10 ms·
This is definitely interesting, scientifically, and may help us better understand Autism (and its causes). I cannot imagine this will see widespread adoption o
by Someone1234 10y ago
This is definitely interesting, scientifically, and may help us better understand Autism (and its causes).
I cannot imagine this will see widespread adoption outside of research. MRI scans remain expensive and many MRIs have waiting lists at hospitals. Even today, they regularly use less safe technology (e.g. CTs) because they're less expensive and there will be more available.
There's no safety reason why you shouldn't do this. MRIs are darn near harmless. It is just an economic issue with gaining time on an MRI to discover information which may not change the overall outcome for the child (pediatricians are getting better and better at detecting early signs of autism).
Heck, if MRIs were readily available they'd quickly replace ultrasound during pregnancy (since MRIs are likely safer and superior given that they better represent depth). But alas, a MRI costs up to $1m for a "basic" one and up to $3m for a fMRI, and that's ignoring the space/training/power utilisation issues.
- clarkmoody 10y ago+1 for the quality and safety of MRI > they'd quickly replace ultrasound during pregnancy Since scan time goes up with detail, and babies are really squirmy, it would be interesting to see how a quick-scan (low resolution) MRI compares with ultrasound quality. But ultrasound destroys MRI in terms of portability, availability, and cost: just wheel in the cart, apply some goo, and there's the baby. Perhaps more serious situations should use MRI more often instead of diagnostic ultrasound.
- timClicks 10y agoI expect that portability is actually a reason why often even visual ultrasound isn't used. Doppler scanning is often all that's needed to monitor heart rhythms
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- timClicks 10y agoSquirmy babies shouldn't be too much of an issue. They do cardiac MRI all the time and hearts are hopefully beating during those ;)
- roywiggins 10y agoThose are much easier because heartbeats are regular, breathing is regular, and you can image a bunch of breaths and heartbeats and synthesize a nice clean movie. Motion in general is harder.
- lostlogin 10y agoRandom motion is far harder to control for. Irregular heart beats cause a lot of trouble, as do moving babies. So imagine foetal cardiac MRI. There are new methods using some pretty mind boggling maths (at least it is tonne) that deal with movement very well. But as with all clever MRI stuff, you can have nice, or you can have quick.
- highd 10y agoI've been working on a bootstrapped company building a low-cost MRI for about a year now. We're hoping to have a demonstrable prototype in another year or so. So we think that we can get to that future where people pick MRI based on application and not cost or availability.
- ClassyJacket 10y agoI'm so glad to hear that. I've been thinking for years that MRIs seem like an industry that could and should be disrupted. The benefits could be massive. I'm not in the medical field, but I really believe the future of cancer medicine will strongly lean towards prevention and early detection, as opposed to just cure.
- highd 10y agoRegarding cancer, we think you're right. That and possibly maintenance - for example, most prostate cancers are asymptotic for life if untreated. For slower cancers that are acquired in old age it can make sense to use less aggressive chemotherapies that maintain quality of life. We think that being able to monitor the development of the cancer closely and frequently is a key component of enabling future therapeutic approaches like that.
- gozur88 10y agoWhere I live there used to be radio advertisements for a service that would give you a full body MRI in an effort to find cancers that could be treated before they spead. After a bit of reseach I discovered it's a false promise. A lot of people have benign lumps and growths they can carry around for a lifetime without any trouble, and while MRIs are quite safe biopsies are not. If you don't have a reason to think you might have cancer, i.e. the MRI is a screening tool and not being used for a diagnosis, the very small chance you'll die of complications from unnecessary biopsies outweighs the very small chance you'll save your life by discovering a treatable malignant growth. At least, that was the state of the art 7-8 years ago.
- Dove 10y ago
- randerson 10y agoLess safe for an infant though since they have to be sedated in order to stay still.
- ohitsdom 10y agoOn fetal MRIs: "It also does not require intravenous contrast material (dye) or sedation." http://www.utswmedicine.org/stories/articles/year-2016/fetal-mri.html http://www.utswmedicine.org/stories/articles/year-2016/fetal...
- munificent 10y agoFetuses are relatively easier than infants because they are effectively strapped into the womb and don't even know they're getting an MRI. They can obviously wiggle around some, but don't move as much. Infants are harder: http://www.medscape.com/viewarticle/499273_11 http://www.medscape.com/viewarticle/499273_11 My daughter had to have a second, sedated MRI because she moved too much during her first one.
- Coincoin 10y agoYoung children need sedation so they will stay perfectly still; definitely not without risk. My 1 yo son needs a scan every 3 months and the hospital had to figure a better way to scan him so as to avoid sedation. They finally settled on ultrasound: faster, risk free and precise enough once you know what you are looking for.
- lostlogin 10y ago> There's no safety reason why you shouldn't do this. When you have seen a few done wrong you disagree with this. They have an inherent potential for death and injury and incidents are frequent, unlike US. Then there is the whole implant safety and contrast safety side of things. People won't be replacing pregnancy scans with MR any time soon, and the cost of the machine is not the primary reason for this. They scan too slowly and pregnant women aren't that keen on lying still for ages. It's sometimes even unsafe to encourage extended periods of lying supine. US is just too cheap and readily available. Source: I do MR scans.