6 ms·
If anyone reading this thread is interested: I would pay non-trivial amounts of money on a regular basis for a service that systematically worked to eliminate r
by JoshTriplett 10y ago
If anyone reading this thread is interested: I would pay non-trivial amounts of money on a regular basis for a service that systematically worked to eliminate records like these (and the sources they draw from), as well as chasing down sources of junk mail and the lists they ultimately draw from.
The value would depend on effectiveness, and on the degree to which the service clearly reported exactly what they did. Calling and unsubscribing from sources of junk mail would be a moderate time-saver, but finding out where they got their names and addresses from and destroying those would be far more valuable.
It'd take some optimization and batching of the process to figure out how to avoid taking an excessive amount of time per person.
- mehrdadn 10y agoI've come across sites like these (SafeShepherd, though it doesn't claim to wipe your information from the "sources", only the sites they see your information on); the problem is I'm not sure I would trust them with something like my driver's license photo. Would you? Or what if they decide to sell your information behind your back later? Edit: Maybe it was a different site that needed your license (I thought it was SafeShepherd but I can't find it anymore). I know I've definitely come across ones that do.
- JoshTriplett 10y agoI wouldn't trust them with a driver's license (why would they even need that?), but I'd trust them with name/address/phone/email information, because that's the information that seems far too readily available already.
- mehrdadn 10y agoI know they need it because a lot of the info-searching sites that they "opt" you "out" from require it. I feel like I read that some need SSN too but I'm not sure about that one. Also note that SafeShepherd has this fine clause right at the end [1]: "You agree that Safe Shepherd isn't liable for any failure to comply with these Terms." What is this supposed to mean? Would you accept it? [1] https://www.safeshepherd.com/tos https://www.safeshepherd.com/tos
- LeoPanthera 10y agoWell that seems to imply that if you violate the TOS, it's your fault, not theirs. Seems reasonable?
- mehrdadn 10y agoIt also implies if THEY violate their TOS, it's your fault, not theirs. Seems reasonable?
- fanpuns 10y agoThere was a time (not sure if it's still the case) that the sites that post your info require proof of identity to remove your info
- devicenull 10y agoSafeShepherd seems like it's dying. They were active shortly after launch, but it's basically been radio silence ever since. I used to have an account with them, and I didn't find much value from them after the initial cleanup wave (they didn't seem to be keeping up with the new sites that came online).
- jquast 10y agoThis service exists, I've used it, can vouch for it. https://www.abine.com/deleteme/landing.php https://www.abine.com/deleteme/landing.php
- LeoPanthera 10y agoThis Reddit comment suggests DeleteMe doesn't work so well. https://www.reddit.com/r/privacy/comments/3q0cfz/thinking_about_signing_up_for_safe_shepherd_to/cwb0owe/ https://www.reddit.com/r/privacy/comments/3q0cfz/thinking_ab...
- JoshTriplett 10y agoQuoting that comment: > Your information will show up on those sites sometimes - it'll pop back up after being removed. That suggests that they're not actually tracking down the sources, just poking the downstream sites that get data from those sources. Much less useful.
- justin66 10y agoThe sources include government agencies at the state, local, county, and federal level. Those agencies are not going to hide public documents with your name and address on them just because you ask them to. There's a legal process to, for example, expunge a criminal record. On the other hand, most counties aren't going to seal the records associated with your house or other property you've bought just because you would like them to.
- dbg31415 10y agoCan confirm... manually went through and opted out of everything I could find... made me feel shitty because I had to provide photos and ID card photos to do it... less than a year later it was all back again. Hired one of the services to do it the second time around... they got maybe 50% of it... and less than a year again it was all back (note I was still paying the monthly subscription to have it all purged). Worse... I had to tell them what sites I found that they missed and waste time dealing with support issues... and let's be honest neither the companies who put the shit up, or the companies who you pay to take it down, are all that honorable. Extortion, pure and simple. Wish Google would just kill their site rankings, that would largely make the problem go away. Google is allowed to de-list spam sites... why they haven't classified all this crap as spam yet is beyond me.
- jameslk 10y agoI've considered working on this problem from a business standpoint, but I couldn't figure out a good business model for it. I don't think too many people will pay a monthly fee to have their information removed from these services. My guess is that they would sign up for a month and after their information has been removed, immediately cancel their subscription until they needed to do it again. And a yearly fee seemed like it would cost too much for mass adoption. There's also the problem that you'll often need to get the customer to "opt out" by providing their own information to verify they own it or they will need to click on a link from an email or receive an SMS text verification code. This gets really messy as an automated service.
- samstave 10y agoWhat about letting a user enter all their pertinent details, then having a "NUKE ME" button and it would eval how many sites and places to nuke from, and you base your costs to the user based on the effort to nuke the info you find. Then give a very straightforward list to the user and let them select which site/item they want to nuke and provide an upfront cost to them. * You're found on sites 1, 2, 3 * Nuking site 1 is $10.00 * 2 is $1.50 * 3 is $22.55 --- Or something like that?
- Dotnaught 10y agoOffering a reward that rises in proportion to the number of sites with your personal information might just provide an incentive to create more such sites. The more you'd pay for privacy, the more it would be worth to violate it.
- samstave 10y agoGame theory on your comment, sure... but I was just referring to "price per record/line item" -- how to separate these???
- web007 10y agoI used to work for https://www.reputationdefender.com/privacy https://www.reputationdefender.com/privacy - that is (was) exactly their business model. One of the big selling points was the time savings, where it would take you 80 hours a week or some crazy number if you did it yourself, filling out forms and keeping up with all of the new services that aggregate and sell this stuff. Doing it once is great, but won't help you after that month - all of the same places that initially sent all your data in to the aggregators are just going to do it again next month, so you'll get a new record all over again. They have largely pivoted since then, into a service primarily for reviews and feedback management. I don't have any insight into the quality of the existing service on either side.
- mikehollinger 10y agoI actually am running a (year long) experiment. I found a data broker who had my info. They offered a way to "correct" the record, so I added a car that I don't own (who's warranty should be ready for extended warranty offers in a few months) and added many many "off by one" errors like an extra zero on my income, or transposed digits on the size of my house. We'll see where it lands. I personally would also pay for this sort of service.
- mehrdadn 10y ago> I found a data broker who had my info. How...? Or do you just mean sites like InstanCheckmate themeselves? > They offered a way to "correct" the record, so I added a car that I don't own That's amazing! They didn't need proof? How did you convince them? Is this legal?
- literallycancer 10y agoWhy wouldn't it be? It's not like you are lying on tax forms.
- uiri 10y agoIs this legal? IANAL That said, fraud is usually defined as "An intentional misrepresentation of material existing fact made by one person to another with knowledge of its falsity and for the purpose of inducing the other person to act, and upon which the other person relies with resulting injury or damage." So, in order for such misinformation to be illegal, the data broker needs only to demonstrate injury or damage. Unless the data broker makes assurances to their customer about the truth of the information and gets sued by one of their customers for providing false information, I find it hard to believe that the data broker will be able to demonstrate injury or damages. I think the data broker knows better than to make such claims about their data but who really knows. And it isn't like the downstream customers are going to independently verify all the information.
- mirimir 10y agoThat makes no sense, unless there's a contract, or at least a business relationship.
- vonklaus 10y agoi think the best way to handle this is exactly the opposite. go on mechanical turk, and pay $500 to have them fill out every single free offer, product trial, social media account, ect with slightly similar but incorrect information. Give each turk 10 different pictures that look very similar to you, or are you in bad lighting, and pay them to upload them to G+, FB, ect. It is much easier to make your correct info difficult to ascertain, than it is to remove it all.
- JoshTriplett 10y agoThen they'll just spam all of them. And if you have other reasons to not want to be tracked down, then having 20 or 30 addresses will not help much.
- fanpuns 10y agoHere you go: www.safeshepherd.com I've been using them since way back when they were on earlibird. It's not perfect, but it has reduced the amount of times I show up in these sites significantly. The only disheartening thing is that most of these operators seem to just dump in batches of data periodically, ignoring any prior requests to remove so it has to be done again (which is fine, that's what you pay their automated search and remove request feature for)
- jszymborski 10y agoI've been recently: 1) Segregating automated email to some @customdomain.com address (Yandex and Zoho host vanity domains for free) 2) Forward all email @ that domain to a common inbox 3) Sign-up with servicename@customdomain.com (e.g: facebook@customdomain.com) You no-longer need to unsubscribe using dubious e-mail links, just automatically black-hole emails that come from spammer@customdomain.com So, far, so good. EDIT: List formatting
- JoshTriplett 10y agoUseful for email, but this is primarily about postal spam.
- jszymborski 10y agosomehow misread this entire post
- o_____________o 10y agoThis also helps obscure the very widespread practice of selling data to third parties that identify you with a stable, cross-purpose ID. (Liveramp, et al)
- ChuckMcM 10y agohttps://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Safe_Shepherd https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Safe_Shepherd These guys don't do it for you? Basically it is there business plan.
- ams6110 10y agoI have a foolproof plan for junk mail: I throw it away.
- mirimir 10y ago> junk mail Back in the day, junk mail often had "Return Service Requested", and senders had to pay return postage. So we would tape address labels to cardboard-wrapped bricks, and mark them as "moved with no forwarding address". But that doesn't work anymore.