14 ms·
How a French scholar was treated at US airport
- teddyh 10y agoI wondered why a “French scholar” would have so much trouble. Near the end, he reveals: “Maybe it's my birthplace, Egypt [..]”, which, if indeed he looks Egyptian and not French, goes a long way towards explaining it. Racism is a thing.
- stagbeetle 10y ago> I am apparently the only European - the only "white" Let's not rule out that his skin color is on the lighter side of the spectrum.
- neves 10y agoThis guy looks like my grandpa: https://www.google.com.br/search?q=henry+rousso&safe=active&client=firefox-b&biw=1403&bih=889&source=lnms&tbm=isch&sa=X&ved=0ahUKEwi8vcr_yLDSAhXFIpAKHRKpAx0Q_AUIBigB https://www.google.com.br/search?q=henry+rousso&safe=active&...
- teddyh 10y agoHuh. I guess my hypothesis was incorrect.
- pjc50 10y agoApparently he's Jewish, and left Egypt decades ago due to anti-semitism there.
- brandonmenc 10y agoLeft, or was expelled?
- pjc50 10y agoI was going by wikipedia "He emigrated to France with his family in 1956 due to the rise of antisemitism in Egypt.", but if we click through to the source for that statement we get http://www.jta.org/2017/02/25/news-opinion/united-states/u-s-authorities-almost-deport-french-jewish-holocaust-era-scholar http://www.jta.org/2017/02/25/news-opinion/united-states/u-s... (caution, stupid modal) which says "He and his family were forced out of Egypt in 1956 under anti-Semitic measures instituted by the Nasser regime." NPOV working about as well as it usually does there.
- a_bonobo 10y agoWikipedia on the Nasser expulsions, didn't know about this before: >As a result of the Suez Crisis, Nasser brought in a set of regulations imposing rigorous requirements for residency and citizenship as well as forced expulsions, mostly affecting British and French nationals and Jews with foreign nationality, as well as many Egyptian Jews. Some 25,000 Jews, almost half of the Jewish community left in 1956, mainly for Israel, Europe, the United States and South America. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Gamal_Abdel_Nasser https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Gamal_Abdel_Nasser
- shitgoose 10y agoRan, most likely.
- nom 10y agoI'm not even half through this article but I felt an urge to say this: The automatic french-english translation is so good, I didn't even notice it at all. Good work, google! Edit: now that I'm aware that the text I'm reading is a translation, I see the errors. I guess my brain just filtered it out. Still awesome though!
- pwdis_password 10y agoWell, to be fair, the language used is rather simplistic. The vocabulary itself is of a higher level, but the grammar is really basic from the start to the end. Most of the article is also pure description and not a thesis or something. I guess all that helps a lot the automated translation tool.
- nom 10y agoGood to know, it makes a lot of sense. What do you think, was it written by a non-native speaker or is it comparable to something you find in a french newspaper?
- laurentl 10y agoThe original article, in French, is very well-written; the grammar didn't strike me as "basic", but rather the writing of someone used to getting messages across clearly. Largely on par with most articles in French newspapers. That said, the automatic translation holds up pretty well, except for some gender issues and mistranslation of colloquialisms.
- angry_octet 10y agoThe author is an experienced academic historian and hence the language is precise, perfectly formed and persuasive. Google Translate does indeed do quite well. Where GT fails is in colloquial context sensitive language, like IRC or facebook, where it is terrible.
- d--b 10y ago
- yazbo_mcclure 10y agoThe leadership in that airport sec seams pretty crappy.
- monodeldiablo 10y agoHave you been to one where it was decent? I haven't. Every single time I've had a run-in with CBP or DHS they have (with two notable exceptions) come across as a hoard of malicious little fascists, delighting in how much power -- and how little oversight -- they'd been given over another person's life. I was traveling shortly after 9/11 and the National Guard was deployed to many airports. Fair, calm, and respectful, they were a comparative delight to deal with.
- smcl 10y ago> A police officer beats a woman whose three-year-old runs in all directions Is anyone able to give a better translation of this bit? Looks like the original sentence was "Une policière engueule une femme dont le garçon de trois ans court dans tous les sens"
- joncrocks 10y agoFrom google: engueuler. (transitive, informal) to give (someone) a roasting, to tell someone off. (reflexive, informal) to argue, to have a row. So I think the officer just gave her a telling off.
- rxdazn 10y agoA police officer berates a woman whose 3 y.o kid runs around
- Theizestooke 10y ago"engueuler" is berating, not beating. e:fb
- zdkl 10y agoEngueuler is yelling at someone, not beating. This woman got scolded because of a hyperactive kid, from your sentence.
- jbrun 10y agoA police officer screams at a lady whose three year old child is running all over the place.
- geggam 10y agoHow is it the same people working for one president less than 60 days later act so different ? or are they ?
- skocznymroczny 10y agoProbably it's been like that always at the US border, it's just now it's popular to showcase such stories as an example of "look what Trump did to our country". I heard of horror stories at the US border way before Trump took office.
- throwayawnotime 10y agoIt is not so, such behaviour would have gotten reported as well under Obama, many countries are just waiting for the US to slip up as it is doing now, to justify their own less-than-stellar human-rights records: "see, it's just as bad in the US". Sadly ESC:bdw Luckily! the US is still better, For how long?
- nraynaud 10y agoI guess there is a self selection bias in the people who apply to work in the DHS, ICE and CBP in particular, and now they are given a political validation to their instinct. But it's clear, my personal close call at the US border was under Obama, and that I am far from calling him someone in love with justice.
- dagenleg 10y agoThat's one of the good things about this whole media campaign against Trump. The media is throwing everything they can find at him and in the process expose a lot of heretofore ignored problems that have been festering for years. Maybe something will finally change?
- Arnt 10y agoObama didn't get blamed for such things because he clearly didn't want them to happen. They happened, can't tell how often, but he didn't want or intend that. I didn't have the impression that Dubya wanted to harass random foreigners either. Trump, OTOH, is the kind of person who wants to throw out all the Yemeni in case one of them is another Timothy McVeigh.
- joncrocks 10y agoI think the appropriate outcome depends on whether they were going to be paid by the US institution. If you're going to get paid, you need an appropriate visa. Unfortunately some institutions don't understand this/don't want to understand this/tell you "it's fine, we do this all the time." But if you say the wrong thing at the border, you'll be denied entry and it'll get noted down for the next time you try and enter the country.
- peferron 10y agoSure, but how does that apply to this article? He was going to get paid and had an appropriate visa.
- jobigoud 10y agoThe only appropriate visa to get paid is a work visa, like H1B, O1 or J1. He didn't have one, his J1 is expired. His situation is peculiar because as a scholar there is an exception. But if it had been to, say, tech talk at a conference, you can't get paid. So I think it's relevant to the article because that's probably what the CBP agent was thinking. And the fact that he'd have been doing it for 30 years doesn't change anything. Otherwise as French we don't need a visa just to visit the US, we are on the visa waiver program (ESTA).
- peferron 10y ago> The only appropriate visa to get paid is a work visa, like H1B, O1 or J1. No. There are plenty of situations where you can get paid in the USA without having a work visa. As you mentioned, the scholar in this article is one example. Another example: my spouse has a H-4, which is not a work visa, but has received employment authorization (EAD) and can get paid. Another example: athletes can enter the USA on a B-1, which is not a work visa, and get paid prize money. We could keep going, but the point is that a rule with too many exceptions stops being useful and just becomes a false statement. This led the first CBP officer to incorrectly detain the scholar in the article. This also led the author of the original comment I replied to to visibly stop reading the article halfway through, and post to HN that the scholar did not have an appropriate visa and that it was the university's fault, both of which are explicitly debunked at the end of the article.
- curiousgal 10y agoIANAL but isn't getting paid for an intervention considered a job and thus requires a work visa?
- DerpyBaby123 10y agoDid you read the article? Lawyers and the immigration officials concluded otherwise. Your spreading of FUD here is not needed.
- metasean 10y agoNo need to be a Derp about it, curiousgal was asking a logical question. Yes, the answer was in the article, but it was toward the end. Since many of these days skim articles or read HN comments first or some combination _and_ getting paid to do something for others is a common, if not defining aspect of "work" [0], her question is logical. As for FUD spreading, before she even asked the question, she started by stating, "IANAL" which indicates anything said about the law should be taken with more than a bit of doubt. So take a chill pill. Yes,it is important to answer the question to remove doubt or ambiguity, but there was no need to be rude or disrespectful or to berate her for asking a question! [0] The societal definition of "work", not the physical sciences definition. edit for spelling and formatting
- gillianlish 10y agoheres a logical question. ISNT PUTTING SOMEONE IN A ROOM FOR TWELVE HOURS FOR NO FUCKING REASON A CRIME
- dboreham 10y agoYou'd think. The culture in the US just seems to tolerate too much of this "Show me your papers!" attitude imho. Source: I grew up in the UK where you (still) don't need to carry a drivers license. Meanwhile in the USA where I'm now a citizen I get a cold sweat if I forget my wallet when I take a 10 minute drive to buy some milk in case I'm pulled over by the cops..
- nraynaud 10y agoFor an added bonus: he is an historian expert in the Vichy government. So I guess he knows a bit about rounding people for deportation and internement camps at the southern border.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- staticelf 10y agoI am about to visit the US soon. I am planning not to bring my personal phone and computer. It feels like I am going to visit China, not the US. I would probably not personally pay for a trip to the US now.. I don't want to pay a lot of money in order to be rejected at the border.
- DyslexicAtheist 10y agothis is worth reading then https://medium.com/@thegrugq/stop-fabricating-travel-security-advice-35259bf0e869#.m72h1wrsa https://medium.com/@thegrugq/stop-fabricating-travel-securit... EDIT (what to do): https://twitter.com/thegrugq/status/829855684636274688 https://twitter.com/thegrugq/status/829855684636274688
- lawless123 10y ago>Carrying no devices Is this article seriously suggesting i can't travel without a device or can't wipe before i go, because these CBP guys are so easily triggered?
- DyslexicAtheist 10y agoyes, both could be triggers
- csydas 10y agoI understand the basic scope of the author's intent, stop advertising fool-proof solutions to avoid vetting checked by the CBP, but their praxis comments require a bit more sourcing and evidence for some of the claims, and quite frankly, most just sound like scaremongering. The CBP actions and incidents as described by first hand accounts do not seem to define an institutional directive guiding the decisions as to who warrants further investigation, and more importantly, who warrants having their entry denied. From the article earlier today on Henry Rousso's experience, the Immigration Lawyer that helped secure Dr. Rousso's release suggested that agents themselves are looking for reasons to deny entry rather than reasons to admit. [1] This isn't to excuse their behavior - it's deplorable, but to suggest there is a rhyme or reason to what's happening isn't really sensible. The issues is emboldened agents abusing power, not an institutional directive. Quite honestly, travelers worried about drawing the ire of the CBP don't have many reassurances right now since you're not looking for what makes you suspicious or unsuspicious to the CBP, you're trying to guess what makes you suspicious or not suspicious to the individual agent you're reaching. The agents' attitude absolutely needs to be checked and unfortunately this likely means there will be more of these cases until something institutional is sent down to curb the behavior. [1] https://mobile.nytimes.com/2017/02/26/us/french-historian-detained-immigration-henry-rousso.html https://mobile.nytimes.com/2017/02/26/us/french-historian-de...
- Rexxar 10y agoFor french speakers, here is the direct link : http://www.huffingtonpost.fr/henry-rousso/muslim-ban-donald-trump-etats-unis/ http://www.huffingtonpost.fr/henry-rousso/muslim-ban-donald-...
- clebio 10y agoI'm curious how good the translation is. I could read the translated article (the English version), but there were clearly some weird words. Is there anything off in the translation at a higher level?
- jcranmer 10y agoI read the French version and only skimmed the English version. Didn't seem anything terribly off to me.
- rocky1138 10y agoWhat about the part where the policeman beat the woman for having a child running in all directions?
- JeromeLon 10y agoFrench version: "Une policière engueule une femme dont le garçon de trois ans court dans tous les sens". So, the policewoman bawled the woman out. No beating involved.
- startupdiscuss 10y agoI was worried about that as well.
- startupdiscuss 10y agoI was a few paragraphs into it when I noticed something was off. To me, that is mind blowingly good.
- fowlerpower 10y agoThe article gives me anxiety. It gives me anxiety that people can be held at our borders for hours and sometimes days (in my country non the less). All because some junior border officer did not understand the visa type well enough. How can they not even apologize? How can they not even acknowledge these types of errors. Will they do this to us when we travel abroad on a tourist visa?
- monodeldiablo 10y agoWill other countries begin to reciprocate? Will other countries/institutions begin demanding compensation for wrongful detention/deportations? Perhaps my biggest concern is this: How long until this pushes someone over the edge? It's precisely this kind of persistent harassment that can convince an angry, disaffected young man that, yes, the system really is rigged against him.
- krzrak 10y ago> Will other countries begin to reciprocate? We shouldn't. A trait of civilized society is that it doesn't reciprocates on the barbarians with their methods.
- tartuffe78 10y agoHistorically I don't think that's ever been true.
- molmalo 10y agoAt least Brazil did.
- devmunchies 10y agoThese articles should have been written a decade ago. The media is being honest all of a sudden now that they don't like the government. These aren't new happenings.
- KKKKkkkk1 10y ago
- dandare 10y agoIt feels like the age of the US is nearing to an end. I am not looking forward (on behalf of my children) for the transitional period that will follow.
- stagbeetle 10y agoOn what grounds? From the state of border control? From one measly article?
- Beltiras 10y agoYes from the state of border control and not just this one. CBP is doing industrial espionage with their phone data seizures. I'm avoiding US conferences because of it where I have options elsewhere. I imagine many are doing the same. I probably have to bite the bullet this fall and go to San Fransisco for a conference. I won't be carrying any electronic devices for that trip as a security precaution that CBP asks me to unlock my devices so they can read data. It would be gross negligence towards my employer if I were to allow them to copy my email correspondence, some of which contains details about product development. I'm not being hyperbolic about it. I just need to mitigate the risk.
- taneliv 10y agoI consulted for a large non-US technology company, which enforced a policy of sending people to the US with wiped out laptops, and imaged at the destination with their standard software. That was more than 10 years ago.
- strictnein 10y agoWaste of effort. The US has never been into the industrial espionage game at the government level.
- benedikt 10y agoCompletely off topic, but this thread is a bit old anyway. Did you use the this nick on #linux.is@ircnet a "couple" of years ago ?
- robk 10y agoUPDATE: "It turned out this whole story has nothing to do with Egypt or Holocaust. Historian claimed that he would give a speech for money. Incompetent CBP officer incorrectly concluded that its a work without a proper work visa."
- officelineback 10y ago"Never attribute to malice that which can be attributed to incompetence."
- merraksh 10y ago"N'étant pas en possession d'un document fédéral m'autorisant à travailler aux États-Unis, je suis en infraction. La décision sera confirmée plus tard par son supérieur hiérarchique – que je n'aurai pas la possibilité de rencontrer." It seems the decision by the officer was actually upheld by his/her direct superior (referring to the original. Translation: "Not being in possession of a federal document authorizing me to work in the United States, I am in violation. The decision will be confirmed later by his superior - that I will not have the opportunity to meet.").
- jobigoud 10y ago> Incompetent CBP officer incorrectly concluded that its a work without a proper work visa. It's more subtle than that. If it hadn't been for the very specific exception for scholars it would indeed have been work without a proper work visa.
- johnnyhillbilly 10y agoWell, the CBP should bloody well train their staff on the rules they're tasked with enforcing.
- wazoox 10y agoI just decided not to go to the US this year. I should have this April but really, I don't feel like it anymore.
- devmunchies 10y agoThese are practices that have been going on for a few years. Everybody is thinking this is a new Trump-era thing, which is not true. It is large scale confirmation bias. Making life decisions (not visiting the US) based off a knee-jerk reaction from reading a huffpo article is not helping. I understand that for foreigners to see trump sworn into office and then all of these stories pop up would make them think america has changed so recently, but its not true. It like an episode of the Twilight Zone.
- erelde 10y agoI was hesitating to visit the US landmarks for years now under Obama's administration -and even before that under Bush's- but under Trump's, his attitude and words only indicates that it would get worse... I don't want to subject myself to questionning and genuflecting just to travel somewhere, live and work where I please, I am too much used to crossing borders as if they didn't exist. (I am French and travelled accross Europe, never went to the US)
- wvenable 10y agoI agree. But supporting what the US has become over the last decade isn't any better -- the fact that these issues are getting more attention now should not diminish that reality.
- ritchiea 10y agoFor everyone on HN that's afraid of being harassed for their politics because of how Trump support was received, this story and worse ones to come are exactly what we were afraid of coming from Trump. This was never just about policy, the current administration is giving license to treating people who don't look "American" enough with suspicion and they made that intention clear in their campaign. If this was just about tax rates and government spending policies no one would be nearly as upset.
- nmeofthestate 10y ago>this story and worse ones to come are exactly what we were afraid of coming from Trump. To dial back the hyperbole for a second, we've seen this kind of story happening before Trump took office, and in countries other than the US. Crossing borders carries with it a non-zero chance that you'll be treated like total crap and even when you're lucky enough that the system corrects itself you'll almost certainly get no apology. Having said that, there is no reason why this kind of thing should be tolerated. Edit: somebody else remembered the similar story from last year.
- throwaway_374 10y agoTo dial up the reality for a second, we've not seen this kind of animosity towards foreign cultures before Trump took office.
- mercer 10y agoI agree that it's too early to be certain that Trump taking office makes a difference. I've certainly had concerns and bad experiences entering the USA well before Trump. That said, I don't think it's all that strange to be extra worried now that Trump is in charge. It makes complete sense to think that things will get even worse under Trump, although I'm open to arguments to the contrary because I'd love to be proven wrong!
- arca_vorago 10y agoLove all the doom and gloom outrage. Just because trump got elected I feel like way too many people are in a mild form of hysteria, and use any excuse to vent their uncontrolled expression of emotion. Look, this was a stupid decision made by a stupid officer. An officer who lives es in Aggie land too! (For those of you not in Texas, Aggies aka A&M people are known for being good old country levels of dumb, and are often the butt of jokes.) Now, that's not an excuse, but this was an outlier fuckup that has happened for years before Trump, though I'm willing to grant its probably more likely to happen with overzealous people in this political climate. Its funny that the UK has been doing stuff like this to vast amounts of US persons visiting the UK on the same bad understanding of people giving payed for speeches/debates, but everyone has suddenly forgotten about that. Look, there is room for improvement, and officers in this position should be held to a higher standard by their superiors, but when all you have is a hammer(outrage mode), everything begins to look like a nail (outrageous action), so let's work on calming down and being a bit more rational and focused on practical ways to solve issues please.
- stereo 10y agoThis is nothing new, and the same thing happened to this American going to a conference in Europe in 2016: https://medium.com/@rachelnabors/wtfuk-73009d5623b4#.1079ksbw7 https://medium.com/@rachelnabors/wtfuk-73009d5623b4#.1079ksb... HN thread: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=11876453 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=11876453
- NoirDesir 10y agoUK is not Europe.
- Flimm 10y agoThe UK is part of the continent of Europe. It's also still a member of the EU for the time being.
- Beltiras 10y agoThe UK is actually an island off the continent of Europe. If we are being pedantic. It may belong to Europe culturally in some respects but geographically, it does not.
- richrichardsson 10y agoGeologically however : https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Eurasian_Plate https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Eurasian_Plate
- cr1895 10y agoYes, it most definitely is part of Europe, and it is currently still part of the European Union too.
- NoirDesir 10y agoMember of the European Union, not member of the Schengen Area... UK has always been whimsical and not reflecting the "European" values... thus, UK is not Europe. They're free to run things the way they like, but please don't keep telling that UK is Europe... especially after they chose and got the Brexit... not a single true european will endorse its mistakes.
- pcr0 10y agoI wonder how much the increased rates of unpredictable deportations is costing airlines, given that they're responsible for paying deportees' return flights.
- timeu 10y agoSomething along these lines (although by far not that bad) happened to me when I traveled to NYC for vacation of New Years Eve 2016/2017(this was before Trump took office). At the border control I was asked to follow the officer and wait in a room. I was waiting with a couple of other people but most people there were only waiting because of small formalities with their passports and they could leave after a couple of minutes. I thought it will be the same for me. However in my case the officer who was also checking my passport at the border control asked me to follow him into a separate room where I had to do a 40 minutes interview telling him basically my entire life history (names of all my relatives, where they live, which countries I have visited, all my social media accounts). I did so and the officer was friendly and after the interview I asked him why such a thorough interview. He responded that this is above his pay grade. the computer spits out names randomly and this was a level 1 interview. If he had been more suspicious of my answers the interview would have taken much longer. This was probably due to my background and name. My mother is from Iran and my father from Turkey. One month later (Trump was already in office) I had to travel again to the US (this time to LA) and I had zero problems but probably because they already had all the information.
- clubm8 10y agoIt may have been random. I'm pretty sure they pick a small # of people to do these do regardless of what intelligence says.
- DyslexicAtheist 10y agoI'm not so sure. seems to be human bias on top of data bias. great for context https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=gdCJYsKlX_Y https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=gdCJYsKlX_Y
- rhapsodic 10y ago> Something along these lines (although by far not that bad) happened to me when I traveled to NYC for vacation of New Years Eve 2016/2017(this was before Trump took office). Incidents like this have probably happened hundreds of thousands of times throughout history, at customs checkpoints for many different countries. But now that Donald Trump is the president of the United States, a certain percentage of the ones that pertain to entry into the US will become international news stories that will routinely make it to the front page of HN.
- xutopia 10y agoI realize this is exceptional but I've spoken to a few Canadian friends who aren't bothering to visit the USA anymore. Avid travellers and hikes a lot of them are going to spend more time within their country and Europe during this presidency. The simple idea that we might have to give our social media passwords is revolting more than a few... this story just adds to this feeling.
- udev 10y agoIn addition to that, I now place a premium on flights that don't have connections through US. They just seem more attractive, even if at higher price. I realize I might need to go to US, e.g. for business, and that's fine. But for sure the random weekend hiking in the Adirondacks is now way less likely to happen.
- 49para 10y agoDo they even need your social media passwords ? The companies like FB give up your data freely anyway. That's assuming the NSA doesn't already have it anyway.
- kahnpro 10y agoAs a Canadian, I absolutely actively avoid flights connecting through the US even if it's a few hundred cheaper. Not subjecting myself to the horror of US customs just to fly to Europe.
- pier25 10y agoIn 2007 I crossed the border on bus going from Montreal to NY. The girl I was travelling with was accused of illegal importation of fruits because she was carrying an apple for the trip.
- KKKKkkkk1 10y agoWhat happened to her?
- jknoepfler 10y agoA minor delay and a confiscated piece of fruit, most likely.
- pier25 10y agoYes, that was it.
- areyousure 10y agoNot your parent commenter, but I was on a bus once from Toronto to NYC. One of my fellow passengers had a coconut confiscated at the border. We all felt sorry for him, but when he got back on the bus, he pulled out a second coconut from his coat. :) More interesting, my neighbor on that bus ride did not possess a passport nor even a photo ID! He was Amish and had no problems crossing the border. His papers (which I examined) included a handwritten description of his appearance.
- wyldfire 10y agoIt might seem silly to you but I think that the import controls to protect domestic agriculture make sense and preventing unintentional/incidental imports like this one is an important part of CBP's job. They should spend more time on this and less time on rejecting visitors to the US. Unfortunately government employees can be remarkably bureaucratic and power trip. They should quarantine or destroy incidental contraband like individual apples and let people get on with their business.
- partycoder 10y agoYou can assist conferences with a B1 visa. "Traveling for a scientific, educational, professional or business convention, or a conference on specific dates" is an intended use case of the visa type. (https://www.uscis.gov/working-united-states/temporary-visitors-business/b-1-temporary-business-visitor https://www.uscis.gov/working-united-states/temporary-visito...) However, you cannot get paid for it. In addition the conference must not be about recruiting.
- peferron 10y agoWrong. https://travel.state.gov/content/dam/visas/BusinessVisa%20Purpose%20Listings%20March%202014%20flier.pdf https://travel.state.gov/content/dam/visas/BusinessVisa%20Pu... > Lecturer or speaker: If honorarium will be received, ... [list of conditions that the scholar in the article visibly meets]. It baffles my mind why multiple people in this HN thread keep suggesting that the scholar in the article didn't have an appropriate visa.
- partycoder 10y agoThanks for pointing it out.
- dmode 10y agoPeople are naive if they think this has nothing to do with Trump. I know friends and relatives whose visa applications are now being routinely denied for no reason. The executive branch provides guidance on how to implement laws that are pretty vague. So they have wide discretion and control over the behavior of the border agent. Let's face it, the tough guy border agent is a mall cop. Once you tell him that your priority right now is to do "extreme vetting" of foreigners they are going to step over their boundaries. This is only the start of such stories and there will be more to come. Yesterday I read that a computer scientist from Nigeria was similarly detained and asked to write code. There is an excellent NYT story about how ICE has been empowered to make wide arrests and I am pretty sure they are routinely violating civil rights and Constitution every day now
- blizkreeg 10y agoHow does this not enrage people more? What can the citizenry do about this blatant and unrestrained abuse of power?
- nraynaud 10y agoQuestion your president and civil servants: "if you love the constitution so much, why don't you extend it to the border, and to immigrations matters in general?". They are perfectly free to apply due process (or even common sense) at the border, it's just that they have not been forced to.
- WildUtah 10y agoMost of the H1B folks who are here for 3yrs don't live out of the bag for 3 yrs. If this attitude remains, the smart folks will avoid US entirely. This would make most Americans really happy. We don't want H-1Bs.
- klipt 10y agoMost Americans don't even know what an H1-B is (or how visas work in general). They think foreigners can just show up in the US and "apply for citizenship".
- dang 10y agoNo ideological provocations in HN comments, please. The community is divided enough on such a hot topic as it is—we don't need flamebait making it worse. We detached this subthread from https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=13745607 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=13745607 and marked it off-topic.
- getpost 10y agoI still don't get it. Assuming it's true that there was a lack of clarity on whether he had the appropriate type of visa, why was he held 10 hours? Why was so much time spent on his case? And why badger a 70 year old Australian children's book author who had visited the US 116 times previously? [1] Not to ignore or minimize abuse by CBP officers, but from the CBP perspective, from the tax payers' perspective, what possible value derives from this behavior? Is this purely a result of a lack of leadership, bad management, and hiring unsuitable people for the task? [1] https://www.theguardian.com/us-news/2017/feb/25/australian-childrens-author-mem-fox-detained-by-us-border-control-i-sobbed-like-a-baby https://www.theguardian.com/us-news/2017/feb/25/australian-c...
- jacquesm 10y ago> Not to ignore or minimize abuse by CBP officers, but from the CBP perspective, from the tax payers' perspective, what possible value derives from this behavior? I'm fairly sure the net value is a negative, especially when taken in accumulation.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- shitgoose 10y agothe border guard was using government AI system, and was triggered by the rule: if (visitor.countryOfBirth.ContainsAny(listOfScaryMuslimCountries)) visitor.giveExtremelyHardTime(); irony is that professor is Jewish, but that sub-rule was not implemented yet.