12 ms·
'The Great Shame of Our Profession'
- anigbrowl 10y agoWhen I read articles like this, what i don't understand is why the brilliant minds in the various different departments that are actually experts in their domains don't get together and come up with a scheme to oust the administrators. How can you educate students to go out and change the world if you can't even fix your own institution? What exactly is stopping faculty from going on strike or figuring out a way to subvert the power structures which everyone can see to be damaging tot he university's mission?
- nickff 10y agoThe university's stated mission may have something to do with learning or teaching or research, but most universities are run by bureaucrats with the actual mission of continued existence and expansion, like every other expansive government-funded institution. Professors, lecturers, and researchers are expendable tools for the administration, so they have no real power to 'rise up'.
- drewrv 10y ago> most universities are run by bureaucrats with the actual mission of continued existence and expansion Existence is a prerequisite for all learning/teaching/research, and expansion is implied in these goals too. Unless their stated goal is to further knowledge, but not too much! I'm skeptical that shady administrators actually don't care about the goals of their organization and have ulterior motives. What seems more likely is that universities are like any other large organization. Most people involved want to do a good job, but only a few are truly passionate about success. Fewer still know exactly what needs to happen for success and are able to rally others to fulfill their vision.
- BuckRogers 10y agoYou may as well ask why doesn't a genius out there topple the Trump administration or why did no one topple Stalin? It's unclear that power structures are so vulnerable to even the best-laid plans.
- jerf 10y agoYou're allowed to set up a new University or place of learning/teaching. You aren't allowed (to a first approximation) to set up a different fully-sovereign government.
- xyzzy4 10y agoYou're also allowed to own 100 Lamborghinis, but that doesn't make it feasible for most people.
- jerf 10y agoYou can get together with a few people and some investors and start a new place of learning that may someday become a university. You can't get together with a few friends and start a new government without a lot more hassle than that. The metaphor is unsalvagable.
- BuckRogers 10y agoOnly in your mind. The only difference is one is more difficult than another. It doesn't matter what you're "allowed" to do or not, the point is about any power structure exerting its will strip you of any ability to meaningfully oppose it.
- jerf 10y ago"the point is about any power structure exerting its will strip you of any ability to meaningfully oppose it." Yes, but you can leave non-governmental power structures; the power of the Foot Veto is huge. By your logic, no new companies ever form because existing companies will strip you of your power to form them. Your logic predicts a society a great deal less flexible than the one we actually live in. The metaphor is unsalvageable. I suggest to you that it may be worth your time to meditate on this a bit more for your own health, which I mean fully literally. Your worldview quite easily leads to an excessively fatalistic feeling of a lack of control, which is a major factor in depression. Escaping non-governmental power structures may not be easy, but what worth doing in life is? It is well within the domain of possible.
- gydfi 10y agoThe actual professors have already got theirs, so screw everyone else. And the adjuncts don't have any power and are easily replaced. Also everybody knows that if the university administrators actually got replaced by sensible rational people then the English department might not exist any more anyway so they're all living on borrowed time.
- jerf 10y agoWhat if the adjunct professors are making something rather closer to the market rate than the high-paying jobs they're eyeing? There's an oversupply in a lot of these fields. The universities pay these terrible wages precisely because they can. Yeah, it's mind-blowingly hypocritical of the Universities to pay market rates when it suits them (but don't you dare do it; the University administrators have only the most educated rationalization skills unlike the rest of you hoi polloi), but it still suggests that the market rate probably is that low. If that's the case, starting your own learning program, even ignoring the question of how to get people to use it, may not actually provide a living wage without a lot more clever work. You're probably not going to be able to do it just by setting up competing classrooms, you're probably looking at something that looks a lot more like an edutech startup than a university. Which is great if you can pull it off, but an adjunct professor of the humanities is statistically missing almost every skill necessary to do that.
- anigbrowl 10y agoAn astute analysis - depressing but hard to disagree with.
- mathattack 10y agoThe universities are effectively run by the tenured faculty members. As long as they produce more labor than they need, they can hire scabs if teachers go on strike. The real question is why so many bright minds want to go into this to begin with.
- wfo 10y agoNo, universities are run by boards of directors like every corporation and a president/CEO. Tenured faculty has some vote (but NEVER a controlling or even large vote, they often have to fight to be included at all in serious decisions). It's top-down business decisions by investors and the CEO, who tell the deans/provosts/chairs/faculty/adjuncts, all the way down the totem pole to the grad students, "oh we'd like to pay you decently and hire enough workers, we really would, but the market simply can't bear it, we don't have the funds, I'm so sorry. We're on the same side here, really, it's just the practicalities of the situation. You wouldn't understand, it's business, and you're an expert in Art/English/Engineering/Chemistry which I totally respect, but you just wouldn't get it so just trust me. I'm one of you. Oh, and by the way your faculty parking lot is being redistricted into stadium parking, and since you aren't an administrator you'll have to purchase a special faculty pass (half off!) that isn't valid on game day. You can take the bus on game day, you like that kind of stuff, you're a liberal, right?" I think nearly unconditional tenure is kind of untenable. There is so much dead weight in any academic department and it's so easy to see. Ask any grad student which professors don't do research or take students and teach like absolute trash. There are always plenty. Usually old, taking up the few slots available for bright young PhDs. But we could also make more slots. There's nothing wrong with being a teaching professor, lots of people love it and they love it so much it doesn't need to pay well, just decently, and how about tenure-ish-track teaching only instead of shunting teachers off into second class citizens who can be fired if some students drop their class the day before? There's plenty of room to expand if that was the goal. But it isn't. Cuts are made where they can be made. It isn't really a market, quality of education isn't really the measured output of paying tuition so the market will NEVER select for what we think of as 'good', but the institutions are being run as if they are operating in a market instead of a public service, which is THE central neoliberal fallacy whose implementation has been as disastrous in education as it has been in any public service which is not a real market (eg healthcare)
- jdhopeunique 10y agoThe administrators are often former or current faculty. In articles and discussions similar to this there is often this conflict portrayed between faculty and administration but the reality is that they are often the same people. If not from the same institution, then from another institution. Universities sometimes require or encourage support staff to have higher ed. degrees. Computer tech support positions may require a bachelors degree. Career counseling or academic advising may require a masters. Faculty encourage students to get graduate degrees at the universities they(the faculty member) got their graduate degree from. Politicians and alumni get favors for their families. Universities are practically influence and nepotism laundering machines. Faculty are simply part of the power structure, each trying to improve their position within. Grad school practically selects for individuals who are invested in the institution and will not rock the boat.
- maverick_iceman 10y ago>The administrators are often former or current faculty. That used to be true but not anymore. A lot of the administrative stuff these days are career administrators.
- BeetleB 10y agoVarious points: 1. Don't assume these are "brilliant" minds. It takes a certain type of mindset to become a college professor. Do not equate this with brilliance. 2. You're not listing a solution. Ousting the administrators won't solve anything in and of itself. They will be replaced by some other administrators (perhaps of your liking). But what actually is the solution? The realities they have to deal with won't change: Money has to come from somewhere. 3. Some of the author's complaints don't strike me as being a fundamental problem. As an example, it's not obvious why the publishing companies behave the way he would like them to. He's acting as if they have a responsibility towards people like him. Why? 4. Agree with the problem of too many administrators and too many adjuncts and teaching getting the shaft. But don't trust numbers too blindly. As an example, a local university showed their numbers. Since 1980, funding per student from outside (state/federal, etc) dropped a huge amount. Almost all of the tuition increases accounted for it. Overall funding for instruction per student did not drop at all - just the manner in which they obtained it. All the sports stuff was "extra". 5. The latest generation of faculty members - especially in disciplines like engineering - do not share this mindset. It's not at all unusual for me to hear a young engineering faculty member talk about the waste that are the humanities. I suppose primarily it's because the pressure for funding is huge on engineering faculty members, so they are predisposed to viewing everything as a fixed pie, and the less that goes to humanities, the more for them. 6. As several have pointed out, teaching is not something most faculty members today are hired for (especially in STEM). This is a problem from within - not something imposed by administrators. 7. As someone who spent time in academia, faculty members are focused on being individualistic and trying to stand apart from their peers. You cannot expect them to "get together" to oppose these changes. They have trouble getting together for pretty much anything. Don't let multi-author collaborations fools you.
- anigbrowl 10y agoThanks for this very comprehensive reply. 1. I'm trying to be positive :) 2. I should have gone into more detail on that, but the solution I had in mind was not so much a specific policy as a putting-forth of basic principles which they wanted to see administration recentered around. 3. True enough. 4. I know it's more complex than it looks at first glance. Administration increasingly requires compliance with many state and federal regulations which costs money, and likewise sports teams bring in cash from nostalgic alumni, and indirectly subsidize other things. 5. This goes to the heart of what I'm talking about. I find myself wanting to arrange blind dates between members of the engineering, humanities, and economics faculties to figure out ways they could be supporting rather than competing with each other. 6. for sure, and I hope that changes. 7. Clearly I'm leaning too much on a vision of the university as a calling and not enough on its reality as a cut-throat research marketplace. Thanks again for this in-depth exploration of the issues. I'll keep it in mind on my future reading.
- rhizome 10y agoSounds a little like "shit's easy syndrome": http://steve-yegge.blogspot.com/2009/04/have-you-ever-legalized-marijuana.html http://steve-yegge.blogspot.com/2009/04/have-you-ever-legali...
- maverick_iceman 10y agoThe tenured faculty has no incentive to go on a strike/subvert the power structure. They are very much beneficiaries of the system.
- jankotek 10y agoI think great shame is that many educators lie about future career prospects in their profession. It is like pyramid scheme; only way to make living is to teach at university, and create more educators.
- spott 10y agoI think the great shame is that many educators don't know about future career prospects in their profession.
- everyone 10y agoImo that article is written in an overwrought, unclear, and bloated fashion. Though I guess thats what the author has been trained to do.
- shaftoe 10y agoI stopped reading after paragraph 5 when I realized he was nowhere near making the point alluded to in the title.
- crystalmeph 10y agoThe first two paragraphs were incomprehensible to this computer science graduate. Something about literature reflecting society reflecting literature? But the actual thrust of the article - that English departments are intentionally turning out more graduates than the job market, which consists almost entirely of the exact same English departments, can absorb - was clear enough.
- xaa 10y agoMany interesting points here, but the most striking to me is how this is yet another industry that is socializing their costs by paying employees so little that they have to get food stamps, hiring people part-time so you don't have to pay benefits, etc. I guess you sort of expect that from Wal-Mart, but a university? It is true that supply exceeds demand for PhDs, especially in humanities, and prospective PhDs should be aware of this, but I can't really see any excuse for this behavior by universities. It's bad for the taxpayer, bad for the employee, and bad for the students. Only one it's good for is the administrator, who can pocket a bonus for cutting costs. The government shouldn't stand for this, IMO. I think this would be a good way to frame an argument for a minimum wage in such a way it would appeal to a conservative. "Businesses: you must pay employees enough so they aren't eligible for (most forms of) public assistance." As the link points out, faculty are complicit too by taking on unsustainable numbers of grad students out of pure self-interest.
- humanrebar 10y ago> I think this would be a good way to frame an argument for a minimum wage in such a way it would appeal to a conservative. "Businesses: you must pay employees enough so they aren't eligible for (most forms of) public assistance." Is it better to not pay them at all? If the problem is that people can't afford their bills, the solution is to help them afford their bills (minimum income, negative income tax, cash welfare, etc.), not to distort labor markets. We need to make sure that there is modest marginal cost to employment or else people will have limited ability to retrain or otherwise break into new labor markets.
- VLM 10y agoYes its better not to pay them at all because it sends a strong economic signal of "go do something else you're not wanted here". Far better they get a new career and become net sources of tax money rather than net sinks. At the macro level you have a totally different problem if there's 320 million people and only 90 million jobs, well... There is no logical reason retraining or breaking into a market naturally requires receipt of food stamps. If there were a healthy demand, pay would be healthy.
- 6stringmerc 10y agoHere's all you need to know about the greatest shame in Academia: >According to the most recent MLA jobs report, there were only 361 assistant professor tenure-track job openings in all fields of English literature in 2014-15. The number of Ph.D. recipients in English that year was 1,183. Many rejected candidates return to the job market year after year and compound the surplus. Now, this begs a much deeper, more heady discussion regarding priorities and values within the US Higher Education system. The question to consider is Does this out-of-whack-ratio mean we have too many English graduates or not enough English jobs? And - while you'd probably knee jerk to the former rather than the latter, I think I could make a compelling case to disagree. It's not that it's wrong to pursue a lifetime in English or Music, it's just very tough to realize that as a nation, the US has its priorities terribly fucked up and refuses to support even a decent standard of living and healthcare for those who would devote their lives to such pursuits. This should be in bold text on every student loan application in the Liberal Arts, and perhaps others as well. We don't need room after room of high minded PhDs talking Milton, but we do need PhDs to be taxpayers, and there are plenty of immigrants year after year that if English was a priority, it would get funding and infrastructure to support both the Educators and Students. Which, as we can see, isn't the case for now.
- xaa 10y agoI'm a grad student, so I'm sympathetic to these arguments, trust me. But I simply think there's no way around the fact that if you double the positions, you'll (at least) double the number of graduates. Assuming the faculty:grad-student ratio remains constant. It should be kept in mind that there are other jobs for PhD besides faculty. (Although I don't know about English; maybe editor, etc?) I have mostly made my peace with the fact that by going into academia you are trading money for some intangibles, like doing what you enjoy, flexible hours, etc. Anyone who gets a PhD without knowing the risks is...not very smart. I work in medical research. Trust me, it's not pleasant that total government spending on medical research for a year amounts to the cost of a few dozen bombers. Or that the Iraq War's cost could have funded all our research spending for something like 50 years. But at this point, pointing out how our societal decisions are irrational is like pointing out the sky is blue.
- azernik 10y ago
- hackuser 10y agoFWIW, adjunct professors I know have been corroborating this for awhile. Also note that conservative politicians in the U.S. are increasingly applying ideological pressure on academic research, and also as government budgets are cut, more is funded by private interests looking for particular results. Adjuncts have little power to protect themselves and the integrity of their work. Finally, looking at the political situation in much of the developed world, you wouldn't be surprised by the fact that the study of the humanities (and social sciences) has declined; perhaps we need to invest more in it.
- k5329 10y ago>Also note that conservative politicians in the U.S. are increasingly applying ideological pressure on academic research Conservatives didn't politicize the academy alone. Studies[0] have shown left-wing professors will openly admit to discriminating against conservative peers and students. From the abstract I quote: "In decisions ranging from paper reviews to hiring, many social and personality psychologists said that they would discriminate against openly conservative colleagues. The more liberal respondents were, the more they said they would discriminate." Other studies[1] have confirmed that there is an incredible lack of political diversity in certain university departments and that it's likely caused by outright discrimination. "This article reviews the available evidence and finds support for four claims: (1) Academic psychology once had considerable political diversity, but has lost nearly all of it in the last 50 years. (2) This lack of political diversity can undermine the validity of social psychological science via mechanisms such as the embedding of liberal values into research questions and methods, steering researchers away from important but politically unpalatable research topics, and producing conclusions that mischaracterize liberals and conservatives alike. (3) Increased political diversity would improve social psychological science by reducing the impact of bias mechanisms such as confirmation bias, and by empowering dissenting minorities to improve the quality of the majority’s thinking. (4)" Given that these university departments are overtly discriminating based on political affiliation, is it any surprise to see funding for these university departments being politicized? Sorry, if you're discriminating based on political affiliation, you're not doing science, you're doing activism. [0]: http://yoelinbar.net/papers/political_diversity.pdf http://yoelinbar.net/papers/political_diversity.pdf [1]: http://heterodoxacademy.org/2015/09/14/bbs-paper-on-lack-of-political-diversity/ http://heterodoxacademy.org/2015/09/14/bbs-paper-on-lack-of-...
- Animats 10y agoJournalism used to be a second source for jobs for English majors, but that's dried up.
- primelens 10y agoI'll repost what I wrote on a previous discussion of this article on FB: Most versions of this discussion lament the fact that students come into graduate programs with little idea of what the academic job market is like. One could respond - and many do - that it's a "free market," no one is forcing them to choose this profession over any other. However, this rational-actor reasoning can only be expected to work if effective channels were set up to inform students before they've sunk in too much time, and cost (both in terms of money and lost opportunities). Do such channels exist? While I agree that the responsibility largely lies with faculty, there are few incentives in the system for them to lower the number of PhDs. And any system that depends on the uprightness, or clarity of vision of individuals (even liberal humanities professors) is bound to be leaky at best. While this essay puts some numbers to the problem - approximately 1 job for every 4 PhDs per year, for example - I think this is one domain where more data and analysis could serve as a wake-up call. Those 1 in 4 odds, I'm sure, are far from evenly distributed. They are heavily skewed towards a handful of elite institutions. Go to school elsewhere and the odds stack up much higher. Consider the applicants who graduated in previous years but have remained in the market and the odds are even more daunting, and made worse during job shortfalls like that after the '08 downturn. If informing graduate students of the magnitude of the challenge they are taking on is the best approach to the problem, then the profession needs to do better than trust this to individuals and institutions who have no incentive to scare away a large portion of their students. Does a dataset exist that makes this information accessible? I'd expect some resistance from departments to share detailed information, but the MLA should have enough information from their member surveys. When grad students send in their first $23 check to the MLA, perhaps they should receive a dossier with employment data for the last 10 years and a few choice graphs to scare the living daylights out of them!
- woodandsteel 10y agoMy understanding is that this problem is in part due to the huge boom in higher education after WWII. Departments got into a growth mode where they produced more ph.d.'s than were needed to replace the present generation of college professors. When the grow came to an end in the 1960's, they should have cut way back on graduate students, but they didn't, and so we now have a great surplus of would-be professors as compared to the number of available slots.
- Balgair 10y agoVery good paragraph here: >The truth is that teaching is a diminishing priority in universities. Years of AAUP reports indicate that budgets for instruction are proportionally shrinking. Universities now devote less than one-third of their expenditures to instruction. Meanwhile, administrative positions have increased at more than 10 times the rate of tenured faculty positions. Sports and amenities are much more fun. The author alludes to sports and nice dorm rooms as the place where the money goes, but is that true? Do they really take up all of the slack that was once the use for instruction? That can't be right. There has to be a lot more corruption than that these days. Still, if the University really has become High School 2.0, then this makes sense in a way. But the real question we then have to ask is what happens then to the MA/S? Is that then the new BA/S? I have been told so by many hiring managers that it is the case. Follow the logic here, that then means the PhD is the new MA/S. Perhaps these students are smarter than the author lets on.
- apozem 10y agoSports and luxuries for students have absolutely become the focus of universities. It's hard to sell an ethereal "better education." It's easy to show off your new athletic dorms and massive scoreboard. I know that's absurd, but that's how administrators seem to think. http://www.usatoday.com/story/news/nation/2013/09/15/athletics-cost-colleges-students-millions/2814455/ http://www.usatoday.com/story/news/nation/2013/09/15/athleti... http://www.washingtonpost.com/sf/sports/wp/2015/11/23/running-up-the-bills/ http://www.washingtonpost.com/sf/sports/wp/2015/11/23/runnin...
- slackstation 10y agoThis is what happens to a market when the person paying for it and person receiving the service are seperated. It can be generational (parents pay for kids education) or time (a person buys something at 20 that they will pay off at 45). I also think that the prestige of a degree combined with less and less real world application of that degree has something to do it with. I think that the market value for certain degrees is falling below the market price for said degrees and what you are hearing is people complaining loudly. I think if there really was a serious market for pure academics and high value, quality degrees someone would be tapping that market already. There is plenty of expertise, plenty of study in the subject and plenty of players would would be ready to provide that service. I think far, far too many people look at college as a four year luxury party with a side of academics rather than the other way around. People going to college today seem like the most privileged demanding consumers. The new source of costs in colleges which eclipses academics today is services that didn't exist 20 years ago. It's gone way beyond merely housing and a few health services. Colleges are giving students what they want and what they want is scoreboards not lower student-to-professor ratios or cutting edge research. People have always wanted more cake and circus. College is just as consumer driven in this culture as anything else.
- patmcguire 10y agoIt'll be interesting to see what happens when the tenured start dying off en masse. They're not going to replace everyone with tenured faculty — what is the university going to look like if almost no one has tenure?
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- scythe 10y agoThis will be fixed when there is a suitable economic signal, which can accurately be used by the customers of universities in order to estimate the quality of instruction at a university. If this sounds like a ranking, let me remind you that the rankings have been destroyed by Goodhart's law for decades now. Markets depend on some level at consumers who know what they're buying; if all of the consumers are blindfolded, firms will sell them pieces of paper. If a university can attract students by investing in its instructors, it will do so. Currently they can't.
- slackstation 10y agoWhy do we treat people with PHDs as idiots who in their 10 years of collegate level study don't ever think about their debt, their job prospects or their lives as they do it. Do you think that grad students don't read articles like this? Do they understand points that author laid out? If they do as a group stop applying for PHD programs knowing that their job prospects are abysmal? If so, why don't more people either a) cut their losses or b) not pursue a PHD in a wholly oversaturated market? The exploitation argument works if you have completely illiterate and uninformed workers who work on the promise of advancement or pay that never comes. This doesn't hold water for professionals who literally spend every day working with the people they are trying to become. The question then begs why do all of these intelligent, well educated people go through such great hardship, knowing full well the level of poverty involved. Every grad student I've ever known has joked about how poor they will be, how little they get paid, how miserable they will be on the other side. Here's a radical idea; intelligent people are choosing this hard life because they value something in it more than the hardship they are going through to get it. Now, you may disagree that the hardship is more than what they will get in return. You may also make the point that by definition, most of them won't even have the opportunity to achieve their goals. You may even make the point that colleges don't prioritize academics. I would agree with you on those points, especially the last one. What's clear though is that they are people making this decision deliberately. College isn't the kind of thing where you just fall into like some academic gulag. At every step of the way, people applied, got loans or secured financing, moved across the country and put in hard work to achieve. All of this to say that somehow they were tricked by the "system" that's against them and is out to exploit them and their labor? Now people are saying that colleges and society needs to put out a helping hand to all of these poor souls who find themselves in a position after a decade of deliberate decisions. If people put more support for this and made English PHDs more sustainable, I predict that you would see ever more PHDs and even more people trying to get into the field. The problem lies in the fact that some people will make irrational decisions. Some things cost more (in money) than will give out (in money). Some people will get caught up in their love of books and academia and pursue a degree for the joy of literature but, then complain that a decade or professional reading and writing has yielded a mountain of loans and little else as prospects in the job market. It may even be that well meaning but, nefarious English professors are inspiring students to fall in love with Literature and teaching and speaking and this infatuation is causing a glut in the job market. I would be more sympathetic if it weren't for the fact that this is a decade long process and you are doing in the very environment you are trying to enter. It'd be one thing if it took a decade to become an astronaut on Mars and we had a professional industry for training astronauts that lied or hid the fact that there aren't astronaut jobs available. But, people see struggling grad students for four years in undergrad, and spend a decade being a struggling grad student. All the while pressing on. I have no sympathy for smart people making dumb decisions all the while studying books. The loud suffering of people who have made bad decisions is an important vital thing to listen to. Allow people to keep making these decisions. Post this article and send it to every current and prospective grad student. Let them know that the road to a PHD is paved in suffering and misery (as if they don't already know). Watch how few of them actually change their minds and alter their course. They are adults and are making decisions for their own lives inside dynamic systems that will work against their favor. I don't want to impose artificial limitations on the freedoms of a system because so many people make irrational (by my perspective) decisions for their own lives knowing full and well the consequences.
- michaelmrose 10y agoThe genesis of the current stupidity is that the government is willing to lend tens to hundreds of thousands of dollars for people to learn about literature regardless of whether there is any market whatsoever that would justify the expenditure. The managerial/administrative class sucks up as much of this wealth as it can for itself and like minded individuals while burning lots of it in conspicuous displays of wealth like football stadiums designed to attract more interest/wealth some of which will stick to their hands. This waste is probably nowhere more apparent than in areas of study which require so little special equipment and expenditure like literature. The single most valuable resource, a library, is available for free to most, next up is the teachers time which costs only a small fraction of what the student is paying. When basically students are paying 20x the actual cost of the teachers time for the credentials to participate in the institutions that only exist because of the easily borrowed money in the first place it seems that this is unsustainable nonsense most easily rectified by cutting off the money supply. In the longer term it will be necessary to implement means by which we can legitimize means to connect teacher to learner without an unnecessary intermediary that takes almost all of the resources. Providing a way to achieve this wouldn't be terribly hard fixing our entire system which depends on credentials from this dysfunctional industry to legitimize employment isn't but cutting off the money is the first step.