make a small amount of chicha (a fermented drink similar to beer). Tedious and painful, but possible. Hunter-gatherers who developed a taste for chicha likely learned they could save time by saving some of the seeds they gathered and scattering them in areas where they'd grow well. Return to the same spot in a year and the next batch of chicha will be easier to make! Selective breeding was a next step. The important notion here is that, because they were making chicha, these hunter-gatherers had motivation to save themselves time and effort without actually having to rely on a crop that was not able to feed them enough calories to pay back the effort expended on it. Thus, humans didn't have to magically peer thousands of years into the future and start domesticating crops so that agriculture would one day become possible. They just had to like beer and be lazy.
- zeveb 10y ago> They just had to like beer and be lazy. Fortunately, this is something that ancient & modern men alike excel at! It is kinda funny to think that a prime reason for us developing advanced societies, civilisation & technology is also a prime factor in damage to society, uncivilised behaviour & destruction.
- posterboy 10y agoat least in the beginning, more likely then premediated spreading the seeds is accidentally planting in dung, if you know what I mean.
- kozak 10y agoWhat concentration of alcohol has to be in water to make it resistant to getting stale? E.g. if I have ethanol and drinkable water, how much should I add to get the water protected from the bacteria without turning it into a serious alcoholic drink?
- mrob 10y agoThere's no fixed threshold. It depends on the alcohol tolerance of the microbes that happen to be present. 2% ABV might make a noticeable difference. 20% ABV will probably last forever. However, it's not just the alcohol acting as a preservative, it's also the yeast using up other things microbes need, such as nitrogen sources ( https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Yeast_assimilable_nitrogen https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Yeast_assimilable_nitrogen ). 100% malt beer wort usually contains more than the yeast needs, but fruit juice, honey, and adjunct-heavy beer wort can have lower levels, and even in the 100% malt case the yeast might be able to use all of it. The yeast will use up vitamins and minerals too. It can be a problem if it means the yeast stops working before all the sugar is fermented ("stuck fermentation"), but adding excessive nutrients is also bad, because they'll make the final product more hospitable to other microbes.
- arxpoetica 10y agoThe article briefly mentions a new study done on mice that can "affect the mind as adversely as cocaine." But nowhere (that I can find) is the study cited. Can anyone find the study or does anyone know what study is being cited?
- noosphere2017 10y agoBut "cannabis and psilocybin created religion" http://www.botany.hawaii.edu/faculty/wong/BOT135/Lect20b.htm http://www.botany.hawaii.edu/faculty/wong/BOT135/Lect20b.htm
- dieg0 10y agotea is awesome. In the US peeps don't drink it because there isn't any good ones available... this is crazy, not even trader joe's or new seasons carry good ones. I drink herbal teas every day, and during my time in the US it's one of the things I missed the most. Also, maybe this is only me, but coffee gives me diarrhea.. lol
- Avshalom 10y agoit's likely that it's not diarrhea exactly it's just that caffeine (in any form coffee is just the most concentrated that most people drink) promotes/causes peristalsis. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Caffeine#Side_effects https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Caffeine#Side_effects
- michael_h 10y ago"In the US peeps don't drink it because there isn't any good ones available" The internet has taken care of that. Also, the Canadians have been supplying us with Red Rose for more than a century, which, while not top of the line, is a highly acceptable everyday bag tea. Also, you can get PG Tips pretty much everywhere. Edit: To be clear, I'm not holding up RedRose and PG as the pinnacle of teadom - they're just very acceptable and available widely.
- HeyLaughingBoy 10y agoA Chinese friend of mine brought me what he said was very high quality tea when he went back to China to visit his parents. I like tea, but I honestly couldn't tell the difference between it and the stuff I get at the supermarket.
- thunder-ltu 10y agoI say, people created civilization, take That. Logic.
- thadk 10y agoThis chapter of Calestous Juma's new book on pushbacks around innovations has a fascinating chapter about how coffee and coffeehouses were like a kind of social media product that got banned and unbanned from its introduction in the 1500s Middle East to Europe and USA: https://books.google.com/books?id=i5dHDAAAQBAJ&q=Coffee#v=snippet&q=Coffee&f=false https://books.google.com/books?id=i5dHDAAAQBAJ&q=Coffee#v=sn...
- keithwhor 10y agoInteresting. My first thought was, "well, they've certainly helped create hundreds if not thousands of startups."
- astrodust 10y agoIt certainly created the very first start-up: The idea of growing crops. To a hunter-gatherer the very idea seemed stupid, so much time spent planting and tilling when you could go out and beat something with a club and have dinner in minutes. You can't really forage for alcohol. You have to farm it. Then the hunter-gatherers were probably interested in trading for alcohol and the economy was born.
- andrepd 10y agoThose are some really wild unsubstantiated guesses :^)
- aaron695 10y agoBut like Jared Diamond it is entertaining.
- RangerScience 10y agoSounds like a good start to a http://bahfest.com/ http://bahfest.com/ submission!
- luhn 10y agoFallen fruit can ferment and apparently it's not uncommon for wild animals to get drunk from it. So you can forage for alcohol ;) http://www.smithsonianmag.com/science-nature/the-alcoholics-of-the-animal-world-81007700/ http://www.smithsonianmag.com/science-nature/the-alcoholics-...
- astrodust 10y agoThere was a cherry tree in the backyard of a house I used to live in and every year the fruit would get funky and ferment. Birds and squirrels would make a habit of eating it and the backyard would be filled birds all flopping around and squirrels trying but mostly failing to find their way up trees. They knew what they were getting into, and they indulged. For about one week a year it was like a frat house out there. I can imagine people discovered the principle there, but brewing on a more industrial scale is necessary to provide a steady supply. Just about anything can be fermented, but that proecess takes time to do properly. It's a form of farming. So yeah, you can forage for it, but you'll get so little it's barely worth the trouble.
- andrepd 10y agoThe "beer as a safe alternative to water" is likely a myth. See https://www.reddit.com/r/AskHistorians/comments/1yts0v/comment/cfnrg32 https://www.reddit.com/r/AskHistorians/comments/1yts0v/comme...
- mc32 10y agoIt's likely a myth with regard to the middle ages, but what about ancient times --ie Roman, Greek, Egyptian, etc? These places had urban centers.
- bigbugbag 10y agoIf they had urban centers, then they had civilization already debunking the claim.
- peterwwillis 10y agoAncient (specifically Roman) civilizations had fantastic systems to transport water and even developed indoor plumbing. They didn't need to augment their water quality with wine. Wine was simply made ubiquitous due to their civilization determining that it should be enjoyed by everyone. Of course there are stories of soldiers augmenting pond water with wine, but this could have been as much to make it more palatable as preventing oneself from getting sick. Here's a paper that talks about Ancient thoughts on water: https://issuu.com/eajournal/docs/articulo_-_van_tillburg_-_drinking_ https://issuu.com/eajournal/docs/articulo_-_van_tillburg_-_d... Basically, humans have for a really freaking long time been able to determine whether water is basically more or less safe to drink, and have not really worried about it more than any other thing (and certainly not drank beer or wine because they feared for the quality of the water)
- mirimir 10y agoA counterexample is cholera. http://www.ph.ucla.edu/epi/snow/choleratheories.html http://www.ph.ucla.edu/epi/snow/choleratheories.html
- 10y ago
- blakesterz 10y agoGastropod has a really neat episode where they talk the history of coffee and caffeine and how it came to (and changed) Europe. https://gastropod.com/caffeine/ https://gastropod.com/caffeine/
- mirimir 10y ago> "... Those who drank coffee instead of alcohol began the day alert and stimulated, rather than relaxed and mildly inebriated, and the quality and quantity of their work improved … Western Europe began to emerge from an alcoholic haze that had lasted for centuries.” That's quite a claim. So did prior high-tech civilizations have equivalents? Tea in China, of course. But others?
- lostboys67 10y agoI think I have heard of this thing called "the renaissance" :-)
- srcreigh 10y agoFor what it's worth, as recently as early 17th century England did not have coffee. If you grant that the difference in caffeine between coffee and tea is significant, then we can conclude that Western Europe must have received those benefits only by the 1650's - 1700's. Source: 25. The Turks use likewise a kind of herb, called " coffee," which they dry, grind to powder, and drink in warm water. They affirm that it gives no small vigour both to their courage and their wit. Yet this taken in large quantities will excite and disturb the mind; which shows it to be of a similar nature to opiates. from Francis Bacon in The History of Life and Death, published in 1638 posthumously. You can read the full work here: http://www.sirbacon.org/historylifedeath.htm http://www.sirbacon.org/historylifedeath.htm
- BurningFrog 10y agoThe Industrial Revolution started around 1760 in Britain, so the timeline looks plausible.
- taway_1212 10y agoThe Turks already had coffee, so why the industrial revolution didn't start there earlier?
- 10y ago
- peterwwillis 10y agoCaffeine (and other stimulants) have been traded by many civilizations over many millennia in different areas of the world, and have not always given rise to technological progress. In addition, progress in the methods of creating alcohol have often been a side-effect of growing civilizations, not a cause for them. The article makes an argument that here we humans were, dumb and boring, and suddenly we decided to create a means to produce certain products, and then we created trade routes for these products, and then suddenly this caused civilization to flourish, as if the presence of civilization was not necessary for these things to happen to begin with. It's like saying "the horseless carriage developed America", as if America didn't exist before it was created, to say nothing of paved roads. Clickbaity clickbait.
- 11thEarlOfMar 10y ago> "and the quality and quantity of their work improved" I've always said that I owe my career, what there is of it, to caffeine. I guess I wasn't kidding.
- Rainymood 10y ago>I've always said that I owe my career, what there is of it, to #DRUGOFCHOICE. I guess I wasn't kidding. Kinda weird how caffeine, still technically a drug like speed/ritalin/adderal etc, is so accepted in today's society. Sorry if I'm mixing up drugs with active ingredients I know very little about drugs.
- exprA 10y agoYou'd think you should be more confused about how alcohol is as accepted as it is. I feel more pity for the way people still want to impose control over other folks life – and quietly dream of the day more people accepted that substance abuse is the problem, not the substances themselves (and gave more room for personal responsibility and different choices in life). I personally don't see a fundamental difference in people turning away from society for e.g. spiritual reasons, or because they want to get high, but think they should only do so if they can afford it wholly by themselves. (I do accept if assistance – financial, etc.. - comes with obligations.)
- koverstreet 10y agoI know I owe my career to adderall.
- charlesism 10y ago> No two drugs have defined human civilization the > way alcohol and caffeine have. Tobacco? As much as one can quantify it, I'd argue it played as large a role as coffee up until a few decades ago. Possibly larger. Not that I'm planning on starting :)
- qeternity 10y agoOnce you factor is the geopolitical effects due to cash crop trade and production, I think you'd certainly be right.
- rangibaby 10y agoNot a drug, but wars have been fought over spice (in real life).
- magic_beans 10y agoSalt too!
- lostlogin 10y agoBut don't be forgetting Dune or Dune II. It was so fantastic.
- rangibaby 10y agoin real life, too ;-)
- devoply 10y agoTobacco and Coffee were both discovered in the new world. Civilization is much older than either of these discoveries by Europeans for Europeans. It was used by Indigenous Americans up to 1000 BC. But no one else knew about it.
- jalayir 10y agoCoffee is from Ethiopia. Maybe you're thinking of chocolate.
- zeteo 10y agoOr rather "alcohol bad, caffeine good". The author is from Cato Institute - are they planning to bring Prohibition back now? Anyway here are a few major holes in the story. - "People drank alcohol because it was safer than water". If you want safe water, all you have to do is boil it. A lot simpler than beer brewing. - "People became smarter after the Englightenment and started drinking coffee instead of alcohol". How about drinking coffee in addition to alcohol? The coffee houses developed in parallel with the beer houses, not instead of them. We recently had an article on HN that made the point that alcohol consumption actually increased in the 19th century. - "Adam Smith was so smart because he drank coffee". He also drank lots of wine - preferably Bordeaux (or claret, as they called it in Scotland). Some of the most bitter passages in Wealth of Nations are directed against the British government using taxation to promote port wine (Portugal was a British ally) over claret (France was usually an enemy).
- gambiting 10y ago- "People drank alcohol because it was safer than water" This has literally never been proven to be true. Just one of the myths invented recently.
- mfukar 10y agoIt's interesting that you use quotes that don't appear in the text, because if passing those messages was the intention of the writer they succeeded beautifully.
- empath75 10y agoGiven that the Cato institute is strongly in favor of legalization, I doubt they want to ban alcohol.
- NoGravitas 10y agoIf I recall, gin was the crack/meth of its day, in the 18th century. As immortalized in Hogarth's Gin Lane.
- flukus 10y ago> "People drank alcohol because it was safer than water". If you want safe water, all you have to do is boil it. A lot simpler than beer brewing. Easy to say when you know about germ theory. > The coffee houses developed in parallel with the beer houses, not instead of them. We recently had an article on HN that made the point that alcohol consumption actually increased in the 19th century. The usage was very different though wasn't it? With beer halls people weren't drinking when they were working, they were drinking after work.
- Jach 10y agoAs Yang Wenli says... "Alcohol is humanity's friend. Can I abandon a friend? Humans were drinking alcohol five thousand years ago. And they're still drinking it now. And five thousand years from now, they'll be drinking alcohol. Although it's unlikely there will be a human race in five thousand years." (https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=E_YxauHnpyg https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=E_YxauHnpyg) I don't partake, and think if any drug ought to be illegal it should be alcohol for the damage it has caused, but then I wonder what humanity would look like if our brains didn't respond to it any more than water.
- jnordwick 10y ago"The History of the World in Six Glasses" by Tom Standage lays out a similar time line. He breaks the world into two sections - alcohol and caffeine - and each of those into three periods: beer, wine, spirits, coffee, tea, and soda. Each period be described how the drink became so important. It's a very interesting and quick read. https://books.google.com/books/about/A_History_of_the_World_in_Six_Glasses.html?id=P-_3AgAACAAJ&hl=en https://books.google.com/books/about/A_History_of_the_World_...
- trhway 10y ago10M years ago a primate developed ability to efficiently metabolize alcohol and that primate became common ancestor of humans, chimpanzees, and gorillas. So, yes, alcohol was key ingredient that led to creation of our civilization.
- Nano2rad 10y agoAlcohol consumers and old people tell the truth. Youth are not able to decipher the truth, even if they do they cannot tell.
- sn41 10y agoThis seems an inane and oversimplified view. Sure, coffee would have helped. But ignoring colonization, and its huge positive impact on Western Europe and negative impact elsewhere, and concluding that industrialization is a corollary of a stimulant is strange. I think these kind of "historians" rarely bother to place themselves in historical context. This article seems right in the much derided class of insight porn articles. I believe history is not the result of "one minor cause" - you could write articles equally myopic that the Chinese invention of sailing against the wind created civilization, gunpowder created civilization, double-entry bookkeeping created civilization, steam power created civilization, better glasswork and telescopes created civilization, etc. It was not one thing by itself, but probably everything together.
- dublinclontarf 10y ago> and negative impact elsewhere This is factually incorrect. The USA, Canada, Australia and NewZealand we're colonies. Certainly under British rule colonisation had a hugely positive impact.
- allendoerfer 10y agoFor the Europeans, who moved there. The original inhabitants might think different. In their point of view, these colonies actually were the most devastating.
- waqf 10y agoBut leaving aside whether the advantages accrued to one ethnic group or another, didn't colonization increase the economic output on those land masses? Overall, I mean (unquestionably it was destructive too).
- sn41 10y agoI can speak about India. India went from controlling 25% of the world's output in the 1500s to controlling 2% of the world's output in 1947. Till about 1900, Indians were banned from starting industries. Just so that you don't think that Indians had no industries, the first Fellow of the Royal Society from India was a shipbuilder [1]. British colonization was devastating for Indian commerce. You can argue that it is only now hobbling back to normalcy. On balance, British did introduce railways, which was instrumental in unifying the country, and a unified legal system. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ardaseer_Cursetjee https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ardaseer_Cursetjee
- EugeneOZ 10y agoIf Homo sapiens survived because of alcohol and coffee, monkey survived because of skills, then who is smarter? Not author of this article.
- dnprock 10y agoNot true. No alcohol in Islamic sphere. No caffeine in East Asia. You still got civilizations developed.