6 ms·
More importantly for some, it's a 95W AMD part vs a 140W Intel part. If the power delta stays the same even for mainstream parts, does this mean AMD will become
by nottorp 10y ago
More importantly for some, it's a 95W AMD part vs a 140W Intel part. If the power delta stays the same even for mainstream parts, does this mean AMD will become a good quiet option too?
By quiet I mean "I can't hear it at night" not "I can't hear it over the music".
Edit: Also, I think data centers these days are limited in density by power delivery and cooling. Even a 25W delta adds up when you're talking about thousands of servers.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- hocuspocus 10y agoThe 65W versions should be trivial to cool silently, a $40 heatsink with a single low speed 12cm fan (500~600 rpm) does the job well with my CPUs. For a 95W TDP you might need to spend a little more (like on those big Noctua heatsinks with 14cm fans), but silent air-cooling is definitely possible. (Water is always trickier, AIO kits will typically be a little noisier due to the pump).
- Lev1a 10y agoAFAIK the Ryzen 1700 (TDP 65W) is supposed to come with a "Wraith" cooler from AMD and those new ones are apparently better than their shitty older counterparts from the Vishera days (I had one and I'm glad I switched to a near silent Arctic cooler).
- auxym 10y agoSame here, the Artic Cooler was 20$ and the difference is dramatic. Cooler temps all around and near silent at modest loads, where the stock cooler was annoyingly loud.
- jandrese 10y agoWorse, loud fans seem to fail the most. I've always been annoyed when a $75 CPU comes with a $.25 fan that is going to crap out in a year or two.
- jdietrich 10y agoAt these TDPs, fully passive cooling is an option: http://www.silentpcreview.com/NoFan_CR-95C_Copper http://www.silentpcreview.com/NoFan_CR-95C_Copper
- hocuspocus 10y agoThat's huge :) In a smaller HTPC it can make sense to go passive but for an 8-core desktop workstation I'm not convinced it's worth the trouble. Your PSU and GPU will likely have fans, also with a PCIe SSD it's better to have some airflow.
- jdietrich 10y agoIt's now possible to build very high-performance rigs that run completely silently. Palit offer a fanless 1050ti; Asus Strix 1060/70/80 cards will run with the fans stopped under light loads. Fanless 500w PSUs are readily available, which will happily power an eight core machine with a GTX 1080. The brilliant Silverstone FT03 case uses a chimney-like vertical design that can create significant airflow through pure convection. Passive cooling isn't for everyone, but the remarkable efficiency of modern components has made it a perfectly feasible option even for high performance workstations. You can choose whatever level of noise you prefer, from extremely quiet to dead silent.
- CydeWeys 10y agoThe biggest reduction in computer noise I've noticed over the past ten years has been eliminating HDD chatter by switching to SSDs. I still have one older PC that I use occasionally that has an HDD, and it is pretty serious. You can feel when the filesystem is under load by the frantic vibrations of the arm moving across the disk. Fans, in comparison, tend to be a steady thrum, and thus fade into the background in a way that HDD chatter doesn't.
- catdog 10y agoI second this. Even without chatter a spinning HDD is quite noticeable while fans are not that noisy as long as you are able to keep them at moderate speeds.
- barrkel 10y ago6 core 140W 6800K I have under my desk is cooled with a Noctua NH-U14 - very quiet and max core temp I've seen under load (mostly video transcoding) is 54 degrees - that's about 30 degrees above my office room temperature.
- jsheard 10y agoTDP is a bit tricky to compare in this situation. The TDP of Intels HEDT chips is dictated by their 256-bit wide AVX units which drive power consumption through the roof when fully loaded, and the chips don't get nearly as hot when AVX isn't being used. Ryzen doesn't have this edge case because it sticks with 128-bit SIMD units and runs AVX instructions over two clock cycles. I expect the "140W" Intel part will have closer power consumption to Ryzen in non-AVX loads, and outperform Ryzen in AVX loads while using more power.
- jabl 10y agoThe Intel chips (at least the Xeon ones, don't know about the consumer parts, but I'd presume they behave the same?) clock down when running AVX2-heavy code to fit within the power envelope.
- Symmetry 10y agoIntel chips use a lower base clock frequency when they're running AVX code than when they're running non-AVX code for the very reasons you mention. In Intel's example[1] they talk about a base freqeuncy of 2.3 GHz without using AVX dropping to 1.9 with AVX[1]. That drop isn't much in frequency terms but you also have to figure in the voltage drop that the lower frequency allows you to cut power much more than you cut frequency. The end result is somewhere between power dropping with the cube or square of frequency depending on whether active or leakage power is dominating. Which is to say that they can save between 30% and 40% of their power by reducing the frequency at the same time they're lighting up a large area of new silicon. So I assume they chose the specific frequencies so that they're always hitting the same TDP whether they're making us of AVX or not. Of course, performance scales not to far from linearly here so going to AVX is a large net performance win, as you say. It's just that I'd assume equal power consumption on non-AVX loads. [1]http://www.intel.com/content/dam/www/public/us/en/documents/white-papers/performance-xeon-e5-v3-advanced-vector-extensions-paper.pdf http://www.intel.com/content/dam/www/public/us/en/documents/...
- iheartmemcache 10y agoI agree with you but when I clicked your footnote source, oh god - the marketing wank. The problem with all of these benchmarks (starting with LAPACK in 1979, up until modern day benchmarks used in the TOP500 or the TPC which models a bank for RDBMS performance) is the synthetic nature of the tests and the unreasonable locality of what they end up testing. One of the bazillions of reasons why the base frequency can drop in those tests Intel used is because your CPU(s) isn't(aren't) context switching or having to do things a normal MSSQL or Oracle DB will do. I.e., LAPACK/BLAS benchmarks are just really big linear algebra matrix problems, so obviously your pre-fetch and branch prediction performance will be significantly better since you aren't dealing with interrupts, locatedb, or Windows DCOM events firing off in the background. You have a huge set of matrices with a very predictable set of branches, fetches, and decodes, so obviously your CPU can optimize for that load, you're just paying for it in latency on the back-end (RAM fetches are the new disk swap ;)). On all those benchmarks, (i.e. your standard LU matrix decomposition which previously was the basis of the LAPACK benchmarks, though things might have changed in the ~10 years since I've really looked at things) isn't CPU-bound anymore, so of course your instruction-per-cycle load on the CPU isn't where you'll be bottlenecking (and hasn't been since "let's avoid floating-point operations and just use static look-ups instead since we don't want the 10x cost of using the FDIVP instruction!"). Your processor can very easily anticipate from where in that sparse-matrix your next data fetch is going to be. It's the cost of that RAM fetch[1] going along that copper trace which is going to be where you're going to bottleneck on any heavy numerical computation. The power consumption on your CPU might drop a nominal amount which is great for those marketing white papers, but for a numerically heavy load, you're paying just as much (in total power consumption per 4U in the data center, total heat generation/dissipation within the case, and total processing time) on the back-end for those fetches. [1] https://i.stack.imgur.com/a7jWu.png https://i.stack.imgur.com/a7jWu.png (I normally cite academic references, but this is 'good enough' to convey my point, I hope).
- marcosdumay 10y agoIs AMD still publishing the real power envelope of their chips while Intel is publishing "normal" power consumption?
- edvinbesic 10y agoI believe it is, AMDs TDP is the maximum the CPU will consume whereas Intel is maximum under normal workloads meaning you can push it past the advertised TDP
- zouhair 10y agoMaybe Calyos[0] technology might interest you. Fanless and totally silent technology, here is the other Linus[1] talking about it. [0]: http://www.calyos-tm.com/calyos-fanless-pc-workstation/ http://www.calyos-tm.com/calyos-fanless-pc-workstation/ [1]: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=9PJOrfpiVwE https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=9PJOrfpiVwE
- falcolas 10y agoSlick. Heat pipes from CPU and GPU back to a large passive cooler embedded in the case. I'd be curious what the limits are - how much heat can it absorb before the lack of active cooling affects its performance.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- driverdan 10y agoAll CPUs are silent when you water cool them. You can get a decent closed loop cooler for <$100 now.
- nottorp 10y agoActually it very much depends on what kind of fan cools the radiator. You're using that liquid loop just to move the heat from the CPU to somewhere else. That somewhere else is generally a large radiator with a quiet fan, but not always. Anyone building their own silent pc should hang a bit on silentpcreview before they buy anything.
- jdietrich 10y agoWater cooling rigs are relatively noisy by modern standards. A really quiet pump produces about 19dBA@1m. That's about the upper limit of "quiet" these days. On top of that, you have one or two fans blowing through a radiator. A good air cooler will easily handle 125w TDP at acceptable temperatures while producing as little as 11dBA@1m. A Noctua NH-D15 or a be quiet! Dark Rock Pro 3 will match or exceed the performance of a 240mm AIO, with considerably lower noise in a decent case. There aren't a lot of applications where water cooling really makes sense. If you're cramming a very high performance rig into a tiny ITX case, you might be better off with an AIO. Competition-grade overclocking rigs will naturally benefit from a custom open-loop watercooling system. Otherwise, modern components just don't put out enough heat to stress a good air cooler. The performance of water cooling can be deceptive, because of the relatively high thermal mass of the water in the loop. If you fire up Aida64 on an air cooler, the CPU temperature will climb fairly rapidly before levelling off. A water-cooled CPU will see a much more gradual increase in temperature, taking up to an hour to reach a maximum. Water coolers look really impressive if you only stress them for a short benchmark run, but they're far less impressive under sustained load.
- gens 10y agoIf your goal is quiet and quiet alone, i would suggest a good cooler. A cooler master hyper 212 is really quiet. I thought data centers are going for ARM cpu's now, as shoveling data is not all that cpu intensive ?
- Zancarius 10y ago> A cooler master hyper 212 is really quiet. I second this. I've been using the Hyper 212+ for 5 years and it's been great. The 212EVO looks just as good. Only drawback is the height (not an issue with larger cases). Funny aside: I actually replaced the fan on my 212+ thinking the one it shipped with had failed. Turns out I'm an idiot and either didn't install the rubber dampeners correctly or the mounts came loose during shipping (can't remember which). The replacement's been solid for 5 years and although the original was relegated to spare (nothing wrong with it), I doubt I'll ever need it before I retire this build. DEFINITELY better than the crummy cooler my Phenom II shipped with. That thing was noisy and ineffective. Next upgrade is definitely including the newer series 212 as well.