11 ms·
Oh please. Not this again. I recently had the pleasure of checking in on Windows for the second time in 7 years. I had been a PC user since the DOS days, start
by Razengan 10y ago
Oh please. Not this again.
I recently had the pleasure of checking in on Windows for the second time in 7 years. I had been a PC user since the DOS days, starting on a 286, and going all the way to Windows 8 when I switched to Macs around 2010. I've only ever needed Windows for games since then, and decided to install Boot Camp on the 15" 2016 MacBook Pro that I just got (which happens to be a pretty good machine [1], all in all, and runs Paragon [2] in high detail at 1920x1080 60 FPS; enough for me.)
There is still so much wrong with Windows I honestly don't know where to begin. The UI remains a convoluted Escher'esque nightmare. Apple and macOS are still FAR from fucking up badly enough to make me want to willingly head back to Microsoft.
I am running both Sierra and the latest version of Windows 10 side-by-side (with Parallels Desktop) so the differences are very glaring and obvious. Maybe I'll write up an in-depth comparison later.
[1] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=13790106 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=13790106
[2] https://www.epicgames.com/paragon/en-US/home https://www.epicgames.com/paragon/en-US/home
- angry-hacker 10y agoThe fact that I still had to do 3 hours worth of updates and restarts after fresh install is beyond me. Install (only) MS Word - - another cycle of updates. Restart, check updates, more updates!!! It's just insane. Why does it download Outlook spam filter update, 100mb?I don't have Outlook installed, I only wanted freaking MS Word.
- cube2222 10y agoWhat version of windows are you on? (10 or 7)?
- angry-hacker 10y agoJust did fresh W10 install a few weeks ago and had to go through that pain.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- gist 10y ago> Oh please. Not this again. Exactly. Honestly it's linkbate nonsense. Sucks you in like a car crash on the side of the road or a hockey fight.
- MrBuddyCasino 10y agoSad but true. Apple may be on a slow descent, but they have years until their flight path intersects the nether realms of Windows. Granted, Windows has a usable file manager (Explorer) and Finder is an embarrassment, but theres always Path Finder.
- AsyncAwait 10y agoPath Finder is great, but I've always hated how on OS X you have to pay for 3rd party replacements of even the most basic software.
- arkades 10y ago> The UI remains a convoluted Escher'esque nightmare. Comments like this make it hard to take any side of the discussion seriously. /Neither/ of the OSes are "Escher'esque nightmare[s]." My elderly mother can kludge her way through both of them, more or less reliably - admittedly, with more trouble than using her phone, but not a lot more. Nothing that a tech-illiterate can reasonably use on a day-to-day basis qualifies as a "nightmare." Can we please stop pitching hyperbole-for-effect until it nullifies the entire discussion?
- Razengan 10y ago> Comments like this make it hard to take any side of the discussion seriously. /Neither/ of the OSes are "Escher'esque nightmare[s]." • macOS Finder: http://i.imgur.com/9Y5hK0e.png http://i.imgur.com/9Y5hK0e.png • Windows Explorer: http://i.imgur.com/ef7CnJ4.png http://i.imgur.com/ef7CnJ4.png Alright. Maybe not nightmarish, but one of these IS objectively more convoluted than the other. Let's start with something simple: WHY does the "Options" button on the Windows Explorer Ribbon (in the top-right corner) drop-down to reveal a SINGLE menu item which DOES THE EXACT SAME THING as clicking on the button itself? (Bonus: This is what happened when I tried to take a screenshot first: http://i.imgur.com/UsN554o.png http://i.imgur.com/UsN554o.png — Explorer hanged when trying to remove a shortcut to a now-missing network share.)
- Ezhik 10y agoThat ribbon is hidden by default.
- Razengan 10y agoBut it's not on the Finder, and the Finder defaults to the "All My Files" view which is completely empty on a new user account, so I changed one thing on each side to make the screenshots more comparable, but here are the absolute default views for each OS: http://i.imgur.com/Dni0Kpo.png http://i.imgur.com/Dni0Kpo.png http://i.imgur.com/TM8ZyLg.png http://i.imgur.com/TM8ZyLg.png The Finder is still less cluttered, with all its buttons in 1 toolbar instead of spread across 4.
- andrewdski 10y agoAn in-depth comparison would be most welcome. I use Windows (7) all day writing code at work, and use Sierra at home nights and weekends. I do prefer MacOS, but I'm very curious what your issues are because I don't see them. If I really wanted as powerful a (desktop) machine as I could get for gaming, I'd definitely go Windows. No contest. (I don't want that.) Apple's notebooks are excellent, no argument there.
- ntsplnkv3 10y agoI'm a huge fan of Windows 7. The UI is simple, everyone is familiar with it, it's relatively stable, but most importantly, basic tasks are so much easier to deal with. In my opinion, it is the best Windows OS made. Unfortunately Windows 8 and 10 are just not great OSs, in my opinion. A major theme on these threads is "Apple is trying to force mobile onto desktop computers." yet I see Windows doing it just as much, and not nearly as smooth, as Apple. Cortana, weird metro UI layout, terrible settings, confusing maintenance, updates never work, slow response times, etc. I gave up on Windows 10 when I got my father a new laptop and had to troubleshoot my sister's. The OS is a mess. Finding basic things is so difficult. Just give me a control panel. Now we have "Settings" too, which is just a mess. Windows Update never works properly. It constantly needs a troubleshooter to run and start and stop the services again. My dad didn't want to log in with an email to his laptop. So I disabled it (which was difficult to find, so I had to google it.) Now it's suddenly back, and he's complaining about it. There's no way he manually did it purposefully. Trying to disable things like Cortana never works right. The huge debacle of info being sent to microsoft and needing heavy workarounds to actually prevent it from occurring. And then being force fed apps with advertisements built into the OS...come on. Apple simply needs to improve their hardware at their price point and 90% of these threads wouldn't be made. The OS needs some additional features and improvements, but the experience is just so much better than Win10 and 8 for me. My current build uses Windows 7 and whenever it is officially unsupported I will move on from Windows completely.
- scholia 10y ago> Just give me a control panel. The old Control Panel is still there. > Trying to disable things like Cortana never works right. Cortana is a settable option. There's no reason to try to disable it. *> Now we have "Settings" too, which is just a mess. Settings is a clean, well-organized and simple app that does what most people want. It saves ordinary users from having to grapple with the Control Panel. You'd probably do better if you spent more time in learn mode instead of in angry mode.
- dualogy 10y ago> The UI remains a convoluted Escher'esque nightmare. Totally disagree. I hopped from OS to OS for over a decade every other year or 3 (Win, OSX, Linuxes with various DMs/WMs) and it's always, always an adjustment period from "WTF is this" to "totally productive with this now", usually a matter of 1-2 weeks. Happy with Fedora/Gnome right now but have to say just Explorer itself beats Finder and Nautilus (rebranded as "Gnome Files" apparently now) for keyboard users when it comes to out-of-box file managers. The weird new tiles/metro UI stuff they tried pushing from Win 8 is of course a pretty bad attempt to Microsoftify the "secondary desktop layer" concept that has been prevalent on the other OSes for longer, and better. It sucks, but also useless and thus not used for many/most power users I'd guess. The rest of the "UI" question is in the hands of individual independent app developers, as it properly should be.
- AsyncAwait 10y ago> Explorer itself beats Finder and Nautilus Have you checked out Nemo, which is basically the good old, full-featured Nautilus?
- saghm 10y agoLinux file explorers (Nautilus, etc.) aren't exactly a pleasure to use, but then again, as a Linux user, if I have to open a GUI to do something with my files, I'm usually not happy about it in the first place.
- keevie 10y agoEver use ranger? Of course, not exactly comparable, but it's pretty amazing.
- saghm 10y agoOh, this looks interesting! I've never really tried out terminal-based file managers, but I could see myself using something like this. I'd definitely need to spend some time getting used to it though, not to mention learning how to do various things (show hidden files, etc.)
- adekok 10y agoI'll agree with most of this. We had a new hire come in with his personal Windows laptop. We tried to get him connected to the corporate WiFi, and into the corporate net with our own client certs and private CA. Uh... no. No, you can't do that. WiFi configuration was annoying. Lots of clicking. No consistency to the UI. And for a relatively new laptop, it was slow. OSX in comparison was simple, relatively straightforward, and responsive. Certificates were a joke. We could import certificates and CAs. But once imported, they didn't do anything. Access to the corporate intranet was still blocked with "unknown CA". When we went back to see if the certs had been imported... nope. No certificates. OK, import them again? Nope, still no certificates on the machine. We gave up and let him use a spare Mac Mini. I hate where Apple has been going with OSX: Slow strangulation by oxygen deprivation. But until it becomes entirely unusable, it's still better than Windows for me.
- mathnode 10y agoThe UI is a mess of old and new in Windows 10. Generally "advanced" options means switching to and old menu style (win 7 and older).
- throwawayish 10y ago"win 7 and older"? There are still plenty of configuration dialogues that have only seen the slightest of changes since Windows NT 4.0; I'm not exaggregating. Windows is easily the most visually inconsistent OS out there -- even in comparison to a Linux desktop. That has it reasons of course, many features are in there that didn't need any kind of update in the last 15+ years, therefore their UI was never updated to conform to updated guidelines and so on.
- rado 10y agoYes. Windows 10 is a commendable effort, but nothing more. Seeing multiple styles of typography in different windows is just sad. And ugly. macOS is untouchable, whatever sins Apple has committed.
- tempodox 10y agoEscher would turn in his grave being compared to that.