10 ms·
VMware joins Linux Foundation: what about the GPL?
- bykovich 10y agoI gotta say that I think this is just not a big deal for most people. I understand that FOSS ideals have appeal, I understand why people would like them to be protected -- but at the end of the day, I do feel like FOSS advocates, as well-meaning as they are, are perhaps investing their concern in the wrong place. FOSS rhetoric is nice, but it just doesn't seem that important.
- rrdharan 10y agoI'm very biased, since I worked at VMware for nine years. Nonetheless I disagree with you. I think it's worth actually pursuing this and settling the VMware situation clearly. Uncertainty is rarely a good thing for anyone in these kind of situations, and so I'm disappointed that there still hasn't been a real ruling on the merits of the case. Personally I remain convinced that the vmklinux/shim usage pattern is ok by the letter of the license, but I can understand Harald Welte and Christopher Hellwig's viewpoint.
- mikekchar 10y agoAs much as I agree with you, I think it is unlikely to be cleared up to any great extent. In my mind, the main question of whether or not VMware is in violation of the GPL rests pretty squarely on whether or not it is a derived work. That definition, in a legal sense (AFAICT -- I'm not a lawyer) is intentionally vague. Potential violations in this sense will almost certainly have to be tested on a case by case basis. Which is frustrating for everyone. Like you, I hope for a speedy resolution of the VMware situation, but I'm not so confident that such a resolution will shine much light on similar issues in the future.
- yuhong 10y agoThe entire fiasco started with Linux Foundation pulling funding to SFLC.
- alfalfasprout 10y agoinb4 the Stallman disciples descend upon this comment. The things with FOSS is there are different degrees of rigidity. On the one hand, you have copyleft licenses like GPL that tend to make commercial development very tricky. On the other hand you have more permissive licenses like MIT and Apache that do encourage further open source work but where the vast majority of improvements don't get committed back upstream (since they become a part of proprietary offerings).
- jasonkostempski 10y agoThat's the difference between OSS and Free software. One focuses just on the benefits of working openly, the other is about making sure the user have full control of what their machine does. Open Source is a side effect of Free and it's a selling point to creators but the consumer is the priority. Edit: To be clear I'm talking more about philosophy, not licensing. I do still struggle with the idea of GPL requiring changes to be made public.
- lolc 10y agoGPLv2 does not require you to make your source changes public, it only demands that this remains an option for anybody who acquires a license from you. So if I sell you software under the GPL, I have to provide you the source. You are then allowed, but not required, to publish the source.
- latj 10y agoWhat is tricky about using GPL for commercial development?
- cyraxjoe 10y agoIf you modify some free software, repackage and resell it without contributing the changes, then you are breaking the intentional viral effects of the license. Most of the web stuff that people work on these days is rather outside of this problem, unless is an AGPL license. It is tricky if you want to base your commercial product on a derivation of a GPL licensed software.
- johnmertic 10y agoI see this article that cover's Linus's thoughts as an insightful counterpoint... http://www.zdnet.com/article/linus-torvaldss-love-hate-relationship-with-the-gpl/ http://www.zdnet.com/article/linus-torvaldss-love-hate-relat... Net-net, I struggle to get more worked up about GPL compliance than the author of the affected open source compliance.
- e12e 10y agoI find this stance odd to say the least. I'd be happy to throw out copyright (and copyleft along with it) -- but to only enforce classical copyright, and not enforce copyleft? That's crazy. Are you also advocating ignoring OS X license terms (ie: do you advocate running a bought copy of OS X in a vm on non-apple hardware to build iOS/OS X applications)? Pirate Microsoft Windows, SQL Server - or run Oracle databases without paying a license fee? If not, I can't see how you can support not following the rather simple copyleft licenses. If a company don't want to leverage all the years of developer effort that is given away for free with the Linux kernel - they're free to invest the millions of dollars worth of work to write their own kernel. I mean, if a grad student could write the Linux kernel in the early 90s, surely VMware can write an OS kernel today?
- bykovich 10y agoMan, defraud multibillion-dollar corporations all you want. I'm absolutely fine with that.
- latj 10y agoSo many people take FLOSS for granted- especially in a place like this where most people are just trying to figure out how to get equity in the next pied piper. The bottom line is that everyone's life is better because of FLOSS. So many of us owe our careers to an army of forgotten programmers who share their time and brain power to build software for the public domain. If offers artists in other countries an alternative to expensive software like photoshop. It allows a startup to lower the cost of opening a call center by not having to buy Windows licenses. The cancer researchers trying to find a personalized treatment for your colon cancer use FLOSS. Your state government uses software from Microsoft and Oracle. And even those are affected by and improved due to the existence of FLOSS. I know you wont understand this. But there are a lot of kids reading this too and they should know not everyone agrees with you.
- bykovich 10y agoNo, I benefit from free software every day. I'm glad that there's software that isn't encumbered by expensive licensing schemes. What I'm taking issue with is free software orthodoxy, or with the notion that there is some sort of "ethical" issue at play with software that is different from the ethical issues at play with the usage and distribution of /any/ kind of product. "Software freedom" is an odd end-unto-itself.
- mi100hael 10y ago> I gotta say that I think this is just not a big deal for most people. I'm assuming by "people" you mean pirates like VMWare or mindless end users like yourself, since it's a huge deal for developers. When I make the conscious decision to license my work for others to use under the GPL instead of something completely permissive like MIT, I clearly don't want some commercial enterprise ripping off my work and using it to line their own pockets without even contributing back their modifications.
- bykovich 10y agoI agree that that is irksome. That being said, we're all victimized by commercial enterprises constantly -- it's difficult to see /this/ particular violation as uniquely worthy of outrage (although I confess that this is not a particularly good argument that FOSS violations are uniquely /un/worthy of outrage).
- starkruzr 10y agoYou could substitute any number of important principles in for "FOSS" here and the same group of people would nod soberly and/or disaffectedly at it. FOSS makes the Internet possible at lower cost and with more innovation than it would be without it. Full stop.
- scandox 10y agoI gotta say this comment makes me feel I like I need to take this a lot more seriously than I have been.
- crpatino 10y agoCould you elaborate? What specific concerns you disagree with? What are the importation issues that, in your opinion, FOSS advocates fail to take into account?
- ygaf 10y agoAbiding by licenses is a big deal, and as far as the article is concerned VMWare haven't. I'm anti-GPL, anti-RMS, but find it as obnoxious as anyone else when a company not only goes with breaking the GPL, but admits it and discards all civility ("take us to court").
- mtgx 10y ago> It sends the following messages: - you can abuse Linux, the GPL and copyleft while still being accepted amidst the Linux Foundation Members - it means the Linux Foundations has no ethical concerns whatsoever about accepting such entities without previously asking them to become clean - it also means that VMware has still not understood that Linux and FOSS is about your actions, particularly the kind of choices you make how to technically work with the community, and not against it. I think all of those apply to Microsoft, too. The Linux Foundation tainted its image when it accepted Microsoft without even demanding that it "becomes clean," as the author says, in regards to its exploitative use of patents against OEMs that dare to use Linux-based operating systems.
- AlexeyBrin 10y agoMicrosoft provides a lot of open source software with open source licenses, usually MIT.
- ergo14 10y agoMicrosoft also threatens lawsuits to Android companies if I'm not mistaken.
- cestith 10y agoThat's purportedly over patents, not copyright. They're probably weak claims, but it has nothing to do with GPLv2 vs. GPLv3 vs. MIT vs. BSD vs. Apache vs. any other license. It has to do with not getting patent suit indemnification from Google. Google did go to court multiple times for copyright claims from Snoracle.
- monochromatic 10y agoAnd?
- ergo14 10y agoAnd I find it interesting that people suddenly claim MS is now the "good guy" and is friendly to OS community.
- arca_vorago 10y agoGPLv3 is the fix, but Torvalds refuses to apply it to linux... root of the problem imho. When I can have a gplv2 linux on my samsung TV that gets rooted by the CIA but I can't root it without bricking it, you know it's time to switch to gplv3.
- AlexeyBrin 10y agoAre you seriously claiming that GPLv3 could protect you from CIA ?
- jeffmcjunkin 10y agoI think arca_vorago is just commenting on the difficulty of seeing the code to make his or her own modifications to the TV because of GPLv2, and saying that the barrier to entry is considerably higher, such that groups like the CIA can modify the software for nefarious purposes.
- true_religion 10y agoI feel like they'd just apply the software through their partners, then when anyone complains the partner agency will make a reasonable sounding argument about how whatever they're doing is legal because of some separation between the GPL code and the blackbox code. It will either then be decided invalid in court much later---in which case the CIA has plenty of time to do whatever it is they wanted to do. Or the existing incestuous relationship between the government and the private company will ensure that this remains a grey area of law for a long long time.
- eeZah7Ux 10y agojeffmcjunkin point still stands. In a world of open software and maybe even open hardware, where tivoization and other tricks are prevented, planting backdoors and ensuring they stay undetected becomes very difficult. More so if software is build reproducibly, signed, and so on.
- 10y ago
- ChuckMcM 10y agoWhile I respect the angst the author feels, this snippet ... "... allowing an entity like VMware to join, despite their many years long disrespect for the most basic principles of the FOSS Community (such as: Following the GPL and its copyleft principle), really is hard to understand and accept." I think this presumes a different rationale on the part of the Linux foundation. The answer to the question "Here is some money, can I join?" is always yes. And with enough money it is "heck yes!" And that leads to "I guess I was being overly naive :(" Which is yes, you were. Why do politicians, managers, and ex-lovers all have to just "put their differences aside and move on." ? Because if you don't you can't make any progress even if the penultimate step here was one that hurt you badly. The best way to score this is that VMWare is going to participate in a forum with others who can help guide them to a better compliance record. Both to understand why compliance is good, and to alleviate fears that VMWare might have that complying would leave them vulnerable. What they were before is in the past, now you have a way to work with them to move forward. Consider the alternative that they don't join, they continue to be huge FOSS scofflaws and continue to provide some sort of 'you don't really have to comply' example to others who might be uncomfortable with the GPL. When you look at it this way, it really is a good thing.
- rrdharan 10y ago> alleviate fears that VMWare might have that complying would leave them vulnerable I don't think this is the case. VMware (and their lawyers) have studied the GPL and genuinely do not believe they are not complying with its requirements. This isn't the typical "shady hardware vendor embeds modified busybox" situation where the (in this case alleged) lack of compliance is out of laziness, fear or ignorance. [Disclaimer: as per my other comment, I used to work at VMware, and am inherently biased in that sense, although I also happen to agree with VMware on the whole ESXi/vmklinux situation.]
- paxcoder 10y agoI didn't study the busybox connection, but why would anyone think vmkernel and vmklinux could be "reasonably considered independent and separate works in themselves" especially considering the source from the sfconservancy site linked to in the article?
- andrewshadura 10y agoWell, it's sort of well-known that key Linux Foundation figures are openly against GPL enforcement, even in its most harmless forms such as those SFC does.
- jdanisek 10y agoSo you drank the Kuhnaid huh? Bradley Kuhn has done more to turn companies away from the GPL than anyone else... Is this anti-GPL too? Helping companies get it right? https://lkml.org/lkml/2017/3/8/158 https://lkml.org/lkml/2017/3/8/158
- throw2016 10y agoA lot of the Linux bodies with community sounding names like Linux foundation are actually groups of corporate interests. I had looked up some of the people behind these foundations a couple of years ago and they came across as careerists with little connection to Linux, open source or Linux advocacy. There is nothing wrong with this, but the names of these bodies should reflect their interests. A name like 'Linux Foundation' should be the flagship organization promoting Linux and open source globally as well as user and developer interests. Some thing like 'Linux Industry Group' is a better reflection of the work Linux foundation does. Ultimately its high time end-users organize some kind of funded entity to support open source projects and protect user interests. Not just one but multiple such bodies. Without that the interests of those funding projects, developers and industry bodies will triumph and you will just have to accept what ever is 'decided' for you. I think forums like this should also gently encourage all the thousands of startups who dip into the Linux ecosystem pool but do not contribute anything back even after they are successful, sometimes wildly. Github and Redis comes to mind. That doesn't feel right. Hiring people working on specific open source projects is good, but its not support, its protecting your own interests. Non-conditional funding so they can continue to do their work that you have benefited from is better. Its like a river, if you keep on taking from it eventually there will be nothing left.
- nwordsam3 10y agoYou are bringing your own assumptions and preconceptions to what Linux is about. Linus Torvalds is not Richard Stallman. Linus has his bread buttered by the large corporate interests that contribute to ensure Linux development. The Linux foundation was initially basically a way to setup a commercial entity to pay Linus for his work. Since Linus holds the Trademark for Linux, it's kind of his say what gets to carry the moniker Linux Foundation. And there bodies, what are the FSF and Apache Foundation after all? There's also the GNOME foundation, etc, etc.
- pythonaut_16 10y agoWho will fund it? And if you have startups like Github and Redis funding it, how is that free from the accusations you level at the Linux Foundation?
- bcantrill 10y agoI understand the consternation -- I have very mixed feelings about the Linux Foundation (I am on the TOC of the CNCF, an LF project), but the reality is that as a 501(c)(6) they are much better resourced than the 501(c)(3)s dedicated to open source. In my opinion, the LF therefore represents our (current) best shot to achieve some common good, and (speaking personally), I have resolved to work from within the LF to make it more useful to the broader constituency of open source communities. (As a concrete example, I championed the LF/CNCF acquiring and relicensing RethinkDB[1].) Similarly, I think applying a purity test to the LF would be counterproductive: it would end up refusing essentially everyone's money and becoming the FSF or Apache Foundation -- two flat-broke 501(c)(3)s. (Aside, individuals should never ever donate to the LF; donate to a 501(c)(3) instead.) To sum: I would rather have VMware in than out, and then influence the LF to abide by its broader open source constituency, funding projects at the grass roots that are the lifeblood of open source -- but I also understand those that would view taking VMware's money as selling out that constituency! [1] https://www.joyent.com/blog/the-liberation-of-rethinkdb https://www.joyent.com/blog/the-liberation-of-rethinkdb
- jimjag 10y agoThe ASF a "flat broke" 501(c)(3)? Hardly. We simply run a tight, fiscal ship. But broke? Please stop spreading FUD.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- bigbugbag 10y agoGood for you that you're TOC of CNCF an LF project, but I didn't understand a single sentence you wrote. Maybe try using actual words and explaining what may seem obvious to you because it's probably not to others reading you.
- drostie 10y agoApproximate η-expansion: "I understand your outrage, and I also have mixed feelings about the role of the Linux Foundation in open-source. I am on the Technical Oversight Committee of the Cloud Native Computing Foundation which is a Linux Foundation project. However I do want to say that the Linux Foundation is a not-for-profit 'business league' under US law, rather than a not-for-profit 'charitable organization.' The fact that they have these partner companies which make them up, gives them a lot more money than the open-source charitable organizations can provide. Because they have more money, in my opinion the Linux Foundation has the potential to do a lot more good for open source, and so my personal goal is to work from within the Linux Foundation to help it do that. For example, I was very vocal about us buying and open-sourcing RethinkDB. What you're asking for is for us to test the 'purity' of businesses before we let them join the league that is the Linux Foundation. That is a bad idea. It just means fewer businesses will join the league and less of their money will be available for open-source. The Free Software Foundation and Apache Foundation are good examples of similar things: charitable organizations which now do not have very much money because they are not willing to be 'tainted' by big business. On the flip side, please do not donate to the business league as a private individual; give your resources to these charitable organizations who need it instead. But I would rather have VMWare be one of the league contributors than not have their money. We can always work from within the Linux Foundation to say 'you have to listen to these people who want Linux to remain committed to open-source,' so that they keep funding these projects that keep our open-source movement going. On the other hand I understand why you think that taking VMWare's money is essentially 'selling out,' saying that we care more about the money than about our principles."
- guelo 10y agoThe GPL is just incidental to Linux at this point. Linux is a collaboration between dozens of giant corporations many of which actually hate the GPL. The success of the Linux Foundation is in convincing all those companies that the viral nature of the GPL has been neutralized and it is safe to use it in their proprietary products. There is no idealism remaining but Linux is still an amazing achievement that benefits us all.
- rini17 10y agoWhat benefits? Only "benefits" that I can see are distributed very unevenly - strong entities like Microsoft can extract patent fees from Linux users, despite they contributed almost nothing. On the other end users like you and me are blocked from fixing the software built on GPL components on the devices they own. Which was the very situation GPL was intended to prevent.
- trome 10y agoPretty much, why can't I run a modern kernel on the average device running Linux, whether that be an IP Camera, or a smartphone? Why are we forced to run ancient, unpatched & insecure software by Qualcomm, LG, Samsung & Google?
- AstralStorm 10y agoTechnically, you can run new also insecure software by yourself on most Samsung Exynos devices at the very least, including the bootloader. Includes new kernel versions. See: http://linux-exynos.org/wiki/Main_Page http://linux-exynos.org/wiki/Main_Page Qualcomm is much more iffy, there is some work on integrating support to mainline but it's only beginning. You lose the warranty bit and still cannot replace FCC-approved modem firmware, because certification reasons.
- Nomentatus 10y agoThe GPL incidental largely because the kernel can't do anything on its own, so the patent grab is meaningless in any practical way. That wouldn't be true of the tivoization clause in GPL3, of course.
- chappi42 10y agoI almost didn't read to the end (got annoyed). Isn't it wonderful that 'Linux' is able to be friends with companies and welcome them? So many slanderous remarks, 'you can abuse Linux', 'the Linux Foundations has no ethical concerns', 'work with the community, and not against it'. And shouldn't there have been mentioned that VMware afaiu won a (first?) court case? The questions are important of course. Here a imo much more fruitful reading, likely well-known: https://lists.linuxfoundation.org/pipermail/ksummit-discuss/2016-August/003580.html https://lists.linuxfoundation.org/pipermail/ksummit-discuss/...
- chappi42 10y agowhy downvote?
- jdanisek 10y agoA 501c6 like the LF has to accept any member at a membership level so long as they comply with the Bylaws and policies. There are antitrust issues if they selectively blocked someone. Also, consider that the LF may now be helping VMware with their compliance issues. They have many programs to help companies build compliance processes and tooling - is the author suggesting VMware can never right its wrongs? Would we say the same thing about Intel who wasn't that great in its initial Linux journey? Just turn them away for trying to get better?