3 ms·
In what sense has eminent domain been eroded? Given that the Supreme Court ruled about ten years ago that eminent domain may even be used to make way for priva
by emodendroket 10y ago
In what sense has eminent domain been eroded? Given that the Supreme Court ruled about ten years ago that eminent domain may even be used to make way for private enterprise it seems to me that it is quite powerful.
- monodeldiablo 10y agoA close family member is an urban planner, and he blames a succession of legal challenges that have forced public entities to account for all sorts of value that the property could never actually attain. And, of course, the increase in number and density of holdouts has driven acquisition costs way, way up for large public projects, since time delays incur costs. Lawyers have learned that, even if the city/state makes a good offer, they can get a better one by grinding through the process slowly. Eminent domain is a powerful (and easily abused) idea, but it's devilishly hard to strike the right balance between property owners' rights and the common good. At least on the West Coast, the scales seem to have tipped in favor of property owners.
- emodendroket 10y agoI mean, I don't think it would really be ideal for the government to be seizing property for a pittance left and right either.
- monodeldiablo 10y agoNeither do I. As I said, it's a delicate balance to strike. Personally, I'd rather it tilted in favor of property owners than the other direction. There's no denying, though, that it's a huge and increasing cost to public works projects.
- nradov 10y agoSure eminent domain remains legally powerful. But politically it has become more of a hot button issue in certain conservative circles who actively lobby against its use. And when eminent domain is used the takers have to pay fair market price so with the huge increase in urban real estate values over the past few years it's much harder to just find the money.
- monodeldiablo 10y agoNot to mention all the accounting and legal shenanigans that can be used to pump up "fair market" value. Including the costs of arbitration if the seller doesn't feel the offer is fair. Which itself gets budgeted into the price...
- cgriswald 10y agoGiven its frequency of use and the fact that since Kelo it can be used to the benefit of private businesses, I'd say it is very much politically powerful as well as legally powerful. You don't think the decisions to remove people from their homes, which people to remove from their homes, and the price they should be paid for this major disruption to their lives is already a massively political issue? The poorest among us are disproportionately affected by eminent domain, because their property is the cheapest and because they are least able to defend themselves. Kudos to the 'certain conservative circles' who are trying to defend those people and shame on anyone who tries to trivialize that battle.
- nradov 10y agoYes I think it's already a massively political issue. But there are more powerful and vocal people focusing on eminent domain for ideological reasons after Kelo. Before that it was easier to take advantage of poor property owners and kind of slide things through under the radar.