4 ms·
>"Edward Anthony Anderson, January 15, 1996, shot while handcuffed and on the ground. Frankie Arzuega, fifteen years old, January 12, 1996, shot in the back of
by djsumdog 10y ago
>"Edward Anthony Anderson, January 15, 1996, shot while handcuffed and on the ground. Frankie Arzuega, fifteen years old, January 12, 1996, shot in the back of the head; the following Mother’s Day, his family received taunting phone calls from anonymous sources: they dialed *69 (call back) and the police answered. Anthony Baez, December 22, 1994, chocked to death for playing football on the streets of New Your City. Rene Campos, whom police said committed suicide in custody by stuffing more than half his T-shirt down his own throat, reaching three-quarters of the way down to his lungs. Garland Carter, seventeen years old, January 8, 1996, shot in the back by police who earlier that day had driven by his home, making their fingers into the shape of a gun and “firing.” Angel Castro, fifteen years old, October 23, 1996. Having already moved out of a neighborhood because of death threats from the police, Castro rode his bike back to the neighborhood to a friend’s birthday party: He accidentally ran into a police cruiser, breaking his teeth, and as he rose from the ground a cop shot him. Sherly Colon, April 25, 1997, pushed off the roof of a housing project, after which police removed the cuffs which had held her hands behind her back….The list is as long as you want to make it..." –The Culture of Make Believe, Derrick Jensen
The Culture of Make Believe is a very difficult book to get through. The author talks about hate crimes and power, and how we've developed these very odd cultural norms around violence. It's pretty depressing.
- TallGuyShort 10y agoSounds very similar to some of the most chilling stories from South Africa during Apartheid: political prisoners whose corpses were photographed and clearly beaten to a pulp with the official cause of death listed as, "fell against chair."
- kabouseng 10y agoO please the old story of the big bad apartheid regime. For a bit more perspective: During the difficult transition period 1990 - 1994, security forces (police) caused 518 deaths[1]. Compare that with 2013 US police caused 930 - 1240 deaths and South African police caused 409 deaths[2]. Keep in mind that during this transitional period there was basically a civil war of sorts going on, with 14000 political murders between ANC and other freedom factions during this time (1990 - 1994). And even today under a free and democratic government it is reported that police behavior is a least just as bad as under apartheid[3]. Currently the police death rate, taking into account population differences is twice as bad as the USA police death rate and four times as bad as during the worst years of police brutality during apartheid. Fact is South Africa is a deeply divided country and single sentence statements such as the one of the parent poster does no justice to the complexities that is the continually worsening South African situation. [1]https://www.censorbugbear.org/genocide/how-many-people-died-in-sa-in-hatecrimes-during-apartheid-as-compared-to-after-1994-2 https://www.censorbugbear.org/genocide/how-many-people-died-... [2]http://mg.co.za/article/2015-06-10-fdf http://mg.co.za/article/2015-06-10-fdf [3]http://www.aljazeera.com/programmes/africainvestigates/2015/11/south-africa-echoes-apartheid-151118121841557.html http://www.aljazeera.com/programmes/africainvestigates/2015/...
- adventured 10y ago1) The US has six times the population of South Africa. 2) A police officer killing someone, is not necessarily murder. You're going to have to break out how many of those are acts of self-defense, because it's a non-trivial number (likely the majority are in fact self-defense). [1] Some of America's inner cities are wildly violent, with murder rates on par with the worst areas of Latin America (ie some of the worst areas on earth for murder). Try policing a perpetual war zone that has been raging for 40 years. [1] http://www.newsweek.com/how-many-americans-do-cops-kill-each-year-480712 http://www.newsweek.com/how-many-americans-do-cops-kill-each...
- kabouseng 10y agoFrom your comment I'm not sure if you are agreeing or disagreeing with me, but: 1)The US has six times the population of South Africa. Absolutely, thats why I said South Africa currently has about twice the police killings rate the US has. So the math is: South Africa police killings = 409 to be comparable on a per capita basis with the US rate of between 900 - 1200 divide by 6 = 150 to 200 death per year if the US had the same population as South Africa, which is a rate your linked article also supports. Compare that with the apartheid rate of 518 deaths over 4 years, so about 130 deaths per year. (But ok I have not taken 20 years of population growth into account). 2) A police officer killing someone, is not necessarily murder. You're going to have to break out how many of those are acts of self-defense, Absolutely, but that is a very difficult thing to do, especially only armed with google. Furthermore police statistics these days in South Africa is renowned to be of especially poor quality, so I have to work with what I have. 2) Some of America's inner cities are wildly violent, with murder rates on par with the worst areas of Latin America (ie some of the worst areas on earth for murder). Try policing a perpetual war zone that has been raging for 40 years. Your joking right. South Africa has an average murder rate of 34 / 100 000 [1], seven times worse than the USA. And if you want to compare the worst with the worst (Detroit), compare it with our farm murder rate of around 300 / 100 000 [2] which is actually worse than most war zones. So in summary, police killings during the worst years of apartheid was less than or at least on par with police killings in the US currently and police killings in current day South Africa is about twice as bad as both. >>Try policing a perpetual war zone that has been raging for 40 years. Yup...South Africa :D [1] https://africacheck.org/factsheets/factsheet-south-africas-201516-crime-statistics/ https://africacheck.org/factsheets/factsheet-south-africas-2... [2] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/South_African_farm_attacks https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/South_African_farm_attacks
- hueving 10y agoWhile those are horrifying examples, I dislike this approach of cherry picking and focusing on the worst cases. It can make a problem seem much worse than it really is and make it difficult to tell what is the result of systemic problems and what are individual bad actors. It's akin to someone mentioning flying and then going into gruesome detail about all of the terrible airline accidents over the years to suggest that flying is unsafe.
- cletus 10y agoI disagree. The question isn't if this is representative, the problem is this happens at all.
- jostylr 10y agoExpecting no problems is absurd. Zero is very different from small, in terms of possibility and cost. The real issue is, how did the system react to this? How does it self-correct? This is where so much of government falls down as they close ranks around themselves, identifying with the role they have first instead of identifying with their fellow citizens. This is a natural way to be (tribal), but it is also extremely problematic.
- gech 10y agoBringing examples like so is important for correction.
- hashkb 10y agoYou're considerably more likely to be abused by police than be involved in an aviation accident.
- aisofteng 10y agoAviation is by far the safest mode of transportation in the world, so that is not surprising.