7 ms·
Is having non-standard DRM-enablers really any better? There is a real need for DRM, people and companies are asking for it, it's not going away.
by oblio 10y ago
Is having non-standard DRM-enablers really any better?
There is a real need for DRM, people and companies are asking for it, it's not going away.
- chimeracoder 10y agoYes. It forces the costs of supporting DRM primarily onto those who want to use it, rather than primarily on the browser vendors. As it stands, it is now legally impossible to create a fully standard-compliant web browser without paying licensing fees. That's a huge problem.
- derefr 10y agoThat's a separate issue, though; you could (at least theoretically) have a fully patent-unencumbered DRM standard.
- IshKebab 10y agoIt's not about patents. It's about closed source blobs. Sure you can write an open source DRM module but good luck getting Netflix to support that.
- derefr 10y agoI was responding specifically to the point the GP post made about licensing fees. What I meant was that there's no reason that there couldn't be a form of DRM that wouldn't require "licensing" in order to use it. It would indeed still have to be a closed-source binary blob—because, like you said, Netflix wouldn't accept anything less—but it could be a freely-redistributable closed-source blob, that any browser would be legally in the clear to include without seeking out a licensing arrangement. Re: "it's not about patents"—while other IP laws (e.g. copyright) determine whether you have the right to just redistribute a copy of the DRM blob, patents determine whether you can reverse-engineer the original blob to make your own blob with the same ABI that embeds the same keying material, or whether that's also illegal. Patents, thus, are the ultimate difference between a blob you have to pay to license, and one you don't.
- vetinari 10y agoWhy would anybody make closed source, freely distributable blob in the first place? Making zero money from it, but assuming responsibility for support (both client and server side) AND legal responsibility when hacked? Plus doing business development, in order to gain acceptance at all? I'm afraid you are asking for unicorns there.
- matt4077 10y agoHave you heard of this thing called Flash? Or Adobe Acrobat? Silverlight? MS Edge? Uber (the app, and incidentally actually/metaphorically Unicorn)? Google Maps? Netflix for iOS?
- vetinari 10y agoFlash is not free. Flash Player is. Flash is actually for-money product. Adobe Acrobat is also for-money product. You probably meant Adobe Reader, which is similarly positioned to Acrobat like Flash Player to Flash. Silverlight was and Edge is a way for Microsoft to prove value of the Windows platform, and in case of Silverlight, also of Microsoft developer tools. Isn't Uber, the app, a way to sell services? Doesn't Netflix for iOS sell Netflix subscriptions? Isn't Google Maps, together with all Google apps, a way to keep people online, use Google Search... and provide Google audience for ads? Neither of these would be true for a free DRM. Just like Flash player was financed by selling Flash, Reader by selling Acrobat, Silverlight by selling Visual Studio, Edge by selling Windows, Uber and Netflix by selling services, Google apps by selling ads - what would you be selling in order to provide freely embeddable DRM binary? And tangent question, how would you build your brand?
- matt4077 10y agoI'd be giving away the client for my streaming service.
- charlesdm 10y agoI've done some work on this last year -- it's possible to integrate with the Widevine PPAPI component (DRM library) included in Google Chrome to support decoding Netflix videos in any type of app. Not legal to distribute though, I think.
- colde 10y agoSorry, but that is simply not correct. You can implement a fully standard-compliant web browser by just implementing the ClearKey option. That has no patents associated with it. It is likely a much better issue that H.264 is the dominant video standard used, and that requires paying licensing fees.
- a_imho 10y agopeople ... are asking for it where? No sarcasm, genuinely interested
- vetinari 10y agoLet's make an intellectual exercise. What would happen, if these companies would not get what they are asking for? - Would the companies go back to distributing disc? Hardly. - Would they make their own clients? Probably yes. And the difference wrt today situation would be what? 1) The browsers and standards would remain clean - unlike today. 2) Only supported devices and platforms would be able to play videos - Just like today. 3) If you wanted to play DMRed video, you would have launch separate application. In my eyes, that's acceptable price to pay for 1)
- charlesdm 10y agoNot sure I agree on this. I don't think DRM is great (hate it, actually), but I do understand why the content companies would want it. If I were a content owner I would want to use some sort of DRM system as well, even if it's easy to circumvent. Does it really matter whether DRM is enabled in Chrome? It has to do with ease of use more than anything. I don't like it, but I don't see how not including EME is good for the end user, if the alternative is having to install a secondary app. You should want the whole process to be as frictionless as possible, even if that means giving up "amazing code quality" or "a beautiful standard". You can have great code and a crappy app. I don't think the world needs more crappy apps with great code.
- vetinari 10y agoSure they want it, if I were content owner I would probably want it too. From my POV, DRM enabled Chrome matters. It matters, because - it makes browsers that do not include DRM uncompetetive (especially those who have another business model or do not have bizdev capabilities of Google, Microsoft or Apple). - it taints the standards and, - sets the expectations or baseline for having the DRM available. If the alternative would be to install a secondary app, things would be more obvious: - that there is a price in developing, maintaining and supporting DRM, - that price would have to be paid for those who wish the DRM, - having DRM available would not be seen as automatic, - you could not use bizdev capabilities in DRM to be able to push your browser - i.e., only Edge supports Netflix in FullHD (Chrome only in 720p). Yes, the official excuse is that Edge supports DRM X and Chrome only DRM Y, but in the end, it is only a business deal that DRM X is deemed acceptable for FHD and DRM Y is not.
- schiffern 10y ago> Is having non-standard DRM-enablers really any better? There is a real need for DRM, people and companies are asking for it, it's not going away. >it's not going away "Powerful people are forcing it on everyone, therefore it's good." Sorry, not buying it.
- pornel 10y agoNote that there is no standard for the DRM itself. You can't play Netflix using W3C's specs. The EME standard is only a JS API for launching arbitrary and deliberately non-standard DMCA-protected Content Decryption Modules (which are like plug-ins, but bundled with the browser). In this regard EME is even more closed and less standardized than Flash and Silverlight were. The de-facto NPAPI was at least known and could be used by anyone. Now the CDM API is a vendor-specific DMCA-protected secret.
- charlesdm 10y agoBut, unlike Flash and Silverlight, they actually work well out of the box in for example Chrome and Safari. That's a first. If the alternative is installing a secondary app, I'll take embedded DRM any day of the week.
- pornel 10y agoWe've traded freedom for convenience here. You used to be able to integrate playback with any browser you like. Now you can only watch Netflix in browsers that have a contract with a Netflix-approved CDM vendor. Netflix now has both legal and technical means to control what browsers are allowed to do, and they can prevent you from using an open-source browser to avoid it.
- charlesdm 10y agoWe sure did. But for that same reason I often prefer using a commercial product with a limited functionality subset vs an open source equivalent which supports literally every feature imaginable. Convenience. It just works for what I need it to do.
- ouid 10y agoDRM is physically impossible. In order to enjoy content, at some point in the delivery chain, it must be decoded to a human readable format. There may be a desire for DRM, but there is also a desire for time travel.
- manigandham 10y agoVery little in this world is based on absolutes. It's all about the relative costs of one thing vs another.
- jhbadger 10y agoLocks are physically impossible by exactly the same argument. In order to enter cars and homes, at some point doors must be opened. The fact that people have managed to circumvent locks hasn't made them any less desirable -- the mere act of making it difficult, if not impossible to circumvent has value.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- ouid 10y agoThis assertion is just wrong. It's wrong in at least 4 ways, but I'm only going to give one, because I think you should be working this out on your own. The reason people don't take advantage of the time when my door is open is because of the active security measures at that point. In particular, I am present, I represent a reasonable amount of security just by being present, and the law is also present. The reason that theft is rare is because theft is illegal, and confrontational, not because theft is hard.
- jhbadger 10y agoPeople who want to burglar somebody's car or home are generally smart enough to wait until there isn't anybody in them, so I'm not sure what presence has to do with the issue. It's kind of beside the point of the analogy anyway. The point is if you can open a locked door with a valid key, a skilled person can get past the lock with their lockpicking tools, much as hackers can get through DRM. But in both cases, casual unauthorized access is prevented.