9 ms·
We definitely need a universal OS for all our devices and I really believe Google is in a great position to get us there. It would really surprise me if Apple
by pier25 10y ago
We definitely need a universal OS for all our devices and I really believe Google is in a great position to get us there.
It would really surprise me if Apple got there first. Tim lacks vision and will keep on milking iOS even if the iPad Pro is a failure as a laptop replacement.
Windows is still king in the desktop space, at least as far a user base goes, but it's terrible on tablets and phones. MS has all the tech in place with UWP, but it's still pretty far in the race in terms of simplicity and usability.
Chrome OS ticks all the right boxes, and is experiencing a huge growth, but it's not universal. If Andromeda is real, and it's able to become a universal OS that merges Chrome OS and Android it might be the best thing since sliced bread.
- forrestthewoods 10y agoWhat? God no. We need competition. A single OS controlled by a single corporation with their own conflicting interests is a million miles from what we need.
- supremesaboteur 10y agoOperating System is about applications. Even if Google comes up with a universal OS there will be many applications that only run on Windows forcing people to continue to use it
- remir 10y agoAnd this is why we need an open source clone of Windows, which is king of the desktop OS. Beside geeks, the average people doesn't care about operating systems, they care about being able to run their apps. It's sad that ReactOS doesn't get more support from the community.
- mastazi 10y ago> Windows [...] [is] terrible on tablets and phones. Surface tablets seem to be doing OK though.
- MBCook 10y agoWhat percent of people regularly use them as tablets without the keyboard?
- mastazi 10y agoI think there are several different characteristics that make us categorise a device as a tablet vs. a laptop, input methods being just one of them; there are many others e.g. form-factor, weight, battery life etc.
- MBCook 10y agoMy point is I don't think people are buying Surface Tablets, I think they're buying Surface Computers (that can operate as Tablets).
- bitmapbrother 10y agoHow many touch optimized apps are on the Surface? I haven't seen many. The majority are still desktop apps and using desktop apps on a tablet isn't a very good UI experience.
- mastazi 10y agoYes I know where you are coming from but as I said in another comment I don't think that the input method should be the main element that defines the difference between a laptop and a tablet.
- wmccullough 10y agoTerrible on tablets and phone? Phones I can agree with but the surface line is getting to be really solid. I've been an iPad guy for years and my next tablet will be a surface.
- stephentmcm 10y agoA surface isn't a tablet, it's a laptop with a touch screen. I've tried them and they are really nice as laptop but they fallback to a finger hostile UI way to often to be called tablets.
- pier25 10y agoIndeed. The tablet aspect is pretty mediocre.
- nathanasmith 10y agoI had a Surface Pro 4 for a while and it is really great for the first few weeks but when the honeymoon period is over, the warts start to show. Slowly but surely I gravitated back to my iPad and laptop. The day the SP4 went back to Costco was when I realized it had been collecting dust for over a week.
- thewhitetulip 10y agoYes, we do. I want my phone and my laptop to be in total sync, I want to be able to write code on my mobile which I can just continue on my laptop without any hindrance, currently I have a mac and an android phone, I do have Go and Python installed on my mobile, but it isn't that great to code on my mobile, I have to host the repo on an internal version of gogs to get the code synced up and I still have to manually push the code around. All hail Universal OS!!
- gigatexal 10y agoOn OS X all my stuff syncs between my iDevices
- thewhitetulip 10y agoBut I don't have an iPhone, I have an android phone, I use syncthing, but this isn't the kind of sync I hope, I want both the OSes to be quite same with inbuilt sync not through the internet but through my LAN
- gigatexal 10y agoApple will never outright tell you this but the answer to that is "you're using OSX wrong". I really think for best results you have to be vertically integrated and have Apple gear for all things you want to work together and to do it well. If not I guess rely on someone making a third party app that does what Apple does for its devices.
- flukus 10y agoWhat exactly are you trying to sync? For music/files rsync is great.
- thewhitetulip 10y agoI have syncthing for syncing files, that isn't an issue. I want a universal OS which allows me to just plug my phone into my machine at home and it'll do magic and I can then continue my work. I have no other alternative than reading when I am on the bus. I want the mobile to be a native extension to the laptop
- azatris 10y ago> We definitely need a universal OS for all our devices Wait, do we? Why?
- mixedCase 10y agoSave man-centuries of platform-specific work?
- jug 10y agoI'd say to have a common interface towards hardware that is quickly becoming similar across smartphones, tablets, and even laptops (read Chromebooks)? I think why they would _not_ have the same interface between similar hardware and similar applications is a better question. As for the user interface and bundled applications, let's not confuse "Operating System" with that although it's popular for some stupid reason. The one and same OS could of course have e.g. completely different window managers adapted for different human-device interactions and use cases. But that's very distanced from the actual OS, that is pretty much only interested in how to run and expose the hardware to the software.
- macintux 10y agoYou may "definitely need" a universal OS but I'm far from convinced I do. I don't buy that a finger and a mouse/trackpad pointer are equivalent input devices. One obscures the display and is imprecise. The other, well, isn't. I'm fine with a different server OS than desktop. I see no compelling reason why I need a single OS for all of my personal devices.
- skj 10y agoYou listed windowing/UI concerns. And, while they may commonly come bundled with the OS, they're not the same thing.
- macintux 10y agoThey're a platform concern. Not only does the OS UI reflect the input method, every single application you run does as well. A touch-optimized application will be clumsy and primitive when using a mouse; a mouse-optimized application will be miserable when using a finger. If an application can be written once for both, often it'll be a poor compromise or only properly support one of the two input methods. Look at how awful early Java "write once run everywhere" applications were. Yes, some of that was the Java platform itself, but developers were given the opportunity to ignore platform-specific UX concerns and many eagerly embraced it.
- skj 10y agoI think a single platform for all our devices: mobile, tablet, desktop, etc, is a mistake. The word platform means more than just the OS and includes the entire L&F/experience with the UI. I think a single OS for them all is fine. Consider gnome+linux vs android+linux. They're both linux, and they're not the same platform.
- macintux 10y agoBy that definition, I could argue Apple got there years ago by using the same core kernel and frameworks for OS X and iOS. That's clearly not what the original poster was arguing.
- vlunkr 10y agoDoes Tim lack vision, or does he just not share your vision? You might think we "need" this but not everyone agrees. Combining Chrome OS and Android is uninteresting to me, since I wouldn't be able to develop on it or really do any of the things I use a computer for. Unless they plan to really build on it and attempt to compete with more mature desktop operating systems.
- pier25 10y agoHe lacks vision, not because he doesn't share my vision, but because of everything he has done in Apple. That's not to say he is a bad CEO, he isn't IMO, but he is only polishing the same ideas from 10-15 years ago. I'm not even arguing that's a bad thing per se, it's just how things are. Also, I really don't see how a developer could argue against the notion of having a single language, API, IDE, compiler, etc, for working on all devices. > Combining Chrome OS and Android is uninteresting to me, since I wouldn't be able to develop on it or really do any of the things I use a computer for. Time will tell.
- nitemice 10y agoAs much as I'd like to see it, I don't think Windows will ever quite get there. Not, at least, in any recognisable form. They value backwards-compatibility way to much (which is to be commended in some ways, but won't save them here). While they seem to have everything lined up to be able to turn it into something, developers seem too reluctant to get on-board too. Apple will have to go through all of the growing pains Microsoft has already weathered, so they're miles off, but maybe they can do it faster because they don't care as much about what people think of them, and are willing to do whatever they think is right (if it is or not is to be seen). Google is well placed because, while they have a bunch of platforms, the only one in the desktop space is basically dead, and really didn't ever have too much investment in it, so not too many feel put out if they get rid of it. But that not even the case, because they're able to engineer everything so that it stays relevant.
- mastazi 10y ago> developers seem too reluctant to get on-board too Might be limited to your specific environment though. As a counter-example among the people I know there are far more .NET devs than the total sum of iOS/Mac/Android devs.
- bitmapbrother 10y agoLimited to their specific environment? You mean the world?
- mastazi 10y agoWell there is life outside of the SV :-p
- nitemice 10y agoI'm not referring to .NET. I know tonnes of people getting on board to .NET train. I'm referring to the UWP apps. Nearly no one seems to be getting on board that.
- 10y ago
- frik 10y agoExactly, Google is in the best situation. Their Android is by far the most used OS/shell (world wide market share). Apple's CEO lacks the vision and is milking the status quo. Their iOS market share is a lot smaller and limited to a few devices. Microsoft's CEO lacks the vision and is aggressively milking the status quo. They aggressively try to enforce a switch to software-as-a-service plus they are no in the gray adware/spyware business capturing way too much end user data which shades bad light. And the killed their QA. Their products since 2010 are a disaster. That's why XBoxOne tanked in all market beside US, WinPhone tanked world wide, Win8 and Win10 marketshare is lot smaller than Win7, which is the major desktop OS - and there is little reason to switch away from Win7. MSFT would profit from a 180 degree U-turn with a new management.
- Sanddancer 10y agoWe don't need a universal OS. I'd go as far to say that a universal OS is bad. A universal OS leaves no place for experimentation, no place for different UI concepts, no place for people to customize things to the way they want. Would you really want every shirt to look the same? Every refrigerator, every door? Style is important.
- pier25 10y agoPeople usually confuse an OS with a UI. Obviously different devices need different UIs.
- sametmax 10y agoDo you really want Google, that has DNS, fiber, search engine, emails, calendar, phone contacts, ads, deep learning, app store, CDN, analytics, web browser, maps, power plants to ALSO handle your desktop OS ? That seems very, very dangerous to me. Actually we already are in the red zone, I just wish we don't go crimson. But I doubt people will care. They didn't up to now, no reason it changes.