15 ms·
Another factor here is when people abuse the word "fact" regularly. If you ever get into a discussion with somebody who claims they've proved their point by cit
by brightball 10y ago
Another factor here is when people abuse the word "fact" regularly. If you ever get into a discussion with somebody who claims they've proved their point by citing "facts", then actually follow up on their citations and discover that it doesn't actually say what they think it says it creates an impression of the messenger, not the message.
Enough messengers saying the same faulty message over and over and you distrust the message just because it's been repeated so often.
This is an easy thing to do with conversations on subjects like guns where the key of slanting the message is based on subtle wording changes that allow you to leave out some data or include other data. The person presenting their information thinks they have "facts" because they see numbers that support their point of view without knowing what's been left out.
I seem to remember a github repo that was posted to HN a couple of years back that did exactly that. They showed the same data set and presented 3 different ways with 3 entirely different conclusions.
- coldtea 10y ago>then actually follow up on their citations Not to mention that citations are not all they are touted to be. Just because something has been written by someone somewhere doesn't make it an objective reality fact. Just because something has been published on a peer reviewed journal doesn't make it an objective reality fact. Just because something has the consensus opinion doesn't make it an objective reality fact. Just because something is supported by the numbers given by some government, state agency, NGO etc doesn't make it an objective reality fact. And in many cases someone with actual "skin in the game", who knows a subject empirically can be right, and know they are right, against "citations" from all of the above.
- guelo 10y agoOK, but many times that I see people making this argument they turn around and point me to some conspiracy theory from some guy yelling on youtube. There are dark ugly forces that benefit from the destruction of trust in the press and democratic institutions. You have to maintain a balanced world view. The government and the press have their biases but they are not always in conspiracy mode out to destroy the little guy. Many times they are on your side.
- mehaveaccount 10y ago>OK, but many times that I see people making this argument they turn around and point me to some conspiracy theory from some guy yelling on youtube. So special interests can pay the money to tell their opinions on TV and in newspapers so they get to be "legitimate", but people who use cheaper channels accessible to the poor are "conspiracy theorists".
- coldtea 10y ago>The government and the press have their biases but they are not always in conspiracy mode out to destroy the little guy. No, but they often are. And not just in easy to point fingers at regimes. Not that long ago, the might NYT were writing about the fabled "WMDs", were independent bloggers (no YouTube existed yet) were speaking against that BS. To a third party those would have looked like conspiracy theorists. Guess which side turned out to be true?
- guelo 10y agoBack in 2003 there were plenty of partisan bloggers on both sides of the WMD argument.
- MaxfordAndSons 10y agoBut the NYT, along with the rest of the world, was misled by the Bush administration. Sure they could have been more circumspect in evaluating the "facts" as presented by Colin Powell - but why do you jump from them being notably mistaken on a handful of occasions to believing they are "often" "in conspiracy mode out to destroy the little guy"?
- goatlover 10y agoSo, the Saddam regime was the little guy the mainstream media was out to destory? I'm not sure what this example is trying to show. That a good portion of the world was misled into thinking Iraq still had WMDs, which justified an invasion?
- brightball 10y agoExactly. When that is a known reality you're left with breaking things down into logical positions or acting emotionally.
- xapata 10y agoAnd amazingly, someone with skin in the game can also be wrong despite years of experience and training.
- balabaster 10y agoand amazingly the amount of information that comes out with peer reviewed science that has been repeatable enough to be accepted as fact and advertised as such can be thrown away 15 years later as wrong... how can a fact be wrong? Either it was a fact back then and you were right or you were wrong back then and it wasn't a fact but information supporting a non-factual hypothesis... given how often we see this presented on news programs, newspapers and touted as fact only to have it revoked years later leads us all to question how much we really know about these "facts". Case in point: Sugar is great, sugar is bad, fat is great, fat is bad, red wine is bad, red wine is good... blah blah blah. A fact is a fact, indisputable. Yet many of the facts when chased back to first principles seem to have enough ambiguity to beg questions over just how much we really know and how much we just think we know. I have whole days where I question everything I think I know and am still no wiser at the end of the day.
- jimbokun 10y agoBecause the reality is humans don't really "know" anything the absolute certainty, but there are still ways of assessing which beliefs are more likely to be true than others. There is always the possibility the findings of a peer reviewed, journal published, replicated study are wrong. They are just more likely to be correct than assertions without such support.
- meheleventyone 10y agoThis is fundamental to science though. Nothing is ever proven to be true. Scientific facts are contingent and corrigible. Science is just more rigorous than our other methods of establishing facts about reality.
- balabaster 10y agoSo you're saying that my definition of the term "fact" is wrong... http://www.dictionary.com/browse/fact http://www.dictionary.com/browse/fact Fact: a truth known by actual experience or observation; something known to be true. So... are you saying that a fact isn't something that's known to be true? Because my understanding of the word "fact" is that it means something indisputable, an underlying truth upon which you can base other truths and know them all to be true. If this is the case, then what can we possibly know with any sense of conviction?
- jimbokun 10y agoAll you are really saying is its impossible to know anything for certain. Having a citation from a well regarded source is better than having no citation. Peer review is better than no review. There is probably a higher correlation for a statement from an official state agency being true, than a random statement with no attribution. So yes, a statement can satisfy any of the things you mention, and still not be true. But that doesn't mean those factors can't be helpful in assessing the likelihood of a given assertion.
- coldtea 10y ago>All you are really saying is its impossible to know anything for certain. Yeah, in the sense that all you are saying is its possible to have degrees of trust on difference sources of "facts". That said, you'd be surprised how often the fact (pun intended) that it's "impossible to know anything for certain" is lost on people. >Having a citation from a well regarded source is better than having no citation. Peer review is better than no review. That's the problem: we can't even say that. http://journals.plos.org/plosmedicine/article?id=10.1371/journal.pmed.0020124 http://journals.plos.org/plosmedicine/article?id=10.1371/jou... (Of course we shouldn't trust this paper either: it's, after all, published too).
- conistonwater 10y ago> That said, you'd be surprised how often the fact (pun intended) that it's "impossible to know anything for certain" is lost on people. I think David Hume was quite good on this subject. If chance of being right is all there is to knowledge, then maximizing your chance of being right is what knowledge is. So all the peer review, the numbers and statistics, for example, contribute to knowledge even if it might be wrong. And if you dismiss, as you do, statistics because they just might be misleading or biased, and are thus not "objective reality fact", that does damage to your ability to know things, because you are discarding data without considering it, and that damage should be avoided. Whereas the proper thing to do is consider it on merits, whatever the actual merits are.
- timje1 10y ago
- coding123 10y agoI ABSOLUTELY agree with this, and this is completely lost on people. For every study that says coffee is bad there's 10 more that say it's good, simply because people want it to be good, NOT because it's actually good. The problem is, we humans play right into that as if the number's game actually means something - 1 out of 10 studies says something is bad - the other 9 say it's good. So rather than actually work off the truth (the objective fact of whether coffee is good or bad) we go off the numbers instead. Now take coffee and replace that with any number of other things.
- meheleventyone 10y agoIsn't this more a distinction between science and science reporting. Coffee is complex and interacts in ways that can be described as good and bad. The press reporting blows by the wind of the press release that day. Hence the Daily Mail and others reporting lots of common things both causing and protecting us against cancer.
- coldtea 10y ago>Isn't this more a distinction between science and science reporting In a way yes, but if we include the summaries of findings that scientists deliver to the public/governments/etc as "science reporting", then science reporting is 100% of science as we know it (unless we happen to practice it). Consider dietary advice that has since found to be BS, that was passed in the 70s and 80s as "scientific fact", not just by the press, but by scientific advisory boards (to governments etc) comprised by actual scientists.
- meheleventyone 10y agoRight but wasn't that advice basically the state of the field at the time? That we know different now doesn't mean the scientists then should have acted on information unavailable to them.
- Brockenstein 10y ago
- ch4s3 10y agoThis is the classic boiling down of empiricism, not to make a judgement either way. But, if anyone is interested in the philosophy that coldtea is espousing here, check out this treatment of Rationalism vs. Empiricism https://plato.stanford.edu/entries/rationalism-empiricism/#1.2 https://plato.stanford.edu/entries/rationalism-empiricism/#1...
- hinkley 10y agoOn a broader view, if one considers how hard it is to get quality in anything, then the majority of things you encounter are going to be of dubious quality to begin with, and population count should factor against the common thing, not for it. Otherwise, there are more Starbucks so does that mean they have the best coffee? McDonald's has the best burgers? No. They are numerous because they pander, and because of ethically questionable but not illegal business policies. Why would anything else be different? How often is the popular or loudest choice the right one?
- gmarx 10y agoIf I remember my science training properly "fact" is a synonym for "observation". One interprets facts in order to develop a model or "theory". So facts published in peer reviewed articles probably represent objective reality (if you believe in objective reality and trust the author to record observations accurately); the conclusion in peer reviewed articles (theories for example or statistical associations) should not be considered objective reality.
- dredmorbius 10y agoThe etymology of fact comes from event. http://www.etymonline.com/index.php?term=fact&allowed_in_frame=0 http://www.etymonline.com/index.php?term=fact&allowed_in_fra...
- sjy 10y agoEspecially an evil action: this earlier meaning lives on in accessory after the fact.
- pcmaffey 10y agoAnd then Heisenberg happened.
- TheSpiceIsLife 10y agoBayesian probability is supposed to be the answer to this idea that we can't know anything for certain. Just because something can't be known for certain doesn't mean it can't be known to a high probability.
- kbenson 10y agoThe problem is that any layman not specifically in that chain has no way of making a determination between the person with "skin in the game" that is right and the corpus of information stating otherwise, not the contemporary expert with "skin in the game" that agrees with the existing literature. The opposite scenario can be true as well,where the literature is correct but the expert is wrong, for any number of reasons (including random distribution of experience). In the end, without some probability distribution between the scenarios, which is likely wildly different based on field, we can't use this information to any useful effect beyond acknowledging that the consensus can be wrong, which is useful in itself. In the end we are left having to decide whether following what we hope is usually careful scientific consensus has left us better off than alternatives, to which the answer is I don't know, but I sure hope so. :/
- innocentoldguy 10y agoThere are two types of citations. There are, of course, the Wikipedia, CNN, or HuffPo links, which are at best facts mingled with opinion, or, at worst, contextually inaccurate sound bites. Then there are scholarly citations, which consist of scientific data, complete, primary-source media, etc. The latter are the only types of citations I typically take seriously. Even then, as you point out, there are other things to consider. For example, if a scientist publishes something controversial in a peer-reviewed journal, you still have to wonder what his or her motivations are. Who is funding them? Have their personal biases, or those of their benefactors, tainted their results? I tend to strive for scholarly citations in my arguments, but in the end, I realize we are all emotional beings, and personal biases and emotions tend to trump knowledge, wisdom, and logic more often than we'd like to admit.
- adekok 10y agoIt's often pretty simple to check that studies are biased and wrong: --- Q1: For black people, how many times have you mugged a white person? Q2: For white people, how many times have you been mugged by a black person? Conclusion: There's a one-sided racial problem! --- It's not always that simple, but too many times it is. I've found the various social sciences to be the worst at this. All of the popular media tropes of "X people are like Y!" are generally not just wrong, but biased and often opposite to well-done studies.
- leshow 10y agoCitations add 'support' for or against one side of an argument, they almost never state anything that's factually true or false in a general sense.
- luhn 10y ago> I seem to remember a github repo that was posted to HN a couple of years back that did exactly that. They showed the same data set and presented 3 different ways with 3 entirely different conclusions. Does anybody remember what repository this was? I'd be interested in seeing it.
- brightball 10y agoFound it: https://guns-vs-homicide.github.io/ https://guns-vs-homicide.github.io/
- jimmaswell 10y agoSimilar idea: https://fivethirtyeight.com/features/science-isnt-broken/#part2 https://fivethirtyeight.com/features/science-isnt-broken/#pa...
- Amorymeltzer 10y agoNot sure about GH, but here are two examples, from the NYT about pollsters[1] and from Nature[1] about red cards. 1: https://www.nytimes.com/interactive/2016/09/20/upshot/the-error-the-polling-world-rarely-talks-about.html https://www.nytimes.com/interactive/2016/09/20/upshot/the-er... 2: http://www.nature.com/news/crowdsourced-research-many-hands-make-tight-work-1.18508 http://www.nature.com/news/crowdsourced-research-many-hands-...
- nsxwolf 10y agoOne thing I've noticed related to this - your average global warming skeptic that you talk to in day to day conversations (not entrenched stakeholders on the internet) becomes far more willing to believe in man made climate change once you remind them that they are under no obligation to support or accept any particular policy to mitigate it. But if you tell them they have to give up this or that lifestyle, or pay more in taxes, or support a one child policy or whatever else you come up with, they instantly become allergic to the facts.
- tbrownaw 10y agoWell yeah. If you conflate those things or tie them together, you've basically declared your intent to demand a mile if they give so much as an inch. Which means the only sensible response is to fight tooth and nail every step of the way.
- Spivak 10y agoThis is basically the NRAs strategy as well and it's been incredibly successful. They know that their opponents intend to use compromise as a foothold for total disarmament so they have no choice but to occasionally take extreme or irrational stances. I don't blame them in the slightest.
- brianberns 10y ago> They know that their opponents intend to use compromise as a foothold for total disarmament. Really? Care to provide any factual evidence for that statement?
- kbenson 10y agoI'm not the GP, but I think it's obvious that of the spectrum of desired outcomes regarding gun control and the people that support them, there exist some that want nothing less than the total ban of firearms (as some other countries do). Any measure less than that will appease some, but others will continue to advocate. The part that wasn't spelled out is how any appeasement helps those who want more extreme measures. I think that is explained somewhat by allowing them to then point out that you've capitulated on gun control for safety reasons, so the argument is no longer whether guns are unsafe, but how unsafe they are, and being able to reframe the argument in that manner is likely to result in further restrictions later as current events are used to pass more stringent laws. I'm not sure how true that is or not in practice, but that's what I assume the GP was referring to.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- conistonwater 10y ago> Enough messengers saying the same faulty message over and over and you distrust the message just because it's been repeated so often. This seems like a really bad heuristic: it will mislead you any time the consensus opinion actually managed to get it right. It also leaves you wide open to confirmation bias.
- brightball 10y agoExactly. People only have so much time to dig in and verify everything they hear on the internet, so the result is that you get enough bad information from a labeled group of people that you save your time by dismissing it.
- dllthomas 10y agoRight. There are infinite flawed arguments for every correct position. Just because one of them got mind share doesn't mean there are no other, good arguments. One would hope that correctness of an argument would have a strong correlation with its memetic success, but it doesn't seem so.
- conistonwater 10y agoIf you disagree, why did you put "Right" at the beginning? I don't understand your comment, there must be a misunderstanding somewhere.
- dllthomas 10y agoI didn't think I was disagreeing... can you expand on what you are seeing?
- conistonwater 10y agoThe way I parsed your comment: there are so many bad arguments possible even for good ideas that if you see people use a bad argument for their idea, it doesn't mean there isn't a good argument instead that can replace it. Then, you'd think good arguments would get accepted more universally than bad arguments, but probably not. Is it even in the same ballpark?
- coding123 10y agoSimilarly people use the word "science" even if there isn't actually any evidence or "science" behind whatever they're arguing for. Their just using it as their argument's firewall. Unfortunately it's basically a trick you can't get around as us humans don't have the intellectual capacity to know "all science facts" to take down the argument.
- exclusiv 10y agoSo true. There's numerous studies that show we're programmed to just trust those in uniforms, especially lab coats. And given how often science turns out to be wrong, or that we can rarely even reproduce studies and results, you'd think we'd welcome more challenges to what's reported by way of science.
- leshow 10y agoA citation isn't a statement of fact in a general sense anyway. A bit of information from a study, means that under these very specific set of conditions, this happened. Your ability to generalise that to a 'fact' which is true in all cases is pretty limited. All citations do is add support for or against an argument, they aren't statements of fact.
- cortesoft 10y agoYeah, I was thinking of this when I got to the part about people not immediately changing their minds when presented with new facts. In reality, this makes sense if we think of knowledge in a Bayesian sense; we don't have absolute facts, we have little bits of information we gain over time. When a new bit of information comes in, we have to determine our new reality - what is the chance that our current views are wrong versus the chance that the new information is wrong. If we keep getting new information saying our current beliefs are wrong, we might end up changing out view eventually.
- Mz 10y agoWhat you describe is what the book "How to lie with statistics" covers in detail. It is a great read. I highly recommend it. A lot of so-called facts are just blurbs intended to support someone's manipulative agenda. Sadly, this is even true of this article. Towards the end, it begins making ugly political commentary instead of sticking to psychological phenomenon. The people who claim to have science on their side are often merely claiming to be intellectual elites and implying that anyone who disagrees with them is an idiot. It isn't scientific at all. So, it is unsurprising that it does not go over well with people who are basically being called stupid by people more interested in winning the argument themselves than in trying to have a meaningful discussion of good information.
- pps43 10y ago> I seem to remember a github repo that was posted to HN a couple of years back that did exactly that. They showed the same data set and presented 3 different ways with 3 entirely different conclusions. Probably this one: http://guns-vs-homicide.github.io http://guns-vs-homicide.github.io