11 ms·
65535 interfaces ought to be enough for anybody
- ungzd 10y agoAndroid is worse — it limits number of methods to 65535 (but has hacks to workaround it) https://developer.android.com/studio/build/multidex.html https://developer.android.com/studio/build/multidex.html
- throwawayish 10y agoA coworker mentioned that multidexing also take ages and uses huge amounts of memory.
- d33 10y agoAre there any legitimate use cases for that many methods?
- taormina 10y agoI mean, it means you can't pull in Scala. I mean, you can, but pull in enough bloated Java 3rd party libraries and you might be hitting that limit pretty quickly. Google broke Google Play Services out into a large number of small dependencies once they were past the 15k method mark. Mind you, certain compilation settings will totally strip out unused methods, but it's still annoying.
- kelnos 10y agoIIRC the Facebook app had many more than that at one point, and had to use multi-dexing. Not sure if that's still the case. I've also heard that scala apps on Android can sometimes hit the limit, because pulling in the scala stdlib greatly bloats the method count.
- Exuma 10y agoAd SDK's have tons of methods.
- BoorishBears 10y agoIt sounds like a ridiculous number of methods until you realize just importing Guava brings in 20k methods, using half the Amazon SDKs would probably bring another 20k-40k, Apache's main utils bring about 10-20k, etc.
- jayd16 10y agoFor example, the amazon sdk jar has 40,000 alone or something insane. You can hit if you're using a few large libraries. That said, you can use proguard to strip your unused methods and it usually fine even for large applications.
- ungzd 10y agoBecause of "single responsibility principle" it's better if classes and methods do one thing. That usually leads to lots of small classes and small methods.
- vkou 10y agoJava's crippled generics, lack of tuple support, and lack of default parameters encourage interface bloat in utility libraries. Given how bloody good Java IDEs are (By which I mean to say - how good IntelliJ is), the cognitive cost of this interface bloat is very low... Until you start developing for Android.
- monocasa 10y agoWouldn't Java's crippled generics actually help reduce the method count since due to type erasure they're all the same method at the VM level anyway?
- Matthias247 10y agoFor reference types probably yes, but Java also often needs extra methods or overloads for handling primitive types, which would get unnecessarily boxed when used in generic methods.
- josefx 10y agoOn the one hand yes, on the other hand Java also generates Bridge methods when you implement a generic interface. A MyType implementing Comparable<MyType> will contain a compareTo( MyType ) method and a generated compareTo( Comparable ) bridge method. It is more likely that generated classes, countless getters and setters and a tendency to small methods has a higher impact.
- Benjammer 10y agoWhy do people always talk about multidexing like it's such a nightmare? https://developer.android.com/studio/build/multidex.html https://developer.android.com/studio/build/multidex.html It's really not that bad, It only gets a little squirrely if you're trying to support super old android versions.
- karmelapple 10y agoOur app's build time ballooned by 2-3X or more when we went to multidex. We've had some luck reducing it, but we'd still like to axe multidex. I definitely consider a 3X build time increase (not 30 seconds to 90 seconds, but 1 or 2 min to 5-8) to be a significant problem, bordering on nightmare... especially since we just included a few more libraries that put us past the 65k mark. Is that what other people have seen?
- dgfgfdagasdfgfa 10y agoSurely that's just a release build, though...? How would this bottleneck productivity for a team?
- orbitur 10y agoWhen you deploy release-like builds to your QA team (as you should), a tripled-build time is a bit problematic if you're trying to iterate quickly.
- Benjammer 10y agoWho needs to "iterate" so quickly that several minutes added to your build time becomes a huge issue?
- BoorishBears 10y agoMe? I work on embedded android installations that have over a thousand years combined of running with 0 software crashes. Once I get to a certain point in developing an app for our installations I start profiling for the slightest memory leaks by watching changes in memory usage profiles for different user flows. And I can only do that with release builds if I want useful numbers. I've had us split up apps over build times because of Multidex (for example, most of our AWS centric code lives in a separate app that exposes specific functions via an AIDL interface because the SDK was bringing in too many methods)
- ungzd 10y ago> A short fact about .NET: if you have an interface IFoo<T>, the runtime generates a separate method table per each IFoo<int>, IFoo<double>, IFoo<bool>, and so on. In Java you have to do the same manually: https://docs.oracle.com/javase/8/docs/api/java/util/stream/Stream.html#mapToInt-java.util.function.ToIntFunction- https://docs.oracle.com/javase/8/docs/api/java/util/stream/S... wow such polymorphism much ad-hoc
- Grollicus 10y agoRemember how we laughed about visual basic which supports just 65536 different variable names?
- Beltiras 10y agoAfter yesterdays posting of the list of incorrect assumptions programmers make about the world I put it into my daily web routine to visit the page and read one list per day till done.
- dsacco 10y agoDo you have a link to this? I missed it and would like to read it. EDIT: Think I found it? https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=13640409 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=13640409
- Beltiras 10y agohttps://github.com/kdeldycke/awesome-falsehood https://github.com/kdeldycke/awesome-falsehood
- rdtsc 10y agoThis sounds familiar. Mono worked for me until it didn't. And it would be some corner case like timing and sockes, or HTTP connection issues. By that time we already bought into it and so I was running around opening a huge black box trying to figure out the internals.
- to3m 10y agoAny time you have a 16-bit count, it won't be enough. It's a dangerous size...
- jandrese 10y agoThe same is true of 32 bit numbers. 64 bits might finally be enough. crosses fingers
- paulddraper 10y agoWell, for counts 32 bits is enough, unless you count something really small, like every individual byte in something. And for counts 64 bits should be enough, since it's 20 billion billion.
- to3m 10y agoAssuming you managed to accumulate enough items to fill a 64-bit counter, if you got 1 core of your super-fast PC to increment a 64-bit value for each one, it would take over 100 years to count them all. (Assuming you don't just decide to pop -1 in the counter. Presumably you'd want to make sure you haven't miscounted during the accumulation phase.)
- duskwuff 10y agoFor counts of things you have in memory, 32 bits is usually enough -- even if each thing is just 8 bytes, 2^32 of those objects would require 32 GB.
- JoeAltmaier 10y agoFile this under 'premature optimization bites after 12 years'.
- justifier 10y agoi'd argue the opposite.. i mean, i think you're referring to malloc when you cite premature optimisation, but this seems more of an issue of failing to optimise for the future or generalise beyond the initial needs of the developer
- astrobe_ 10y agoWhy makes you say it is "premature"? Isn't it possible that they hit that limit because the project is a monolithic monster? Or because it uses libraries that waste those resources?
- Florin_Andrei 10y agoIs it still "premature optimization" if it bites after 12 years?
- amelius 10y agoAlso: 65535 tcp-ports ought to be enough for anybody [1] 65534 hardlinks ought to be enough for anybody [2] [1] http://stackoverflow.com/questions/113224/what-is-the-largest-tcp-ip-network-port-number-allowable-for-ipv4 http://stackoverflow.com/questions/113224/what-is-the-larges... [2] http://unix.stackexchange.com/questions/5629/is-there-a-limit-of-hardlinks-for-one-file http://unix.stackexchange.com/questions/5629/is-there-a-limi...
- sixothree 10y agoI find it extremely awkward that we actually use numbers for ports. Port 80 is typically used for HTTP, but there's nothing preventing another application from using port 80. Why not call the port "HTTP" instead. Better yet why not give it an integer range of ports to go along with the naming - Eg MyApp[1], MyApp[2]. If you want to hide a port from being probed then give it a GUID as a name. No more port scans.
- phicoh 10y agoEasy to do with DNS SRV records. Just add: _http._tcp.hostname SRV priority weight port target. and you can use any available port you like. Of course, current TCP has 16-bit ports hard coded. But IPv6 has almost unlimited addresses. For some reason, SRV records are not in wide spread use.
- pixl97 10y ago>For some reason, SRV records are not in wide spread use. No legacy tooling supports it. Poor support on the products already there. Huge numbers of firewalls are hard coded to 80:443 so alternate ports would be blocked. When you make a poor choice on the internet, it lasts forever.
- tangent128 10y agoAt the time TCP/UDP were invented, keeping packet size small was very important. A string or GUID as addressing information would have been out of the question. (If there wasn't a need to distinguish multiple clients on the same machine, we might have only had 255 ports!) A standard port for HTTP servers is needed, as most HTTP clients don't support DNS SRV records. That said, in the IPv6 world there's no technical reason you can't just let every service bind a different IP address.
- antfarm 10y ago16 bits can represent 65536 different values, not 65535.
- StringEpsilon 10y ago0 Interfaces 1 Interface ... 65535 Interfaces
- recursive 10y agoI can't tell if you're joking, but when you're counting a quantity, you don't start from 0.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- YSFEJ4SWJUVU6 10y agoQuantity as in great amount? Either way, sounds like the worst kind of premature optimization to save one bit's worth to lose the ability to ever have the quantity be zero.
- surye 10y agoWhy not? Is having zero interfaces not distinct from having one interface?
- recursive 10y agoIt is. But when you have one interface, that interface can be given the number 0. So you have a total of 1 interface, even though you've only counted up to 0. Edit: I misunderstood. I'll leave the comment up. But I originally interpreted the story as meaning that each interface needed to be assigned an unsigned 16-bit id, which allows for a total of 65536. That was just inference on my part though. It literally says that more than 65535 are not allowed.
- ska 10y ago
- janstenpickle 10y agohttp://www.catb.org/jargon/html/Z/Zero-One-Infinity-Rule.html http://www.catb.org/jargon/html/Z/Zero-One-Infinity-Rule.htm...
- tonyg 10y agoIt's almost as if programming languages should support integers, rather than just machine words. Or, put differently: Fixed-Width "Integers" Usually Harmful.