3 ms·
Why do you think that artificially influencing market to influence one group of people (citizens) at expense of another (tourists) is justifiable?
by golergka 10y ago
Why do you think that artificially influencing market to influence one group of people (citizens) at expense of another (tourists) is justifiable?
- tacostakohashi 10y agoThese groups of people aren't playing on a fair field in the first place. The citizens, who live and work in attractive city, pay hefty taxes to make the whole thing possible - running the public transport, collecting the garbage, keeping the running water and sewage operating. Obviously taxation policies and city budgets vary a lot from place to place, but it's very common for these things to be funded by income taxes on the citizens salaries - which is fine with the citizens, but then why should to tourists get to come in and freeload off all the nice things paid for by those taxes? In a parallel universe where all these services were paid for by taxes on property values or rents, I would agree with you - whoever wants to pay the most per night can have it, but in the real world the market is already skewed to start with.
- JoeAltmaier 10y agoTourists spend out of proportion to local citizens? Most towns welcome tourism, even advertise for it. I'm guessing its because businesses thrive, tax revenues rise, and the community prospers.
- yummyfajitas 10y ago...why should to tourists get to come in and freeload off all the nice things paid for by those taxes? For the same reason retirees should not be permitted to move into a city funded by income taxes. In the US, far more cities are funded by property taxes than income taxes. NYC and Yonkers are the only cities I can think of with an income tax.
- golergka 10y agoWait, it seems I don't know something here. Do people in US or wherever pay income taxes to local authorities and not to central federal government?
- tacostakohashi 10y agoYes. It varies (hugely) from on place to another, but typically there is a state income tax, and also sales taxes and property taxes that go variously to the city, county, or possibly state. It's quite possible that a person might pay, say, 1/3 of their taxes to these non-federal entities.
- bnegreve 10y agoYou're assuming that the market is something "natural" and thus fair. GP may not agree with this. It is certainly debatable.
- golergka 10y agoThe only unquestionably "natural" thing is the heat death of the universe. The very concept of "naturalness" is extremely artificial and unhelpful.
- paublyrne 10y agoI'm not the GP but I would suppose this comes down to if you have a philosophical objection to cities being engineered or not. I personally think that they should be. If the quality of life of citizens of a city is better served by having limitations on this kind of short-let activity, then I think it's reasonable that city managers should have the ability to impose those limitations. If you believe in Laissez Faire, or that the market should be allowed free rein to shape or society, you would perhaps disagree.
- golergka 10y ago> quality of life of citizens While I can agree to some extent to this being the metric optimized, this metric depends on who gets to be a citizen. For example, the situation when the city becomes too expensive for particular class of people and they move out leads to increased in quality of life of remaining citizen, but people (not me) usually express negative views on this.
- paublyrne 10y agoPoor people leaving a city increases the quality of life for (richer) people that remain? That's not the obvious result of gentrification. I didn't say cities should optimise for quality of life, but quality of life should be an important consideration in the generation of policy. Other factors like cultural diversity also need to be taken into account, as well as mixing people with different income levels. I have found apartments in Berlin, for instance, that I was unable to rent because they had maximum income caps (and very low ones).
- golergka 10y ago> Poor people leaving a city increases the quality of life for (richer) people that remain? That's true, but not what I meant: by changing the group you measure the metric over, you change the value of the metric.