8 ms·
Payouts may have contribued to a talent exodus at Google's car project
- zitterbewegung 10y agoI think the article is overemphasizing the money that the people earned with the project but instead people got disillusioned with the project and since they amassed enough money then that is why they departed the project. They even state this in the article.
- no_wave 10y agoExcellent journalism - anonymous sources speculate as to what might have caused people to leave a company. Also pushes the new business-friendly narrative that it's good for companies to pay their engineers less. Well done, I hope the author's boss is proud.
- alexc05 10y agoYou don't feel this is a strong argument in favor of the de-regulation of minimum wage? Freeing businesses from the growth stifing yoke of employee voluntary attrition? /s Ughh... reading this is ridiculous. Do we think bankers' salaries prevent them from staying at banks? Doesn't the first sentence answer the question of what really happened? > For the past year, Google's car project has been > a talent sieve, thanks to leadership changes, > strategy doubts, new startup dreams and rivals > luring self-driving technology experts. Poor leadership & competition. Easy to point fingers elsewhere, but everything we know about motivation says that autonomy, making a difference and a whole host of other "soft reasons" are the factors that drive it forward. The people who left didn't STOP working on self driving cars. So they still love the work and are engaged by the dream of doing that. So theoretically - if Google had adapted to their needs & wants they could have retained the employees. Instead poor leadership drove them out the door.
- no_wave 10y agoBut the anonymous sources are saying that the only problem was that Google was too generous. Clearly we should believe them at face value.
- maxxxxx 10y agoI am all for higher salaries but there is some truth to the dangers of overpaying. Give me 5 million dollars and you will never see me again. Give my CEO 5 million dollars and he'll keep going. On the other hand, give me 250000 dollars and you will have a very happy and loyal employee.
- JackFr 10y agoI doubt very much that you would quit after getting a 5mm bonus. I've seen some pretty ridiculous Wall St bonuses from the 90's up close. I think a more typical response would be, "Hmmm. That wasn't so hard, let's see if they do it again next year." And when they don't -- that is typically when you walk.
- 1024core 10y ago> I've seen some pretty ridiculous Wall St bonuses from the 90's up close. That's anecdata. Not everyone is the same. I know friends who would quit in a heartbeat and pursue other passions (music, teaching, non-profit work, etc.) if they got F-you money.
- pcsanwald 10y agoEveryone is different, and I realize that the actual number doesn't matter, but most people able to make 5MM in bonus on wall st wouldn't consider that amount anywhere near "F-you money".
- maxxxxx 10y agoI would quit after even less money. I would dabble with tech but no way I would ever go into an office again. Some people like CEO's genuinely seem to enjoy business but I personally don't.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- ryandrake 10y agoReally, because $5M seems like an enormous fortune to me. It's an amount you could stick in a savings account yielding only 1% interest and pretty much live the rest of your life with a decent lifestyle somewhere with a low cost of living. OR, you could quit your high-stress job and augment that interest with a more fulfilling career. I can pretty safely say a single $5M bonus would amount to an instant lifestyle change (namely less pressure to work) for me.
- ryandrake 10y agoYou're probably right on, despite the down-votes. This is almost certainly a Submarine Article [1] pushing the tired "engineers are overpayed" narrative. Wonder who's funding whatever PR firm put it out... 1: http://paulgraham.com/submarine.html http://paulgraham.com/submarine.html
- tptacek 10y agoAlmost certainly, you say! It's hard to think of something Paul Graham wrote that has done more damage to discussions on HN than his piece about submarine PR pieces.
- clock_tower 10y agoThat doesn't mean they aren't real. Did you see that article on cursive writing? (https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=12193539 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=12193539)
- skj 10y agoThe submarine piece was a submarine piece to try to get people to generally ignore the press for anything substantive and instead elect Trump as president.
- SilasX 10y agoWhen people thought that every published article was some journalist independently deciding something was newsworthy and thus writing up their neutral research on it, they were wrong. When people thought every published article was some propagandist's attempt to sway public opinion, they were wrong. But the second view is a lot less wrong than the former.[1] "Journalism is printing what someone else does not want printed: everything else is public relations." -- George Orwell. [1] Didn't feel like following Asimov's pattern for the third line.
- metaphorm 10y agoare you saying that the post you responded to did damage to this discussion? I think you should justify that claim. what damage? to whom? I think that your comment might be the damaging one because it attempts to delegitimize the opinion of another community member without any reasons given.
- beamatronic 10y agoI just realized the genius of the name "Alphabet". By investing in this company you are "betting" that they will be able to generate "alpha" ( in the financial sense ) http://www.investopedia.com/terms/a/alpha.asp http://www.investopedia.com/terms/a/alpha.asp
- sparky_z 10y agoYeah, they said that in the original press release.
- beepboopbeep 10y ago...Oh hell, I just thought it was because they had such a big portfolio of endeavors. Now it just comes across as tacky.
- kyrra 10y agoThis was called out in the announcement of the company: We also like that it means alpha-bet (Alpha is investment return above benchmark), which we strive for! https://googleblog.blogspot.com/2015/08/google-alphabet.html https://googleblog.blogspot.com/2015/08/google-alphabet.html
- CobrastanJorji 10y agoYou could also consider Google as Alphabet's primary, or "alpha" bet, but Google is also investing in a variety of "other bets". The name also provides for cool URLs, like https://abc.xyz https://abc.xyz.
- FreedomToCreate 10y agoI don't think getting paid a large sum of money is the contributing factor for the departures. If this was true, than logic would dictate that no company should be able to retain executives based on their compensation payouts each year. If anything, the exodus at google shows clear lack of vision and direction from the management and executive teams. Engineers care about achieving something they can feel proud of and if the project lacks that, they move on. This article is written in a way that suggests engineers should be paid less so that they remain loyal...you know, like slaves.
- tptacek 10y agoTwo problems with this first-principles analysis: 1. The highest paid executives in other industries tend to be at the apex of their careers, and new startups would be a status step down for them. 1. Empirically, executives do switch companies somewhat routinely. Your last sentence presents a false dichotomy: either we're meant to reject the notion that flight money is a real phenomenon, or we're required to believe engineers shouldn't be compensated above slave levels. There's a huge excluded middle in that argument.
- phillmv 10y agoI would buy this more if we routinely heard "problems with retention" as an issue with runaway executive compensation. It's possible I've not seen them, but seems curiously absent in the discourse to me.
- maxander 10y agoEngineers with skills related to self-driving car development are also currently much rarer than highly trained executives, and companies trying to get into the autonomous car sector need more engineers than executives. Failing to retain an executive simply isn't as much of a problem.
- tptacek 10y agoThis response basically ignores what my comment said. We don't have "flight risk" problems with executive compensation because there is no higher-status place for an executive to go from the helm of a company that can reliably pay 8-figure salaries than to the helm of another such company. Starting new companies is a step down for those people. And, in fact, that's the ostensible reason executives make so much: because they can and do switch companies in pursuit of better compensation packages. These are positive statements, not normative ones.
- throwawaycanada 10y agoClearly you can't pay commoners too much. Only upper class people should get upper class money. One has to maintain the social order. God forbid those people who all "quit" use their newly earned capital to start their own enterprise.
- dang 10y agoPlease don't post snarky rants to HN. Doing so pulls discussion quality below the level we're hoping for.
- startupdiscuss 10y agoIn an alternative universe: 1. the regulatory environment in the US was relaxed 2. the cars were a big hit, and 3. there are articles about how far sighted Google was for letting the research project have these startup like returns.
- jessaustin 10y ago...the regulatory environment in the US was relaxed... Have onerous regulations been a problem for robocar development? If they were, I sort of think I would have heard of it, particularly here on HN where such vehicles are a common topic of conversation.
- ocdtrekkie 10y agoGoogle has routinely claimed or indicated that regulations are a significant roadblock[1][2][3][4] for self-driving cars. I would argue this is a misdirection, as regulations would not be an issue if the cars were safe to drive. [1]https://www.wsj.com/articles/googles-self-driving-cars-hit-regulatory-traffic-1426717776 https://www.wsj.com/articles/googles-self-driving-cars-hit-r... [2]https://www.texastribune.org/2013/02/21/googles-self-driving-car-too-advanced-texas-laws/ https://www.texastribune.org/2013/02/21/googles-self-driving... [3]http://time.com/4152958/google-california-self-driving-car-regulations-disappointed/ http://time.com/4152958/google-california-self-driving-car-r... [4]http://www.reuters.com/article/us-google-selfdrivingcar-idUSKCN0WH2S2 http://www.reuters.com/article/us-google-selfdrivingcar-idUS...
- waisbrot 10y agoIf there weren't these rules about not killing pedestrians or ramming buildings I could make a robot car myself! Another small business smothered in the crib by government overreach.
- startupdiscuss 10y agoThis is the point I was making, although this is a more amusing way of making it. I didn't say they should not be relaxed, by the way. I do think at some point there will be a big public fight about what we are willing to accept. I have heard it said that even current self-driving tech is safer than humans. But I haven't looked at the stats myself.
- waisbrot 10y agoI'd interpret the content of the article as the opposite of the title: "One (the only?) reason staffers didn't quit Google's car project before now? The company paid them so much" Multiple big players want to get into autonomous cars (and other vehicles -- this is the same space as military contracts for drones) and Google's executives were in total disarray. You'd think they'd lose out but instead they successfully hit some giant milestones by throwing enough cash at the problem. I mean, if the staffers had been paid poorly, wouldn't they have quit without waiting for that 16x bonus that only comes after meeting the division goals and then waiting four years?
- gigatexal 10y agoIsn't there an on-premise labor economist on the payroll? I mean, a bachelor level econ student could have told them this. Interesting still, is that there is real-world proof of an upper limit to pay in this industry given the a typical labor-leisure curve
- JustSomeNobody 10y agoAnd a million MBA heads just bobbled as they agreed, "Yes, yes, we pay engineers too much! Mwaaaahahaahahaa!"
- Steeeve 10y agoThat's a bozo of an excuse if I ever heard one. Lack of vision, lack of direction, failure to set expectations or execute a plan, better opportunities elsewhere, poor management... those are all reasons for brain drain. Gave them too much money? That's absurd. Honestly, it looks more like a propoganda message to pre-explain shrinking bonus money.
- amorphid 10y agoCrazy thought... If this is even possible, create a standard for everything key employees should know. Pay people great, but not GREAT. Bank up "eff you" money for them. If they want to quit, they get the banked money as long as there are enough people on team to carry on without that person. Might not be practical for a number of reasons. Just sounds interesting, without having put any thought into the idea beyond the time it took me to write this comment.
- matart 10y ago"F- you money" is the amount of money that allows you to do what you want, i.e. leave when things do not go your way. This must mean the staffers did not want to be there for some reason or another. This is interesting because they were helping build the future. It's easy to see why people might not be excited or passionate about the next CRUD app but self driving cars seems like a passion project to me.
- ocdtrekkie 10y agoMany of these people are passionate about building the future. ...that's why they left Google. Bear in mind, many of them are still working on self-driving cars, they just went to work for other companies. If as you say, it's a passion project, they are going to go to whoever they think is best equipped to accomplish the vision. Especially since money is no longer an issue for them.
- yalogin 10y agoDid they pay F-You money to the engineers or the management? Because no matter how much you pay its not going to be enough to make one retire (in 5 years). Unless of course they really paid 10s of millions. That means if they are really paid, employees would rather not leave. The main reason its a sieve is that they realized they could make more money by leaving. They saw examples with Otto and others.
- loeg 10y agoI'd be comfortable retiring with a "mere" $2 mil bonus payout. But I'd also stay on at a job I enjoyed, especially something as important to society as self-driving vehicles.
- gmarx 10y agoI really enjoy the tone of this article. It's written like they are tracking down the steps that led a company to dump toxic chemicals outside a grade school. Considering I see Google self driving cars self driving all over the place and I don't recall seeing that before 2010, maybe the idea worked?
- carsongross 10y agoI wonder if companies will ever take a page from the public sector and offer crucial employees pensions based on staying on for a long time.
- jayjay71 10y agoHow many companies will still be around in 50+ years?
- loeg 10y agoI don't know that that can work in the tech sector — you'd have to scale down "long time" to accommodate higher pay (and thus earlier retirement) and even then I'd be wary of taking a job if I knew the pay was heavily backloaded.
- gregshap 10y agoAs usual it sounds like the story is more nuanced than the headline. A more accurate phrasing might be "One reason staffers quit google's car project? The company structured their pay so that an intermediate project milestone was treated like an IPO event." It's not that the employees got rich so they no longer cared about money, it's that they basically got their maximum bonus from Google, so they were better off taking their talents elsewhere to get the next big payout. Given that their CFO discussed these payouts on the earnings call of a company with $6.6 billion in operating expenses, it sounds like these were entering the $100million range. Makes sense given that Google was trying to recruit and motivate people to work on startup projects, while overall Google market cap wasn't going to grow exponentially the way that a 2011 facebook or uber might. It probably wasn't a bad idea, they just executed in a way that only incentivized employees to get partway done.
- anindha 10y agoAgreed. If they were told to hit a certain set of milestones, and they did, I don't see why its an issue after the fact. The people that received the bonuses did their job and deserve what they were promised. After hitting all those milestones and not seeing a car on the road, I can imagine that as a reason to be disgruntled and wanting to move to another company.
- jorblumesea 10y agoBut they also got the best people in the industry and the results they wanted. Engineers that may have ended up working at Lyft, Uber or other companies. This just in, startup type incentives does work and also produces startup like effects including bouncing around more than they would like.
- Fricken 10y agoMaybe in a decade when this is all water under the bridge we'll get the real story about what sort of drama went down to cause all their top people to flee. It may be been banal. Now that the visionary part of the program has been executed, and with development more or less on rails, it's possible there simply isn't anything exciting left for the top guys to work on. That and they're all extremely valuable to car companies who would rather not get left in the dust.