10 ms·
Watch German Typhoons Intercept a Boeing 777 That Lost Contact with the Airport
- aedron 10y agoVery cool video. I wonder what the fighter jets could actually achieve by pulling up alongside like that? I don't suppose they could do any kind of visual inspection or signaling at that distance - even though one did seem to inch closer at one point. The wording from the airline statement was a bit funny: "the German Air Force deployed its aircraft to ensure the safety of the flight and its guests" - considering that their main purpose was presumably to blow up the jet if it posed a threat. On a side note, I had never seen a video like this before and it really drives home what massive amounts of exhaust these machines put out.
- eliaspro 10y ago> and it really drives home what massive amounts of exhaust these machines put out. It just looks this massove, but that's mistly due to condensation of water vapor. Sure, those engines have a massive throughput of air, but the visible "exhaust" is barely the result of burning kerosene.
- sandworm101 10y agoAnd water vapor from the burnt fuel. Hydrocarbon + o2 = co2+h2o. Those contrails are burnt fuel, just like car exaust on a cold day. The water is a product of burning.
- sandworm101 10y agoActually there us much they can do. First off they can verify that people are awake. Some depressurization or fire events can see everyone knocked out. They can also verify the exact location and identity of the aircraft. If bad actors are in control the transponders and other locators cannot be trusted. If the pilot isnt responding to the radio, say if he turned to the wrong freq, then reports from passengers/crew of fighter jets will see the pilots recheck all coms gear. Them being there tells the pilots that something is very wrong, that they should start talking asap. The fighters are trying to get the attention of passengers. Thats much safer than getting in front where the crew can see them (crew rarely look out the windows without good reason anyway). Candian cf18s have a light mounted below the pilot to illuminate intercepted aircraft at night. Blink that a couple time and passengers will start screaming about UFOs.
- detaro 10y agoAs far as I know they fly close enough to look into the cockpit if they don't get a response. Also, if it is just a pilot error fighter jets appearing should quickly get their attention, have them check radios etc, and/or follow the jets to the nearest airport. Here is an article about US no-fly zones that describes some of the protocols in that case: https://www.wired.com/2017/02/air-force-fighters-keep-rogue-pilots-no-fly-zones/ https://www.wired.com/2017/02/air-force-fighters-keep-rogue-... (After 9/11 a law was added in Germany that would permit shooting down a plane if there is no other option to prevent it being used in a sucessful attack, but said law was scrapped by the constitutional court. There has been some public debate about what to do in case such a situation happens anyways)
- twelve40 10y agoThere is an established procedure they have to follow to establish contact with the plane, that presumably all pilots should be aware of - https://www.faa.gov/news/safety_briefing/2015/media/Intercept-Procedures.pdf https://www.faa.gov/news/safety_briefing/2015/media/Intercep...
- chmod775 10y agoThat link is only relevant to US of A airspace.
- detaro 10y agoThese rules are an international recommendation (set in the "Rules of the Air" by ICAO), so while the link technically is US-only the procedure described in it is not.
- sokoloff 10y agoCan confirm (I'm a private pilot). Here is the ICAO intercept procedures document (Appendix 2, starting on PDF page 58): http://www.icao.int/Meetings/anconf12/Document%20Archive/an02_cons%5B1%5D.pdf http://www.icao.int/Meetings/anconf12/Document%20Archive/an0...
- jlgaddis 10y agoOut of curiosity, are these (and/or similar) procedures things that are taught very early on, to pilots of all levels?
- sokoloff 10y agoYes. They are taught pre-solo. I've been flying almost 20 years, so I can't swear exactly whether they were on the FAA knowledge ("written") test or not, but these are taught very early on as part of ground school. Many kneeboards and emergency procedure checklists have them handy as well. Realistically, if you can remember to tune to 121.5 MHz (the universal VHF emergency frequency), that's going to be good enough for all but lost comms. For a lost comms scenario (including electrical failure), the intercept procedures are unlikely to come into play; you'll instead proceed to an airport and land.
- kogepathic 10y ago> The wording from the airline statement was a bit funny: "the German Air Force deployed its aircraft to ensure the safety of the flight and its guests" Not every case of lost communication with an aircraft is due to hijacking. Sometimes it's due to a serious accident on board, such as cabin depressurisation. [0] In these cases, observations from the intercepting aircraft can be vital to understanding the circumstances leading up to a plane crash. [0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Helios_Airways_Flight_522 https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Helios_Airways_Flight_522
- Markoff 10y ago> As a precaution, the German Air Force deployed its aircraft to ensure the safety of the flight and its guests. sure, safety of the flight and guests, you mean humanely killed by rocket instead of hitting some target on ground?
- foepys 10y agoThere was a huge debate back then when the government wanted to legalize shooting down a plane that is being controlled by terrorists and has innocent people on board. The German Supreme Court ruled that this is unconstitutional and illegal.
- wongarsu 10y agoThe supreme court ruled that the law that allowed the order to shoot down the plane was unconstitutional. There are differing oppionions on how other laws apply, for example Nothilfe (defence of a third person). At least a fighter pilot acting on his own accord seems to be legally able to shoot a plane down if a real danger seems to exists.
- dogma1138 10y agoMaking visual contact and making sure that the passengers and the crew are not in distress. Could've been cabin preassure loss and all of them are passed out all dead just as much as hijacking. Shooting down can be just as achieved with surface to air missiles. We send jets to establish contact and use short range and if needed LOS communication to figure out what is going.
- tomp 10y ago> cabin preassure loss and all of them are passed out What could the fighter jets possibly do to "save" the passengers in such a situation?
- Piskvorrr 10y agoNot much. That's why you send someone to actually take a look up close, and see if that's actually the case or not. OTOH, both pilots dozing off or becoming distracted - now that tends to happen, too. In that case, "knock knock, who's there? German Airforce" tends to resolve the situation fairly quickly and without further incident*, as seen here. (Other than "a wild mountain of paperwork appears")
- std_throwaway 10y agoIn the northern hemisphere these warplanes are called "Tornado".
- roryisok 10y agoEurofighter Typhoon and Panavia Tornado are different aircraft.
- manicdee 10y agoIt was an obvious joke relating to regional names for weather events.
- std_throwaway 10y agoOf course; it doesn't even make sense for Europe to have a "Typhoon" aircraft due to the geographical location. I guess Europe has some "Penguin" submarines, too.
- TeMPOraL 10y agoWe'll consider renaming the plane when US changes the Apollo program to something that doesn't refer to European heritage.
- roryisok 10y agooops. I obviously have no sense of humour today. would it not be "hurricane" though?
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- roryisok 10y ago> In the meantime, we have some pretty mind-blowing video of what such an incident actually looks like from the air. Mind-blowing is a bit of an exaggeration. it's just a video of three planes flying along side one another.
- tomp 10y ago> As a precaution, the German Air Force deployed its aircraft to ensure the safety of the flight and its guests. Does anyone still believe this bullshit? Clearly there's nothing that the fighter jets could do to ensure the safety of the flight/passengers - the most they could do is to shoot the plane down in a safe area to avoid casualties on the ground, if it were e.g. controlled by terrorists. And the media/institutions wonder why people don't trust them...
- Already__Taken 10y agoYou're right of course but they could also have an easier time guiding a plane down if the pilots watching the aircraft needed to get a passenger to do it. Perhaps hijackers seeing armed missiles out the window might rethink their negotiating position. You never used to hijack a plane to kill people that's fairly recent.
- skarap 10y agoYou don't expect "Jet Airways" (or any other airline) to say that directly, do you?
- Piskvorrr 10y agoThere are other possibilities beside "plane controlled by terrorists" - radio failure, for example (for all the redundancies, this still happens in the 21st century). In that case, rudimentary visual communication comes in handy. In other words, not all in-flight emergencies follow the Hollywood movie conventions ;)
- Piskvorrr 10y agoAnd voila. Pilots turned down radio volume and took a nap, it seems. Hardly a case for shootdown - or Hollywood ;)
- iSnow 10y agoIt would be illegal in Germany to shoot down a hijacked airliner and ordering the pilot to do so would be an illegitimate order the pilot would be forbidden from following. The most anyone could do would be the Minister of Defence of the Chancellor talking directly to the pilot and telling her that they would take the fall if her conscience allowed them to shoot down the plane. The pilot would still face a trial with uncertain results. So, please stop with the alternative facts and the conspiracy stuff. Not every country works like the US of A, unbelievably.
- guruz 10y agoSemi-related: There was a TV event/movie in Germany/Austria/Switzerland last year about a (fictitious) court decision about an airforce pilot that shot down such a plane. The plane was taken hostage by terrorists and took course to a football stadium. The (non-fictitious) audience in Germany could vote if the pilot is guilty for killing the people in the aircraft or not. 86,9% in Germany voted that the pilot is not guilty. http://www.imdb.com/title/tt5680442/ http://www.imdb.com/title/tt5680442/ https://de.wikipedia.org/wiki/Terror_%E2%80%93_Ihr_Urteil https://de.wikipedia.org/wiki/Terror_%E2%80%93_Ihr_Urteil
- sgift 10y agoTo give a bit more background: The law strongly disagrees with the court of public opinion here. It is illegal to shoot down an aircraft in such a situation in Germany. The German government at one point tried to change this and our constitutional court told them that their new law violated the constitution and has to be scrapped.
- emiliobumachar 10y agoVery interesting. I wonder: what about gunning the engines until they fail? That would leave the plane unable to go far, but still able to make a risky crash landing using a nearby sea, road or field. Or even an appropriate runway if one timed things right.
- chmod775 10y agoPlanes are pretty frail. You'd risk completely destroying the wings. That would leave you with a tube filled with 300 people 10km in the air - but rapidly approaching ground level.
- wongarsu 10y agoA plane that's deemed a danger to anything is probably not 10km in the air. At that height it wouldn't even hit Mount Everest, let alone any people. And a plane without wings still has momentum and the lifting body effect going for it to assist an emergency landing. Then again, destroying (part of) the wings probably also causes all the fuel stored in the wings to ignite.
- iSnow 10y agoCould anyone comment on why both lower fighters keep to the left side of the airliner? For better visibility, I would have expected them to take it between them. Additionally, the sun seems to be on the left, so they would be hard to make out.
- zuzun 10y agoIt's all standardized interception behaviour. The flight leader is trying establish contact with the plane on the left side, the other jet is just on standby. Edit: And they picked the left side because that's where the pilot in charge of the plane is supposed to sit.
- Piskvorrr 10y agoPlus, I would imagine, the interceptors are leaving the right side clear: should an additional aviation emergency develop, the plane is still safe to maneuver in 5 directions (the sixth being blocked by the interceptors).
- soebbing 10y ago[Contact] was briefly lost while flying over German airspace. Communication was safely restored within a few minutes. That sounds like the whole incident didn't take more than 15 minutes. Does somebody know how fast the Typhoons were with the airliner? I know there are some guidelines for the Luftwaffe like "a fighter needs to be able to get to any point in german airspace within 15 minutes" or so, but that all sounds VERY fast. Edit: Formatting
- dingaling 10y agoWe've had a couple of incidents in the UK recently that demonstrated the 'lag' in interception of non-communicative aircraft. In April 2016 a German-registered Challenger business jet flew east-west across the UK and was just about to enter Irish airspace when the RAF Typhoons reached it. Then in October the same happened with a Volaris A320 that managed to fly most of the south-north extent of the UK before being intercepted, again just before leaving UK airspace. In both cases if there had been any malicious intent then it could easily have been executed over major cities. In fact I watched that A320 fly over my town... The problem in the UK is that the main fighter bases are on the east coast, to combat the Soviet hordes that never arrived. So basically everything is a supersonic tail-chase for the interceptors unless it's coming from the Benelux countries. The RAF really needs to redispose its units for dealing with the new 'threat' but there's simply no money to do so.
- 21 10y agoThere are vary levels of readiness, from pilots sitting in the jet with the engines turned on, to pilots sitting equipped 2 minute away from the plane, and so on. And it looks like the 2 planes came from different bases.
- jagermo 10y agoIt depends on the level of altertness an "Alarmrotte" has. That can range from 5 to 15 minutes from "beeing on the ground" to "flying to destination". If you look at this map of German airforce bases, one of the biggest is in Cologne (Köln-Wahn), so its no surprise that they were this quick http://www.luftwaffe.de/portal/a/luftwaffe/start/team/stan/!ut/p/z1/04_Sj9CPykssy0xPLMnMz0vMAfIjo8zinSx8QnyMLI2MfMIsXQw8DX29TS0tnYyCQs31wwkpiAJKG-AAjgb6wSmp-pFAM8xxmOFoYmCqH6wfpR-VlViWWKFXkF9UkpNaopeYDHKhfmRGYl5KTmpAfrIjRKAgN6LcoNxREQCTwpeP/dz/d5/L2dBISEvZ0FBIS9nQSEh/#Z7_B8LTL2922LV9D0I1MK599BA405 http://www.luftwaffe.de/portal/a/luftwaffe/start/team/stan/!...
- ajeet_dhaliwal 10y agoQuite the LOL at the chatter between the the British Airways pilots filming this saying I expect they love the opportunity to do this. Any excuse and the other one yeah.
- codeisawesome 10y agoEverything is so beautiful, up there.