4 ms·
Where isn't that true in the developed world currently? Very few places. Take a look at the extreme household debt to income ratios in Denmark, Sweden, Canada,
by adventured 10y ago
Where isn't that true in the developed world currently? Very few places.
Take a look at the extreme household debt to income ratios in Denmark, Sweden, Canada, etc.
Look at the completely collapsed savings rate in Japan (stacked against their catastrophic budget / public debt situation that demands ever greater funding, while the economy has near zero spare taxing capacity). Japan has seen their real standard of living drop by at least 1/3 in 25 years and it's continuing to erode. That's the world's #3 economy and formerly an economic juggernaut.
Or look at the financial situation across most of the EU or Eurozone - most of Europe is hooked on between zero and negative real interest rates. Italy is in a ten year rolling depression. Spain, Portugal and Greece still haven't recovered. Russia's commodity based economic miracle is long over, as the price of oil isn't going back to $100 any time soon. France is averaging wage growth about 1/5th that of the US. Germany's economy has barely net expanded since 2008. Or take a look at the long-term unemployment figures for most European nations, contrasting 2006 vs 2016, it's clearly dire.
The US is in better shape than all but a few developed nations. That includes unemployment rate, income levels, wage growth, GDP growth, household income to debt ratio, cost of living, housing affordability.
- thechao 10y agoBut why? Is there anyplace to read about this?
- AnthonyMouse 10y agoA large part of the problem is that the international financial industry has entirely too much quiet political power. So we end up e.g. subsidizing mortgage interest and student loan interest instead of subsidizing e.g. new housing construction and teacher salaries. The result is that people borrow more money, creating much greater exposure to interest rate fluctuations (but much higher profits for lenders). Other countries don't have exactly the same policies but they follow the same trend. Income taxes rather than consumption taxes that encourage spending/borrowing and discourage savings, sold as "the rich wouldn't pay consumption taxes" even though they don't pay income taxes either, examples abound.
- SilasX 10y agoA high debt ratio seems less insane in those countries, where their social insurance heavily insulates them from the biggest catastrophic events: job loss and medical bills.
- coliveira 10y agoThe difference is that in the US there little social support for people who lost their jobs. Even employed people have a comparable lower standard of life, because there are so many social services available in Eastern EU countries not available in the US. Just for the biggest example, consider that Americans have no public option for health care, so if they lose a job their lives are at risk.
- refurb 10y agoYou're making it seem like there are no social services in the US yet 2/3 of the federal budget pays for just that. If make up to ~200% (varies state to state) of the federal poverty level you qualify for Medicaid which has almost no out of pocket expense for the patient.
- Spooky23 10y agoThat budget is mostly social security and Medicaid. In New York, it's 138%, or $16k/year for a single person for $33k for a family of 4.
- cmdrfred 10y agoPerhaps that lack of social support (and thus lower taxes) is the very reason why the US is not in the same situation as the Eastern EU.
- kalleboo 10y agoI don't know about the other countries but Sweden is in a ridiculous housing bubble, where even for someone with poor finances, it makes more sense to buy an apartment and just pay the interest on it (and then sell it for more than you bought it for when you move out) rather than to try find a rental apartment and pay the same amount you'd pay in interest in rent. This means that everyone has these huge home loans that look like "safe bets" (and there's no reason to expect the bubble will burst anytime soon since housing isn't being built fast enough)