8 ms·
Researchers have found more evidence that butter is heart-healthy
- amalag 10y agoIf they want to research they should research cultured butter. It was the traditional way to make butter. The culturing of the milk into yoghurt does change it.
- DougN7 10y agoFirst salt, and now butter? How long until we find out sugar is a super food?
- crusso 10y agoSugar was the default super food for decades as a result of the 70's and 80's push to lower dietary fat. It's only been recently that the medical community has realized that sugar is actually the number one hidden danger in the modern diet.
- ktRolster 10y agoIn the 70s people were pushing "low-glycemic index" diets. That precludes sugar.
- e40 10y agoDifferent people that were pushing high carbs, though.
- gozur88 10y agoI remember all the talk about "carb loading" for athletes and how many people decided "If atheletes do it, I should do it too."
- crusso 10y agoThose people did exist, but were largely ignored because the medical bureaucracy and Federal government got into the food pyramid and dietary guidelines business. The real money for the food industry then became pursuing the low-fat diet.
- kevin_thibedeau 10y ago> actually the number one hidden danger in the modern diet. As opposed to a sedentary lifestyle spent passively consuming entertainment from the safety of environmentally controlled living spaces that requires little energy to be expended on any activities.
- prostoalex 10y agoThat theory does not stand the test of time or geography. US obesity rates and dental problems started skyrocketing around war time, when sugar was introduced to soldiers' rations and by virtue of subsidies into mainstream diet. Many of life's comforts like cars or TV sets (and radios before them) were available in that era. At the same time countries with low obesity rates exist today, and residents of Thailand, Moldova or Japan are not particularly deprived of cars, TVs or PCs, nor do they exert significant physical effort to hunt and gather their food. On the other side of the spectrum, countries with high obesity rates (Mexico, Nauru, Cook Islands) are not particularly car-infested way way higher when compared to peers, nor do they have extreme TV/PC consumption numbers. The only relevant variable seems to be the amount of sugar (consumed from all sources) in the diet. The sedentary lifestyle theory does help sell fitness club memberships, though, so it's not completely useless.
- prewett 10y agoYou can't use possession of cars as a proxy for sedentaryness. If you look at the number of people on sidewalks in the US (approximately none) versus the number of people walking in Japan or Thailand, you'll see a stark contrast. In the US, people (myself included) will take a car to the grocery store a ten minute walk away. In most cities around the world you get used to walking places, but since it's rarely feasible to walk in the US, you get used to driving everywhere.
- prostoalex 10y agoThe closest they came to testing that hypothesis was to conduct surveys across residents of various countries, and it turns out the "laziest" countries are not the obesity leaders (although arguably laziness here is self-reported) http://www.telegraph.co.uk/news/health/news/9405918/British-people-among-laziest-in-Europe.html http://www.telegraph.co.uk/news/health/news/9405918/British-... I don't know if anyone has good data on the amount of walking per capita per country. Maybe FitBit would have decent stats, but then their userbase is a bit self-selecting.
- Shivetya 10y agoto think Woody Allen had it right with Sleeper. (movie where some previously bad foods/habits were good for you, and no I am not serious) A lot of past recommendations were likely co-opted by whatever the industry was starting to push. Plus there was a tendency to focus on one issue to the point of ignoring side effects of correcting it. i have been a fan of natural fats for a long time and never have cooked with fats other than animal, butter, or olive/avocado oils. I find most distressing are store bought salad dressings and any mass market vegetable oil. Sure it has its place, shortening is an absolute for some baking but the prevalence of it in about everything else is uncalled for. Yet at the end of the day I always wonder, how do our genetics affect us? Smoking is bad yet lung cancer does not require it and there are smokers living to ripe old ages. Same for some old standard foods that current dieticians bemoan but I remember as staple of grandparents.
- clock_tower 10y agoCould we get a less audacious title? The article's about how butter appears to be healthier than corn oil -- and that, in general, the health differences between butter and linoleic-acid-based vegetable oils may be a wash. This is pretty interesting, but it doesn't upend the apple cart quite as comprehensively as the current title suggests.
- ythn 10y agoToo late, I'm already drinking a cup of liquid butter to help my heart
- clock_tower 10y agoDon't forget that sugar is the next superfood!
- brendangregg 10y agobulletproof coffee, hold the coffee
- maxerickson 10y agoThe previous discussion of this topic went with Replacing butter with vegetable oils does not cut heart disease risk (2016) even though the title of the Atlantic article was Is Vegetable Oil Really Better for Your Heart? https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=13632116 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=13632116 The Quartz article, which was apparently posted today, talks about research published "this week", but it links the same research article from April 2016 as the Atlantic article.
- clock_tower 10y agoThat sounds like a better title, at least IMHO... I didn't realize this had been discussed recently. (Wait, "recently" as in "yesterday"? Is this article just a duplicate?) (As for which fats to use, I figure olive oil used in modest quantities probably can't hurt me, so I'll stick to that for cooking at the moment.)
- lucidguppy 10y agoThis is like comparing cigarettes to menthols. Both are poisons. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=AYTf0z_zVs0 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=AYTf0z_zVs0
- mjevans 10y agoI hypothesize that if a comparison contrasts a suitable quantity of buttering / fat for flavor and refined sugars for flavor (because who actually uses molasses/etc) then either hybrids or fat biased foods will be easier to process and regulate for most individuals.
- surfmike 10y agoMaybe butter's good but their accompanying picture is pancakes with syrup, as if that's ok to eat now as long as it has butter.
- lvspiff 10y agosounds like a plan to me - put butter on it makes it healthier! Donuts? Butter glazed maybe! Fries? Fry em in butter! Starbucks? Instead of cream add butter! Forget the BigMac sauce I'll take butter!
- duderific 10y agoIronically putting butter in coffee is a thing now...in keto/paleo diets especially: http://www.thekitchn.com/whats-the-deal-with-butter-in-coffee-190911 http://www.thekitchn.com/whats-the-deal-with-butter-in-coffe...
- blafunke 10y agoHahah yeah they definitely had coffee with butter in it back in the hunter gatherer days.
- anigbrowl 10y agoOn a side note, there's more than one kind of butter. I hate mainstream US dairy products; most of them are from Holstein cows which have the highest milk production of any breed but whose milk tastes insufferably bland to me. If you can get milk from Jersey cows, the difference is like night and day - much higher butterfat content.
- 09bjb 10y agoTry Kerrygold, 100% grass-fed and grass-finished...or the U.S. equivalent. You'll never go back.
- lettergram 10y agoI'd second this! First time I bought some from Costco, my family asked why my food was so delicious. It's not even much more expensive than regular butter.
- anonymousDan 10y agoAnd I'll third it! As an Irishman living abroad I find most local butters extremely tasteless. Luckily it's not too hard to find Kerrygold in most supermarkets in the UK.
- anigbrowl 10y agoThat's exactly what I had in mind but I didn't want to sound like a butter commercial XD I grew up with it and I'm baffled by what passes for butter in the American market. We probably spend twice as much on food as is average for the amount we consume, but it seems both tastier and healthier. Part of why I have negative opinions of capitalism is the inescapable fact that the baseline of food quality is so bad. The most popular and well-known food brands, which take up the most shelf space in most supermarkets and are thus the default choice for many consumers are just awful. They're somewhat-to-direly awful nutritionally, they don't taste good, and many people are so conditioned to sugar and artificial flavors that they find real food weird at first. I feel like this is a serious social problem. What seems like a large majority of Americans don't know how to eat well and this causes all kinds of second-order problems - not just things like obesity and diabetes, but things like criminal recidivism too. The idea of nutrition and healthy eating in prisons is treated by most people as a contradiction in terms, as if diet didn't have any impact on self-control, learning ability and other factors that are likely to impact future behavior. (This is sadly far from an exclusively American problem.) When people aren't properly nourished they under stress and when they're under stress they make poor decisions.
- surfmike 10y ago"The subjects were broken into two groups. One was given a diet in which liquid corn oil was used in place of usual hospital cooking fats (including butter and hydrogenated oils) during meal preparation. The other group received meals cooked with common margarines and shortening. " Where is butter in this study?Am I missing something?
- burkaman 10y agoButter is a type of shortening, but I don't know why it's phrased like that. The actual study mentions butter: http://www.bmj.com/content/353/bmj.i1246 http://www.bmj.com/content/353/bmj.i1246
- surfmike 10y agoOk thanks. The way it's worded it still sounds like the group was a butter/margarine mix, so not a clean comparison.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- emptybits 10y agoI'm not sure the study had much to do with butter. It mentions butter just once but leaves it very unclear how much butter was actually involved (versus "shortening"). The study talks extensively about "shortening" which is primarily a vegetable-based product now AFAIK. FWIW, the Wikipedia article tells us "the term "shortening" seldom refers to butter, but is more closely related to margarine."
- burkaman 10y agoYeah it's very confusing. Maybe these words meant something different in 1968.
- umberway 10y agoButter is good for you provided you don't fry with it. If overheated it supplies more than the usual amount of inflammatory compounds. Instead, fry with ghee (clarified butter) or tallow.
- greglindahl 10y agoIs there any evidence that people frying with butter actually damage themselves?
- failrate 10y agoMy stance has always been that butter is so delicious that I am willing to accept a reasonable amount of risk, whereas I find margarine so foul that I would rather eat food without any fat than consume it.
- analog31 10y agoAmusingly, I quit butter for that reason. I had a major health scare just over a year ago, and despite being skeptical of dietary advice in general, I decided that at least I could lose weight. So I cut butter out of my diet. The result was that I ate a lot less food overall, because it eliminated most of my favorite snacks, such as buttered toast. Sure, I missed it, but I've gotten slimmed down, and am having no problem keeping it off so far. It took months, but the day arrived when I actually enjoyed a piece of toast with no butter! So, this has more to do with me hacking my own brain, than about any sort of nutritional science.
- rch 10y agoRye/spelt sourdough toast with no butter is delicious. I'll also add a little olive oil and salt.
- failrate 10y agoIn my case, I lost the weight by eliminating a lot of carbohydrates from my diet. The only way I would bother touching a piece of bread would be if it was unusually delicious.
- analog31 10y agoFor me, butter was the lubricant for stuffing myself with carbohydrates.
- amelius 10y agoOne component of butter, butyrate, has been shown to have many health benefits. See e.g. [1] (not endorsing this reference, I just link to it because it was easy to find and it references a lot of relevant literature). [1] https://selfhacked.com/2016/05/07/health-benefits-butyrate-derivatives-sodium-butyrate-phenylbutyrate-trybutyrine-butyric-acid-butyrate-prodrugs-butyrate-producing-bacteria/ https://selfhacked.com/2016/05/07/health-benefits-butyrate-d...
- tbv 10y agoThere is quite a bit of evidence to support that a diet rich in animal fats, and poor in vegetable oils has many advantages, including higher HDL cholesterol, lower LDL cholesterol, and improved thyroid function.
- ASpring 10y agoInterested in sources supporting this.
- zardo 10y agoButter may be healthful! (In a comparison with another believed to be unhealthful dietary choice) Corn oil has a very high Omega6:Omega3 ratio.
- paulcole 10y agoThis is what's so great about online nutrition journalism. Love butter? Great there's an article that backs up your beliefs. Hate butter? Even better, there's an article for that, too!
- coldcode 10y agoI only use butter and duck fat. Nothing better than cooking with duck fat.
- dennis_jeeves 10y agoI've been having more than 100 gms of butter every day for the last 4 years. I'm on a ketogenic diet. I have to do it. Helps a lots with my sub-optimal health. Questions welcome.
- ZeroFries 10y agoWhat health conditions are you trying to treat with your diet?
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- dennis_jeeves 10y agoI was originally trying to alleviate my sleep problems. After I switched my diet to a ketogenic (only meat, eggs and diary) not only did my sleep improve dramatically but a whole bunch of other things that I did not expect: mood, digestion, acidity(not sure about this), stamina, cold tolerance, fat redistribution in the body (reduced tummy flab, but less gaunt face.) etc.