5 ms·
Sorting Out Chess Endgames
- Tichy 17y ago"It is a bit funny to recall we paid millions of dollars for this amount of memory, when today you can buy it for tens of dollars—and then put it in your pocket." I wonder how much research could easily be delayed a couple of years until it becomes cheaper to carry out. Was it so important to do that experiment back then? "Hector, always logical, said he never used the machine, but he knew they ran “hot”—they were known to have cooling problems. So he kept his on all the time, and used it like a space heater." Again, it seems as if responsible use of tax payer money was not really a concern at that place...
- pgbovine 17y agoI wonder how much research could easily be delayed a couple of years until it becomes cheaper to carry out. Was it so important to do that experiment back then? one of the goals of academic research is to take high risks (and costs) to explore possibilities for the future (looking forward 5, 10, even 20 years). if people only invested in 'affordable' research that had direct practical applications within a 1 or 2-year window, then the likelihood of 'game-changing' breakthroughs appearing would be much lower.
- dmfdmf 17y agoI have no problem with high-risk, long-range research projects as long as they are funded voluntarily and no fraud or misrepresentation is involved in getting the funding. You seem to be forgetting that the tax money is take by threat of force.
- jacquesm 17y ago> You seem to be forgetting that the tax money is take by threat of force. That's a fairly extremist position, there are lots of people that would voluntarily give a portion of their income up for taxes if it would lead to a better society. I'm one of those, and I'm fairly happy to give up my 40+% in return for a relatively safe society, subsidized health care and reasonably good public roads and free education, as well as a catchnet for people that are down on their luck, even if I personally probably have a bit less expendable income because of that because I produce more that goes in to the system than I consume. But maybe next week I'll have a car accident and a half a million dollar bill will result and I will still have a house to go back to. Now I realize that not all of that money is spent wisely, and maybe we could make things more efficient, but societies cost money to operate, and societies that are 'social' (as opposed to socialist, it seems to be a common mistake to think of them as identical) cost a bit more.
- dmfdmf 17y agoThere must be some level at which you would object, no? On what grounds do you object when the percentage becomes 50%, 80% or even 100%? You've already conceded the principle and a slave is still a slave regardless if he cooperates with his master. Moreover, nothing I said implies that roads, education, medical services or even charity would not be funded -- in fact you proved my point, these things would be funded voluntarily precisely because many people (myself included) value them. Funding these things by force is immoral. If you think my position is extreme, try not paying your taxes for a few years and learn what the "threat of force" really means to your own freedom and right to property.
- jacquesm 17y agoI don't think you understand what the word slavery entails. I can stop working any time. No master tells me what to do or when to do it. There is no punishment for not being productive. I am free to go where ever I want. and so on. Comparing taxes to slavery is pure hyperbole and whatever cause it is that you are promoting here you are harming it by association.
- raganwald 17y agoAah, Churchill's old insult: "Madam, would you sleep with me for a million pounds?" "Umm, well, I suppose so." "Her's a tenner, lift your skirt." "What do you take me for?" "We have already settled the question of what you are, now we are haggling over the price." Makes for a humorous story, but it's a terrible reduction ad absurdum argument. The fact that I am prepared to give up x percent of my income in exchange for a given set of benefits that have value to me says nothing about how I would feel giving up 2x or 3x percent of my income for some possibly different set of benefits. Speaking as an Ontarian, I'd be horrified if a political offered to cut my taxes in half and give me the "freedom" to choose my own health care in the "free market." That doesn't make me a slave, it makes me someone who pools certain funds in a coöperative manner. If you want the same argument back at you, try dismantling your army and giving every citizen the right to defend themselves from foreign aggression, buying their weaponry and training on the free market. Choosing to voluntarily pool some portion of your income with other citizens to fund a common defense is not slavery either. It's another kind of freedom.
- joe_the_user 17y agoI think that was the unwanted machine. How costly is it to use a million dollar computer as a space heater? Exactly as costly as using a ... space heater as a space heater, by the second law of thermodynamics. That also why all electric space heaters are essentially 100% efficient (thought energy is wasted in transmitting the electricity to the heater and that's lost in the form of heat too).
- Tichy 17y agoIsn't it very inefficient to heat with electricity to begin with? That's what I was told anyway. You are right, transforming electricity into heat is probably very efficient. But generating electricity is more inefficient than generating heat directly, hence heating by other means is a lot more efficient. He might be excused, though, if it simply was another era when there wasn't yet any kind of consciousness for that kind of thing.
- jacquesm 17y agoHold a second here, when you're from Europe you may not know this, but in the United States and in Canada 'baseboard' electrical heating systems are very common and natural gas systems (like you see all over Europe) much less so. Other heating systems common in the States are based on fuel oil ('red' diesel) that is atomized in a central burner and then used to either heat water (like in most European central heating systems) or air. Elecrical forced air heating systems combined with air conditioning for the summer are also pretty common. In Europe electrical heating is a rarity, unless for additional heat (small 1KW space heaters and such).
- Tichy 17y agoThanks - I am from Europe. So why is electrical heating so common in the US? Or is it really a legacy from the days of SUVs and cheap energy?
- nkurz 17y agoPartly a legacy: 'all electric' was a selling point in the middle of the century when lots of new houses were being built. Partly cost: if you already have a modern electric hookup, the equipment is cheaper. Also, I think a lot of subdivisions and rural areas in the US were built without gas hookups. Whether it's less efficient depends on what metric you're using. In areas that have hydroelectric or nuclear generation for electricity, the CO2 emissions are less with electric heat. Cost varies: there are places where electric simply costs less, particularly if you can spot heat instead of using a central system. Here's a couple links: http://www.iwilltry.org/b/projects/comparing-natural-gas-vs-electric-heating/ http://www.iwilltry.org/b/projects/comparing-natural-gas-vs-... (concludes that switching to electric makes cost sense in BC, Canada) http://www.leonardo-energy.org/webfm_send/377 http://www.leonardo-energy.org/webfm_send/377 (European view concluding that from a CO2 perspective electric is a win in Austria and France)
- pavs 17y ago(most) Chess engines without end-game database will play horrible endgame to the extend that a lowly IM can beat the strongest chess engine on the best consumer hardware. At least this was still true last time I was keeping tabs on Computer Chess scene. But with 4-5-6 pieces endgame its not only perfect but it also effects game quality in the middle-games, where most of the games are decided between human-comp games. Nowadays, Computer Chess scene is not as exciting as it was 10 years ago (not because of Deep-blue). Now it has come to a stage that it is less about knowledge algorithm tweaking and more about, fine-tuning and narrowing down opening books to few sets where a particular engine is strong at and use extensive positional and book learning from previous games on those or similar lines of moves and win games. Now when you (or GMs) play against a computer engine, you are not as much playing against an engine, but playing against a huge database that has been fine-tuned over 100,000s of games. This is why no chess engine author will agree to an official tournament games against a top GM, without opening-book, EGTB, pos-learning, book-learning.
- jacquesm 17y agoI played chess a lot when I was younger and enjoyed it a lot. Then I joined a chess club. Biggest mistake I ever made. Everybody was cramming openings instead of playing the game themselves. It really was terribly boring. My strategy for dealing with this was to open with a really bad but non-standard move. This led to an immediate abandoning of all studied openings by the opponent and usually that led to a relatively quick win because they spent so much time on openings that they forgot how to play. Funny that. Of course, against a really good player that will just get you slaughtered but the people that rely on knowing tons of openings to gain a favourable position in the mid game will fail miserably. I quit because of that, the fact that in order to be competitive I'd have to cram openings too instead of being able to simply play and hone your skill against the wits of the opponent in front of you, instead of the dead corpses of all the GMs before whose games they studied. I really don't want to play Caro-Kann all over again, I'd like to play my own games.
- janzer 17y agoFor you or anyone else that dislikes the memorization parts of Chess, you may find Arimaa (http://arimaa.com/ http://arimaa.com/) interesting. Personally I also like it better than chess because of the somewhat more simple/elegant rules while still leaving a game that seems to have a large strategic depth. Of course it also has a great hacker aspect of being very difficult for computers, but I think that's really only a rather marginal side issue. The game really is a fun game to actually play.