5 ms·
Many prevailing theories of intelligence suggest that people with lower IQs are the ones most likely to break the law, since impulsivity, struggles at school, l
by AndrewKemendo 10y ago
Many prevailing theories of intelligence suggest that people with lower IQs are the ones most likely to break the law, since impulsivity, struggles at school, lack of social bonding, and lack of foresight are all linked to criminality.
...
the overall amount of crime in this range is still “much, much lower” than among people with very low IQ scores.
In fact what I would expect you find is that these groups of people break different laws, not fewer.
The "low IQ" group likely have less capability of breaking say, regulatory laws, by virtue of standing or access. They are more likely to break laws like B&E, drug dealing, petty larceny, etc... that are more harshly and more frequently prosecuted.
The laws that high performing, and High IQ people would be breaking, securities, privacy, regulatory etc... might not be prosecuted at all, or at most would lead to civil fines.
I think the bottom line is that "high IQ" people will tend to have more capability to break white collar crimes, and will do so with better cover (lawyers, special accounting etc...).
- adrusi 10y agoThe article implied greater incidence of violent crimes as well These included minor offenses such as trespassing and copyright violations, but also serious crimes such as arson, fraud, and kidnapping. Only one crime mentioned qualifies as "white collar".
- pc86 10y agoIsn't one of the major reasons to commit arson insurance fraud? I'm not saying arson is a white collar crime just that if you're desperate for money for whatever reason, and you're generally pretty smart, you may be inclined to try to get away with something like that. The same with kidnapping, although that seems much more violent and likely to end badly for everyone involved than arson.
- omouse 10y agoCopyright violations? Hahahaahahaha. Copyright itself is the offense. Ridiculous.
- sqeaky 10y agoI feel that if stated differently there is real potential for an argument here. Starting with an example of why copyright is bad, such as the preposterous 100+ year time for works to enter the public domain or that it was originally as a tool of censorship by European royalty would both be reasonable starting points. The way you put ityou are likely to get even anti-IP people, like myself, on the other side because we don't want to be associated with you.
- Mathnerd314 10y agoThe easy version is to just say "copyright monopoly"; everyone knows a monopoly is bad, and by mentioning it you automatically create an association. The fact that such an association doesn't necessarily exist (http://www.copyhype.com/2013/01/three-reasons-copyright-is-not-a-monopoly/ http://www.copyhype.com/2013/01/three-reasons-copyright-is-n...) is irrelevant, since most people don't reason logically anyway, and of course there are arguments for why there is in fact a monopoly (http://www.digitalmusicnews.com/2014/08/08/copyright-monopoly-nothing-artists/ http://www.digitalmusicnews.com/2014/08/08/copyright-monopol..., e.g. lack of advertising access).
- sqeaky 10y agoSound bites can be powerful when convincing people. I will use this in the future, at least to get a real conversation started. Without the backing of real conversation sound bites can be used to dismiss meaningful arguments. In turn this leads to them being dismissed. Switching back to copyright, I think that saying "copyright is not a monopoly" it is not as cut and dry as the linked site would indicate. I think one's ability to hire lawyers matters here. Consider Disney, they will have a much easier time defending themselves, where a smaller author might not be able too. Disney will also have a much easier defeating a legitimate defense of another real author than a lone author might be able to. It is not hard to imagine a hypothetical Disney of yesteryear suing people to keep other space operas down with their Star Wars IP. It is harder to imagine a small defendant succeeding in that defense even if it is legitimate. I think this is largely a non-issue, because Disney of today is less of jerk. Of all the kinds of Intellectual Property I think Copyright is most fair, the kind of legal abuse I described is much more common with Trademarks and Patents. I think the recent "flow" trademark issue or anything King software (the candy crush guys) does with game names so how asymmetric IP laws can be in general.
- kps 10y ago> minor offenses such as trespassing and copyright violations Not a terrible comparison, there. Trespassing is the use of someone else's property without permission, in a way that doesn't deprive them of it, typically isn't even noticed unless someone is watching out for it, and becomes frequent only where the approved route is disproportionately difficult.
- thatcat 10y agoNot a great one either. Trespassing has the additional aspect of physical space invasion that infringes on privacy and causes liability in a way that copyright can not. Digital copyright infringement is sharing data without a license which hasn't conclusively been shown to have a negative financial outcome for the holder of the copyright.
- wahern 10y agoTurning into someone's driveway to make a U-turn on a narrow residential neighborhood is trespassing. Without knowing more the best we could say is that high-IQ people are more aware of their crimes or maybe more willing to admit to them. For example, a property lawyer might be more likely to admit to trespassing than the average person just because he's more aware of how often he commits it. At the same time, his awareness of and persistence in such unlawful behavior doesn't mean he's flouting the law more than anyone else except in the most pedantic, literal sense. The whole study sounds dubious. Relying on self-reporting is excused as necessary. That there are no practical alternatives doesn't make the method magically sound or even remotely accurate. That in the aggregate self-reporting roughly corresponds with crime statistics says absolutely nothing about the accuracy of self-reporting for niche subgroups. It's this kind of pseudo-science that gives science in any field a bad name. I can appreciate that it might be especially difficult to find funding for a study that, first, establishes a strong correlation between self-reporting and IQ. But until there's significant push back from the community for studies premised on barely-tenable assumptions that funding will never be forthcoming.
- SomeStupidPoint 10y agoMy anecdata suggests most drug dealers beyond the lowest tier street level dealers are quite intelligent (and become more so as you move up the chain). It's almost like drugs are a business and businesses take intelligence to run.
- AndrewKemendo 10y agoThe biggest drug dealers are in banking, shipping and in governmental office. So they are breaking treaties instead of municipal criminal statutes. If you're smart enough, you get someone else to break the laws with the highest chance of arrest.
- js8 10y agoAnd if you are even smarter, you convince everybody that what you are doing is not a crime, but rather something like "natural order of the world".
- api 10y agoI find it funny that illegal drugs can be a 12-figure business globally and yet people seem to think it's just street level gang bangers doing this. Now who would have a vested interest in people thinking that? :) I'm sure there are organizations that would easily make it to the Fortune 100 if they could be listed as such. They're also smart enough to let disposable thugs break the street level laws. Real drug kingpins never physically handle product.
- paganel 10y ago> I'm sure there are organizations that would easily make it to the Fortune 100 if they could be listed as such. Case in point, a report from a couple of years ago claimed that the Calabria-based 'Ndrangheta had a turnover of 53 billion euros, approximately 3.5% if Italy's GDP. This is one of the articles discussing it: https://www.theguardian.com/world/2014/mar/26/ndrangheta-mafia-mcdonalds-deutsche-bank-study https://www.theguardian.com/world/2014/mar/26/ndrangheta-maf...
- 10y ago
- drzaiusapelord 10y ago>I think the bottom line is that "high IQ" people will tend to have more capability to break white collar crimes, and will do so with better cover (lawyers, special accounting etc...). I want to challenge this a bit. With common crimes, its obvious you're committing a crime. Breaking into someone's home, mugging, etc are clearly victimization. Now compare that to a technical crime that may or may not be a crime depending on which judge you get or how a jury decides to interpret a regulatory bill that's hundreds of pages long and can only be understood by a team of experts who most likely don't agree with each other. Or the creation of a new kind of investment vehicle no one has seen before. Or starting a new industry that no one understands. It becomes very difficult to equate these with street criminals who go into something knowingly they're breaking the law and acting unethically compared to a technical violation of something incredibly complex. More often than not, these kinds of things only become illegal well after their creation. So we're talking more about doing novel things and the lag between doing and regulation. That's not really crime. For example for a tech industry perspective, how many patent laws has even your most hobbyist of coders violated? The Linux kernel was analyzed a few years back and found to be potentially infringing on over 200 patents, for example. So anytime we monetize linux we're potentially 'white collar criminals.'
- barrkel 10y agoThe further up the value chain you are, not only can you eat a bigger parasitic load, but you're also insulated from "real" victims; because the value chain is built out of imaginary social constructions like companies, contracts, debt etc., you can dissemble by pointing out its non-substance and debatable social construction, like you demonstrate. The extra leverage (and thus reward) that comes from bending the design of social constructions and the ease in dissembling is exactly why I think it should be more harshly punished, rather than less.
- drzaiusapelord 10y agoThe problem with your approach is that you unfairly target the wealthy simply for being wealthy and educated and make excuses for the poor and uneducated. Consider two scenarios. My finance firm creates a new security that in the long run hurts people. A criminal breaks into a home and rapes a woman. I get the death penalty and he a lighter sentence for... reasons. I think you're just engaging in classism here. If anything, violence should have more serious punishments as its never justifiable outside of self-defense and can be expected to continue unless the state steps in. Also, the finance people are the bad guys right now but when society sees what automation is truly doing to their jobs, they'll come after us. So all of us who are automators are now going to jail. Beware witchhunts, because there's nothing that keeps you from becoming a witch. Law, morals, and intent won't matter once we're designated, as a class, as 'white collar' criminals like you are doing to finance people currently. Instead we should lean on the rule of law and not make special exemptions or special witch-hunts for any group. Write good law and policy. Don't engage in classist rhetoric that makes no sense outside of feel good and frankly, hysterical, ranting about "jailing the bankers!"
- tracker1 10y agoIt comes down to analyzing risk vs. reward... If there's near zero risk, with relatively large payout, then it's more likely to be worthwhile. Also, even then it's a consideration of the potential punishment. That doesn't even consider those that feel the law itself is unjust and may circumvent for other reasons.