3 ms·
I'm biased, as I work in civil service. Frankly, the reality is often coming from the bureaucracy. We all chuckle about government absurdity, but many of the t
by Spooky23 10y ago
I'm biased, as I work in civil service.
Frankly, the reality is often coming from the bureaucracy. We all chuckle about government absurdity, but many of the true experts in these areas are in these bureaucracies, and get silenced when their work conflicts with the narrative the political administration wants. As costs have grown in healthcare, public safety and other areas, other functions get starved of attention.
I will guarantee you that in all of these cases, people who know what they were talking about were advising about these issues or unable to do their jobs due to de-funding... especially when republicans have had their fingers in things.
We lost a lot when the postwar and 1960s generation aged out of the workforce. The folks in charge of government agencies in the 1960-2000 timeframe were better educated and more competent. The politicians, even the machine people, had a better fundamental respect for what government did and does.
I'll tell you from an anecdotal perspective that the people in my state who inspect dams and bridges give a shit about their jobs and are not complacent. I know a few people in each category. They have a frustrating job, but do it well.
- vacri 10y agoFor an example of what you're saying: a friend of mine has a father who use to work in my state (Victoria, Aus) Surveyor General's office. The surveyor general's office knew what the land was like all over the state, what good farmland was, or what was best for other kinds of development... including what land was worth at market rates. Then a 'business friendly' government came along and abolished them, because "developers know better than these guys, who just provide red-tape obstacles". Fast-forward 20 years, and there's no pattern to developments, meaning things are built without concern to infrastructure or services, plus lots of prime farmland has been lost (so much for the 'economic forward-thinking' of that 'business-friendly' government). It turns out that the government actually needs that knowledge, because the state government is now hiring back whatever surveyors they can find again from the old days, and at grossly inflated private contractor rates. They lost the expertise, the professionalism, and their value for money, all for short-term business thinking. Not all government positions are filled with 'jobsworth' drones - there's a lot of vital stuff out there in ye olde bureaucracy.
- mdpopescu 10y agoReason #1,234,567 why I don't like governments: there's no bankruptcy penalty.
- Bartweiss 10y ago> Not all government positions are filled with 'jobsworth' drones - there's a lot of vital stuff out there in ye olde bureaucracy. I've thought for a while that the US suffers from not having a popular-media equivalent to Yes Minister. It's a great cultural touchstone for the idea of bureaucratic knowledge, and the danger of being politically or morally correct but unable to actually do things well.
- btilly 10y agoThe question isn't whether the bureaucracy has lots of good, competent people who want to do the job right. It is whether the people who rise to the top and represent the bureaucracy to decision makers are reporting reality accurately, or telling decision makers what they want to hear.
- trome 10y agoAn engineer will say a bridge will fail, or a foundation they designed 20 years ago will give way under 4x the load it was designed for, but the politicians and businessmen at the top will overrule them, people may die, and the only person blamed will be the engineer, despite the paper they wrote and published years before saying to tear the 60 year old bridge with spalding concrete and rusted girders down. You can lead a horse to water, but you can't make them drink it. The same goes for accepting reality, hence why many choose to live in an alternative reality.
- aswanson 10y agoIm always amazed and in fear of bridges in terms of engineering. The Ben Franklin Bridge was built in 1923, before mass transportation, cars, etc. and routinely handles full traffic jams every day. The engineer could not have had that in mind when it was built, and yet it stands.
- jacquesm 10y agoThat's because those engineers did take their safety margins and unforeseen uses serious and engineered in enough redundancy to make this work. Obviously there are limits, chances are those limits are fairly well described and if they are ever exceeded it will be ugly.
- marcosdumay 10y ago> and the only person blamed will be the engineer, despite the paper they wrote and published years before If that's really the case, it's a pretty fucked-up situation. The expected outcome for a politician ignoring technical advice and people dying as a consequence is for the politician to be always blamed. Even when the technical advice was nonsense, what leads to a lot of different problems (including politicians working hard to silence technicians). I can't imagine what kinds of problems make politicians able to shift the blame onto people that say the structure is not secure, but I'd start searching for corruption at the judiciary branch.
- arjie 10y agoI'm not sure the evidence supports the evidence. They blacked out the entire NorthEast, lost multiple bridges with people on them, and lost three dams over the period of a year starting in 1963. Considering that they were busy killing people through poor design and lack of maintenance, I'd be interested in evidence of their superior competence. Personally, I think they did a great job with the inferior engineering and safety science of the time but the results are better today.
- kemiller2002 10y agoI'm a contractor for civil service, and I can attest this is true.