14 ms·
Wow. This sends so many thoughts cascading through my head that I'm dizzy. Some things to consider, China has been working up to getting a space capability to
by ChuckMcM 10y ago
Wow. This sends so many thoughts cascading through my head that I'm dizzy.
Some things to consider, China has been working up to getting a space capability to send people to the Moon with the full backing of the government funding, by 2035[1]. They started in 2003. SpaceX was founded in 2002 and they are saying they will fly someone around the moon next year? Dragon has the deltaV to land on the moon (not sure if it has enough to get off again though) and SpaceX certainly has the expertise in building spacecraft that land.
The next person to take a picture of the Earth from moon may not be on a government funded mission. That one really blows my mind. For so long it was only countries that could do something like that, now it is nearly within reach of individuals.
The UN has treaties about claiming (or not) the moon by a nation state, but there isn't anything about a privately funded and established outpost that wants to declare independence. All this time I imagined that some country would establish a base there, and grudgingly offer up some space for non-state use, and now there is this possibility of a private facility that states have to ask permission to visit? That is priceless.
[1] http://blogs.wsj.com/chinarealtime/2016/04/29/man-on-the-moon-china-sets-lunar-mission-date/ http://blogs.wsj.com/chinarealtime/2016/04/29/man-on-the-moo...
- hackuser 10y ago> The next person to take a picture of the Earth from moon may not be on a government funded mission. Note that the press release says: Most importantly, we would like to thank NASA, without whom this would not be possible. NASA’s Commercial Crew Program, which provided most of the funding for Dragon 2 development, is a key enabler for this mission. Your tax dollars, if you are American, helped pay for this. Thank you and congratulations - if it works out; if not, was it worth the risk? EDIT: In response to many below, remember that the U.S. military isn't the only alternative use of the money. Taxpayers could keep it, or it could go to other programs such as education and health. (Personally, I'd happily pay more taxes for more space exploration, education, health, and military necessary for security.)
- lettergram 10y agoRockets (or any research) > bombs any day of the week. Yes, my tax dollars going towards research (even indirectly) is better than the way most of my money is spent
- maxerickson 10y agoHistorically rocket research has been funded to develop the capability to deliver bombs.
- TeMPOraL 10y agoWhich seems to imply that military spending is pretty beneficial for humanity as long as it's spent on researching new cool ways of killing each other, and not on actually using them.
- lucaspiller 10y agoMilitary spending in WWII led to the invention or development of (to name a few) penicillin, radio navigation, synthetic oil and rubber, jet engines, nuclear power and computers. However some of these were pretty close to being invented even before the war, so it's hard to say how much the war progressed technology.
- kbenson 10y ago> However some of these were pretty close to being invented even before the war Penicillin, for one, was discovered over a decade prior to WWII. A method of mass production was developed in 1940, but have no idea how much that had to do with the war.
- justin66 10y ago> Which seems to imply that military spending is pretty beneficial for humanity as long as it's spent on researching new cool ways of killing each other, and not on actually using them. The sixties-era DARPA method: throw a bunch of defense money at a bunch of really smart people without getting too specific about how much of the research should proceed.
- mikeash 10y agoThe tax dollars we spent on this would probably have funded about twelve seconds of the Iraq occupation instead, so I'd say sure, easily worth it.
- 1001101 10y agoAlong those lines, just the air conditioning for tents in Iraq and Afghanistan circa 2011 eclipsed NASA's budget http://gizmodo.com/5813257/air-conditioning-our-military-costs-more-than-nasas-entire-budget http://gizmodo.com/5813257/air-conditioning-our-military-cos...
- Stanish 10y agoLuckily, it was all worth it. Iraq is a free democracy now, and spreading peace throughout the region.
- irrational 10y agoAt the very least it is cooler there now. That is what the A/Cs were for... right?
- ChuckMcM 10y agoAs a taxpayer (who was just reminded this past weekend of how much that is :-) I'm really glad that NASA had enough budget to spend on the Commercial Crew program. Given that the NASA budget of $18.5B[1] is a rounding error on the overall budget $3,540B[2], seriously it's a half a percent. And commercial crew was only $1.2B [ibid] of that NASA budget. So less than .05%. Again rounding error. And with that money they are getting two different spacecraft that can fly missions. So I think it was a great way for NASA to contract out the development of a crew capsule they could use on their missions. That one of the companies that participated has done so in such a way that they can make a commercially feasible 'tourist' vehicle out of it? That blows my mind. [1] https://www.nasa.gov/sites/default/files/files/NASA_FY_2016_Budget_Estimates.pdf https://www.nasa.gov/sites/default/files/files/NASA_FY_2016_... [2] https://www.cbo.gov/topics/budget https://www.cbo.gov/topics/budget
- Cerium 10y agoIf instead of increasing military spending 54 billion, we gave it all to NASA, we could be quadrupling NASA's budget.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- spydum 10y agoThe risk is that more money does not always mean more progress. Government organizations tend to grow all by themselves (would be interesting if you could legislate some productivity targets into budget expansion maybe?)
- Tepix 10y agoNASA should pass it on to Elon. If we establish a permanent Mars colony, that would really increase security for all of mankind. Building more nuclear weapons is NOT increasing security.
- whyenot 10y agoWhy is it so important to send people on these missions outside of some 21st century version of manifest destiny? NASA could do so much more with its limited funding if it just cut out all the humans.
- Florin_Andrei 10y ago> if not, was it worth the risk? yes
- splitrocket 10y agoThe reason you have a computer that fits in your pocket, much less requires its own room with a reinforced floor is due to the NASA space program. On edit: meant for the parent comment, but its parent instead
- Animats 10y agoThe reason you have a computer that fits in your pocket, much less requires its own room with a reinforced floor is due to the NASA space program. No. That's a common misconception. ICs were a commercial development, and microprocessors came from the calculator industry. Pre-IC electronics miniaturization was pushed hard by the USAF; NASA just used it. The USAF had a flyable transistorized computer in 1954, before NASA existed. The Minuteman I missile (1962) carried a transistorized guidance computer.
- pinewurst 10y agoAlso Polaris, a little bit earlier (deployed 1960) had a very small transistorized guidance computer which was the design root of the Apollo Guidance Computer. Polaris was much more of a DDA (digital differential analyzer) than real computer though.
- ascorbic 10y agoICBM development is basically a space program with a different budget code though, right?
- pinewurst 10y agoAnd a delivery service too - "Your package delivered in 30 minutes or less or next one's free!" (There at least used to be a Minuteman silo with the door painted like a pizza box with that slogan)
- BurningFrog 10y agoTax dollars, yes but not as any kind of subsidy.
- lorenzhs 10y agoNote that NASA encourages its contractors to use their stuff for private missions as well—building more of the things reduces unit price (by amortising development cost) and thus costs for NASA, so it could be that this results in lower overall cost to US taxpayers. In addition it helps collect more data on safety etc, which is in NASA's interest, too.
- dperfect 10y ago> China has been working up to getting a space capability to send people to the Moon with the full backing of the government funding, by 2035[1]. They started in 2003. SpaceX was founded in 2002 and they are saying they will fly someone around the moon next year? I don't want to downplay SpaceX at all because I'm a huge fan, but isn't flying someone to the moon (and presumably back) more complicated than just flying around the moon and back? As I understand, apart from the challenge of achieving orbital velocity (no small feat), flying around the moon might require ~41% more velocity (assuming escape velocity to orbital velocity being a ratio of something like sqrt(2):1) and you can use the moon's gravity to redirect you back to earth, whereas landing on the moon and returning requires even more energy (slowing down to land + escaping the moon and returning), not to mention the various other technical requirements involved with the landing itself. "Beyond the moon" makes this sound like it'll be a greater achievement than the Apollo moon landings, but I'm not sure that's really true. Don't get me wrong, the fact that it's a private (ish) company doing this is incredible, just not quite "moon landing" incredible... yet.
- lisper 10y agoYes, that is exactly right. They are not going to land, for exactly the reasons you say.
- jessriedel 10y agoRight. SpaceX doesn't have a craft capable of lunar orbit rendezvous https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lunar_orbit_rendezvous https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lunar_orbit_rendezvous so they would need to return to the Earth directly from the surface of the moon https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Direct_ascent https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Direct_ascent Direct ascent requires a much larger initial launch mass, i.e., a larger rocket than has ever been built. Since it took the massive Saturn V to complete the Apollo missions using lunar rendezvous, and SpaceX's Falcon Heavy is smaller, I don't think they are even close to having the ability to land on the moon and return. (And that's assuming there's not other insurmountable factors preventing Dragon from landing on the moon and taking off, which there probably are.) Hopefully someone with more knowledge can chime in.
- 10y ago
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- xcode_ 10y agoAs far as I understand, the press release doesn't mention anything about landing. Quoting from the article: "SpaceX will launch the private mission on a journey to circumnavigate the moon and return to Earth"
- matthewmcg 10y agoI certainly hope they allow permission for any emergency landings required at Clavius...could create a bit of a diplomatic row if not.
- jboggan 10y agoNasty flu this time of year, or so I've heard.
- sandworm101 10y ago>> For so long it was only countries that could do something like that, now it is nearly within reach of individuals. And that is something we all need to think long and hard about. Sure, spaceflight is cheaper these days, but we also live in an age of extraordinarily concentrated wealth. The necessary implication of individuals with power enough to rival governments is that, well, they can rival governments. Anyone else see that giant superyacht in london? The one that used HMS Belfast as a dock. Some really do have toys to rival governments. https://www.thesun.co.uk/wp-content/uploads/2016/09/nintchdbpict000264521121.jpg https://www.thesun.co.uk/wp-content/uploads/2016/09/nintchdb...
- simonh 10y agoI think you have to do a lot of squinting to see things this way. The vast majority of the funding for SpaceX has come from a government.
- mindcrime 10y agoThe necessary implication of individuals with power enough to rival governments is that, well, they can rival governments. Do you think this is a bad thing? Personally I quite like the idea of having enough wealth / power to rival a nation-state, since I trust the average nation-state exactly as far as I can throw it.
- sandworm101 10y agoAn elected government, at least i theory, is tasked with doing good by its people. That isnt always true, but at least there are elections. An individual person suffers no such limitation. That can act purely in thier own interest without even a tueoretical check. If they want to ride a rocket to the moon, while children on earth starve, there is absoluely nothing we poor can do about it.
- mindcrime 10y agoAssuming their wealth was acquired legally, why do you think you should be able to "do something about it"? Wouldn't that require initiation of force, or threat of same? From where would you derive the authority to deprive someone of the legally acquired property? That isnt always true, but at least there are elections. The last of which got us Donald Freaking Trump, Jeff Sessions, Kellyanne Conway, and the other Stooges.
- JumpCrisscross 10y ago> there isn't anything about a privately funded and established outpost that wants to declare independence Practically speaking, there isn't anything the UN can do if America sticks a base on Mars and calls it sovereign soil. We've already started legalising private ownership of celestial bodies through the SPACE Act, in direct contravention of the Outer Space Treaty.
- gydfi 10y agoBut practically speaking there's also not much the US can do in that scenario if Russia or China ignores US sovereignty over Mars and sets up their own base. The US's only recourse would be to start a war, and would that be worth it? Sovereignty is more of a practical concept than a legal one: you own what you are both able and willing to defend. See also the Russian bases in the Australian Antarctic territory. Australia asserts sovereignty over a third of Antarctica, Russia ignores it and sets up bases anyway. Australia has neither the ability nor the desire to fight Russia, so we studiously ignore it.
- nenreme 10y agoAustralia definitely has the ability to prevent Russia from setting up bases in Antarctica. It more like that they don't intend to do that because all their claims of sovereignty over Antarctica is a joke.
- alirazaq 10y agoThe Outer Space Treaty was only meant to prevent governments from claiming ownership of celestial bodies. The SPACE Act echoes that: >It is the sense of Congress that by the enactment of this Act, the United States does not thereby assert sovereignty or sovereign or exclusive rights or jurisdiction over, or the ownership of, any celestial body
- sidlls 10y agoThis is great, but let's have some perspective, please. SpaceX is the beneficiary of decades of research in engineering and basic science by the US government. They aren't making this achievement as a result of their own original effort or even funding (NASA provided a significant portion of the funding). I don't think it is fair to compare the SpaceX plan with China's (who have almost certainly had to acquire the expertise from a starting position far, far behind where SpaceX started).
- ChuckMcM 10y agoI'm not sure I understand what you're trying to say. China was the beneficiary of decades of Soviet research into space as well, their early program flew Soyuz craft, their current craft maintain backwards compatibility if what is available is to be believed. They have a space station and put a rover on the Moon. So how is that an unfair comparison? And how does using existing research take away from anything SpaceX has done? Sure NASA bought missions from them before they were sure that they could deliver, that sort of seed funding is not uncommon. Blue Origin benefited from a wealth of data in the DC-X project, also funded by NASA but its still remarkable what that they took Newshepard up and down from space four times. I disagree that the Chinese started from scratch. From where I am sitting they started at the exact same place SpaceX did, using the research and know-how from a well funded and storied space organization to bootstrap their goals.
- avmich 10y ago> I disagree that the Chinese started from scratch. From where I am sitting they started at the exact same place SpaceX did, using the research and know-how from a well funded and storied space organization to bootstrap their goals. We can count it different ways. Besides having millenias long history of rocketry, China modern space program started with von Karman student: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Qian_Xuesen https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Qian_Xuesen
- gozur88 10y agoBut let's have some perspective, please. NASA was the beneficiary of years of research in engineering and basic science by the German government. They didn't make anything as a result of their own original effort. So what? Nobody reinvents the wheel if they don't have to. And I don't know why you think China started behind SpaceX. China benefited from US technical assistance in a way that SpaceX didn't.
- zardo 10y ago>Dragon has the deltaV to land on the moon (not sure if it has enough to get off again though) and SpaceX certainly has the expertise in building spacecraft that land. Not if you count de-orbiting as part of landing it doesn't. It has something like 300m/s dV. Landing would take 2000ish, and that just gets you down.
- MichaelMoser123 10y agoHow will Elon get us to the moon if Tesla is burning up all of his money? [1] Also a private entity can't assert jurisdiction over anything, you have to be a state to do just that. [1] https://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2017-02-27/tesla-slumps-in-premarket-trading-as-goldman-downgrades-to-sell https://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2017-02-27/tesla-slu... Downvotes? Ah, i forgot that around here one is not supposed to question anything that Elon does.
- mikulas_florek 10y agoAn analyst downgrades Tesla, and shares lost ~5% of their value == Tesla burning up money? A delay in production? That's your argument? All of these articles are complete, and proven bullst.
- MichaelMoser123 10y ago'Burning cash' 'unproven business model' 'problems with execution' also they switched several senior managers recently.
- ordbajsare 10y ago"privately funded and established outpost that wants to declare independence." It will be the only way to escape global communism.
- andrepd 10y ago> All this time I imagined that some country would establish a base there, and grudgingly offer up some space for non-state use, and now there is this possibility of a private facility that states have to ask permission to visit? That is priceless. That is scary, and dangerous, more like.
- samstave 10y agoI've always held the following questions about space, and moon - in-specific - exploration: * Why are we not placing a DNA/Seed-vault on the moon * Why are we not depositing resources on the moon * Why dont we plan, plant, place autonomous robotic pods on the moon that can be called down/up carrying various resources * what happens to the moon if we transfer water/create water on the moon * Why cant this be a global effort, in the sense that we are talking about colonizing/visiting mars, but we can't even colonize the moon? What/Who is blocking this effort? * Why aren't we actually practicing mars colonization on the moon first??? --- There are so many questions that I have about moon colonization/exploration that are so flippantly replied to as cost... It feeds my tinfoil: there are things on the moon they dont want us to see??? (I know, just as flippant - but c'mon humanity, get your shit together and put some known colonies on the freaking moon!)
- dragonwriter 10y ago> Why are we not placing a DNA/Seed-vault on the moon Because it's expensive to get it there, useless on the moon, and expensive to get it somewhere useful in the event of need, all because of gravity wells. > Why are we not depositing resources on the moon Same answer. > Why dont we plan, plant, place autonomous robotic pods on the moon that can be called down/up carrying various resources And, again, same answer, both for the pods and the resources themselves. > what happens to the moon if we transfer water/create water on the moon It boils off and leaves, possibly after freezing for a while, depending on the time of lunar day you deposit the water, IIRC. > Why cant this be a global effort Because a really bad idea doesn't get better because more people are involved. > Why aren't we actually practicing mars colonization on the moon first? Because the Moon isn't very much like Mars in ways relevant to colonization, so there is no value to doing that. While perhaps some relevant technologies might benefit from the shorter feedback cycles of Earth-Moon missions for refinement, the costs of such missions are close enough to Earth-Mars missions that it's generally not worth it to go to the Moon if your goal is Mars. Just go to Mars.
- ChuckMcM 10y agoTo the DNA/Seed Vault question, I heard a really interesting point of view expressed which resonated with me. It was this, "Why not create a mechanism to record all of our knowledge and information so that if an extinction level event occurs we can come back from the brink?" And the answer was "If we allow ourselves to become nearly extinct, especially through our own action or inaction, isn't is more reasonable to let what ever comes after us to have a fresh start?" Can you imagine if all of a sudden, out of the ground a bunch of Dinosaur scientists emerged having kept themselves in cryo-suspension with all of their dinosaur tech to reestablish themselves as the dominant species on the planet? Are they going to be conflicted? Do they just eradicate humans because they were first? I'm sure Charlie Stross could make up a good story along those lines. I'd read it for sure :-) But the meta question, the big one behind all those "Why"s up there, is well understood. As a planet, and certainly as a nation, and even on as small a scale as a city, we are divided in our understanding of the reasoning for why being a multiplanet species might be more important than say, feeding the starving in Sudan. You can have a room of 100,000 people shouting in unison to colonize Mars and that is an insignificant fraction of the people who would have to be aligned to make that the generally agreed upon plan. And that is one of the things that makes this announcement so amazing to me. When we achieve that moment where a small enough group of individuals can effect a legitimate colonization effort, then it can happen without consensus of a nation-state and can proceed based on the self interest of a much smaller group. And while it is a staple in science fiction that corporations have fleets of space craft they use to achieve their interplanetary goals like an inter-solar Dutch East India company, I never expected it to be possible for a company to be able to do that in my lifetime.