17 ms·
Ask HN: Who really gives your personal info to Intelius, Instant Checkmate, etc?
Please excuse the frustrated tone; the "secrecy" all over the internet about the whole issue has been driving me insane.
The usual useless BS is "oh, these companies get it from governmental public records". Yeah, right. I'm pretty darn sure that some of the personal information I can find online on MyLife, Intelius, InstantCheckmate, Spokeo, etc. is not in some government agency's public record, and regardless, surely there's no way that hundreds of companies are repeating each others' work over and over again when they could just buy the information from someone.
Someone (or a few) hidden underneath has to be doing the heavy-lifting of scraping people's data from sketchy sources and selling them to third-party companies while staying hidden. My question is, who are these, and (where it is possible to know) whom are they selling to? How can I find out? Surely someone knows, and I'm tired of playing this goose chase where those who don't know just make random guesses as to how the information must be coming from some some public records, and those who do know say hardly anything beyond "you have to know where to look".
I'm not looking for just 1 pointer, though I would appreciate it. I'm tired of pointer chasing. I'm just looking for as comprehensive a list as possible. It has to exist somewhere... after all, when a court needs to order that someone's information be purged (for whatever reason, e.g. for safety), it's got to have a list of these data aggregators somewhere, so I'm sure some people must know. So how do I find out? I'm hoping to also learn to fish in addition to being given the fish.
Thank you!
- showkiller 10y agoI believe and based on the links below the data is sold by different entities to companies like Intelius etc. https://www.scientificamerican.com/article/how-data-brokers-make-money-off-your-medical-records/ https://www.scientificamerican.com/article/how-data-brokers-... http://triblive.com/news/allegheny/8690215-74/drivers-information-companies http://triblive.com/news/allegheny/8690215-74/drivers-inform... http://spectrum.ieee.org/riskfactor/computing/it/us-states-selling-hospital-data-that-puts-patients-privacy-at-risk http://spectrum.ieee.org/riskfactor/computing/it/us-states-s...
- pandabear187 10y agoI have insider knowledge as I used to work for one of these companies. Depending on the product you purchase the data comes from multiple sources. Also these companies have sophisticated machine learning capabilities to build a profile based on various attributes found in seemingly unrelated pieces of data. So the list consists of credit reporting agencies, public records, your online profiles with public access, court records, aggregators like LexisNexis and dozens like them. This heavy lifting you speak of is done differently by each company and consists literally based on multiple sources to enrich your profile. These companies spend millions on data and engineering and make even more, and whatever preconceived notion you have about courts ordering to seal your records, it doesn't happen in a centralized fashion, you would need to contact each data vendor individually to be removed. But it would be like playing whackamole.
- deegles 10y agoAs a person who used to be involved in that industry, do you try to protect your data more? Or is it just a losing battle?
- pandabear187 10y agoYes, I protect the shit out of my personal info. I have introduced a seeding mechanism to figure out who is sharing my data whenever I sign up for things. Public records are different and you have to create a Trust or a company to hide behind to not be personally listed. I would suggest anyone wanting to not be exposed to never use your real name or address online if you're not confident they won't share it. Introducing typos or initials or use a nickname for online orders that allow to list billing address separate from shipping address. Billing data typically has a better chance of not being resold, but there are no guarantees, read their TOS if not sure.
- samstave 10y agoI really think you should do a how-to / AMA Financial ignorance is an exceedingly exploited issue in the US, and I do not think anyone is doing anything about this.
- pushECX 10y agoWould you be willing to write up a guide of some sort about the steps that someone could take to protect their information? Personally, I would be willing to pay for something like that.
- mehrdadn 10y agoThank you for the reply. Can you actually give some kind of a list though? The entire problem here is everyone explains the how but no one is willing to explain the who. I certainly understand it's "multiple sources", I'm asking who are these sources I keep hearing about. There can't be nearly as many sources as there are sites who buy from them. If you'd like to not name the company you worked for yourself then could you at least please list as many other ones as possible? That would be far, far more helpful than just saying they use machine learning and that they use multiple sources, etc.
- slv 10y agoLexisNexis is one of the aggregator that is frequently used.
- mehrdadn 10y agoI thought was a court case database, not a personal information aggregator! +1 thank you!
- daxelrod 10y agoLexisNexis provides all sorts of databases. I had an experience where I was shopping for car insurance, and just before I signed, my rate doubled from what was previously quoted by the same company. It turned out that a LexisNexis database had an erroneous record claiming I was at fault for an accident.
- mehrdadn 10y agoWow! How did you find out it was LexisNexis? Did the insurance company just straight up tell you?
- TempleOS 10y agoGod is perfectly just. Humiliation equals exsaltation. turn the other cheek. If the eney asks you to confess one thing, confess two. I talk to God. There is perfect justice.
- TempleOS 10y agoHumiliation equals exaltation. You don't understand but I do. KJ21 As many as were astonished at thee—His visage was so marred more than any man, and his form more than the sons of men” ASV Like as many were astonished at thee (his visage was so marred more than any man, and his form more than the sons of men), AMP Just as many were astonished and appalled at you, My people, So His appearance was marred more than any man And His form [marred] more than the sons of men. AMPC [For many the Servant of God became an object of horror; many were astonished at Him.] His face and His whole appearance were marred more than any man’s, and His form beyond that of the sons of men—but just as many were astonished at Him, BRG As many were astonied at thee; his visage was so marred more than any man, and his form more than the sons of men: CEB Just as many were appalled by you, he too appeared disfigured, inhuman, his appearance unlike that of mortals. CJB Just as many were appalled at him, because he was so disfigured that he didn’t even seem human and simply no longer looked like a man, CEV Many were horrified at what happened to him. But everyone who saw him was even more horrified because he suffered until he no longer looked human. DARBY As many were astonished at thee—his visage was so marred more than any man, and his form more than the children of men
- AdmiralAsshat 10y agoHave you ever gone to the doctor, signed up for a gym, or signed up for your local grocery store's membership rewards program? That's how they get your information.
- mehrdadn 10y agoUh, what? This doesn't explain a lot of the information I see on some of these sites. It only explains the basics like your address and phone number.
- codegeek 10y agowell, don't underestimate the idiotic forms that many doctor's offices (in the US) want you to fill. Almost every time, I have seen forms that ask for everything about you. Personal information, Social Security Numbers, Employer information, heck even salary (not kidding). I just don't fill those of course but I am sure many people just fill them out because it is on the form.
- mehrdadn 10y agoAgain: I see information out there that doesn't fall in these categories. And again: even for the information that does, that still wouldn't tell me which companies are the main ones aggregating them and selling them off to other aggregators. That's what I'm trying to find out.
- jonas21 10y agoCan you be more specific on what type of information you're talking about?
- mehrdadn 10y agoPolitical Party? Views & Opinions? Relatives? Education history even if it's outside the country? Check out all the categories, here's [1] a random example. And yes, I know all of this information exists out there somewhere (resumes, mailing lists, social sites, whatever); my question is who is the first layer aggregating them from these sources. [1] https://www.mylife.com/john-smith https://www.mylife.com/john-smith
- clumsysmurf 10y agoOne book that covers the medical perspective is: "Our Bodies, Our Data: How Companies Make Billions Selling Our Medical Records" https://www.amazon.com/dp/B01EE08NXM https://www.amazon.com/dp/B01EE08NXM
- snowpanda 10y agoI read this book, it should be a crime what they do.
- JoshTriplett 10y agoIf anyone reading this thread is interested: I would pay non-trivial amounts of money on a regular basis for a service that systematically worked to eliminate records like these (and the sources they draw from), as well as chasing down sources of junk mail and the lists they ultimately draw from. The value would depend on effectiveness, and on the degree to which the service clearly reported exactly what they did. Calling and unsubscribing from sources of junk mail would be a moderate time-saver, but finding out where they got their names and addresses from and destroying those would be far more valuable. It'd take some optimization and batching of the process to figure out how to avoid taking an excessive amount of time per person.
- mehrdadn 10y agoI've come across sites like these (SafeShepherd, though it doesn't claim to wipe your information from the "sources", only the sites they see your information on); the problem is I'm not sure I would trust them with something like my driver's license photo. Would you? Or what if they decide to sell your information behind your back later? Edit: Maybe it was a different site that needed your license (I thought it was SafeShepherd but I can't find it anymore). I know I've definitely come across ones that do.
- JoshTriplett 10y agoI wouldn't trust them with a driver's license (why would they even need that?), but I'd trust them with name/address/phone/email information, because that's the information that seems far too readily available already.
- mehrdadn 10y agoI know they need it because a lot of the info-searching sites that they "opt" you "out" from require it. I feel like I read that some need SSN too but I'm not sure about that one. Also note that SafeShepherd has this fine clause right at the end [1]: "You agree that Safe Shepherd isn't liable for any failure to comply with these Terms." What is this supposed to mean? Would you accept it? [1] https://www.safeshepherd.com/tos https://www.safeshepherd.com/tos
- chrisgoman 10y agoFor pre-employment screening, we had court runners literally sitting through the courthouses going through paper records for each candidate on an "ad-hoc" basis. Some companies do this in a more organized fashion by having a person just data enter ALL the records (like in North Carolina if I recall) and since they had this data, we just bought the company.
- mehrdadn 10y agoPre employment screening is different though. They need your permission for a legal background check and of course they will do everything necessary to do it. I'm asking about the information that leaks without your permission.
- criddell 10y agoLast year I was getting constant calls and snail mail about buying an extended car warranty on a car that I no longer own. I asked the place where I bought my car if they sell that information and they claimed not to. So where do these sleazy companies get that data? The DMV? This year, I'm getting two or three calls every week about a buying a home security system and monitoring. I don't understand why these calls aren't easier to block. Somebody knows here they are originating from. Why can't I get that information too?
- pc86 10y agoVehicle registration is most likely public record in your state.[0] You can't push a button and stop all of these calls because there are dozens (probably tens of dozens) of companies that search and process public records and other data sets then sell that information to various companies. [0] http://www2.westlaw.com/CustomerSupport/Knowledgebase/Technical/Batch/WebHelp/Public_Record_Search_Coverage.htm http://www2.westlaw.com/CustomerSupport/Knowledgebase/Techni...
- szc 10y agoThe "home security system" calls could be social engineering to find out if your home is protected or not. Just by listening to what they say and not saying you already have one is enough to tell the caller what they want to know.
- criddell 10y agoI would never tell them anything, but I have listened to the recording and pressed '1' to speak to a representative and when I do that, nobody ever picks up. It's baffling.
- executive 10y agoYou mean data brokers (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Information_broker https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Information_broker) Top US brokers: - Acxiom - Experian - Epsilon - CoreLogic - Datalogix - eBureau - ID Analytics - inome - PeekYou - Rapleaf - Recorded Future Protip: loyalty/reward cards are a gold mine, especially drug store purchase receipt data
- AndrewKemendo 10y agoRight, but where do they get their data? Are they rolling their own JS API that developers roll into each page? I certainly have never put any of that into any site I've made or seen.
- mehrdadn 10y ago> Right, but where do they get their data? Yeah, I'm basically looking for the companies whose answer to this question is "by actually mining the data ourselves from your doctor, grocery store, Facebook, etc.".
- dsp1234 10y agoWhy do you think it works this way and not the other way around as well? Grocery stores shop their data around to see who will pay the most for it. A person who is out of work goes to the local courthouse and requests a bunch of records, compiles them into a spreadsheet and then cold (or warm with something like LinkedIn) calls to see if anyone is interested in the data. An online quiz company is going out of business, and as part of their bankruptcy settlement, they sell off their database of answers at auction. etc, etc, etc. As pointed out elsewhere, it's a marketplace, and as such there are going to be buyers and sellers. Some of those sellers are going to be primary sources themselves.
- mehrdadn 10y agoGood question. I thought it works that way because it takes a lot of work to sanitize and cross-link people's data to other datasets accurately, so even if it's a "push" model, I still can't believe that every single website that does this does their own data cleaning & ML & whatnot. It's far too much repeated work and a good business to just do the work and sell it off to others. So I'd assume a few companies have to be making profits at the lower layer regardless of whether it's a pull or a push model.
- VLM 10y ago"when a court needs to order that someone's information be purged (for whatever reason, e.g. for safety)" I believe that is the location of your confusion, that is a Hollywood fiction, mostly. If a collections agency is bugging you there is a way to resolve it via the legal system, but its very much case by case and company by company business. A judge can order one company who's officer or agent is present in the courtroom to do something to one record. A judge can purge his own legal system's record of an arrest if he wants to. Belief in this in general is analogous to non-computer people believing in the CSI tv show or hollywood hacking
- mehrdadn 10y agoWhat about the new higher level companies that pop up amin to Instant Checkmate? How do they know which lower-level companies to buy your information from? There's no way they ALL do the heavy lifting themselves. Someone's gotta be making money off doing the real work and others must be buying from them.
- xenadu02 10y agoMany clients of these services have agreements that require them to contribute data back (or at least they get a discount for doing it). I worked for a telephone company that used a service like this a long time ago and we shoveled customer data back at the provider. We did NOT give them call records though. Almost any medium sized company you deal with is selling your data.
- NickBusey 10y agoSmall tip: At the grocery store or anywhere else with a rewards account linked to a phone number, rather than signing up for one just use (Your Local Area Code)-867-5309 The number almost always exists and is a valid account. Get the discount, don't get tracked. Thanks, Tommy Tutone.
- r00fus 10y agoThanks - I always used my friends' parents old number - so someone I didn't know - this would be even better.
- VT_Drew 10y agoMake sure to tell them that you name in Jenny too.
- gvb 10y agoI've given (area code) 555-1212 and don't recall it ever being questioned. Technically I've given them my phone number, but with one indirection. ;-) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Directory_assistance https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Directory_assistance
- compuguy 10y agoThe last time I tried that, it didn't work (or there wasn't an account associated with it).
- Turing_Machine 10y agoIf I can't conveniently avoid those things, I like to use the names of famous serial killers, with a local address that would be in the ocean (if it existed). I've yet to have a sales clerk question it (or perhaps they just don't care).
- ams6110 10y agoThe clerks don't care. Why would they?
- blacksmith_tb 10y ago
- finid 10y agoPublic records, which is accessible to anybody. So paying to delete your info from one site is useless, because the next site that somebody sets up will have your info, if they use the same public records as the others.
- trelliscoded 10y agoI saw a great talk by a private investigator at a security conference on this topic, and did some research after the talk to confirm what he was saying. The short version is what you're asking for is going to be an uphill battle. Data aggregation companies don't want to disclose their sources because their services are often used by debt collectors and other organizations who want to find people who don't want to be found. If the sources were public knowledge, debtors could avoid them to escape debt collection agencies, for example. The comprehensive list you're looking for doesn't exist. Each data aggregation company has a different list which is the result of many private agreements they have with their sources. If you want a list of the sources, you can't ask the data aggregators. You can ask the sources themselves. Because you don't know who they are, you have to guess. Any company that puts a card in your wallet would be a good place to start. Under California Civil Code 1798.83, you can email companies and ask them to provide you with a list of all the direct marketing companies they sold your information to. Try making a request to your insurance agency. 1798.34 also allows you to ask California government agencies to provide you with an accounting of everyone they disclosed your information to. A 1798.34 request to the DMV should be a rich source of data providers. There's also lists of companies involved in the data aggregation ecosystem in the consumer finance protection board's list of complaints: https://data.consumerfinance.gov/dataset/Consumer-Complaints/s6ew-h6mp https://data.consumerfinance.gov/dataset/Consumer-Complaints... One surprising thing I found out during the talk is that pizza chains are a rich source of data for these companies. If you think about it, this makes perfect sense. The data includes a guaranteed link between a person, a place, payment information, and a phone number. > when a court needs to order that someone's information be purged I don't think this is a thing. A friend had to deal with a DV case and I got to see how all the legal machinery involved works. The court doesn't even bother trying to purge the victim's data when they move out and try to stay away from the abuser. The court simply moved the victim and the DV support organization told them to stay off social media and not to give the new address to anyone (including pizza places.) That being said, the federal government does have a comprehensive list of all the agencies which are members of the federal privacy council. In theory, these agencies are supposed to have a data integrity board which provides oversight for any data they keep on Americans. https://www.fpc.gov/federal-agencies/ https://www.fpc.gov/federal-agencies/
- 10y ago
- e0m 10y agoIf you have your own domain name with a wildcard, it's really helpful to enter: someservice@mydomain.com as your email. That way if it leaks you'll know who did it and can setup much more robust rules to block. I'll use the domain name as the main address so I remember which name goes to which site. For physical address mailings, you can hyphenate (or use a middle name) as the service. So First Service-Last as the addressee name. While harder to setup "mail rules" for, at least you'll know who to never trust again.
- Sephr 10y agoI've been doing exactly this for a while. Here is my list of companies that have leaked the email address I gave them to spammers: https://gist.github.com/eligrey/5084991 https://gist.github.com/eligrey/5084991
- mehrdadn 10y agoNote that (I think) Adobe was hacked, so that doesn't mean your email was "leaked" by them per se, not in the sense we mean anyway. Also, out of curiosity, how long did it take these companies to leak your info, generally? Days, weeks, months, years...?
- Sunset 10y agoDropbox was hacked as well.
- lucb1e 10y agoAwesome work! I do the same with email addresses, but receive very little spam. Mostly I block addresses that start spamming me with newsletters. I've thought about keeping a list, but most companies actually stick to the Dutch anti-spam laws (which are quite good). Only Dropbox and one personal contact ever actually sold/leaked my email address, and Paypal of course but they hand my email address out to all merchants so they're almost certainly not to blame themselves (not beyond the fact that they hand it out in the first place).
- danielk_ 10y ago
- bobzibub 10y agoWould it be possible to copyright our names and use DMCA takedown notices? Just a random thought.
- uiri 10y agoNames do not meet the threshold of originality test[0]. Beyond that, your parents would be the copyright holder until their death when you would inherit it via their estate. They are potentially covered under trademark if you have a brand in a specific industry and others are using your name or a similar name in a way that could cause consumer confusion. [0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Threshold_of_originality https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Threshold_of_originality unrelated: the threshold for code is usually around 15 lines.
- goshx 10y agoIt pisses me off too. US is so concerned about privacy, yet a LOT of your private information is made public once you start opening bank accounts, buying real estate, sign up for gym, etc. When I opened my first bank account they had a typo in my name, which I found out when I received my debit card. I asked them to fix it immediately, however, two to three weeks later I was already getting mail from stores addressed to the misspelled name. When I was buying my first house I immediately started receiving mail from moving companies at my old address before I signed the closing. After I moved I got a lot of junk mail with other kinds of offers. I even started getting PHONE CALLS from a home monitoring/alarm company. When I asked them where they got my number they hang up. It is like all the information is up for sale somewhere.
- diminoten 10y ago> US is so concerned about privacy This is not true, at all. HN may provide that appearance, but the vast majority of people who live in the US do not care about their privacy, based on their actions.
- confounded 10y agoTaking power away from capital to give to individuals is currently positioned as un-patriotic in the US (e.g. pandabear187 above's beleif that regulation of data brokers will lead to fascism or communism, even though he goes to great lengths to protect his own information).
- accountface 10y agoIt sounds like based on the other comments that there's no way to track down one sole source because there are so many varying from public records to machine learning... That being said, is there a simple way to better obscure yourself? Like using a business name and a PO box instead of your personal name when it comes to bills/addresses?
- ennuihenry 10y agoEasy one is they scrape Google for Linkedin bio info. I'm paranoid that USPS sells your info once you fill out their change of address form.
- devicenull 10y agoYou mean like this? http://www.nationalchangeofaddress.com/ http://www.nationalchangeofaddress.com/
- ennuihenry 10y agoWTF. So if Intelius has your address, they can pay the USPS to get your new address. That incentivizes me not to fill out that darn form.
- fanpuns 10y agoSeems like getting mail you forgot to forward would outweigh this
- dredmorbius 10y agoRequest a temporary forward. Up to 12 months.
- JoshTriplett 10y ago> I'm paranoid that USPS sells your info once you fill out their change of address form. They do: https://www.forbes.com/sites/adamtanner/2013/07/08/how-the-post-office-sells-your-new-address-with-anyone-who-pays-and-the-little-known-loophole-to-opt-out/ https://www.forbes.com/sites/adamtanner/2013/07/08/how-the-p...
- bb611 10y agoYou're not paranoid, I don't know if money changes hands but my changes of address have 100% been accompanied by spam snail mail. I just don't change my mailing address anymore.
- samstave 10y agoLexis-Nexis? TRW/Experian/etc? https://www.lexisnexis.com/risk/ https://www.lexisnexis.com/risk/
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- tgarma1234 10y agoReading this thread I can answer the question because I have worked in this industry and given/sold data to Intellius specifically. There are three main sources of ALL of the data: 1. Acxiom http://www.acxiom.com/ http://www.acxiom.com/ 2. Experian http://www.experian.com/ http://www.experian.com/ 3. Neustar https://www.neustar.biz/ https://www.neustar.biz/ Acxiom got it's big start by developing a way to copy phone books in the 90s and they won a court case that sided with them saying the name and address information was basically public info. Acxiom aggregates something like 800 different attributes for each named person at each address using third party vendors and then resells the entire consumer database to list brokers who often times will add additional detail for smaller subsets of the data. You can opt out of Acxiom by going here http://www.acxiom.com/about-acxiom/privacy/consumer-data-information/ http://www.acxiom.com/about-acxiom/privacy/consumer-data-inf... 2. Experian. Same as above but they have a lot more specific data about you because you probably fill out forms related to credit and loan applications correctly. Thus they know all of you previous addresses and they sell that to companies like Intellius. 3. neustar: ditto. The main thing to keep in mind is that each of those three companies have slightly different channels through which they aggregate consumer data so your info comes out a little differently in each database. Almost any list broker or mailing house or telemarketer that you encounter is getting their data ultimately from one of those three companies (and in many cases they would buy data from all three sources). Finally, a company like http://www.criteo.com/ http://www.criteo.com/ uses a process they call "database cookie-ization" to match your online browsing history (hence interests and business) to those three databases via your email addresses. So they know what you look at online, where you live, everything you have ever requested credit for, etc etc. There are hundreds of smaller companies like these (below) feeding data into those databases too: https://www.hgdata.com/ https://www.hgdata.com/ https://www.fullcontact.com/ https://www.fullcontact.com/ http://zetaglobal.com/ http://zetaglobal.com/ https://www.lotame.com/ https://www.lotame.com/
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- dbg31415 10y agoIf Google aggressively delisted shitty companies like this, the problem would go away. There's no value for society in these shit services that make people register and pay to have their profiles taken down.
- ddebernardy 10y agoThen again, Google and Facebook are the biggest aggregators among them. Admittedly, they don't sell raw access to their data.
- monodeldiablo 10y agoI've had the misfortune to be present for an in-person demo of a verification service nearly a decade ago. It involved those relationship questions ("Which one of the following people have you not lived with in the last 5 years?") that are incredibly creepy. I was shocked that they had so much data on me -- I have no debt, no credit cards, no house, no car, no bills, and I had always entered informal rent agreements (I was poor) up to that point -- yet the rep was easily able to list all the places I had resided from college to present, along with a host of off-the-books housemates. "Where the fsck did you get all this?!" I demanded. "Have you ever ordered a pizza?" Turns out, some fast food chains do a brisk business in reselling customer data. I had ordered from Domino's once, but that was enough to link my name to a specific location. This experience has made me extremely sensitive about the information I give while making a purchase. When I lived in the US, I stopped having food delivered, paid in cash, and never signed up for branded credit cards. I rented informally and, whenever possible, tried to just pay the landlord my share of utilities in cash. Anything to keep a lower profile. Far more companies than you realize are collecting as much data as possible about you, your habits, and your relations. So I'm afraid your search for a canonical list of data sources is ultimately fruitless. In this new economy, you are always the product.
- dkersten 10y agoYou might enjoy the book "how to be invisible" by J. J. Luna
- dredmorbius 10y agoTemporary postal mail forewards. USPS NCOA (Change of Address) file is another major data source. https://www.forbes.com/sites/adamtanner/2013/07/08/how-the-post-office-sells-your-new-address-with-anyone-who-pays-and-the-little-known-loophole-to-opt-out/ https://www.forbes.com/sites/adamtanner/2013/07/08/how-the-p...
- bogomipz 10y agoThanks for the tip, from the link: "There is, however, a loophole that keeps data brokers from accessing your updated address. When you fill out the online form to change an address, you can indicate a temporary change that provides six months of forwarding that can then be extended for another six months. That information, unlike the changes marked as permanent, is not included in the master list sold to data brokers." And the online link for online change of address with the loophole: https://moversguide.usps.com/icoa/home/icoa-main-flow.do?execution=e1s1&_flowId=icoa-main-flow https://moversguide.usps.com/icoa/home/icoa-main-flow.do?exe...
- etree 10y agoThe one that surprised me is to learn that virtually all health insurance companies sell your personal health information. Most people think this is illegal because the data is sensitive. But it turns out that if it's generated by a business transaction (i.e. a claim between your doctor and your insurance company) then it's not considered PHI and it's not protected.
- nl 10y agoTake a look at this (2015) pic of the landscape: https://www.slideshare.net/RaviralaKarunakar/luma-display-adtech-landscape https://www.slideshare.net/RaviralaKarunakar/luma-display-ad... The companies you are interested in are in "DMP & Data Aggregators" and "Data Suppliers" section. But this is only the largest, best known companies. There are many, many more.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- yuhong 10y agoThis reminds me of https://www.spamhaus.org/faq/section/Marketing%20FAQs#176 https://www.spamhaus.org/faq/section/Marketing%20FAQs#176
- dredmorbius 10y agoInformation acquired from a number of sources, including working in the data industry (a decade or two back), privacy advocacy, working in Web space, research of my own, stories over beers, legal experiences, etc. There's a large information-brokerage industry. If you want to find it, investigating the question from the consumption side (as in: who will sell me this information) should turn up the larger players, most of whom are already listed in this thread. https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=13804795 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=13804795 The big players are much of the business: Power laws work here as anywhere else, and heading off the larger sources is pretty effective. The value of individual data isn't all that great. Which leads to one of the major PITAs of this industry: there's a lot of invalid, false, or stale data around. The incentives to fix it simply don't exist. The now-defunct Internet Junkbuster used to have a print-your-own set of letter templates which could be sent to various marketing organisations. Doing that in the early 2000s dropped my own junk-mail volumes tremendously, and for years afterward. I suspect SafeShepherd operates somewhat similarly. Finding and hitting the direct marketing association(s) was a big part of that. Putting a fraud hold on your credit reports (TansUnion, EquiFax, Experian) is useful. Any account-based activities or activities in which you are specifically identified are fodder for capture. Credit cards, checks (Luddite! ... hang in there), "loyalty" cards. Gyms and pizza, as noted. Facebook, which should go without saying. LinkedIn profiles. Any online information service which has ever been hacked. (For safety, assume all of them.) Online purchases. Through both the marketplace and your credit card. Court and other public records are manually reviewed and entered. Various school and alumni associations. Organisations such as Classmates.com, MyLife, etc., front-ended to skip-tracing and similar organisations (info via direct communications). Your auto smog testing station. There's an outfit known as ISO, Insurance Services Office, who has a unit that tracks down odometer mileage data. They glean that by buying the state smog check data, which is indexed by VIN and drivers license in mose cases. The notion is that miles driven is an excellent proxy for insurance risk. https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Insurance_Services_Office https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Insurance_Services_Office The US Post Office NCOA (change of address) form, as noted. File a temporary COA to avoid getting listed. Used to be you could submit a "pornographic materials" request to the USPO to have circulars and such removed from your delivery. Though online sources suggest it's possible to block 3rd class mail (Yahoo answers). That's more an annoyance than privacy issue. Magazine subscriptions. Request of any organisations you do business that they not share your information. Use telltales to determine which do (additions to your address, name, etc.). And, if the state of affairs bothers you, get on your government representatives to do something about it. Data are liability, and there's far too much of it floating around. The US in particular has taken an exceptionally piecemeal approach to the problem (video store rental records are protected, bookstore and pharmacy records are not). Request comprehensive data privacy regulations, with teeth.
- mxk17 10y agoThere are far too many too name and they each collect data from different sources - both primary and secondary. Then the data is shared between them through intermediaries that would form a very long list. This duplication/redundancy makes it impossible to remove your data completely from all the owners. Experian Acxiom DataLogix TransUnion Innovis Woodbridge/Thomson Reuters DNB
- tracker1 10y agoYou don't think all those fake facebook/twitter profiles trying to follow/friend you are just for the lulz do you... They're mostly for mining your personal information. This extends to transaction processing agreements with advertisers and merchants for the purpose of analytics and tracking, as well as information sharing from credit card companies themselves, and peering agreements for data. Just your email address alone, let alone combined with IP information can result in being able to find a lot of information about you... then you take that and correlate it to public information, cc purchase history, online profiles, it's a treasure trove. That doesn't even count extra data gleaned from all the tracking cookies. All said, I'm still far more concerned about government use of similar data than I am private businesses.
- tylercubell 10y agoAs far as public records go, real estate data can be quite the treasure trove. There are data brokers that collect, analyze, and resell this information all day long. For example, my startup can pull information on ownership, mortgage and sales history, liens, and foreclosure records, among many other things, for a given property. If you were to cross-reference the data with other public and proprietary sources, it could get pretty, umm... what's the right word?, "interesting", in terms of accuracy and level of detail.