3 ms·
For those interested in learning more about excellent scientists whose work could not be reproduced: Tom Cech and his grad students discovered that RNA can hav
by dekhn 10y ago
For those interested in learning more about excellent scientists whose work could not be reproduced:
Tom Cech and his grad students discovered that RNA can have enzymatic activity. They proved this (with excellent control experiments eliminating alternative hypotheses) and yet, the community completely denied this for years and reported failed replication, when in fact, the deniers were messing up their experiments because working with RNA was hard. Cech eventually won the Nobel Prize.
Stanley Prusiner: discovered that some diseases are caused by self-replicating proteins. Spent several decades running heroic experiments that nobody could replicate (because they're heroic) before finally some other groups managed to scrape together enough skilled postdocs. He won the Nobel Prize, too.
Barbara McClintock- my personal favorite scientist of all time. She was soundly criticized and isolated for reporting the existence of jumping genes (along with telomeres) and it also took decades for other groups to replicate her work (most of them for lack of interest). Eventually, she was awarded the Nobel Prize, but she also stopped publishing and sharing her work due to the extremely negative response to her extraordinary discoveries.
Mina Bissel went through a similar passage, ultimately becoming the world leader in ECM/cancer studies. She will likely win a Nobel Prize at some point, and I think we should learn to read her papers with a certain level of trust at this point, and expect that her competitors might actually manage to level up enough to be able to replicate her experiments.
- j7ake 10y agoThanks for the lisr. I think negative effects of labeling a paper irreproducible when in fact it is not is greater than the positive effect of correctly labeling a paper correct. Because if a piece of work is important enough. People will find the truth. If it is not important enough.. then it does not matter.