3 ms·
I understand why all the Uber negativity exists right now (really it existed since early on), they've earned most of it. However, not a single thing in that art
by adventured 10y ago
I understand why all the Uber negativity exists right now (really it existed since early on), they've earned most of it. However, not a single thing in that article does a good job of arguing why Uber is doomed. Having an emotional reaction and a strong dislike to the way a corporation behaves, isn't an argument for why it must fail. Just wanting something to be, doesn't make it so, and most of what that article does is want Uber to fail.
Back in reality, once a technology company acquires the kind of market position that Uber has, they almost never end up doomed. Quite the opposite, they overwhelmingly tend to go on to dominate their market for a long time. If disliking a corporation could make it fail, Monsanto wouldn't exist, and Microsoft would have been broken into pieces by the government (the hysteria around Microsoft for example, while different from Uber, was every bit as extreme and angry in the tech world circa 1996-2000; tech people flat out hated Microsoft and its behavior with a special passion).
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- dandr01d 10y ago> Back in reality, once a technology company acquires the kind of market position that Uber has, they almost never end up doomed. Most have, though.
- grovegames 10y agoIt would explain how we have the big 4, and not the big 94. Some like yahoo get carved up more publicly, but they all do in the end.
- justicezyx 10y agoThis is an overblown statement lacks substance. If by technology company, it means doing their business through smart phone APP, then Uber is one. In this definition, this statement does not hold strongly. If it means that the company build their business around proprietary technology that few can match, Uber is not yet. It's obviously that any decent technical group can deliver a comparable service as Uber with reasonable amount of VC money. The proof is that there are many such companies across globe. Uber actually realized this, and is strategically focusing on self-driven car, which is no doubt a correct and necessary move.
- AstralStorm 10y agoExcept one that can be as well undercut by competitors. What goes next?
- MarkPNeyer 10y agoNot saying I agree with the article, but they do seem to make a more specific argument: Their argument seems to be "There's no lock in this market, and there doesn't seem to be any network effects."
- __derek__ 10y agoMicrosoft was profitable. Uber isn't. Lacking a non-hand-wavy path to profitability and being default-dead[1] are pretty good arguments against a company's viability. [1]: http://www.paulgraham.com/aord.html http://www.paulgraham.com/aord.html
- warcher 10y agoThe problem with Uber is their valuation. Nobody disputes there's a business here-- it's whether it's as big as it needs to be to make the math work. They could conceivably create a monopoly on ride-sharing, but if they do that and raise prices (probably to roughly taxi parity, all told), then demand basically stays at where it was for taxis, we all live slightly more convenient lives, and all Uber's investor's lose their asses because this was not the moonshot they were promised. For Uber to justify their valuation, they're going to need to invent the self-driving car, and frankly, they don't have time. There will not be a clear winner in the self-driving car market, which does not exist at this point in time, anywhere near the timeframe they're going to have to return their investment or go kick rocks.
- coralreef 10y agoHow does Uber achieve monopolization? What can they do that no one else can?
- huckyaus 10y ago> Having an emotional reaction and a strong dislike to the way a corporation behaves, isn't an argument for why it must fail. I agree with you here, but this is hardly the only argument presented in the article. Something has to change when investor subsidies dry up. It might be a shift to self driving vehicles, a significant fare increase, or a monopolisation of the market. His assertion (which I broadly agree with) is that none of those seem likely to be successful.
- xbmcuser 10y agoIn some countries Uber is not the largest I know for a fact that Grab in East Asia and Careem in Pakistan and many Arab countries is the first option for many people instead of Uber. It's Market position is not because of any technology break through or advantage that can't be copied it is mostly because of discounts. Someone with larger pockets can out muscle them. With the negative publicity around Uber it could become harder for them to get more cash from investors. The next big thing will be self driving taxis where Uber won't be able to compete with car manufacturers providing the same services directly or to its competitors. Even google saw that it is hard for it to get car manufacturers on board with its self driving tech with most opting to do it on their own despite they are a few years behind in tech.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- vacri 10y ago> However, not a single thing in that article does a good job of arguing why Uber is doomed. "rider fares only cover roughly 40 percent of a ride, with the remainder subsidized by venture capitalists" - The equations don't work when the loss-leader is also your only product. The article also talks about how Uber is also burning through the goodwill of the drivers at the moment. Sleeping in your car is not a way for a long-term employee to behave. And also the goodwill of the developers. The article seems to make point after point after point about how Uber is overextended and can't sustain itself long-term. Yes, as long as you're subsidised, you can dominate the market, but how long are VCs going to pump in 60% of every fare? What happens when Uber burns through the available workers?