8 ms·
There also still hasn't been any public evidence that Wikileaks got their Podesta email data from Russians yet. So far we only know the DNC leaks were very like
by dmix 10y ago
There also still hasn't been any public evidence that Wikileaks got their Podesta email data from Russians yet. So far we only know the DNC leaks were very likely Russian. That means until today only about ~50% of the 'election hacks' have been attributed to Russia with public evidence.
Now this leak calls into question some of the evidence about the DNC hack [1]. This evidence being the malware was Russian. But there were many other pieces of evidence that pointed to Russia so I'm personally not anymore persuaded it wasn't Russia for the DNC stuff. The Podesta stuff is still up in the air AFAIK. [edit: see pvg reply]
Either way this leak will just add to the deniability angle for the partisan hawks. Although this is probably way over the head of CNN/Fox News crowd so it's also possible it will have zero effect.
[1] Previous leaks mentioned NSA/Five Eyes collected foreign malware. This leaks adds CIA to that group and further solidifies the "misdirected attribution" angle.
- camperman 10y ago> So far we only know the DNC leaks were very likely Russian. We don't know that at all. There isn't a single piece of evidence for it anywhere.
- res0nat0r 10y agoUnfortunately for this we aren't going to get some 1080p video of someone in a mask sneaking into the DNC server room, just the fact that the 17 agencies all agree based on what they've seen believe that to be the case. Unfortunately everyone these days think everything is a conspiracy or has to have HD recordings of something they think happened as public evidence or it is false, but that's not how the world really works...
- NoGravitas 10y agoThe thing is, "17 agencies agree" doesn't really mean anything, if the evidence that all 17 agencies are relying on is a single report from a private security company hired by the DNC, and not independent investigation. If all of those agencies had looked at the original evidence themselves, the story would be different.
- rev_null 10y agoIf 30 helens agreed, it would be a different case.
- res0nat0r 10y agoBut they aren't just relying on a single report from a private security company, where did you assume that?
- elif 10y agohttps://www.wired.com/2017/01/fbi-says-democratic-party-wouldnt-let-agents-see-hacked-email-servers/ https://www.wired.com/2017/01/fbi-says-democratic-party-woul... fun fact, it is the same private company the government paid for evidence that North Korea (yeah, right) was responsible for the sony hack.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- alasdair_ 10y agoAlso, the "17 agencies" statement came from James Clapper, and not individually issued from each of the agencies themselves. It also bears mentioning that the "17 agencies" include groups that I really, really doubt bothered to investigate ANYTHING to do with a politician getting his emails hacked - do people actually believe that the coast guard was tracking down Russian hackers after DNC secrets? What about the department of energy? These are some of the "17 agencies" mentioned.
- alasdair_ 10y ago>" just the fact that the 17 agencies all agree based on what they've seen believe that to be the case." This simply isn't true. The whole "17 agencies" thing is a talking point that first came up in one of Hillary Clinton's debates and gets repeated without challenge. The "17 agencies" didn't all independently make their own assesments about what happened and decided it was the Russians. Instead, James Clapper (at the time, the Director of National Intelligence) made the claim that the Russians were behind certain hacks. Clapper is the ultimate head of sixteen out of seventeen of the agencies. The actual agencies involved include parts of the coast guard and the department of energy and other groups that seem REALLY unlikely to have conducted an in-depth, independent investigation into the hacking of a politician's emails. Also, this is the same James Clapper who lied under oath to congress. Specifically, when asked “Does the NSA collect any type of data at all on millions or hundreds of millions of Americans?” He responded, “No, sir.” Wyden asked “It does not?” and Clapper said, “Not wittingly." This is perjury and he should have been prosecuted for it. At a minimum, lying under oath makes it less likely that anything else he claims should be taken at face value.
- res0nat0r 10y agoHe wasn't going to out a secret program in a public hearing. The folks asking the questions had security clearance and could have asked the question during a classified briefing but they chose not to.
- leesalminen 10y agoThat doesn't make perjury legal.
- res0nat0r 10y agoIf grandstanding to out a secret program when he knew the answer and was supposed to be asking that question in private I'd say it was fine, and it seems everyone else thought so also hence no charges.
- 10y ago
- troyvit 10y agohttps://arstechnica.com/security/2016/12/the-public-evidence-behind-claims-russia-hacked-for-trump/ https://arstechnica.com/security/2016/12/the-public-evidence... There is some evidence, but no definitive evidence. '"[SecureWorks] researchers assess with moderate confidence that the group is operating from the Russian Federation and is gathering intelligence on behalf of the Russian government," the report from SecureWorks concluded.'
- zigzigzag 10y agoThe "evidence" appears to be simply that one anonymous group about which nothing is known was going after targets that would presumably be of interest to Russia. But that's simply heresy: such targets might also be of interest to western intelligence, or really anyone who wanted to stir up trouble by framing another country. All we can say is that the correlation is interesting, but that's about it.
- jessedhillon 10y agoThis is why we have intelligence -- the evidence for almost anything of consequence will never be able to meet a judicial, syllogistic standard. The idea that we need mathematically perfect deduction before we can make actionable conclusions is an assumption on your part.
- rand83746 10y agoAnd the people inside the government to whom the intelligence is provided have every right to trust the source. However, to us in the public, we don't know these people, and have zero reason to trust them, absent actual factual evidence. What, you wouldn't put it past them to lie all the sudden?
- jessedhillon 10y agoThe logical end of that position is that states aren't allowed to keep secrets, which you are welcome to believe is possible, but it's not the world I believe we live in.
- astrange 10y agohttps://twitter.com/pwnallthethings/status/816622915860963328 https://twitter.com/pwnallthethings/status/81662291586096332...
- pvg 10y agoThe circumstantial evidence in the Podesta phishing is pretty decent, not really 'up in the air'. https://www.secureworks.com/research/threat-group-4127-targets-google-accounts https://www.secureworks.com/research/threat-group-4127-targe... https://twitter.com/pwnallthethings/status/816621553643294720 https://twitter.com/pwnallthethings/status/81662155364329472... (the second link is a lengthy thread)
- dmix 10y agoRight, someone found a phishing link sent to Podesta that reused a GMail login page by autogenerating URLs, hundreds of hashed urls were reversed and a bunch of the target emails were people/companies of interest to Russia. I was only thinking about what the US gov released regarding the DNC leaks. I forgot about that one. It's very possible that many people had access to Podesta's email but the timing of that phishing attempt and the Wikileaks leak was a little too convenient to ignore.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- sparkling 10y agoThere is no hard evidence where the DNC/Podesta leaks came from. However, Julian Assange has repeatedly said that the source is not the russian goverment or a affiliated state party [1] and in a other interview has hinted that the source may be Seth Rich [2], a former DNC staff member that was murdered in Washington DC. [1] https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=uyCOy25GdjQ https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=uyCOy25GdjQ [2] https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Kp7FkLBRpKg https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Kp7FkLBRpKg
- gknoy 10y agoAttributing the release of such secrets to someone who is already dead seems like it could be a very effective way of hiding one's source. ;)
- untog 10y agoIs Julian Assange a reliable actor in this? He has every motive to deny that Russia are the source of the leaks.
- angry-hacker 10y agoWhy wouldn't he suddenly be? Because he exposed the corruption of the party you supported? It doesn't work that way really. Either he is reliable, or not reliable to begin with. I have every reason believe he is, and he has demonstrated that people turn a blind eye on things if it fits their narrative of the world and politics.
- ubernostrum 10y agoWhy wouldn't he suddenly be? Because he exposed the corruption of the party you supported? He was never neutral or objective on the subject of Hillary Clinton. And isn't it convenient that despite our knowing of multiple politicians whose private email got hacked, hers is the only one he felt was worthy of publishing... So, yeah, not exactly a "sudden" lack of objectivity on his part. Also it's been demonstrated his followers will turn a blind eye to things that don't fit their narrative.
- 10y ago
- snissn 10y agoCan you point to information to research about connections to the DNC hack and Russia?
- nyolfen 10y agothis is the best public evidence afaik (and it's pretty good): https://twitter.com/pwnallthethings/status/816622915860963328 https://twitter.com/pwnallthethings/status/81662291586096332...
- WillyOnWheels 10y agoI am nearly convinced by The Grugq's summary: https://medium.com/@thegrugq/the-russian-way-of-cyberwar-edb9d52b4876#.v2muiatty https://medium.com/@thegrugq/the-russian-way-of-cyberwar-edb... "Alternating Competing Hypothesis"
- monochromatic 10y agoWhat public evidence is there that the DNC leaks were related to Russia?
- atmosx 10y agoThere's no evidence. It makes for a good romance though...
- metamet 10y agoMostly this intelligence report from the Office of the Director of National Intelligence: https://www.nytimes.com/interactive/2017/01/06/us/politics/document-russia-hacking-report-intelligence-agencies.html https://www.nytimes.com/interactive/2017/01/06/us/politics/d...
- monochromatic 10y ago"We assess that X happened" isn't really public evidence for X. It's an argument from authority at best.