4 ms·
IANAL, though, so I don't know exactly what Apple is on the hook for. The GPL applies to anyone who distributes a GPL product. Apple is the distributor.
by yummyfajitas 17y ago
IANAL, though, so I don't know exactly what Apple is on the hook for.
The GPL applies to anyone who distributes a GPL product. Apple is the distributor.
- sigzero 17y agoI am not sure that is going to fly though. Apple is the conduit in this case. The developer is still the distributor and has chosen to do so through the store.
- DrSprout 17y agoFarmer : producer. Walmart : distributor. Car manufacturer : producer. Car dealership : distributor. Software developer : producer. Apple App Store : distributor.
- sigzero 17y agoI don't think that scenario holds for the actual "license" and it would just make the GPL suck that much more if you try to hold Apple to something like that.
- chc 17y agoYou're really ignoring the obvious facts in favor of arguments over tiny minutiae. The App Store is a store. Not a conduit, not a dumb pipe, a store. Apple maintains it, Apple choses what to stock there, Apple specifies the terms of purchase and Apple makes a profit off each item it sells there. The developer just gives Apple his app to put in its store. Analogously to this case, if my local store doesn't refrigerate its milk properly, I don't sue the dairy farmer. Apple's App Store is a store in exactly the same sense.
- ahoyhere 16y agoYour analogy fails miserably. If your grocery store fails to refrigerate otherwise perfectly good milk, the analogy to the App Store would be that Apple injected GPL code into the app. No, if Nabisco violates a copyright agreement with the box design of some cookies, and your grocery store sells them (unknowingly), the grocery store is not at fault.
- chc 16y agoThe developer did not place any illegal restrictions on the app. Those are all imposed by Apple's store.
- jacobian 17y agoHm. It would seem that similar logic would apply to, say, an ISP which "distributes" GPL produces over its pipes and applies additional restrictions via its EULA. This sort of "if you touch GPL in any way" reading isn't a very positive one for copyright in general, and I think it'd be a pretty bad faith argument to make. I think, then, that the FSF's argument must be a more nuanced one; but like pierrefar I can't quite suss out what, exactly, they object to. The App Store obvious violates the spirit of the GPL in about a dozen ways, but it's unclear to me how the app store violates the letter of the GPL.
- DrSprout 17y agoDid you read the root post in this thread? Apple is distributing GPL code, and therefore Apple is responsible for providing source. Cut and dry, cannot get any simpler. If you distribute binaries compiled from GPL source, you are required to distribute source. Apple is not distributing source, case closed. Furthermore, the App store license forbids end-users from redistributing binaries, which again, is a cut and dry violation of the GPL, since it not only says the opposite, but that you must allow them to distribute binaries and source. This isn't an "if you touch GPL in any way" problem. It's a "if you give someone something under the GPL, you must follow the GPL." Apple is not a dumb pipe. They are hosting the software.
- jacobian 17y agoDid you read the root post in this thread? Why do you need to do this? I'm trying to honestly engage with the ideas presented here, and what's clear to you isn't clear at all to me. Why do you assume I'm operating in bad faith? Apple is not a dumb pipe. They are hosting the software. Clearly, and clearly it's an important difference. But I'm not so sure where the legal line is drawn. What about SourceForge? They have a EULA, right? Have they carefully written one that's compatible with the GPL? Or what about language package hosts like RubyGems, PyPI, or CPAN? Do they need to be careful about any terms and conditions to avoid violating GPL'd apps placed on their repositories? I'm not a lawyer -- are you? -- and I certainly don't claim to be an expert here. But even if you think I'm an idiot the fact is I actually know quite a good deal about copyright and software licensing, and I still don't see what the FSF's particular legal argument is. And I do want to understand their argument, especially as it applies to other types of "app stores" that might distribute open source code on behalf of other users.