3 ms·
What I've always been specifically confused about, is if there's any point in giving a VM a swap partition inside its virtual disk, rather than just giving it a
by derefr 10y ago
What I've always been specifically confused about, is if there's any point in giving a VM a swap partition inside its virtual disk, rather than just giving it a lot of regular virtual memory (even overcommitting compared to the host's amount of memory) and then letting the host swap out some of that RAM to its swap partition.
Personally, I've never given VMs swap. I'd rather have memory pressure trigger horizontal scaling (or perhaps vertical rescaling, for things like DBMS nodes) than let Individual VMs struggle along under overloaded+degraded conditions.
- 293984j29384 10y agoAh, this is a great idea. It'd also be easier to understand and see service degradation (ie. physical memory being used on the host) directly from something like vCenter instead of relying upon Solarwinds to tell me the host is out of memory.
- moftz 10y agoBut does the host actually know what is an appropriate thing to swap? It doesn't know what is contained in that chunk of memory it just swapped. Although ideally, you would just build the system to contain enough memory for each VM so they can each run at full capacity along with whatever else overhead it may need for your hypervisor. You wouldn't want the host swapping out anything related to your VMs because it's just going to kill any performance of the affected VM. Give each VM its own swap space and let the guest figure out what needs to be swapped.
- tedunangst 10y agoGenerally yes. In fact, this is why "balloon" drivers exist, to allow the host to create backpressure and make the guest swap. The guest knows more about which pages are interesting than the host. If you make the host do the swapping, it will pick silly things, like the guest's disk cache, to write to swap.
- scott_s 10y agoFor clarification to other readers, "Generally yes" was the reply to the originally posed question, which means the above comment actually disagrees with the suggested solution. (I had to read both a few times to get this straight.)