8 ms·
There is the ontological position that mathematical truths are "out there", independent of us, and we are merely "discovering" them. As such, they're eternal, a
by FabHK 10y ago
There is the ontological position that mathematical truths are "out there", independent of us, and we are merely "discovering" them. As such, they're eternal, and you could argue then that you "touch immortality".
But apart from that, I find this sort of talk unhelpful. It's a bit like Schopenhauer who thought that instrumental classical music gave access to the innermost truth of the universe (I'm paraphrasing from memory here) - what hogwash.
Lastly, the headline has not much to do with the article, has it?
- JoeAltmaier 10y agoSo, the value of PI is a human invention? That's hogwash.
- cannonpr 10y agoDon't you feel it's a bit harsh to summarise the entire debate between idealism and realism as hogwash ?
- JoeAltmaier 10y agoJust echoing the parent post there.
- FabHK 10y ago> Don't you feel it's a bit harsh to summarise the entire debate between idealism and realism as hogwash ? Granted, a bit harsh :-) There's more to be said about it. But remember how Ford Prefect wrote volumes about earth in the Hitchhiker's Guide to the Galaxy, and then it was abridged to "Mostly harmless"? So that was (my) very abridged version of idealism.
- ThomPete 10y agoWho else invented it?
- JoeAltmaier 10y agoThat question presupposed it was invented. Its just there. To be discovered. Its not different somewhere else; it wouldn't be different in a different universe.
- ThomPete 10y agoI don't think you are aware of what you are claiming. If something is "out there" as a specific concept as you claim, then it requires a perspective to isolate it as "a thing" which means you are basically claiming there must have been a creator. If there is no creator then there is no perspective other than that of observers like us. Unless you of course claim that the classical physical universe is fundamental not the quantum physical one.
- kordless 10y agoI don't think you are aware of what is claiming this. ;) Perspective matters in terms of "proving" something outside of observation, by the assumed fact observation can change perspective. In other words, if all of this is a single entity, it's going to be hard to prove that because bits would exist outside perception due to the cost of it being a recursive operation. One may not know oneself without recursion.
- ThomPete 10y agoYou are also missing the point. If something exist "out there" as a separate concept then it can only do so because it exist as a discreet entity. Yet QM shows us that the world isn't fundamentally discreet but rather non-local. We can observe because there is a discreet universe to observe within, but that does not make the observable universe the foundation of reality. And so if you want to claim that something exist out there without there being a designer or without our perspective of reality being what turn it into existence then you need to explain how it relates to the entire universe not just the classical one.
- 10y ago
- GavinMcG 10y agoThis is an odd reading of the parent comment, since "apart from that" indicated that mathematical truths being built in isn't what the commenter disagreed with.
- omalleyt 10y agoThe concept of "circle" is a human invention, in that a perfect circle has never been observed in the universe. The value of pi follows immediately as a derivative human invention.
- justifier 10y agoI would argue the 'perfect circle' is inherent in every circle, similarly to how it is inherent in your dismissal of it But if you require a more direct understanding I would say there is a perfect circle in every rotation
- kordless 10y agoThe possibility of a perfect circle exists in this universe, but the last digit we are aware of is definitely a posteriori. In other words, the description of a circle is prior knowledge given it allows calculating pi, but the actual values are post observational knowledge, given they must be calculated and continue to be irrational forever. (At least as far as we know.) It would take an infinite amount of power to calculate every digit in pi, given pi itself is irrational, even while describing how to calculate it is rational.
- justifier 10y agoYou are moving someone else's goalposts I answered where circles are in our universe and you then try to change the original intent of omalleyt's question to mean a symbolic representation of pi > It would take an infinite amount of power to calculate every digit in pi Calculating pi is so simple life without nervous systems does it Now, expressing that value in our limited yet overly verbose base ten symbolic representation would indeed require infinite recursion
- kordless 10y agoI'm not aware of a means by which goal posts can exist in a philosophical debate around rational vs. irrational thinking. Both types of thinking are valid, but I can see how and why some tend to argue for absolute rationality at all times.
- jknoepfler 10y agoThe means of systematizing, expressing, reasoning about, computing with, and teaching about pi are human inventions. Does pi amount to more than the sum of its human parts? You can say "hogwash," but that's not contributing much to a question that requires a careful answer
- lacker 10y agoA circle is a human invention. There are no perfect circles in the universe. Euclidean geometry is a human invention. In the real world, spacetime is curved. Real numbers are a human invention. The universe does not seem to be built of numbers with infinite precision. I would go further and say that the number "two" is a human invention. The universe could carry on just fine without any life anywhere having the concept of "two". But the case is certainly stronger for calculus and geometry being human inventions, than it is for number theory.
- raattgift 10y ago> In the real world, spacetime is curved Why is curved spacetime (in the sense of an infinitely differentiable pseudo-Riemannian manifold with a Lorentzian metric) not a human invention while Euclidean geometry (a limiting case of such a manifold) is? > The universe does not seem to be built of numbers with infinite precision What's your definition of spacetime? It's not that of General Relativity, if you deny infinitesimals. I think you're stuck either with accepting curvature and infinitesimals and the involvement in pi in the relationships between a set of points at a small fixed spacelike distance from an origin, or you're stuck with denying curvature as anything other than a coarse approximation of some manifold with a non-Lorentzian taxicab-like metric. Minimum lengths (abolishing infinitesimals) have been proposed theoretically, and we can readily parameterize with a minimum length equations like the Dirac equation or the Klein-Gordon equation or like the Lagrangian of the Standard Model, and in doing so we see pretty plainly that the Lorentz transformations of Special Relativity must be modified. One concrete modification is the theory of Doubly Special Relativity whose length cutoff is the Planck length. It predicts an energy-dependent speed of light, and that is contradicted by evidence (gamma rays do not win races with infrared rays in near vacuum). Other similar deformations of Special Relativity have been advanced, and they also conflict with experiment and observation, unless the minimum length goes to zero, or other physical quantities are (counter-)parameterized pushing the observation-and-experiment conflict elsewhere. (One programme for this sort of research is the Standard Model Extension). > The universe could carry on just fine without any life anywhere having the concept of "two" The universe could carry on just fine without any life period. Indeed, it almost certainly did in our distant past. However, there is pretty conclusive evidence that there were quadratic relations among various physical quantities in the earlier universe, notably the inverse square laws for electrostatics and gravitation. It seems extreme to blame that on humans...
- FabHK 10y agoNo, as I meant to say with the "apart from that" - mathematical truths are clearly interpersonally verifiable and arguably "out there" to be discovered, not invented. I'm disagreeing with the overly poetic language of "touching immortality" etc. (and German idealism... but that's another topic)
- visarga 10y ago> Schopenhauer who thought that instrumental classical music gave access to the innermost truth of the universe So I get you haven't appreciated Mahler and Bruckner. I can understand your position if you haven't. /s
- snarfy 10y agoIt's true of any idea, not just mathematics. Ideas are discoveries, not inventions. This philosophy goes all the way back to Plato. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Theory_of_Forms https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Theory_of_Forms
- eastWestMath 10y agoWell yes, Platonism is true if you presuppose that Platonism is true.
- coldtea 10y ago>But apart from that, I find this sort of talk unhelpful. It's a bit like Schopenhauer who thought that instrumental classical music gave access to the innermost truth of the universe (I'm paraphrasing from memory here) - what hogwash. How do you know it's hogwash?
- kurthr 10y agoWell, I'd say that Schopenhauer's statement requires a higher level of verification than someone calling him out for BS. If you're asking for a proof, I'd say that the fact that multiple equally sophisticated musical schema are present across the world in different cultures that he didn't acknowledge (and only _instrumental_ music??). The point that I think you inadvertently bring up is that an appreciation of mathematics is so far only human (and we tend to focus on the ones that are useful to us right now)... perhaps when we meet alien life we'll actually know how universally interesting our little parts truly are. In any case, they are still mostly consistent sets of postulates, theorems, and axioms.
- FabHK 10y agoThere is this story related by George Orwell (when he was in Burma) of an opium addict (Indian army officer?) that was convinced that the had discovered the innermost truth of the universe while smoking opium, this profound beautiful infinite insight, but could never remember it when he was sober again. Finally one day he managed to write it down. It said: "The banana is great, but the skin is greater." [1] Basically I believe that instrumental music conveys no deeper truth (for starters, it hardly conveys anything without significant training on behalf of the listeners. Program music like Berlioz' Symphonie fantastique is called program music after all because Berlioz himself handed out a program, notes, explaining (in words) what was going on in the symphony (the artiste falls in love unhappily and poisons himself with opium and has nightmares). Now, you can immerse yourself in profound romantic feelings when listening to it, or find delight in the unexpected deviation from the rounded binary form in a minuet & trio, or "suffer" from a deceptive cadence, but that's because it's previously been communicated and learned, with words and examples. Plus it's not exactly "secrets of the universe" stuff.) Wagner's Gesamtkunstwerk operas also include words, and to understand them, it helps to get an explanation and interpretation (with words). Of course some people claim to have had deep insights under the influence of psychedelics, and some people claim to have had deep insights from classical music. What I'm basically saying is that the claim is not enough, you must also be able to communicate this deep insight. And basically I claim the insight must be communicated in words. And then the words carry the insight. Not drugs or music. Visual arts or music (or drugs?) can support that communication, but they can't replace it. Of course, you could just say, well, there is all this insight in the music, and Schopenhauer got it, and you get it, and I don't, and you cannot communicate it in words, you can just communicate it in music, and so it's there, but I don't get it. That's a bit like what postmodernists like to do when someone challenges the scholarship of their papers - "you just don't get it". And that I call hogwash, I suppose, for now. It might be instructive to listen to an hour of Cantonese opera, and see what insights are gained. [1] https://www.theguardian.com/books/2004/may/06/classics.georgeorwell https://www.theguardian.com/books/2004/may/06/classics.georg...