17 ms·
Warren Buffett’s Best Investment
- obilgic 10y agoI wish Bill or Warren would have run for presidency as an "outsider" instead of Trump. I guess our only hope will be their successor Mark (Zuckerberg)
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- GuiA 10y agoI would argue that in the long term, Bill Gates running his foundation has a much deeper impact on humanity than being president, which would effectively cut him off from his philanthropic activities for 4-8 years. In other words, we're better off with Bill helming the Gates foundation rather than presiding the USA.
- CobrastanJorji 10y agoWould it? If it's permissible now to run a major international business while President, would it not also be permissible to run a giant charity?
- jplasmeier 10y agoI believe the comment was in regards to time spent on either venture, not the legality of doing both.
- rconti 10y agoBack in October, no, it was not permissible to run a giant charity. Apparently.
- obilgic 10y agoI would argue the otherwise. Imagine the resources and the influence power he would have on both U.S. and other nations, compared to few billion dollars spared by few people.
- sn9 10y agoYou're forgetting he'd be hampered by Congress. POTUS isn't a dictatorial position. He can move more or less unilaterally.
- giarc 10y agoCountries where the president can't go because of diplomacy, Bill can. Bill also doesn't have to deal with things like the debt ceiling, F35 contract, nominating supreme court justices etc etc. He can focus on global health.
- lostlogin 10y agoHow many would vote for him if they knew he hoped to help non-Americans with US txpayer dollars?
- adrianN 10y agoThat depends on how good his marketing team is.
- GhiliaWeld 10y agoI know it's called the Bill and Melinda Gates Foundation, but isn't it Melinda that runs and manages everything? I'm pretty sure Bill just donates to the foundation. I could be wrong tho.
- lostlogin 10y agoDid you notice the format that report took? Melinda, Bill, Melinda, Bill...
- girvo 10y agoNot that I feel this is the case, but one could argue that having Bill sign his name to something doesn't mean he's not "just a donor" and they're using his name for marketing purposes. Of course, I don't feel this is true, but I wanted to point it out nonetheless :)
- hamburglar1 10y agoI get Bill and Warren, but Mark?
- jmathai 10y agoA reference to the rumors that he's preparing to run for office. https://www.theatlantic.com/technology/archive/2017/01/zuckerberg-2020/513689/ https://www.theatlantic.com/technology/archive/2017/01/zucke...
- geoka9 10y agoDon't know about Buffett, but I don't get Gates either. He was a ruthless businessman using every trick in the book (legal and illegal) to solidify his company's monopoly.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- criddell 10y agoWell it wouldn't be Gates of 1992 running, it would be Gates of today. Have you changed in the past 25 years? I sure have.
- spooterspooter 10y agoHe'd have to be a fool to change the thing that made him one of the richest men alive. So I assume he's still quite ruthless.
- criddell 10y agoWhy? If somebody was the best marathon runner in the world and they retired and took up fly fishing, would you say they were fools for doing so?
- spooterspooter 10y ago
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- koolba 10y agoI can't help but shudder at the thought of the dystopian future that leads to a Zuckerberg presidency.
- luck_fenovo 10y agoAgreed. That said, I'd gladly read a book based on that premise.
- clydethefrog 10y agoAlready a short story is written about this premise. Democracy 3.0: A science-fiction story about what comes next in America https://qz.com/884971/democracy-3-0-a-science-fiction-story-about-what-comes-next-in-america/ https://qz.com/884971/democracy-3-0-a-science-fiction-story-...
- icantdrive55 10y agoHe'll eventually do a 180 on most things we are miffed about. He already has his name on a hospital. How long will it be before he decides he can do a better job as President? Once these rich boys make their "nut"; they become very moral/ethical in their latter years, except Trump? I think it has to do with their guilt? I don't know a wealthy man who didn't do some very unethical things clawing their way to the top.
- pizza 10y agothink of all the denied pluralities-to-be; those poor, slighted real estate tycoons. It's not hard to argue we're already in that simulation - first it starts with FB trialling their electioneering-algo with Trump as a proof-of-concept. Then once they work out all the kinks, initiate stage 2, reusing the mechanism!
- ethbro 10y agoArguably, a better plan would be to appear apolitically neutral until a surprise election result occurs, then roll out an algorithm in response to the calls for more filtering...
- kornish 10y agoIt's a funny observation that Mark Zuckerberg (32) actually isn't old enough to run for president at the moment (35). The next election would be the first where he's legally able. (all this irrespective of whether or not that's in his or others' best interests)
- ekianjo 10y agoSO there is a minimum age - how about a maximum one ?
- kornish 10y agoThere is no maximum age requirement. The requirements are well-articulated: http://americanhistory.about.com/od/uspresidents/f/presidential_requirements.htm http://americanhistory.about.com/od/uspresidents/f/president...
- logfromblammo 10y agoI wouldn't be averse to an amendment establishing the maximum age of eligibility for any elected federal office to be 130 years old on election day. I figure that if we ever get people to routinely outlive that mark, we may have a problem getting the elder generations to voluntarily yield power to the younger.
- glasz 10y agobe careful what you whish for. very careful.
- aanm1988 10y agoWhy would I ever want Zuckerberg as president? Why would I want any of these intelligent, but unqualified people as president? Trump has about the same qualifications. Look at that so far.
- 3825 10y ago(I'm not trying to be partisan here even though it might appear to be) I don't think it is possible for anyone to have the kind of broad and deep qualifications to be POTUS at any age, much less thirty five. This is one job which effectively requires on the job training and (I imagine) lots of delegating. Sorry if this sounds partisan. It isn't my intention. I'm not saying this as anything in defense of or in opposition to the incumbent. I'm just making a general comment.
- jfoutz 10y agoGovernors of large states are about as close as you can get, i think. They lack the military, intelligence and a lot of foreign policy experience though. I pretty much agree - OJT is intrinsically part of the deal.
- jasonjayr 10y agoOf course, it's a unique job. However, it does require a certain bit of humility, something that I think our current POTUS knows nothing about.
- lostlogin 10y ago> This is one job which effectively requires on the job training and (I imagine) lots of delegating. Do you mean that it should require that? It certainly didn't last year. I lack your 'fair and balanced' approach.
- xapata 10y agoAs far as I can tell, Trump lacks intelligence. I'd rather have a Gates or Buffet presidency. They've at least shown to care about philanthropy a bit. Trump has his foundation, but it mostly seems to do stuff like pay his legal fees and buy portraits of himself.
- pinewurst 10y agoParaphrasing Oliver Wendell Holmes, one generation of sociopaths is enough. Zuck should stick with "curing all diseases".
- foxylad 10y agoBill and Melinda are better where they are, because they are free from political interference. Can you imagine the opposition they'd get from the GOP for pushing contraception so centrally? And if they get into power, probably from the democrats too, for not focusing on their favourite bandwagons. OT: Can someone explain the GOP's strident opposition to funding contraception, both domestically and in the US's foreign aid? Apart from the obvious problems with unrestrained population growth, I'd have thought that aversion to abortion would imply whole-hearted support for contraception.
- throwaway729 10y ago> Can someone explain the GOP's strident opposition to funding contraception, both domestically and in the US's foreign aid? It's a culture war thing from the 80's and 90's. Contraception is for godless libs who fuck like rabbits out of wedlock. (Setting aside the fact that most religious right voters probably use birth control themselves...)
- vacri 10y agoThere are a lot of Catholics on the conservative side of things, and contraception has been verboten to Catholics since the early days ("sex is for making babies, not fun" is the company line)
- vkou 10y agoThis is quite false. Catholics split the democrat/republican vote ~50/50. They voted for Gore, Bush, Obama, and Trump with small margins. [1] They care about this question, but not very much. Evangelicals, on the other hand overwhelmingly vote republican. Catholics, in general, are the most liberal religious denomination in the US. http://www.pewresearch.org/fact-tank/2016/11/09/how-the-faithful-voted-a-preliminary-2016-analysis/ http://www.pewresearch.org/fact-tank/2016/11/09/how-the-fait...
- vacri 10y agoLooking more closely at your link, the white catholics were more likely to vote for Trump than protestants were (higher than anyone except evangelicals), and as I understand it, it's white catholics that are the most prominent in congress. Sorry, I meant politicians (as the parent referenced the GOP) rather than laypeople.
- pjmorris 10y agoIMO, anyone with over a Billion dollars is more like an insider than an outsider. Probably anybody over ~4 Million, actually.
- xapata 10y agoIf you conflate "insider" with economic class, there's no benefit to using the term anymore.
- pjmorris 10y agoIt is very fair to say that there is a class of people of various professions who have a great deal of influence but not a great deal of money. To what degree would you buy my notion that most of those people work for people in a higher economic class? Where do you see decisions being made independent of (or out of proportion to) their economic impact?
- xapata 10y agoNow you're going in a different direction. I'm just saying that not all wealthy people are "insiders".
- pjmorris 10y agoI'm more sure that wealthy people tend to be insiders than the professional non-wealthy. Once you've acquired enough to be considered wealthy, you care about the stability of currencies, banking systems, countries at least to the degree that it preserves your own wealth. 'The sleep of a laborer is sweet, whether they eat little or much, but as for the rich, their abundance permits them no sleep.' - Ecc 5:12
- xapata 10y agoThe way you phrased it previously suggested equivalence (all wealthy are insiders) rather than tendency (more wealthy are insiders).
- dorfsmay 10y agoChances are that they'd want to disturb the military industrial complex and secret government foreign operations, possibly leading to an drastic shortening of their life expectancy.
- deepGem 10y agoor Mark Cuban. His latest twitter spat with Trump is quite interesting. http://www.esquire.com/news-politics/news/a53079/trump-cuban-twitter/ http://www.esquire.com/news-politics/news/a53079/trump-cuban...
- maverick_iceman 10y agoWhile I applaud Bill Gates for his philanthropic work, I would be extremely doubtful of him if he decided to run for public office. His behavior during Microsoft antitrust trial wasn't exactly awe inspiring.
- majani 10y agoNone of those have the charisma necessary to run a successful presidential campaign
- imaginenore 10y agoDo you think George Bush (junior) did?
- princeb 10y agowhen I read comments on the internet like this, where people wish for a single influential person to run the country like, i begin to wonder how many Americans are out there who believe in and long for a "philosopher-king" system without any of the check and balances that the Federal Government has in place... a country like Singapore, with the benevolent dictator Lee Kuan Yew, perhaps? Whose single-mindedness and ability to execute has made the country one of the most successful (by several measures) in the world? Perhaps the US will benefit from blowing up the existing structure, whose rigidity was supposed to prevent demagoguery but appeared to have failed in the new era, and so we're left with is all the bureaucracy and no benefits.
- chappi42 10y agoNice <3 On the opposite number side, I hope they can help to find ways to reduce the population growth. It is unsustainable, especially in Africa and Arabic countries. (Pity one cannot just implement a China-like one child policy:))
- ekianjo 10y agoCheck what Hans Rosling said about this. You don't need to do anything.
- sn9 10y agoWell that's not quite true. You have to fight poverty and improve educational attainments for those most in need. Contributing to those causes will have the side effect of stopping overpopulation.
- ekianjo 10y agoWhat i mean by "not do anything" is not trying to attack the overpopulation issue by putting restraints on population directly. Hans Rosling has shown that as level of life increases around the world, developing countries move towards having less children and therefore the population balances itself in the mid run, at about 10 billion folks. Fighting poverty is done by improving economic openness - while people are always bitching about "inequalities" on the whole even the poorest are getting richer compared to 20 years ago and global poverty is steadily decreasing over time. And starvation is very much a thing of the past (except in conflict zones, for obvious reasons) while it was certainly not the case back in the 80s.
- phkahler 10y agoRISUG seems so promising, I'm not sure why Gates isn't helping put that on a fast track.
- dsjoerg 10y agoHere is the Hans Rosling video explaining why that's not a problem: https://www.gapminder.org/videos/will-saving-poor-children-lead-to-overpopulation/ https://www.gapminder.org/videos/will-saving-poor-children-l...
- johnwheeler 10y agoOne of the coolest things about this letter is it's presented in numbers--the format Warren appreciates the most.
- toastednz 10y agoI find Gates' lack of focus on environmental issues disheartening. I know he does invest in clean energy and feels strongly about climate change, but this doesn't really do anything to prevent deforestation NOW. I know that bringing people out of poverty may have a side-effect of improving some environmental parameters, but it also makes whole swathes of people start demanding more meat, more palm oil, more cars, more disposable goods. The big international benefactors don't seem that interested in rainforest biodiversity.
- downandout 10y agoSo some trees are more important than saving 122 million children? I know I'm going to get all the nasty replies that it's a larger issue than just a few trees, that without trees there won't be people, etc. But comments like these are the reason that people dismiss environmentalists as nutjobs that care more about trees than people.
- orbifold 10y agoClimate change is not just about trees, but about the massive loss of biodiversity that goes along with rapid climate change. Sure most of Europe will be covered in pine trees, but at the same time a lot of species, essentially all that are not able to migrate with the same speed that the climate changes in their habitat will die out. This article for example claims that 1/2 of the known species have died out within this century and 1/6 will die out if nothing is done about climate change: https://www.theguardian.com/environment/2015/apr/30/one-in-six-of-worlds-species-faces-extinction-due-to-climate-change-study https://www.theguardian.com/environment/2015/apr/30/one-in-s...
- downandout 10y agoAgain, you completely missed the point. Bill Gates is one man with a certain amount of resources. He chose to go after a huge problem with known solutions: hundreds of millions of poverty-induced, completely preventable, childhood deaths. Climate change may be another worthy cause, but no one has any business criticizing him for not choosing that particular one over saving a massive number of children because they might cause some additional demand for palm oil. Find a billionaire that is doing nothing for the world and criticize them for not doing something about climate change. Bill Gates is busy doing great things for humanity.
- hxta98596 10y agoIt's hard not to be impressed by what the Gates Foundation is doing. I don't think they get the full recognition they deserve sometimes, maybe because much of their work is abroad in the poorest countries in the world. Hard to fathom the number of people out there in the world thankful and who owe their lives to the foundation choosing to help their community or their cause. With that said and not to diminish the good work. It is sad and eye-opening more progress has not been made on these issues. I think when you really look at the numbers, besides seeing the positive trends one can also see how truly difficult, large and complex these problems are. The foundation has $50 Billion dollars! And Bill can get pretty much any world leader or other billionaire CEO to take his phone calls. Yet, sorry that is not enough not even close. The foundation has to focus on very specific issues and even then it hasn't "gotten to zero" where it wants to (though Polio is close, down to 37 cases). Private foundations can only do so much, the scale of these problems really requires the cooperation of governments. I'm not sure what can be done on that or what that means, just a bit breathtaking how governments can help people or really screw things up on a scale nothing else even comes close to.
- saycheese 10y ago>> "the scale of these problems really requires the cooperation of governments" Right, it's my understanding that orginally the Gates foundation tried to do it without working with the governments governing the people they wanted to help, but were unable to make it work.
- robocat 10y agoI wonder how much of this particular philanthropy is just giving back money that those countries spent? I.e. Microsoft licences, or balance of trade with the donor countries? A kind of benevolent taxation?
- brokenmachine 10y agoNo idea if that's true or not, but who cares? It's saving lives. Most billionaires just hoard a few more islands for themselves.
- 10y ago
- cs702 10y agoTo Bill and Melinda Gates: It was really uplifting to read this post. Because of it, the world now looks a little brighter to me. We're all surrounded by alarmist news every day and often lose sight of the big picture. PLEASE write a post like this one at least once a year :-)
- antongribok 10y agoNot exactly the same, but they've done similar posts the last two years: https://www.gatesnotes.com/2016-Annual-Letter https://www.gatesnotes.com/2016-Annual-Letter https://www.gatesnotes.com/2015-Annual-Letter https://www.gatesnotes.com/2015-Annual-Letter Also, the annual reports are quite interesting as well: http://www.gatesfoundation.org/Who-We-Are/Resources-and-Media/Annual-Reports http://www.gatesfoundation.org/Who-We-Are/Resources-and-Medi...
- wyc 10y agoI truly applaud the efforts of the funds. I don't think I could come up with any more noble endeavor, and I know there are some very capable people throughout their organizations who are dedicated to spending the funds wisely and impactfully. However, is it fair to credit philanthropy as the sole cause of quality of life improvements across the most destitute populations? It's a story about the stunning gains the poorest people in the world have made over the last 25 years. This incredible progress has been made possible not only by the generosity of Warren and other philanthropists, the charitable giving of individuals across the world, and the efforts of the poor on their own behalf, but also by the huge contributions made by donor nations, which account for the vast majority of global health and development funding. I think there is a fair amount of evidence that suggests development funding can have as much disastrous consequence as good. In his book The Great Escape[1], Angus Deaton (Nobel Prize economist) describes how non-interventionist economic development seems to have been the main driver of better outcomes across the world, and not the flush pockets of westerners, as convenient as that would be. Another book called The Road To Hell[2] provides many examples where large charitable efforts regularly produce even worse outcomes than no intervention at all. Is there some good evidence to suggest that the money spent by the Gates Foundation and other charities were solely responsible for the improved qualities of life across whole populations? If you want to posit that their efforts have been invaluable in improving access to medical services across the globe, you'll get no argument from me. However, that's a small part of what makes up "stunning gains." [1] https://www.amazon.com/Great-Escape-Health-Origins-Inequality/dp/0691165629 https://www.amazon.com/Great-Escape-Health-Origins-Inequalit... [2] https://www.amazon.com/Road-Hell-Michael-Maren/dp/0743227867 https://www.amazon.com/Road-Hell-Michael-Maren/dp/0743227867
- pvg 10y agoEven the quote you've pulled doesn't claim the outcomes are due solely to the efforts of charities. The Gates foundation has a strong focus on health issues (just about everything listed in the report, for instance) and not the sort of aid the books you mention are criticizing.
- justinph 10y agoGhostery identifies 10 trackers and uBlock shows 7 advertising scripts, which seems like a lot for a page that you'd think shouldn't need advertising. The page doesn't even display if you block some of these scripts. This is terrible.
- matart 10y agoIt looks to contain a lot of logic about what is shown when it is shared on Twitter, Facebook, etc. I think all the images use this logic.
- johnpowell 10y agoI get this... http://imgur.com/a/y7nmQ http://imgur.com/a/y7nmQ
- aembleton 10y agoYep, I just unblocked the whole site in uBlock. There is tracking but no annoying adverts that I would want to block so I just let it through.
- joosters 10y agoFirefox's 'Reader View' makes it readable.
- giarc 10y agoFor anyone interested in why polio hasn't been eradicated, it is likely related to the capture of Osama Bin Laden. https://www.theguardian.com/world/2011/jul/11/cia-fake-vaccinations-osama-bin-ladens-dna https://www.theguardian.com/world/2011/jul/11/cia-fake-vacci...
- jeron 10y agoI highly doubt this is truly the reason
- mattnumbe 10y ago"Over the weekend, relations were pummelled further when the US announced that it would cut $800m (£500m) worth of military aid as punishment for Pakistan's perceived lack of co-operation in the anti-terror fight." It might not be THE reason, but I guess there would be less than the [1]20 cases of polio that there are now in Pakistan if that $800m hadn't been cut. [1] http://www.endpolio.com.pk/polio-cases-district-wise-2016 http://www.endpolio.com.pk/polio-cases-district-wise-2016
- blandry 10y agoIt is not the sole reason. But I spoke with a Gates Foundation employee after this happened and it was directly effecting their ability to safely send out vaccinators. So it played a part in the persistence of polio in Pakistan.
- giarc 10y agoCare to elaborate?
- elastic_church 10y agonot likely related at all, but interesting story!
- giarc 10y agoHow is it not related? Polio was on the brink of eradication with the last strongholds in Pakistan... CIA spooks Pakistanis into thinking vaccinations are not good...Citizens refuse Rotary polio vaccines... polio remains present in Pakistan.
- WalterBright 10y agoThank you, Bill, Melinda and Warren.
- perseusprime11 10y ago"All lives have equal value" I hope one day all governments across the world operate with this principle. Gates foundation is doing some amazing work. Looking forward to their contribution in the coming years.
- Retra 10y agoThat's only true if you ignore the practicalities and only speak of life in the abstract. Some people, through their deplorable deeds, have made their own lives distinctly less valuable.
- woodandsteel 10y agoYou know, we get a fair number of commenters here at HN who are cynical about the world, who say everyone with any power is corrupt, things are getting worse, and there is nothing you can do about it. Whenever someone like that shows up, perhaps we can refer them to this letter.
- mvp 10y agoI doubt that'll work. Once we develop a cynical view of the world, it's quite easy to see the negative side of everything. Just for example, take the biggest benefit claimed in the letter of 122 million children saved. It seems to suggest that it's because of their work. Has nobody else anywhere , including those in the affected countries done anything to save the children. Why do they or anybody think that all of this can be attributed to to the Gates foundation!! Moreover as the Gates foundation is focussing on childrens' lives, does it make any sense for anybody with lesser resources than them to tackle this problem? There is no chance of getting any recognition, as Gates foundation will claim it and it will be hard to argue against as well. These are not my views, I'm just saying that it's possible to have these thoughts if you are cynical.
- agilo 10y agoTo your first point, if a cynic prefers to credit more than a single foundation or individual for those gains, then that must be so benevolent of them to think so well of a greater number of people. Let us all be cynics then.
- skybrian 10y agoNot your views but I'll respond anyway: You can look at GiveWell's recommendations which do take into account room for more funding. Apparently since vaccines seem to be fully funded, their top charity is bed nets to prevent malaria. (Also, fame isn't the only or even the best reason to donate to charity.)
- sfblah 10y agoRich people circle jerk. Yes I'm impressed but still.
- wallace_f 10y agoIt is an envious position to be in where you can positively impact such an incomprehensible number of human lives in the best of ways. It's incredibly heart warming how many people have been saved by the Gates Foundation. Although, the realist in me worries about the possibility that in the long-run, civil liberties and human rights are also of importance to humanity in saving human lives, and human dignity. Without going into an argument about the relative importance, shouldn't at least some significant portion be distributed towards solving the human and civil rights, liberties, and justice abuses here in America? After all, the reason Bill Gates and Buffet are in a position to be able to help so many people is due the world they grew up in. The opportunities they were given. A large part of that is individual human liberty. Had Gates lived in another time, and been arbitrarily detained during one of his two arrests for refusing to unlock his electronic devices, would he have encountered a legal battle that derailed his entrepreneurship? If he was a minority, would the police had treated him the same way? If he was abused by the police the way Ian Murdock allegedly was, what would have happened to Gates? Would we have lost the opportunity to save 122 million lives to date through the Gates foundation?
- cleansy 10y ago> Without going into an argument about the relative importance, shouldn't at least some significant portion be distributed towards solving the human and civil rights, liberties, and justice abuses here in America? I would guess that a country with stable institutions, high GDP per capita value, democracy and the highest absolute military spending this issue could be addressed in the ballot box. In the richest democracies on earth fixing these issues is a question of resource allocation. And plenty of organizations are working towards that already.
- wallace_f 10y ago> this issue could be addressed in the ballot box I don't believe that is true. Recent history is especially illustrative of this.
- idiot_stick 10y ago
- FuNe 10y agoInteresting read: http://web.archive.org/web/20130912101039/http://www.commondreams.org/views06/0823-26.htm http://web.archive.org/web/20130912101039/http://www.commond...
- hans0l074 10y agoI was wondering today after reading this - what are the statistics on the next stages of the lives of these children? Saving their lives is, undoubtedly, the most important thing anyone can do. I think it's also important to see that they continue to have good lives well into adulthood (perhaps even learning about the frameworks that helped them survive as a baby?). In countries like India (where I'm originally from), child mortality rates have improved, but there seems to be this gravity well made of a mixture of superstition, religion, illiteracy, caste-based nonsense that is difficult to escape from. And this does not help translate this victory into winning the long-term war on poverty.
- OliverJones 10y agoYou don't need a Gates- or Buffett- sized pot of money to make a difference. Sure, they can, and do, place massive orders at vaccine factories to get economies of scale. That's how a dose of the pentavalent vaccine comes to cost about the same as the CD that Windows used to arrive on. You probably can't place a US$50M order at a pharma company. But that's OK. You can find a local NGO or charity that promotes, I dunno, literacy or first-generation college students or refugee settlement, or something. What matters is that they do a good job and you're interested in their mission. You can commit to supporting them with a regular cash gift. That kind of regular gift lets a charity plan their work. (One-off gifts are good too, but they don't have the planning benefit.) But be careful: they may want you on their board of directors. :-)
- derefr 10y agoGiving money to any charity is potentially better for the world than giving money to no charity. But part of the premise of this article—and of the Gates Foundation—is that some charitable acts have much higher ROI (in lives saved per dollar, or whatever other metric you might want to measure by) than others, and you should focus on those if you want your money to go furthest in doing good in the world. This approach is usually known as "effective altruism" — there's a whole part of the blogosphere hanging off that keyword. But conveniently, I can just link to http://www.givewell.org/charities/top-charities http://www.givewell.org/charities/top-charities — this is a (very well-researched) consensus list on which charities turn "dollars contributed" into "good done in the world" most effectively. Reasonably, the entries on GiveWell's list match pretty well with the strategy of the Gates foundation (i.e. vaccines et al.) The differences in the Gates Foundation's strategy mostly come down to the fact that economies of scale for solutions work out differently when you have millions vs. billions of dollars. Of course, you're allowed to disagree with the ranking criteria the EA people use—maybe the global number of "quality-adjusted life-years" people get to live isn't the #1 thing you care about optimizing. But even if you disagree about the particular charities, EA—and the parent post—still have an important point you should understand: no matter the charity, contributing money is almost always higher-ROI than volunteering. (It might feel "lazy", but it's the principle of comparative advantage: the person a charity could hire for the money you can earn in time X at your job, will almost certainly do more good for them than you'd do by volunteering X hours of your own time.) And that "get the highest ROI for my charity dollar" mindset is what's important, no matter what you're measuring ROI in terms of.
- gadders 10y agoI see a lots of charts saying things are improving, which is great, but unless I missed it I can't see the piece that says "We spent $xxx on initiative YYY which caused this improvement."
- allworknoplay 10y agoYeah, nobody here appears to have paid attention, but in this piece Gates fails to differentiate things the foundation has actually done from all the major international public health accomplishments of the last 25 or so years -- it's pretty out there when you think about it. The most specific claims made were about the foundation's participation in groups addressing two of the issues.
- gtallen1187 10y agoThis is amazing. Thank you Bill, Melinda, and Warren.
- erikpukinskis 10y agoI appreciate these efforts, but my mind is drawn to a somewhat orthogonal set of tactics. When I see stats like $1 of vaccines releasing $44 of economic value, I think: there is a market opportunity here. The question I keep asking is: what would a hedge fund look like that was making a bet that most people in poverty could produce the $44 if we invested the $1? What kind of corporate structure would be needed to distribute the resource AND reap part of the economic value? Similar hedges can be made everywhere. If I believe black people are worth more than their social status (and commensurate credit access) would suggest.... how do I make that bet with cash? You can answer "microfinance" but that's just phrasing the question in a different way. The real issue is: how, exactly? It's not an easy question to answer, but I think unlocking it is a trillion dollar opportunity. You are essentially betting against the entire class of employers. Seems stupid, but so did Michael Burry's bet against the entire class of mortgage lenders.
- imaginenore 10y agoIt's not like there's a simple way to invest $1 and extract $44. That $44 is diluted in the total GDP. There's also a quite low limit on how many people you can vaccinate, even if you offer it for free. This kind of thing is quite profitable for the government though, because they get to collect that $44, even if it is diluted.
- erikpukinskis 10y agoI don't need a simple way, I just need a way. The way I am currently pursuing it is basically to build an agency (like a Hollywood agency) for people in poverty and use automation to get economies of scale so it can survive on many slices of small payouts. It's not simple, but it's the only thing I can think of. Arguably TaskRabbit and Uber are a version of this, but they target poor working class people, not those in actual poverty. Would be interested to hear other ideas. I don't expect any of them to be simple.