6 ms·
I find the anti-AirBnB comments on this site quite confusing, because in most other cases HN seems to be pro-free markets. If a landlord wants to rent their pla
by jstanley 10y ago
I find the anti-AirBnB comments on this site quite confusing, because in most other cases HN seems to be pro-free markets. If a landlord wants to rent their place out to short-term tenants, and tenants want to rent it, and AirBnB want to act as a marketplace, I can't see what the harm is.
You don't have any right to say who comes and goes to your neighbours' properties, any more than they have any right to say who comes and goes to your property.
If you want to decide who gets to stay in a given house, you should buy that house. Otherwise it's none of your business.
- amelius 10y agoThere are rules for renting out appartments for good reasons. For example, it influences the worth of appartments around it, and it messes up housing costs in a broader area. Another example of the free market not working outside a very simplistic view.
- ryanlol 10y agoCan you make a good argument for why free market doesn't work here? I don't feel that ... >There are rules for renting out appartments for good reasons. For example, it influences the worth of appartments around it, and it messes up housing costs in a broader area. ... is really an useful argument against free market as it fails to explain why either of those are inherently bad things.
- mehwoot 10y agoBecause there are negative externalities to someone constantly renting out their unit for short term stay. In a completely free market, there are no rules to protect the neighbours from these negative externalities.
- ryanlol 10y agoThis seems to be a solved problem, housing co-operatives exist and enable the shareholders to regulate these things themselves.
- mehwoot 10y agoWhich is another form of non free market. It's just whether you want the rules enforced at the level of housing co-operative, community or the state government. As you move up the levels, the market becomes less free (easier to move to a different apartment block if you don't like the rules than to move to a different state) but becomes far better at protecting against the negative externalities (housing cooperative doesn't have the same enforcement capabilities as local or state governments).
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- willholloway 10y agoIn the case of multi-family investment properties like a duplex or three family, the externalities are positive. Investment properties have incentives in place to not spend money on maintenance, not spend on upkeep to the extent the owner can get away with it. With a vacation rental the incentive is to make it as nice as possible to charge a premium, and the rents support a higher level of finish and polish to a property. I live right between two short term rentals and people come and go all the time, and I love it. I've met so many cool people, especially from Europe travelling in the US. The house is kept up much nicer than the other multi families around it. None of the guests have ever once had a party, made noise, left trash or anything negative.
- jstanley 10y agoIf a new participant enters a market and that causes changes in pricing, it is not because the new participant has made the market less efficient. If the new participant was offering a worse deal than the incumbents, nobody would trade with them. It is only because the new participant is offering a better deal than the incumbents that their actions change the market prices. And that's a good thing.
- amelius 10y agoYou seem to take the free market as a premise and from there deduce that it is a desirable construct. The point was that the nature of the free market has an undesirable effect on prices.
- jstanley 10y agoQuite a good comment. I had never considered that taking the free market as a premise might not be the correct decision. On further reflection, I still think it is the correct decision. If someone wants to rent a property more badly than anyone else wants to (i.e. they are willing to pay more) then why shouldn't they get it instead of the others? This will push prices up, but that's a natural effect of allocating scarce resources to whoever wants them most.
- larkery 10y agoI think you have accidentally conflated "whoever wants them most" with whoever is willing and able to pay the most. I am not sure how you would find out whether I want to live on the street where I grew up more than, for example, a billionaire Russian oligarch, but I think that even if I wanted it one thousand times more I would remain unable to afford it. It may be that many other people gave the oligarch some money to show that they, in some exchange, had a total want for said oligarch to live there more than my want, but this is a different claim implying a very strong assumption about the addition and fungibility of wants, making them indistinguishable from money itself.
- u_wot_m8 10y ago
- CPLX 10y agoOf course you have a right to say who comes and goes in your neighbors properties and what kinds of things they are allowed to do, as I am sure you would insist were they to open a concert venue or dog fighting arena.
- 3825 10y ago> Of course you have a right to say who comes and goes in your neighbors properties and what kinds of things they are allowed to do, as I am sure you would insist were they to open a concert venue or dog fighting arena. Noise complaint is a valid argument up to a certain point. Of course, I don't want anyone to have a concert upstairs. Don't get me wrong. I am no fan of Uber or Airbnb or many of the things they represent. However, we must agree that the ends do not justify the means. This is just one step away from FUD like "Oh, if we have Airbnb we might have {{insert trendy to hate -- black, Hispanic, Arabic, Chinese, Canadian}} people staying over for the weekend next door and who knows what they're going to do to me in my sleep". I think if you subscribe to this idea then we should throw the baby away with the bath water as well. Nobody is allowed to visit anyone in their homes. Absolutely no parties even if you own your home. Only the legal registered occupant may be present at any time (I guess we will add provisions for EMS and law enforcement). I will agree with you the day I can get a fellow passenger kicked out of a train or an aeroplane for failing to quiet their devil spawn that won't stop wailing for over n hours. I am not accusing you of malice but please realize that the anti-Airbnb rhetoric is no more of a "grass-roots" movement than the so-called "tea party movement". Yes, there are people with valid concerns. No, they are not the ones driving this train. It appears we share a common goal with "them" but we do not.
- mgkimsal 10y agoI think - hope - we see a crackdown from insurance companies as airbnb-style sharing becomes more common. They should have more data as to accidents/claims/etc. This is part of the 'free market' wrt sharing that hasn't really played out yet. Most people renting out their house are not telling their insurance companies that they're effectively running a business from their home, and this will effect claims/premiums.
- 10y ago
- gaius 10y agoYou don't have any right to say who comes and goes to your neighbours' properties But you do. You agree to abide by certain rules when you rent/buy and your neighbors have every right to see that the rules you ALL agreed to are followed.
- xapata 10y agoNot everyone belongs to a home-owners' association.
- maxerickson 10y agoIncorporated cities are at least similar to homeowners associations. The property is attached to the corporation.
- chasing 10y agoI'm not anti-AirBnB. I'm pro-community. A house is in a neighborhood. An apartment in a shared building. I think we need to make sure we have some rules in place to make sure AirBnB-style sharing is a benefit to everyone and not just a benefit to a few at the expense of everyone else.
- avip 10y agoIf a city wants to block all roads and cutoff water and electricity to said landlord (it's their infrastructure), I can't see what the harm is either.
- mattnewton 10y agoThe city is run by the people though, not private ownership. Apples to oranges.
- brandall10 10y ago" If a landlord wants to rent their place out to short-term tenants, and tenants want to rent it, and AirBnB want to act as a marketplace, I can't see what the harm is." Have you ever lived next a to unit used for AirBnB? I have. After one incident where 8 college students partied the weekend away non-stop, I finally let the HOA know. They then aggressively enforced the building policy of a 28 day rental minimum.
- mahyarm 10y agoThe solution to that is large HOA fines. They will quickly stop doing AirBnB or make sure the people are quiet. If a bunch of college students or emotional people moved in next door, you would have similar problems.
- brandall10 10y ago"The solution to that is large HOA fines." That's what I meant by "aggressively enforced". I believe our fine is something like $2500 now. "If a bunch of college students or emotional people moved in next door, you would have similar problems." The main difference is those are actual tenants bound to the covenants of the housing complex. The issues with your neighbors are tracked and escalated.
- mahyarm 10y agoThe condo unit is still owned by someone. The issue is tracked and escalated with them. The HOA could say that any short term guest is still bound to CC&Rs also without removing something like AirBnB. Even with AirBnB you have to agree to terms before renting. Not being able to AirBnB your place is frustrating. If you have to go away for a few months due to work or getting fired or similar, it decreases the value of the unit. Most people's houses don't have these restrictions at a municipal level, but still would have to deal with noise complaints.
- rhapsodic 10y ago>You don't have any right to say who comes and goes to your neighbours' properties, any more than they have any right to say who comes and goes to your property. But I do have a say in what types of commerce are allowed to take place in my community, or my country for that matter. And although I am normally a laissez faire capitalist, I would love to see Airbnb utterly destroyed through lawsuits and over-regulation. Why? For political reasons. The latest tactic of the left is to attack any commercial entity that has the temerity to express any pro-Trump sentiments. And I think the only way for the right to counter that is to employ the exact same tactic, a hundred-fold, against companies who publicly oppose Trump, or political agendas supported by the right. And Airbnb, led by the smug boy-billionaire Brian Chesky, falls squarely in that category. There are numerous stories[1] of people's lives being turned upside down as a result of using Airbnb. I think televised congressional hearings are called for. And there are probably billions of dollars worth of commerce that are going untaxed as a result of Airbnb. I don't think a few click-through TOS agreements should shield them from responsibility. 1. http://www.airbnbhell.com/ http://www.airbnbhell.com/
- chasing 10y agoYou make good points about community. As far as politics, you're playing that game of false-equivalence that I thought we'd kind of moved past. Pro- and Anti-Trump aren't just two teams with different uniforms.
- rhapsodic 10y ago>As far as politics, you're playing that game of false-equivalence that I thought we'd kind of moved past. Pro- and Anti-Trump aren't just two teams with different uniforms. I don't even know what that means. I'm only advocating using the same tactics against the left that they use against the right. I would love to see Airbnb's $30 billion valuation go all the way down to zero. That won't happen, of course, because even if their business were effectively outlawed in the US, they could still do business abroad. But it would sure wipe the smug off of some left-wing SV billionaires' faces if Airbnb were to become poison to future investors, and derail their eventual IPO. How sweet that would be.
- Scarblac 10y ago> If a landlord wants to rent their place out to short-term tenants, and tenants want to rent it, and AirBnB want to act as a marketplace, I can't see what the harm is. It's classic tragedy of the commons. Cities that are great to live in and also very attractive for tourists are obviously great places to rent out an apartment over AirBnB in. But when half the city does that, then the whole character of the place changes and what was previously great about the city is lost. That is harm. Luckily, cities have the power to regulate this sort of thing.
- maverick_iceman 10y agoHe is very very far from pro free market. Most people here seem to be Bernie bros who support Soviet style regulations.
- maverick_iceman 10y agoEdit: He > HN
- grzm 10y agoMaking generalizations about HN like this without backing data to support it is unwarranted. There are plenty of diverse views, many of which do not fit nicely in the box you've constructed.
- yomly 10y agoSeems like a bit reductionist to liken concern/acknowledgement that "free market" dynamics may not necessarily be desirable in every case to support for Soviet-style regulation. Airbnb has caused increase in local rent by removing the available to-let properties from the market in London. Considering that there is already an increasing wealth-gap problem, it's hard to stomach something that is exacerbating the problem and reducing social-mobility in the name of free-market dynamics.
- ArtDev 10y agoHighly desirable places also have many second-homes as well. In Hawaii, some neighborhoods are only 20% occupied because most of the owners actually live somewhere else. I am sure second-homes also drive up prices (In Vancouver they even have a special tax for empty houses).
- megablast 10y agoExactly. And if they want to change their house into an iron smelter or a coal power plant, they should be able to as well. Free market!!!!
- wilde 10y agoThere's less incentive on short term renters to respect the people around their rental. This leads to all sorts of bad behaviors. That said, I think it's a question of "why do we have zoning laws". AirBNB gets to profit from encouraging people to break the law, while the rest of us have to live with the decreased housing supply. If we had fewer restrictions on getting long term supply in place, or more effective restrictions on AirBnBs, I think there'd be fewer complaints. Right now it's super one sided.
- zelos 10y agoPresumably the market for renting out rooms started out virtually completely free and over the years regulations have been voted in due to problems caused by that free market. That's not to say that those regulations are all necessary or helpful, but clearly the free market isn't enough in this case. Same with Uber - it starts as a free-for-all, then you get stories like this: http://www.telegraph.co.uk/business/2016/05/11/uber-to-ban-cars-from-causing-chaos-in-heathrow-villages/ http://www.telegraph.co.uk/business/2016/05/11/uber-to-ban-c... and they start introducing rules around it.
- geebee 10y agoThink of it this way: I would like to trade my right to run a hotel out of my house in exchange for a legally enforced expectation that my neighbors won't do this either. I should like to have this enforced through a set of rules, in my case zoning laws, that apply to everyone who buys in a particular geographic region. The law should be clear, so that everyone who does buy here knows that the agreement they've entered. It sounds like you don't believe that residents in a particular neighborhood should be permitted to enter this legally binding arrangement. This is a deep, fundamental disagreement between us, one that probably goes to the heart of how we perceive the relationship between an individual and the community.