4 ms·
>Conscription is straight up slavery. I don't see any way around that. // Which person owns you in your analysis of that being slavery? Or is being owned by an
by pbhjpbhj 10y ago
>Conscription is straight up slavery. I don't see any way around that. //
Which person owns you in your analysis of that being slavery? Or is being owned by another person not a part of your definition?
In a democracy, you're a slave to your own country, effectively. There are people making decisions on your life, all the people voting in the country including you, no?
It may be wrong, just doesn't look like slavery to me.
- LanceH 10y agoWhat does single ownership have to do with anything? Is it somehow better than any number of people can spend your life for you? What other compulsory actions does the government take that authorize the expenditure of your entire life?
- pbhjpbhj 10y ago>What does single ownership have to do with anything? Is it somehow better than any number of people can spend your life for you? // No, it's not automatically better AFAICT, in practice I think it's likely to better on average. It's more that it was claimed to be "slavery" in actuality, not "like slavery" but actual slavery. So it's in some ways semantic but more it's that I think the position is substantially different to slavery - it's not just that it's a group of people, it's that it's a democratic country that you are also part of (as opposed to a corporation owning you, or an individual owning you). They're different conditions. In practice they perhaps share some [a lot of] downsides.