4 ms·
I'd add that "healthcare" as a benefit is a very American concern. In most real countries, that's taken care of separate to our jobs.
by XorNot 10y ago
I'd add that "healthcare" as a benefit is a very American concern. In most real countries, that's taken care of separate to our jobs.
- divbit 10y agoYes, I almost expanded further on the healthcare point for that reason, but then realized the author seems as if they are possibly writing from the UK.
- XorNot 10y agoAustralia (mentioned because Americans love to talk about the size of their country somehow making single-payer impractical).
- shaftoe 10y agoHonestly, when we say size, we mean diversity. Countries used as success examples are far more homogeneous in their population and culture.
- knz 10y agoCan you clarify what impact that has in regards to population? I don't believe the US has significantly different medical needs compared to any other OECD nation?
- extra88 10y agoI don't know if America's "size" is really used as an argument against single-payer working here but if it is, I'm sure what is meant is population size. What's an example of referencing a country's large size meaning more diverse or heterogeneous rather than greater population? But I agree that "size" in this case definitely does not mean geographic size. Geographic size might be a factor for why America doesn't have better telecommunications or rail system, not health care.
- extra88 10y agoI'll walk that last part back a bit, geographic size, and having sparsely populated areas, can make providing health care for all more difficult and therefore more costly. But I think it would be a very minor factor and Australia serves as a good example of that, it has a much smaller population but some of it is comparably far-flung.
- bmelton 10y agoI agreed with, and upvoted your answer, but upon reflection, so long as insurance policies in America are still constrained by state borders, there might well be a (fairly arbitrary) hurdle on risk pools. States with more and a higher concentration of population centers may benefit from a more diverse risk pool than states that look more like Alaska.
- extra88 10y agoTrump and some Republicans have argued for allowing selling policies across state lines but I think more knowledgable people have said it would not make a significant difference in health care costs and poses some race-to-the-bottom risks. I think most insurance providers are multi-state entities so higher costs in one state can be balanced by lower costs in others. But there may be some limits; if the ACA requirement that insurers use 80% of revenue on health care costs is applied per-state, they may not be able balance out a really unhealthy state. But this isn't an issue due to America's geographic or population size or even the quantity of states, it's that America has much more political power at the state level.
- vidarh 10y agoMakes no sense. The EU has a larger and far more diverse population than the US, and yet has universal healthcare and demonstrated exactly how to handle it if you're so diverse: Just set up multiple systems. The US even has very convenient boundaries to split up the systems along: States, just like the EU. Even most countries with universal healthcare further subdivides their systems. E.g. Norway (5 million people) operates regional health trusts that are largely independent. The UK (60 million) does the same on a larger scale (more trusts) and leverages the number of trusts to improve management of individual trusts by occasionally having successful trust take over the running of trusts where management is failing. The "size" argument is almost always a total red herring.
- jdietrich 10y agoI really don't understand this argument. I can only assume it's some sort of euphemism I don't have the cultural context to understand. Belgium is split right down the middle by language and culture, with many people supporting a split into two independent countries. Spain has Catalonia and the Basque country, two culturally and linguistically distinct regions that have long fought for independence. Ireland has spent most of the last century in a slow-burning civil war. Half of Germany was part of the Soviet Union until 1989. When people say that universal healthcare can't work in the US because of "diversity", what exactly do they mean by that word?
- Trill-I-Am 10y agoHe means racial diversity because in America a lot of white people don't like black people
- TheCoelacanth 10y ago"Diversity" is frequently a euphemism for "black people".
- mrmrcoleman 10y agoI believe he is writing from the U.K. but they have the NHS, or did I misunderstand your point?
- divbit 10y agoThe point was that, given the NHS, the health benefits issue is probably, for good reason, not something I would expect the author to consider in their summary of dad jobs.
- mrmrcoleman 10y agoOk, understood, and agreed.
- seanmcdirmid 10y agoYes! This "health insurance is a job benefit" is an artifact of labor competition in the US during WW2. In Switzerland, where health insurance is mandatory, your employer specifically isn't allowed to purchase it for you...you have to go into the same market as everyone else (which is more fair, and doesn't impair labor mobility).
- w8rbt 10y agoGreat point about labor mobility. Many would be American entrepreneurs may never take the plunge (start-up, small business, etc.) because of healthcare cost and fears.
- seanmcdirmid 10y agoMany would also work part time (e.g. to spend more time with their kid) if they could got health insurance at the same time. Detaching health insurance from your job is great for lots of reasons.
- ajmurmann 10y agoThere is another huge issue with the employer playing for health care right now. On econtalk[1] Mark Warshawsky suggested that the current regulations and tax incentives lead to rising health care cost that also leads to a stagnating take home salary for lower end workers. Legally everyone at a company must get access to the same health care benefits. Since health care benefits are paid for in pre-tax money high earners who are already well off benefit quite a bit from better health care. Someone who pays very little taxes and can barely pay the rent probably would rather take some more cash home. However, most companies are more focused on "attracting top talent" so more gold plated health care plans emerge. According to the author most of the wage increases for low pay workers has just been eaten up by increased health care cost. That's supposedly were the income gap is coming from to a larger degree. If everyone got to pick their own insurance on a fair market this would look very different. [1] http://www.econtalk.org/archives/2017/01/mark_warshawsky.html http://www.econtalk.org/archives/2017/01/mark_warshawsky.htm...
- 10y ago
- accountface 10y agoI literally stay at my job because I'm the sole earner for my family and the health insurance is very good (PPO) - if it wasn't for health insurance I'd probably freelance and spend more time at home
- Drumlin 10y agoPrivate healthcare insurance is also offered as a benefit in places like the UK, but it tends to be the bigger companies that offer it. It means the employee can get their treatment weeks, even months before they would have otherwise - that's important if you have a painful or debilitating condition. That is, the employee struggles to be an employee due to government budget constraints.
- knz 10y agoI'm not sure what the UK is like but New Zealand has a public system and, to be clear to American readers who only hear negatives about wait times, you generally are not waiting if you have a life threatening issue. The wait time if for issues like joint replacements and varies depending upon your need and the availability of medical staff etc. A suspect a few people are going to read "weeks, even months before they would have otherwise - that's important if you have a painful or debilitating condition. " and assume that is a given for a public system. You often have to wait for non urgent issues in the US as well if you want a specific doctor or clinic.
- vidarh 10y agoIn the UK most of the private insurance is "top up" type insurance where you go to an NHS GP first, but then can ask to get referred privately if your condition isn't serious enough to get you seen by a specialist "quick enough". So you are paying mainly for extra convenience and speed over what is medically necessary, which also makes these insurances cheap, since with most of them you'll use the NHS for anything urgent.
- criddell 10y agoWhen Obamacare was first passed I thought that the best thing they could do for healthcare in the US would be to phase out employer medical benefits. If the cost of healthcare wasn't hidden, I don't think it would be used in the same way as it is now. At the very least, there should be a federal program that covers all children. We can easily afford it.
- paulddraper 10y agoI get to choose my car insurance separate from my closing my job. I get to choose my life insurance separate from my job. I get to choose my liability insurance separate from my job. Why I have to choose health insurance and my employer together is beyond me.
- bonzini 10y agoBecause even more people would choose not to obey the individual mandate and the system would work even worse. Of course, before Obamacare it was because pre-existing conditions made the private health insurance market ridiculous.
- Joeri 10y agoI think viewing healthcare in terms of choice is the wrong angle to approach it from. You can choose not to have a car, you can choose not to have life insurance. You cannot choose not to get sick. Healthcare is not a market but a basic right that almost everyone needs at some point in their life. Everyone can get the same illnesses and then need the same treatments, therefore aside from a few perks like single vs double hospital rooms there really isn't such a thing as different levels of healthcare. Given that everyone needs healthcare and how much care you need has nothing to do with your income level the fairest way to fund it is progressive taxation, from each according to ability and to each according to need in traditional socialist fashion. Any other system creates perverse outcomes, like forcing people to die sooner because their parents couldn't afford a better school for them which limited employment options. Of course, the trick with healthcare funded through taxation is to avoid having it cut down until everyone is worse off, not just low income earners.
- auganov 10y agoIt's not that it's taken care of - you just don't have much choice in terms of healthcare and neither do your peers, so you end up not caring. If the local healthcare can't help you, you will pay the big money in America anyways. Or you'll just die/suffer. Of course, the degree to which that happens depends on the country.