8 ms·
The Instant Pot came on the market with perfect timing, just as the pressure cooker started to go from "geek" to "mainstream" in its adoption curve. The fawni
by bryanlarsen 10y ago
The Instant Pot came on the market with perfect timing, just as the pressure cooker started to go from "geek" to "mainstream" in its adoption curve. The fawning press articles claim that it was Instant Pot that took pressure cooking from niche to mainstream, but I don't buy that -- I think it would have happened anyways.
It's a good pressure cooker. A good stovetop one will be faster, but it's only significant if you've got a gas or induction range. And of course the stovetop models don't have any automation.
And it's half the price of a good stovetop model.
- SideburnsOfDoom 10y ago> just as the pressure cooker started to go from "geek" to "mainstream" in its adoption curve. Pressure cookers have been around for a long time: first manufactured in 1864 according to wikipedia (1). It's just that they have been out of fashion for few decades - possibly supplanted by the microwave oven in the 1970s and 80s. So maybe the time was right for a better design to come back. The older designs had a reputation for very occasionally exploding, or the lid flying off and getting embedded in the ceiling. Not common, but it did happen and that puts people off. 1) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pressure_cooking#History https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pressure_cooking#History
- mcguire 10y agoThe lids on older models like my mother's were physically capable[1] of being removed while under pressure, which would be entertaining. Still use it, though. [1] The amount of force required is large, though. I'm not sure I could do it without tools.
- GrinningFool 10y agoI think that it wasn't so much a 'geek' thing as it was that a complete generation or perhaps two forgot that they existed - and now the next generation is [re]discovering them.
- soylentcola 10y agoI bought an old-school pressure cooker last year when my rooftop garden unexpectedly produced way more tomatoes and hot peppers than I had expected. Started to get into canning and pickling as a result. Sadly, I no longer live there thanks to a breakup but I'm looking forward to buying my next place with gardening space so I can pick up where I left off. Do these things work for canning or is it mostly just a matter of available volume?
- throwaway9475 10y agoI don't usually post, but please don't use a pressure cooker for canning as it can cause botulism if the food isn't sufficiently acidic. The only safe way to can non-acidic foods is with a pressure canner, not a pressure cooker.
- douche 10y agoHaving now looked up the difference between the two (I've only ever seen pressure canners, with the locking lids and real pressure gauges, but which everyone I know calls a pressure cooker), I'm now curious what in the world you would use a plain pressure cooker for? It seems like a strictly worse piece of equipment.
- maxerickson 10y agoTo cook things faster. Takes an hour or two off of a pot roast.
- unoti 10y agoYou'd use a regular pressure cooker for things like cooking a roast or chili in 45 minutes instead of 4 hours.
- bryanlarsen 10y agoYou can do that in a canner too. A canner can function as a pressure cooker, but a pressure cooker can't function as a canner.
- masklinn 10y ago> just as the pressure cooker started to go from "geek" to "mainstream" in its adoption curve. It's really really weird to read that, in europe pressure cookers have been mainstays of most every kitchen for decades, especially after SEB's "super cocotte" (released in '53, they'd sold 10 million by '69).
- literallycancer 10y agoExactly. "Most people have some concept of urban legends of exploding pressure cookers in their grandmother's kitchens," says Mr Qin. Am in Europe, literally everyone has a pressure cooker, never heard about them actually exploding.
- JoeAltmaier 10y agoWater heaters have many times the risk of exploding, and nobody blinks. Its strange how cookers got that reputation.
- ams6110 10y agoWas wondering the same thing. I had an old one and the pressure relief mechanism looked pretty foolproof. Basically just a weight sitting on top of a vent tube -- when the pressure got high enough, the weight was lifted and the pressure released.
- jml7c5 10y agoPresumably it's because people typically don't stand near water heaters, so there's less risk of injury in the event of an explosion.
- JoeAltmaier 10y agohttp://citywideplumbingpros.com/wp-content/uploads/2016/02/water-heater-explosion.jpg http://citywideplumbingpros.com/wp-content/uploads/2016/02/w...
- 10y ago
- jogjayr 10y agoIf you already have a pressure cooker which you are happy to use, and are content with making soups in a soup pot, are there any advantages to buying an Instant Pot?
- BeetleB 10y agoCompared to stovetop ones: 1. No need to fiddle with getting the heat right to get to pressure, and then lower the heat. Just seal the lid and tell it to get to pressure. It will control the heating. 2. Timer. It will drop the heat once the timer runs out. A lot of people set something to cook for, say, 30 minutes. Then they go out of the house for an errand that takes over an hour. They don't need to worry about overcooking/explosions. It will turn the heat down after 30 minutes and keep the food warm. That's really about it. I own both a stovetop one and an instant pot. Most of the raves I've seen for the instant pot apply equally well to other pressure cookers. Having said that, the two pros above are really, really nice. If people can afford it, I would tell them to buy this instead of a regular pressure cooker.
- jogjayr 10y agoThanks. I guess that's a no for me then. Point 1 is never an issue for me: turn the heat up to medium (or full, if you're in a hurry) until the pressure release "whistle" blows a couple of times, then turn it off. And while I never ever leave the house with the stove or oven left turned on, I guess I could see the convenience factor of point 2.