7 ms·
How to Set Up an OpAmp Circuit to Do Complex Mathematics
- mindcrime 10y agoAnd on a related note. https://archive.org/details/anacomp https://archive.org/details/anacomp Lately I've become really interested in analog computing and want to explore the possibilities of analog/digital hybrid computers. If anybody has done / is doing anything fun in this regard, I would love to hear about it. Also, there's a subreddit for Analog Computing if anyone is into that sort of thing. http://analogcomputing.reddit.com http://analogcomputing.reddit.com
- aswanson 10y agoHear about it, courtesy of nickpsecurity: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=10614952 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=10614952
- nickpsecurity 10y agoThanks for posting it. I wanted to but my mobile didnt have it. Those were best papers I found showing amazing results you can get with analog computing.
- aswanson 10y agoThanks for originally sharing; hoping to do something with this info and will share.
- nickpsecurity 10y agoIf you want some funding or impact, an accelerator for a proven deep-learning architecture could be useful. Prior work in neural computation got plenty results. Just havent seen many independents try it for deep learning. One wacky idea I had was using analog accelerators for complex, evaluation functions in genetic algorithms. The digital chip would just feed each solution to a bank of them with fitness result popping out other side. Another idea was attempting any of that with Field-Programmable, Analog Arrays to see what results they got. Lowers development costs vs making masks for custom circuits.
- aswanson 10y agoThose are awesome ideas, ones I never would have thought of! I was thinking more along the lines of using analog filtering for convolutional layers of deep neural networks, dropout layers and filter templates for 2-d features are just bandpass filters, which analog filters can approximate easily. That analog fpga idea is a good one also; there needs to be a way to perform rapid experimentation on these types of ideas. Are there any products/companies you know of in this area?
- nickpsecurity 10y agoYour ideas are possibly better just because you already have a chance of building them if they're that close to existing analog schemes. I'd try them first to get a feel for the whole thing. Far as reprogrammable, type in what I told you into Google: Field-Programmable, Analog Arrays (FPAA's). Or reconfigurable analog. You'll get companies and CompSci. Also remember that analog works best/easiest on oldest process nodes. That combined with multi-project wafers can get your ASIC prototypes down to thousands of dollars rather than tens to hundreds. Middle ground company is a structured ASIC that's basically like a FPGA programmed with 1-2 masks at fab time. Triad Sdmiconductor does that for digital+analog with claimed $400k per design with few weeks turn around. Idk if their analog cells are suitable, though. Also, for good measure you might enjoy at least looking at the last general-purpose (programmable), analog computer: http://www.comdyna.com/gp6intro.htm http://www.comdyna.com/gp6intro.htm
- p1esk 10y agoHere is a neural network using analog weights and neurons: https://arxiv.org/abs/1610.02091 https://arxiv.org/abs/1610.02091
- mchahn 10y ago> If anybody has done / is doing anything fun in this regard, I would love to hear about it. There were several hybrid computers sold in the 60's.
- westbywest 10y agoAnalog electronic computers actually offered significant advantages in precision over their digital equivalents for much of the mid-20th century, due to limitations imposed by slow clock speeds and small word sizes. Calibrating them was non-trivial, though. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Analog_computer#Modern_era https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Analog_computer#Modern_era
- mindcrime 10y agoInteresting, especially in light of the "modern" view where the prevailing narrative is that analog computers are (in general) less precise, but faster. And, of course, less flexible, but I think that goes without saying. I am curious to what extent an analog/digital hybrid can blend the best of both worlds, especially for something where the speed <-> precision tradeoff may somewhat favor speed. Like training neural networks.
- dragontamer 10y agoIt appears that digital is king for modern calculations. However, digital exists only in the ~millivolt to 5V range, its difficult to get a purely digital circuit to "sense" microvolts or nanovolts. That's where Analog comes in. You can shape and calculate microvolt and even nano-volt level signals before upscaling them to millivolts so that the CPU can handle the rest of things. In general, digital RAM will hold a value more reliably for a longer-period of time than an analog storage device (aka: capacitor). True, RAM is implemented using capacitors (DRAM needs to be "Refreshed" as those capacitors lose value). Its easy to "refresh" a capacitor if you only care about two states: high and low. If you're analog however and care about microvolts / nanovolts, its impossible to "refresh" capacitors. After all, what does a capacitor at 5000uV really mean? In digital, you can refresh it back to 6000uV every few seconds. In analog, you don't know if part of the information leaked out or not.
- brandmeyer 10y agoAt the boundary between analog and digital, you typically need to provide an anti-aliasing filter. If you are measuring a differential signal with a large high-frequency common-mode component, then it also makes sense to perform the subtraction in analog. Otherwise the inevitable small phase shift between the sampling of the two channels in your ADC will end up coupling the common-mode signal into your difference.
- seiferteric 10y agoFor my control systems class several years ago I created a PID controller with just OpAmps. Each portion had a switch to enable/disable to see the results of P+I, P+D, P+I+D etc. The output from each portion could be amplified (controlled by a trimpot) and then was summed (also by an OpAmp) and then went to a pair of transistors to drive a DC motor on a Plexiglas board with a pointer and 0-180 degrees marked out. The input was a potentiometer with a knob to set the desired angle. Pretty fun project. Others in the class decided to do it digitally with a micro controller but seeing it all done with analog components was really cool!
- plandis 10y agoI did something similar with op amps to implement a PID controller. I had a circuit design class in college where each week you would have some new thing to design. One of the assignments was to develop a laser that would find and then track a solar panel. The class had a contest to see which design would track the center of the panel the best. Fun stuff!
- jcoffland 10y agoYou made a servo.
- seiferteric 10y agoYes that's true, just wanted to explain the mechanism behind it. Just a note, I don't think most hobby type servos implement full PID control, though many industrial ones do I am sure.
- snovv_crash 10y agoHobby servos often have controllers far more complex and accurate than PID. Something taking into account the gearbox and motor inertia, input voltage, etc. And not just tuned with high pass, low pass and gain filters.
- seiferteric 10y ago
- bsamuels 10y agoyou don't even need electronics to make a computer! here's a 1953 training film for a mechanical fire control computer https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=s1i-dnAH9Y4 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=s1i-dnAH9Y4
- gozur88 10y agoThis kind of stuff fascinates me. There's an amazing amount of intelligence you can put into oddly-shaped cams.
- tingletech 10y agoBack in the '80s my grandpa worked for Northrup flying target drones he designed the guidance system for back in the '70s. He hated digital computers -- thought there was no way digital with all ones and zeros could ever be as accurate as the continuous values in analog computers he built with OpAmps. (He also didn't like seat belts or the UN).
- dragontamer 10y agoWell, back then analog circuits were likely faster and more accurate. There are lots of textbooks that showed you how to get 6.5 digits (21-bits) or 7.5 digits (23-bits) of accuracy using normal parts machined to 1% precision. These circuits would operate all the way to 100MHz and react to impulses within nanoseconds... even way back in the 80s... and could be mass produced for only a few dozen dollars. You know, back in the era where computers were 33 MHz (That's 30-nanoseconds per clock!) with 16-bit adders and cost tens-of-thousands of dollars. Today, things are different. We have 2GHz octcore computers in our pockets with 4GB of RAM. Analog-circuits have improved, but not nearly as much as digital circuits. The primary issue with Analog is that we've hit the noise-floor. Getting more than 7.5 digits of accuracy on all calculations means getting rid of noise at the -75db (volts) level or 150db-watts. Case in point: 7.5 digits of analog accuracy on a 5V circuit is accurate to +/- 150-nanovolts. At those minuscule levels of voltages and currents, simple heat, airborne static electricity, and even sound... noise... and physical movement... can disturb your calculations. (Crystal Oscillators for example are Piezoelectric and are tiny-little microphones that pick up sound / movement and convert them into voltages!! Every PCB trace is a potential antenna that may pick up a stray radio signal. Things get hard...) Voltages are connected to the real world after all. At some point, the circuit can "feel" you breathing on it (condensation in the air changes humidity, which changes the resistance of the surrounding air. Extra heat decreases and/or increases the resistance of various components)
- HeyLaughingBoy 10y agoYeah. I remember in the late 90's early 2000's patiently trying to explain in so many online forums why a simple feedback control with a couple of opamps or even a single transistor was a faster, cheaper & better approach than throwing a microcontroller and digital circuitry at many a n00b's problem. Today? 90% of those problems would indeed be solved much more easily with a $0.50 microcontroller. Raw speed and price drops pretty much eliminated the benefits of analog circuitry in most applications.
- drfuchs 10y agoMy dad designed Frequency Response Analyzers in the 60's and 70's that used OpAmps to compute Fourier Integrals and then "solve the right triangle". That is, relative to a sine wave it generated, it would take a return analog signal, multiply by sine and cosine waves, integrate both, and then take the square-root of the sum of the squares and also the arctangent of their ratio, to finally output amplitude and phase-shift of the return signal. All as analog voltages; all with OpAmps (and a tiny bit of TTL to turn the integrators on and off). It simply wasn't feasible to do this digitally; it's not just that doing a real-time FFT in the digital sphere was cost-prohibitive at the time, but also the A-to-D converters weren't fast enough to keep up (at the required accuracy). Typical users went from aerospace and automotive ("will our wing or chassis oscillate badly when we hit a thermal or pothole"?) to audio (that's how they would make those Frequency Response charts for speakers) to hard disk drive head servos ("if we send the head from track X to track Y, will it get there directly, or "ring" -- slightly overshoot and then overcorrect for a while?"). One fun detail: eventually they had to encase their OpAmps in special little heaters that would keep them at a constant temperature, to avoid drift as the ambient temperature changed. You can still occasionally buy one surplus on eBay for a few hundred dollars; they were about $10k new (in 70's dollars).
- CapacitorSet 10y agoThat sounds _extremely_ interesting for people who are into control theory! Do you happen to have schematics?
- drfuchs 10y agoI think so; I'll have to look through storage. Drop me a line at {myid} at yahoo.com. Let me point out that the description here is as understood by a pure-digital person: I didn't seem to inherit the analog gene, and as a teen couldn't grok his deeper explanations ("What do you mean 'the imaginary part of the signal'? We're in the real world; the electrons don't have any imaginary components!").
- dragontamer 10y ago
- castratikron 10y agoAnother cool example: solving differential equations with opamps https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=DBteowmSN8g https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=DBteowmSN8g
- b1gtuna 10y agoSounds like a fun weekend project. Any guide on how to actually put this together to run check the math?
- qntty 10y agoGet a breadboard, opamp, some resistors/capacitors and wires. Read the data sheet for the opamp to connect it correctly (connect V+ and V- to +/- 15 V power supplies). Feed in a saw tooth wave and look at the output with an oscilloscope (you won't see anything interesting with a constant voltage for input). If you need a reference for understanding the principles that make it work, use The Art of Electronics 2nd or 3rd ed.
- b1gtuna 10y agoThank you. I had a hunch that this would require a scope and a signal generator. And I have neither unfortunately.
- nanxor 10y agoIs it possible that high precision/performance analog devices might perform some graphics tasks (e.g. ray tracing) faster than digital computers?
- xyzzyz 10y agoSure -- if you cast light at physical objects, and then collect the reflected light with photo-sensitive component, you can perform real-time ray-tracing with arbitrarily good accuracy.
- brians 10y agoWell, sure. An analog ray tracer is called a camera. Scene setup can take a while, though.
- spott 10y agoAn interesting point when using Op-Amps: doing linear operations (addition/subtraction/multiplication by a scalar/integration/etc) is pretty easy (they are "linear devices"). Doing multiplication/division/exponentiation/etc is actually a little more difficult. Typically, they are done through log amplifiers[0], of which there are plenty of monolithic versions. [0] http://www.analog.com/media/en/training-seminars/tutorials/MT-077.pdf http://www.analog.com/media/en/training-seminars/tutorials/M...