10 ms·
Bees can train each other to use tools
- logicallee 10y agoThe researchers recorded the following transcript, translated from bees' dance, a few months after introducing git to the colony: "No you stupid wasp, how many times have I told you, YOU DO NOT REBASE A SHARED BRANCH. Never, ever, ever. If I see you do that again I swear to God I am telling the queen."
- anfractuosity 10y agoNice, it just goes to show how intelligent they are. There are so many cool things about bees. In the paper "Detection and Learning of Floral Electric Fields by Bumblebees" they mention how bees can detect if other bees have harvested pollen from flowers, based on an electric field. Along with the waggle dance, their functioning in a colony. Apparently they might let out a little vibration to express surprise when another bee bumps into them https://www.newscientist.com/article/2121275-honeybees-let-out-a-whoop-when-they-bump-into-each-other/ https://www.newscientist.com/article/2121275-honeybees-let-o... Also they can apparently sense the earth's magnetic field - http://web.gps.caltech.edu/~jkirschvink/pdfs/Bees.pdf http://web.gps.caltech.edu/~jkirschvink/pdfs/Bees.pdf
- cestith 10y agoAlso seen on Ars, it seems that bees when searching for consensus on big decisions will try to quiet dissenters by head-butting them. Enough head butts cause an individual to stop dancing for a while. This allows the remaining dancing scouts to come to a single, unanimous decision. - https://arstechnica.com/science/2011/12/bees-reach-consensus-by-headbutting-dissenters/ https://arstechnica.com/science/2011/12/bees-reach-consensus...
- anfractuosity 10y agoWow, that's very interesting!
- jefurii 10y agoThat's just like consensus processes in humans!
- jly 10y agoWhat's amazing is that honeybees will almost always choose the best option for a new home within an area where options are explored. They do this because scouts individually analyze an option before signaling their approval through a dance. In other words, they don't just take the word of another bee, they confirm and each "voter" is highly-informed. The idea painted in this article I believe is more for helping to resolve deadlocks when there are more than one high-quality choice. There are lessons even we can take away from the democratic process honeybees use to choose a new home.
- jon_richards 10y agoSome bees lie about what they've scouted though
- rybosome 10y agoI genuinely can't tell if this is meant metaphorically or literally. Assuming the former, lying suggests a level of consciousness that I don't expect bees to have.
- Normal_gaussian 10y agoThough it depends whether it is intentionally a lie. If a bee suffers some memory loss or otger failure of cognition causing them to think their position was better / worse it isn't intentional.
- rybosome 10y agoI think the definition of a "lie" implies intention. If one says something that is not true which they genuinely believe to be true, that is a "mistake" rather than a "lie". So the scenario you are describing sounds totally plausible, but I would phrase it as the bee making a mistake rather than lying. =)
- Normal_gaussian 10y ago
- yawz 10y agoHobbyist beekeeper, here. One of the most fascinating things about bee communication (IMHO) is not necessarily the two distinct types of dances they do, or not the precision on the distance and the direction of the target, but doing all that in the pitch darkness of their hive.
- TheSpiceIsLife 10y agoThat got me interested and lead me to this but of Wikipedia which claims they perceive the dance by detecting vibrations and electric field changes: Dancing honeybees (Apis mellifera) describe the location of nearby food sources by emitted airborne sound signals. These signals consist of rhythmic high-velocity movement of air particles. These near field sounds are received and interpreted using the Johnston’s organ in the pedicel of the antennae.[10] Honeybees also perceive electric field changes via the Johnston's organs in their antennae and possibly other mechano-receptors. Electric fields generated by movements of the wings cause displacements of the antennae based on Coulomb’s law. Neurons of the Johnston’s organ respond to movements within the range of displacements caused by electric fields. When the antennae were prevented from moving at the joints containing the Johnston’s organ, bees no longer responded to biologically relevant electric fields. Honeybees respond differently to different temporal patterns. Honeybees appear to use the electric field emanating from the dancing bee for distance communication. https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Johnston%27s_organ https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Johnston%27s_organ
- Typhon 10y agoIt is fascinating indeed.
- exBarrelSpoiler 10y agoIf only more tech companies can learn from bees for when they do on-boarding!
- navs 10y agoYou mean you want tech companies to attack you when you're just putting up your laundry? /me is a recent victim of a Bee attack
- spraak 10y agoI'm not very surprised, but glad that this has been validated. I've always felt that bees are very intelligent.
- vcdimension 10y agoThere are many advantages in training animals to perform tasks rather than building machines to do them. Animals are far more intelligent than current machines, more robust, well adapted to our environment, don't polute, require few/zero raw materials (with the associated environmental costs), have low/zero production costs, etc. I would much prefer to live in an environment of plants and animals than one of concrete and metal. The bottleneck is in the training, and this is where technology could play a part. Robotics and machine learning algorithms could be employed to improve the training process (for example see here: http://thecrowbox.com/ http://thecrowbox.com/).
- asciimo 10y agoOnce you conscript animals into human society they do require tremendous resources and they do pollute. You can look at animal agriculture for an extreme example. It's easy to forget that animals are very inefficient resources because they use most of their input to simply survive, rather than "produce."
- ChuckMcM 10y agoImagine a bunch of different animals all working together to actually run the farm :-) More seriously though your observation arises from speed and density, not activity. Consider chickens for example, which if you have a couple dozen chickens using a hectare (~2.5 acres) to live on their feeding and feces are completely supported in the existing cycles of that land (presuming non-desert, non-arctic). What gets it out of control is when you want 2000 hens laying in a single building on less than an acre. High density, imported feed, waste disposal becomes and issue, etc.
- asciimo 10y agoTrue. Add to that the farming of the grains you're feeding the animals, 90% of which will not be reclaimed in the final product. (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Trophic_level#Biomass_transfer_efficiency https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Trophic_level#Biomass_transfer...)
- 10y ago
- toothbrush 10y agoWhen "even" bees are intelligent enough to teach each other skills, i really marvel at the mental gymnastics/machinery that goes into convincing oneself that humans are somehow a class apart from animals, and it's totally okay to eat them after having kept them pent up in atrocious conditions. Makes mental note to be a better vegetarian (and FWIW: i'm not being morally superior here: i believe that in reality, probably being vegan is the only morally defensible position, but the flesh being weak and all... And in actual fact, probably even that is a tricky position: by surviving one is probably making the calculated decision (conscious or not) to put one's own survival above the cost of some other's demise.)
- webkike 10y agoWell, consider the numerous animals that are physically unable to eat vegetarian.
- whatshisface 10y agoWell, you can claim a little moral superiority - humans are the only animals on earth that might choose to be vegitarian!
- Neliquat 10y agoThat is exactly the bigoted thing I would expect an internet vegetarian to say. Way to live up to the stereotype dude.
- lovemenot 10y agoI don't get the need for ad-hominem here. Though I don't necessarily agree with your parent, it's a valid point of view, and does not require the speaker to be vegetarian or not themselves. The argument reminds me a little of the religious morality argument that only humans are capable of allowing God into their life. Again, I am not making either such claim, just rejecting your negative reply.
- wewiereiuyui 10y agodo we know which other animals have chosen to be vegetarian ? Apparently squirrels are usually vegetarian but they'll eat meat if their survival depends on it
- intrasight 10y agoI'm at a loss for words. First spiders that can strategize [http://thescienceexplorer.com/nature/jumping-spiders-smarter-average-spider http://thescienceexplorer.com/nature/jumping-spiders-smarter...]. Now bees that can tech tool use.