9 ms·
Dot Watch – A braille and tactile smartwatch
- anotheryou 10y agoCan't you spell words letter by letter if it's fast enough?
- ewyueywu 10y agoI remember when this was first announced a few years ago - great to see its progress. It's amazing that visual display tech has advanced so far in 100 years that one can't see the pixels, yet haptic display tech is so primitive that the best displays are only capable of dozens of pixels. It goes to show that motivation and money are what drive tech innovation, not fundamental physical constraints.
- melloclello 10y agoI sometimes wonder what technology would look like if it were developed by an alien culture with no sense of vision.
- semi-extrinsic 10y agoI somehow believe that the evolutionary pressure towards sight is so large (i.e. the benefit of sight is so great) that we're essentially guaranteed any sentient biological extraterrestrial will have it.
- ewyueywu 10y agotrue, but consider other sighted animals but which have a different dominant sense: dogs (smell), moles (touch), platypus (electric-fields) even sight-dominant animals may have radically different vision to ours. Cats for example are more sensitive to motion than to static resolution How we obtain our data about the world is a huge influence over how we conceive of it. I wonder how different programming would be were we to do it entirely by touch
- falsedan 10y agoAll of your examples are related to food acquisition. Consider /imagine the non-sighted analogues of them, and how 'successful' they are/would be e.g. a worm the size of a mole[0] & how trivial it would be for predators to prey on it. [0]: not these ones tho https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Giant_Gippsland_earthworm https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Giant_Gippsland_earthworm
- ewyueywu 10y agoyes i guess the evolution of our vision was driven in part by hunting (being able to resolve animals at a distance) and gathering (being able to discern colours of berries)
- new_hackers 10y agoalso the medium in which we primarily exist (i.e air). If we existed in water, or in soil, then the collection and classification of light would not be as important.
- falsedan 10y agoI think the vast amount of seeing marine creatures is a massive counterexample. Evolutionary biologists think that the ability to detect any photons grants an advantage: in environments where there is light, eyes evolve, even when the light is dim. It's only in completely lightless environments that eyes no longer provide an advantage (i.e. abyssal plain or caves).
- new_hackers 10y agoAgreed, the sea creatures have evolved to capture even more light. I'm only guessing, but I would think the pressure and temperature sensors on fish would be more important than sight?
- 10y ago
- melloclello 10y agoI suppose sonar could be an alternative worth considering.
- logicallee 10y ago>essentially guaranteed any sentient biological The evolutionary pressure toward radar or at least sonar is pretty fucking big too (huge benefit) so where's mine?
- falsedan 10y agoYou have eyes + aren't active while finding food/avoiding predators in an environment with limited visibility & great sound conduction.
- ewyueywu 10y agoalright, what about nocturnal animals with huge sensitive eyes ? or why not evolve searchlights or even lasers ?
- falsedan 10y ago> searchlights or even lasers Think about the return on investment on these: how much energy to grow and power vs. the improved food gathering. Also: would this make the creatures easier to find by predators? Galagos developed large eyes rather than sonar, true. I refer you to my other comment: > Perhaps eyes convey a general advantage, regardless of how you find food?
- logicallee 10y agoI think we can all agree that my point is made, and it's easy to imagine sentient extraterrestrials without photoreceptors.
- Someone 10y agoIf you are a predator and carry a search light, chances are your prey will learn what your search light means. If you are prey, would you think it is a good idea to advertise "there's something to eat over here"?
- panglott 10y ago
- panglott 10y agoWell, under terrestrial Earthlike conditions, anyway. In the deep ocean, the evolutionary pressure towards sight is so slight that most animals gradually lose it (there is too little light).
- JoeAltmaier 10y agoIs that really true? There are many photo luminescent creatures there, so light must be important to them. I'm thinking they appear to be blind to us in normal daylight, perhaps because their sensitivity is to extremely low levels of light. In their environment, they can see perfectly well?
- panglott 10y agoDeep ocean may be an unusual case because species and individuals can relatively easily move between different layers. Unlike caves. But marine creatures have many different adaptations. Cetaceans IIRC have relatively good visual acuity, but are monochromants. Lots of animals lose color vision. Some animals develop huge eyes to pick up tiny bits of light; some have a bioluminescent lure for those fish with sight. Others go blind. But no marine creatures adapted to deep ocean are going to have the level of visual acuity and sensory dependence on sight that terrestrial creatures often have. Blindness is a continuum.
- unwind 10y agoThat looked a bit like blogspam, or whatever the word it. It wasn't very information-dense, anyway. The manufacturer seems to be here: http://fingerson.strikingly.com/ http://fingerson.strikingly.com/. I guess it's a smart watch since it pairs over BT with a cell phone, and can show notifications from the phone. It can show the current time without a phone connection, yay. No custom installable apps on the watch itself as far as I could see, but perhaps something can be done through the phone, too. Can somebody please explain how they count their Braille cells? From reading Wikipedia, a "cell" should be 2x3 dots. The site says the watch has 4 cells, but it clearly has more than 2x3*4 = 24 dots; I count 30. Also the middle cell seems to be split by the vertical line? Very confusing.
- edent 10y agoBetween each cell is a space. From looking at their photos and videos, nothing raises in those locations. Effectively, each line is like: `••◦••|••◦••`
- rkalfane 10y agoIt looks like the 3D renders display a bit too many dots. When you look at the picture of the man holding a prototype, you have 4 cells with no split.
- bigblind 10y agoI deidn't count the dots, but you'd expect 6 dots in each braille cell, 2 vertical rows of 3;
- DanBC 10y agoThe submitted link was to an RNIB podcast that discusses the watch. Audioboom is official home to those podcasts. https://audioboom.com/posts/5655817-the-first-braille-smartwatch https://audioboom.com/posts/5655817-the-first-braille-smartw... The five minute audio podcast has interviews with the company and with users and explains a bit about why this is different to existing braille displays.
- 10y ago
- mrgrowth 10y agoI read that as, "The First Braille Sandwich"
- masterponomo 10y agoYou could do that easily with a 3D printer using an edible medium on bread with a sturdy crust layer. SnackChat?
- riskable 10y agoYeah but after the security geeks tear it apart there will be offshoots... Sandwatch and Burnberger. Better to wait for the sesame seeds to settle before biting off more than you can chew.
- H4CK3RM4N 10y agoI think this is the first real tactile display product I've seen go to market. Have there been any other big ones?
- Cthulhu_ 10y agoEvery braille display strip ever? I mean this isn't exactly big itself, as in, it hasn't proven to be big yet. There was also a tactile clock, iirc involving a pair of spheres on a dial instead of pointers.
- zv 10y agoSorry, this content is not available in your country
- shadowfacts 10y agoThe scroll jacking is really atrocious on my phone. It forces me to go incredibly slowly. Scroll jacking of any kind shouldn't be a thing, but this is worst than most other instances of it.
- tschuy 10y agoI could potentially see technology like this being useful even for people without vision issues. The ability to read information from a display without needing to glance down at the watch would be great.
- TazeTSchnitzel 10y agoIndeed that is the origin of one of Braille's forerunners: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Night_writing https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Night_writing
- micheled 10y agoYou should totally check Eone's watches then https://www.eone-time.com/ https://www.eone-time.com/. A friend has one, they look amazing as well as allowing exactly that.
- iamatworknow 10y agoThere are apps out there for phones and smartwatches that will vibrate text messages in Morse code. With any sort of determined study someone can pick up basic (~5 WPM) Morse code in about a week. Unfortunately the best way to increase speed with Morse code is to learn to recognize entire letters as one object and not count "dots" and "dashes", which is much easier with sound over flashing lights or vibrations.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- amelius 10y agoHow are the "pixels" turned on and off, technically? Is it done by a small magnetic coil? Or by electrostatic means? Or otherwise? Does a non-switching pixel require a current?
- pvillano 10y agoIt could work like the tip of a clicky pen, which doesn't require energy to maintain state.
- blacksmith_tb 10y agoPossibly, but then it would require an even longer throw to engage the latch (clicky pens extend past their writing position when clicked, in order to catch their latches and then settle into writing position).
- hwillis 10y agoIt works like this: https://hackaday.io/project/12442-molbed-modular-low-cost-braille-electronic-display https://hackaday.io/project/12442-molbed-modular-low-cost-br... It is a tiny magnet inside a solenoid. At each end of the solenoid there is a steel part, which the magnets stick to when on or off. To switch state the coil is energized. Hall effect (or other) sensors can tell where the magnet is and what state the pin is in. It doesn't use any power when it's holding state but switching can consume a relatively high amount of power. The clicky pen mechanism is actually patented, and it also can't be made as small as you'd like for this.
- AstralStorm 10y agoDoes it really? This kind of mechanism is not reliable for 10k switches even... (Due to vibration damaging the pin.) And solenoids are nowhere near as small.
- hwillis 10y agoIt may use nitinol wire, which can work with smaller latches. They can last trillions of cycles. I really doubt it though, making something at that size would be extremely expensive, unless they figured out a very simple way to work it. https://g.redditmedia.com/rFj5xjIilFQKXM1N6sq8asAi5i4BQTfUgo6HULvj660.gif?w=320&s=202a544f1d384aae5aa5c3d55a24c32e https://g.redditmedia.com/rFj5xjIilFQKXM1N6sq8asAi5i4BQTfUgo...
- popobobo 10y agoTheir team doesn't look too diverse to me. Not a good culture fit for silicon valley.
- anton_tarasenko 10y agoAny reason for the blind to use this over earbuds paired with Siri, Alexa, or any other voice-based interface?
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- joelcollinsdc 10y agoThe made the mistake of asking this to my gf who is a teacher for visually impaired kids. Braille is reading, and listening to earbuds is not reading. We teach our sighted kids to read even though they could just all have audiobooks, just like we should teach children Braille even though they can still listen. Another good argument she made was it's about multiplexing. What if someone wanted to learn the time while listening to an engaging conversation, they wouldn't want to stop listening just to check the time.
- gravypod 10y agoWhat kind of logic is "people need to do something more difficult because it's easier for people who aren't the same as me"? Also, who's to say that people shouldn't be encouraged to use audiobooks rather then read text-based liturature? When listening to an audio book I can do many other things like study for an exam or program. I can't read a book via text and write software at the same time. I don't think we should handicap people by making them feel like it's "better" to do something that's harder for them for some reason. Blind or not. > Another good argument she made was it's about multiplexing. What if someone wanted to learn the time while listening to an engaging conversation, they wouldn't want to stop listening just to check the time. Most people don't wear watches and it's usualy considered rude to pull out your phone mid-convorsation. I always wear a watch and so people just say "do you have the time"? If you can't ask Siri you can just ask whoever you're talking to. Also, if you express you want to know the time and they say "I don't know" you can then just ask Siri and tell them. It works out nicely. Any other examples?
- smhost 10y ago
- vegabook 10y agotoo cool - I'd love one of these for those long meetings / dates / presentations etc so I can just casually "feel" what time it is without being noticed looking at my watch or phone. I'd have to learn at least a subset of braille (numeric digits?) but it could actually be interesting to do that too.
- canuckintime 10y agoAs those like the moto360 watch straps? Or some other type of non-user replaceable straps? It would be better if they weren't with standard lugs
- falcolas 10y agoA smartwatch for vision impaired, advertised a website without a lot of accessibility provisions (not to mention the scrolljacking and "are you sure you want to leave" onexit hooks). What a world we live in.
- bbarn 10y agoSadly, I came to say this too. Looks more like a kickstarter gauging interest (with the crappy google form for "pre order") than an actual existing product.
- xjconlyme 10y agoThe onexit hook is surprisingly caused by the embedded Google form. https://docs.google.com/forms/d/e/1FAIpQLScqZJxEjHf6j66cX8wynAwxu7TcLGmEk7dk6xJd_04Fw-TW4w/viewform?c=0&w=1 https://docs.google.com/forms/d/e/1FAIpQLScqZJxEjHf6j66cX8wy... That message doesn't make any sense since I didn't even touch the form.
- zodPod 10y agoThis is what I was thinking the whole time... The "Preorder" button scrolls you to a spot on the page where there is no easy information about preordering. This website is really poorly designed..
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- dennisjung 10y agoHi, this is Dennis Jung from Dot Incorporation At the current moment, we are revamping our website https://dotincorp.com/ https://dotincorp.com/ - our goal is to make all information available in both text and audio forms and leave no one behind. We would like to apologize for any inconvenience. Meanwhile, you can visit our Facebook page https://www.facebook.com/dotsmartbraillewatch https://www.facebook.com/dotsmartbraillewatch to find out about our latest updates and news. Thank you.
- pjmlp 10y agoFinally a smartwatch that makes sense!
- timthelion 10y agoPlease don't share sites like this. This is a common theme. People advertise "revolutionary products" for blind people, whithout actually explaining what kind of microactuators they use. I am 99% sure this is a fake non-invention that does not exist.
- sleepychu 10y agoIn the video on the linked page they show several blind people using the watch, they seem genuinely surprised at the information they read from its face. Do you suspect this to be faked?
- timthelion 10y agoYes, I believe it is faked. I worked in the braille community for years and micro-actuators that actually work are like a holy grail. If they had one that actually worked, they would be plastering their site with descriptions of their new world changing mirco-actuation mechanism. They don't show a real video of it actuating. It just makes no sense. Its like if you invented fusion power and spent the entire time showing videos of smiling kids next to dish washers, and never even tried to explain the breakthrough for the containment material.
- tzm 10y agoHere's a video: https://www.facebook.com/dotsmartbraillewatch/videos/1113611635421217/ https://www.facebook.com/dotsmartbraillewatch/videos/1113611...
- timthelion 10y agoAha, wow. That is somewhat convincing.
- Jill_the_Pill 10y agoThe video helps, since the watch face shown on the web page has only 2.5 braille characters to each side of the divider line. I was wondering how that could possibly work, but in the video, there are 18 dots, or three full characters, to each side of the line.
- dfischer 10y agoI've loved the eone watch. Apparently it was also engineered for being usable by the blind. Amazing design.
- bigblind 10y agoI'm visually impaired. I tried the apple watch a couple of months ago, but concluded it wasn't for me because using VoiceOver imposes such a delay that it's not noticably faster than taking my phone out of my pocket. This braille watch might be much more practical. I'm seeing a lot of healthy scepticism in the comment section. I'm visually impaired, not blind, so I haven't checked this page with accessibility tools. And, although I've heard about a lot of failed kickstarters, I'm not good ad judging them. But if this is real, and gets built, I'd love to try one out.
- dennisjung 10y agoHi, this is Dennis Jung from Dot Incorporation At the current moment, we are revamping our website https://dotincorp.com/ https://dotincorp.com/ - our goal is to make all information available in both text and audio forms and leave no one behind. We would like to apologize for any inconvenience. Meanwhile, you can visit our Facebook page https://www.facebook.com/dotsmartbraillewatch https://www.facebook.com/dotsmartbraillewatch to find out about our latest updates and news. Thank you.
- ceejay 10y agoI think an important thing for a product like this to take off will be integrating a good / open api.
- huk10928 10y agoI just like Lemfo LF07,even I created a blog for this smartwatch(https://wearables2017.wordpress.com/ https://wearables2017.wordpress.com/)
- huk10928 10y agoI just like Lemfo LF07,even I created a blog for this smartwatch( https://wearables2017.wordpress.com/ https://wearables2017.wordpress.com/)