4 ms·
Humans can do lots of things robots can't currently do: they can create thoughtful art, write meaningful stories and journalism. They can take care of and raise
by nkrisc 10y ago
Humans can do lots of things robots can't currently do: they can create thoughtful art, write meaningful stories and journalism. They can take care of and raise children. They can easily tailor instruction to individuals, and more.
What do all these roles have in common? They aren't usually valued very highly by society. It seems a lot of people want to work the jobs the robots are good at and not do the ones humans are best at.
- thenomad 10y agoWhat do all these roles have in common? They aren't usually valued very highly by society. Artistic work is valued very highly by society. J.K. Rowling is a billionaire. Notch, creator of Minecraft, likewise. George Lucas is a billionaire 5x over. It seems a lot of people want to work the jobs the robots are good at and not do the ones humans are best at. A very large number of people desperately want to do artistic work, enough to keep doing it on less than minimum wage and/or in terrible working conditions for decades or their entire lives. The problem is not that artistic work, per se, isn't valued. The problem is that artistic jobs in the 21st century suffer from a truly vicious power law curve, and a comparatively small number of people can create most of the art and storytelling most people will consume, and thus reap most of the rewards.
- aioprisan 10y agoYou're picking a few massively successful people out of billions that have come and gone. You could argue the same about any industry by cherry-picking a few successes while the mean comp is much lower, which actually shows that as a society we actually do not value those things very highly.
- thenomad 10y agoMy point is that some artistic work is valued extremely highly. The issue with saying "we'd like everyone who wants to be an artist to be able to make a living at it!" is that thanks to easy duplication, a very few winners take almost the entire pot. That's radically different to most other industries, and so requires different solutions.
- jlg23 10y agoI'd argue that the average monthly income of artists is lower than that of software developers. Same for workers in care.
- thenomad 10y agoThe average monthly income of artists is massively lower than that of software developers. It's probably lower than that of janitors. In the UK a professional author, on average, earns below minimum wage, for example. http://www.telegraph.co.uk/news/celebritynews/11550871/Just-one-in-ten-authors-can-earn-full-time-living-from-writing-report-finds.html http://www.telegraph.co.uk/news/celebritynews/11550871/Just-... Again: power law curve. A very small number of authors create something that becomes a massive hit. They get extremely wealthy, because society really values their work. Most - and by "most" I mean 99.99% - don't. I'd call it an "inverse square law", but the distribution is so uneven that most artists would be tearfully grateful if it suddenly changed to only be equivalent to 1/x^2 .
- jsemrau 10y agoI have several recordings from my teenage years...would you mind forking over some of them billions that society is handing out ? ;-)
- harperlee 10y agoPlease (re?)read the parent's last paragraph: > The problem is that artistic jobs in the 21st century suffer from a truly vicious power law curve, and a comparatively small number of people can create most of the art and storytelling most people will consume. But I think the problem is not unavoidable - for example, you could avoid it by trying to get the locals to have preference for local content, so it alleviates the pain of fighting against global artists. You just need to find a niche to exploit :) for example, being a bullfighter reduces competition as there are not a lot of countries that enjoy it. For music, try folk. Etc.
- nradov 10y agoHumans can create thoughtful art, write meaningful stories and journalism. But the vast majority of that content is garbage and has negative value. I wouldn't want it even for free; someone would have to pay me to consume it.
- PeterisP 10y agoWhat do all these roles have in common? They scale globally and only the best contributors matter. Attention becomes the bottleneck. The top artist in some niche is highly valued, the 101st in that particular niche is useless because only the most narrowminded fan has enough time and attention to consume the 100 artists that do the same thing better - and for the 1001st? Only their mother would care about their work. Producing the best movie or the best jazz record in your town doesn't mean that there will be a nontrivial amount of people that would want that work, because there are more better movies/records than they can watch. It's the same with journalism, it's mostly going away as a profession as there's space for only a very limited number of people to do it for pay, as there are more than enough hobbyists able and willing to produce that content for free. As it goes on (e.g. with automation) it's not unrealistic to expect a market price that goes below zero, i.e., where most of the "industry" are essentially paying to be there instead of getting paid. We already see that in e.g. photography and music with a lot of people who create great art, but their revenue for that doesn't even cover what they are paying for their equipment. And it's going to get even more so.
- pif 10y ago> They aren't usually valued very highly by society. Simply matter of supply and demand. Nobody cares too much about what cab be done by anybody.