8 ms·
Acute exercise increases expression of telomere protective genes in heart tissue
- wslh 10y agoHow much exercise this should be in humans?
- eganist 10y agoNot yet known; this research was only performed on mice so far.
- JshWright 10y agoThis study is looking at one specific mechanism by which exercise may be helpful in improving some aspect of your health. It's not especially useful to look at just this study though, as it doesn't actually link to any outcomes (the telomere protective expression may or may not actually reduce your risk for cardiovascular disease). It's more useful to look at studies that have looked at actual outcomes (e.g. reducing the incidence of heart attack or stroke, etc). In those cases, the bulk of the evidence points to 30 minutes a day, 5 days a week of moderate exercise (e.g. a brisk walk or jog) being the best 'bang for your buck'. There are certainly gains to be made by going beyond that, but the curve falls off pretty sharply, and you can get almost all the (proven) benefits of exercise at that level. EDIT: I would suggest this YouTube video from Healthcare Triage on the benefits of exercise that are supported by good research: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=SFBBjynBpSw https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=SFBBjynBpSw
- Insanity 10y agoDo you happen to know if the crucial thing here is "regular" excercise? As in, is it in important to spread out the excercise over the 5 days? Would doing the 2h30 min excercise over say, 2 or 3 days per week, amount to the same benefit?
- rickycook 10y agofrom what i understand (not being in any way a professional in any related field), its best to even split it up during the day. 15min early, 15min late is better than 30min in a block? so i'd assume that short times more often is better
- dpark 10y ago> so i'd assume that short times more often is better I wouldn't assume this. The logical end of this is to split your exercise into many tiny bursts throughout the day. But it's likely that sustained output is an important part of exercising. The shorter your exercise, the less likely you are to get your heart into an elevated range, the less likely you are to cause an oxygen-depleted state (which encourages vascular growth), the less likely you are to use a significant portion of your free glucose (which is important for insulin sensitivity), etc. I don't know where the threshold is, but it seems like a bad idea to assume that shorter, more often is better. It likewise seems like a bad idea to assume that longer blocks are better (or just as good). Any exercise is far better than none, but there is a lot of support for ~30 minutes ~daily being extremely valuable. Absent evidence, I'd be hesitant to assume that some other arbitrary division of exercise would yield the same results.
- darkerside 10y ago> the less likely you are to cause an oxygen-depleted state I don't know if this is a safe assumption either. What makes you think it would take more than a few minutes of acute exercise to reach an oxygen depleted state?
- dpark 10y agoBasic physics. Assuming you are generally healthy, your body is not usually in an oxygen-depleted state. Therefore it will take some amount of time in a state of increased oxygen use to cause oxygen depletion. Therefore, "the shorter your exercise, ... the less likely you are to cause an oxygen-depleted state". Depending on your fitness level and exercise level, it will take more or less time to put you into this state. An overweight, sedentary person sprinting will be there pretty much instantly. A marathon runner walking briskly won't get there in any amount of time. But all things being equal, more time exercising will be more likely to put you into an oxygen-depleted state (and glucose depleted state, and elevated heart rate).
- rachkovsky 10y agoThanks a lot for the Healthcare Triage link!
- OldSchoolJohnny 10y agoLiterally no way of knowing since they studied MICE not HUMANS. If you want to exercise your mouse though it might be useful...
- CodeCube 10y agoThe pithy response is of course, "Exercise improves health. In other news, water is wet". But of course that's too simplistic ... this kind of research is awesome. Anything that can help us understand these mechanisms are one step closer to a literal fountain of youth.
- untilHellbanned 10y agoI'd bet any amount of money that this data already exists in some form and so re-inventing the wheel - haha - with this study was not particularly useful. Like the parent comment says, water is wet. When you exercise stuff changes. What most biologists never do is point out all the things that don't change. That's how we'd see how special it is in this case that telomeres change.
- untilHellbanned 10y agoOk so me-too apps like yet another photo sharing app is not cool, but me-too incremental biomedical research is cool. Good to know we are all about innovation here.
- TelmoMenezes 10y agoIn science, "me-too research" is also known as "replication", and it's one of the pillars of the scientific method. There should be more of it, not less (as recent crisis have shown). "Incremental research" is 99.999% of what scientists do. Charles Darwin and Albert Einstein are very, very, very unusual scientists. That's a good sign, by the way -- if science was suffering major paradigm shifts every day, that would mean that no stable knowledge was being produced. Keeping in mind that we are talking about extending the healthy lifespan of human beings -- that could be the people you love -- who cares about "being cool"?
- mikk14 10y agoJust a quick note pointing out that also Darwin and Einstein did 99.9% incremental research. Natural selection and evolution were well known concepts before the Origin of the Species, and so it was relativity. What Darwin and Einstein provided was just small steps forward, and a LOT of perspective over what was already there.
- serg_chernata 10y agoFor anyone interested, a friendly plug for Dr Rhonda Patrick[1], who podcasts and speaks on nutrition, exercise, aging and telomeres in particular. 1. https://www.foundmyfitness.com/ https://www.foundmyfitness.com/
- literallycancer 10y agoSomething about the design of that site makes me immediately suspicious and less likely to listen to anything she has to say.
- kortex 10y agoThe favicon is an avocado. snert. Yeah I get that exact same vibe too.
- 0xcde4c3db 10y agoBased on a quick skim she seems more credible than, say, Mehmet Oz (okay, low bar, but bear with me). She seems to have an academic background relevant to the stuff she talks about, and I don't see any obvious sign that she's shilling the usual crap like proprietary supplements, weird exercise equipment/programs, homeopathy, etc..
- timdorr 10y agoI tend to stick to her YouTube channel, podcasts, and Twitter feed. You're right, her website is not doing her any favors. But she's a biologist, not a web developer. Hence, going directly to her content sources seems to be the best option.
- literallycancer 10y agoI assumed someone else is handling her website stuff, so that just means they should try not to make it look like a scam site (subscribe popups on entry, and colorized "cancer" and other keywords). But maybe it's just targeted at different demographics, I don't know.
- 10y ago
- StClaire 10y agoHow would we check these results in humans? Can we safely biopsy someone's heart?
- untilHellbanned 10y agono. more practical to use proxies (this is the hard part) from more readily available tissues like the blood.
- forgotpwagain 10y agobiopsies of the heart can be done, but only for compelling reasons. it carries non-trivial risk to the individual. untilHellbanned described the better way -- ideally, there would be some sort of biomarker in the blood that serves as a proxy for the level in the heart. But how do you find it and validate it? It's challenging (at best...)
- gozur88 10y agoI would think for research purposes autopsies would give you better data than biopsies, and without any risk.
- carbocation 10y agoIt is hard for me to understand why a mouse study in a low-impact journal is at the top of HN. The article does not appropriately adjust for multiple testing, and therefore none of its claims are well supported except the JNK2 decrease in post-exercise mice. Full article is available at http://onlinelibrary.wiley.com/store/10.1113/EP086189/asset/eph12060.pdf?v=1&t=izh254dq&s=b9991ef92571e89cf3782940965238a12904dd93 http://onlinelibrary.wiley.com/store/10.1113/EP086189/asset/...
- droopyEyelids 10y agoLooking at this article, and the one about the supposed use of falcons as anti-drone measures, makes me think about the whole "fake news" thing. Something about how this is the quality of material we choose to promote among ourselves, the need for a critical eye when analyzing news, and how spreading fake stuff must be like shooting fish in a barrel. Not the most joyful thoughts to start a morning!
- kgarten 10y agoDon't understand the downvotes. I had similar feelings (I remember astroturfing articles about how safe nuclear power is after the Fukushima incident on the top of HN).
- Filligree 10y agoTo be fair, those articles were right. The problem with nuclear energy is not a lack of caution... I'm not sure if Fukushima has caused even ten deaths, total.
- nottorp 10y agoOut of pure curiosity, what does this mean in english?
- leereeves 10y agoTelomeres are protective regions of DNA at the end of chromosomes. They get shorter when a cell divides and that shortening is believed to be responsible for some of the symptoms of aging. This study says exercise causes heart cells to produce more of certain proteins that protect the telomeres (in mice). The study didn't actually measure telomere lengths or lifespan, but having more of these proteins might prevent telomere shortening and slow cardiac aging.
- timdorr 10y agoExercise is good for you. More specifically, intense exercise seems to protect the length of the heart's telomeres, which are the ends of your DNA strands and shorten as you get older. They are linked to the effects of aging, so delaying their shortening would seem to indicate delaying the effects of aging.
- mangodrunk 10y agoWhat does "acute exercise" mean?
- jfarlow 10y agoWhen DNA is copied the machine that does the copying must be already bound to the one of the strands of the two-stranded DNA. Physically, this means that the very first few bases of the DNA do not get copied by the machine, because the first few bases act instead as a 'handle' for the copying machine to grab onto the data. Imagine if you could not simultaneously read and copy the data of a running program, and you wanted to copy the entire running operating system (you cannot shut down a cell) - you'd have to figure out a kind of 'scratch space' to keep a few versions of the copy program that you knew you would lose during they copy operation. Over time, the amount of scratch space reserved for the DNA to use to bootstrap its copying decreases. Ultimately, if there is not enough room for the DNA copy machine to bind to DNA without actually mis-copying useful DNA (other parts of the operating system outside the scratch space), a cell will shut down and go into a stasis mode called senescence. This is one of the major causes of aging as we know it. Telomerase is a protein machine that adds more blank bases to the ends of DNA so that the DNA copying machinery can act for longer without shorting the DNA to the point of senescence (it increases the size of the scratch partition at the tips of your chromosomes, called 'telomeres'). Because the length of your telomeres is proportional to your age, the protein machine that lengthens your telomeres is likely helping you age less quickly. Here it is found that exercise likely stimulates the production of that lengthening protein, Telomerase, in the heart. This study is a mechanistic study - it provides useful evidence for how various proteins interact under particular conditions. It was not designed to provide proscriptive behavioral advice for how to live longer. But given that heart failure is currently a major cause of death, understanding how to lengthen the heart's useful life would allow us to understand how to lengthen many humans' lives. Current technologies would let us introduce DNA to cells that would direct them to produce more Telomerase, but these techniques are still mostly used in the lab and are only used clinically in the most extreme of cases because though we know exactly what kind of DNA code we would want to inject, we still have a great deal of difficulty injecting the code into a safe location that won't disrupt other critical running programs. But ultimately it is expected that we will be able to adjust the amounts of these proteins in particular tissues outside of their endogenous regulation in an effort to prevent disease, heart failure, and otherwise correct misregulations.
- DaveSchmindel 10y agoIn other news, smoking is bad for your lungs!
- DaveSchmindel 10y agoIn other news, smoking is bad for your lungs!
- giardini 10y agoFor those who cannot get beyond "mouse", here's an article and references about a human study: "Lifestyle Changes Lengthen Telomeres" http://www.drmirkin.com/public/ezine092913.html http://www.drmirkin.com/public/ezine092913.html The study, by Dr. Dean Ornish, was published in "The Lancet Oncology" 17 September 2013 issue.
- Nomentatus 10y agoI've assumed for a very long time that the purpose of telomeres was to prevent cancer mutations from killing a complex organism, since the resulting growth would be limited to X generations where X is the number of telomeres on the mutated strand of DNA, and then die without those cells being able to divide again. So while I believe the study will likely hold up; I do wonder why exercise adds telomeres. One answer is that exercise reduces cancer risk (it will get you to bed on time, mostly) so the body optimistically adds teleomeres. Alternatively, and perhaps more likely, exercise may trigger more cell division (for purposes of repair, all exercise causes some damage, to collagen if nothing else) so the extra telomeres are added as compensation in order to return to status quo cap on allowed cell divisions; maintaining the preventative but not actually extending it.
- jondiggsit 10y agoTLDR; exercise