6 ms·
Archaea: The 'Dark Matter' of the Microbial World
- __jal 10y agoI love reading about these advances. Not my field, so it is all new to me in a pop-science way. And it reaffirms my belief that humans (and all the other species, but I'm biased) are vastly weirder assemblages than it seems.
- jessriedel 10y agoIs it known why there are no evolutionary intermediates between archea and eubacteria? Nick Lane's book The Vital Questions has been highly recommended by the HN commentariat, and I think it more or less deserves its esteem. Lane gives an extensive theoretical analysis of the sequence of events wherein a eubacterium was engulfed by an archea, and the resulting endosymbiosis that was the beginning of complex (eukaryotic) life. Apparently, the genomic evidence is strong that the original host was an archaeon an the original invader (later to become mitochondria) was a eubacterium. However, I don't think he discusses the origin of this divergence of eubacteria and archea, and why it persists so cleanly.
- jlarocco 10y agoThat's something I've always wondered about evolution in general. Why isn't there a continuum of species? For example, why are there chimpanzees and humans walking around as discrete species with nothing "in between". Seems unlikely that a few chimpanzees gave birth to human babies (or I guess some ancient human ancestor) one day, and then we just branched off and evolved separately leaving the rest of the chimpanzees behind. Why didn't the "better" DNA get fed back into the chimpanzee gene pool and the whole species evolve? Obviously I know nothing about biology, but I'd love a high level explanation. It's the one thing that's always bothered me about evolution, because nobody ever explains it, and it seems like magic.
- pygy_ 10y agoIn general, geographic separation leads to speciation. It can be rivers (IIRC for example bonobos and chimpanzees live on different sides of the Congo river). Another interesting example is I think seagulls along the arctic circle that are split in many species spread along an east-west axis. Most species can interbreed with their immediate neighbour, but not the neighbour of their neighbour (except at one point where the extreme populations meet and the immediate neighbours are not compatible either).
- ihartley 10y agoIf anyone else is curious, this is called a ring species, and there are only four known examples: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ring_species https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ring_species
- delhanty 10y ago>non-breeding, though genetically connected, "end" populations may co-exist in the same region This reminds me of the Riemann surface associated with the complex logarithm: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Complex_logarithm#The_associated_Riemann_surface https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Complex_logarithm#The_associat...
- infectoid 10y agoNot an evolutionary biologist but my guess would be it has something to do with niches in an ecosystem and lack of evolutionary pressure to change in an environment in which you have reached some equilibrium. Chimps for whatever reason were able to satisfy their biological imperatives within their given environment early on and have never needed to change. The human line, not so much. I guess the way I see it is that some mutation in early humans (perhaps selected for by the environment) created a priority on brain development. I'm sure there were many dead-end branches along the way to us that we haven't noticed. We just look back and see a straight line from chimps to humans. Perspective is key here. Of course, I could be completely wrong :)
- MetricMike 10y ago
- dekhn 10y agoLane has a good story and tells it nicely, but I don't think he represents the mainstream, and he conveniently throws all the evidence that doesn't agree with him under the rug.
- jessriedel 10y agoThanks. I did get that impression. Is even the basic eubacteria-inside-archea claim is disputed?
- patall 10y agoDepends on how specific you are as endosymbiotic theory can be very complicated. For example, the nucleus itself could be regarded as a seperate cell itself (which would be the archea), but what was the sourding cell?
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- jballanc 10y agoArchaea and Eubacteria have different Ribosomes. In the world of biology, if DNA is the source code then ribosomes are the compiler. In other words, while both families use DNA to store information and RNA to translate it, all the rest of the machinery used by cells in that process is different. This is why there are no intermediates. Likely (and this is a guess, if an educated one) this split happened before cells were even "cells". That is, whatever the pre-cellular replicons were that eventually led to life, there might have been many variations on (what eventually became) the ribosome, but two won out and gave rise to two distinct lineages of cellular life. The rest, as they say, is history...
- throwaway91111 10y agoSo, if I'm understanding correctly, these pre-cellular replicons are distinctly less efficient at survival than both archaea and eubacteria, hence their not existing in any (recognizable) form today. Is this correct? This opposed to the idea that the archaea existed, then the bridge (which went extinct), then archaea.
- jballanc 10y agoThat is an excellent question! I should start by saying that we don't know, for sure, that pre-cellular replicons don't still exist. They may, and we may just not have figured out the right place to look for them. That said, gaining a membrane is a huge advantage for life. The current working hypothesis is that life started as a series of autocatalytic chemical reactions, but for this to work there must have been just the right combination of chemicals in just the right conditions all at the same time. You can imagine that it wouldn't take much of a stray current to wash all that away, and you're back to square one. By surrounding themselves with a membrane, pre-cellular replicons could begin controlling their chemical environment, enriching it with the raw materials needed and regulating the conditions. Again, though, just because cellular life would be expected to be more robust and, therefore, more successful than acellular replicons, you wouldn't expect those acellular reactions to immediately halt once cellular life arose. If I had to guess, I'd say that acellular replicons may have persisted for quite some time, but ultimately succumbed to the Great Oxygenation Event (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Great_Oxygenation_Event https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Great_Oxygenation_Event). Shortly after cellular life arose (or possibly beginning a bit before cells came on the scene), life cause a massive shift in the Earth's chemistry, freeing vast quantities of oxygen and changing what had been a reducing environment to one that is, on the balance, oxygenating. Oxygen is, to put it bluntly, nasty stuff. It tends to break down complex molecules very readily, and so any acellular replicons that may have survived up to the Great Oxygenation Event were likely wiped out soon after.
- jhbadger 10y agoI like Lane's book, but it is annoying how he praises Bill Martin and basically ignores the actual pioneers of the field. Carl Woese, who discovered the archaea and who fought a long battle to get the world to understand that they weren't just bacteria, gets like a sentence in the whole book.
- jessriedel 10y agoYea OK, but it's really hard to expect authors to dole out praise of scientists in proportion to the size of their contributions as assessed by the community. Individuals will naturally disagree with the community's assessment (which needn't always be correct), and will like their friends disproportionately, etc. A lower bar is just that the author correctly represent the evidence and arguments about the scientific issues, especially with regard to identifying the consensus position and representing it fairly. If Lane fails to do that, it's a more serious charge.
- tomcam 10y agoWhere do the virus and the prion fit into this taxonomy?
- archgoon 10y agoThey aren't. They're viewed as really weird molecules.