8 ms·
The True Cost of Bitcoin Transactions
- pmorici 10y agoThere is a small faction of the Bitcoin community working exceptionally hard to prevent any block size increase. I find their motives really baffling. They had some legitimate arguments a few years ago when discussion of this issue first started but those have all since been superseded by improvements in the protocol like xthin. They now resort to distasteful tactics by running anyone out of town that even so much as suggests a block size increase. They are also working overtime to censor any comments that challenge their world view on the /r/bitcoin sub reddit which is why you see such hostile comments mentioned by the OP in response to users asking about slow transactions. /r/bitcoin is now just an echo chamber where yes men regurgitate the agenda of a select few. Eeveyone else is shadow banned. edit: anyone that doubts this go make a comment in /r/bitcoin that contains the word "censorship" then view the page in incognito mode. The comment is immediately hidden by the automoderator. It really is nuts. Article about the history of censorship in /r/bitcoin https://medium.com/@johnblocke/a-brief-and-incomplete-history-of-censorship-in-r-bitcoin-c85a290fe43#.ihsr0xkhf https://medium.com/@johnblocke/a-brief-and-incomplete-histor...
- knocte 10y agoThat's really baffling, I perceived quite the opposite.
- pmorici 10y agoBased on what? Can you name a single dev that expresses support for bigger blocks that hasn't been systematically ridiculed and excluded from Bitcoin Core development by the small block crowd? It isn't even possible to get an accurate perception of Bitcoin Unlimited support from reading the traditional Bitcoin discussion forums like /r/bitcoin because there is ZERO tolerance for discussion of bigger blocks unless it in a negative context.
- dpc59 10y agoI'm pretty sure this was a sarcastic shitcomment. People who have a basic idea of how finance works understand that decentralized financial products lead to market making.
- nadaviv 10y agoSegWit is a block size increase. Pretty much every developer in the bitcoin community supports SegWit.
- lawn 10y ago> Pretty much every developer in the bitcoin community supports SegWit. Only in the censored outskirts. I recommend everyone to read John Blocke's articles: https://medium.com/@johnblocke/the-importance-of-clear-definitions-in-bitcoins-block-size-debate-f8ce550d0919#.i4vbed4ss https://medium.com/@johnblocke/the-importance-of-clear-defin... https://medium.com/@johnblocke/its-not-the-censorship-resistance-stupid-59a95e5f9b51#.2b1678j4o https://medium.com/@johnblocke/its-not-the-censorship-resist...
- nadaviv 10y ago- 105 businesses and projects from the Bitcoin space support SegWit and are working on implementing it in their products: https://bitcoincore.org/en/segwit_adoption/ https://bitcoincore.org/en/segwit_adoption/ - 54 bitcoin developers signed the "capacity increase roadmap" published by Bitcoin Core: https://bitcoin.org/en/bitcoin-core/capacity-increases https://bitcoin.org/en/bitcoin-core/capacity-increases - 45 companies and individuals signed in support of Bitcoin Core: https://bitcoincore.org/en/supporters/ https://bitcoincore.org/en/supporters/ - 85% of the nodes on the network are running Bitcoin Core: https://coin.dance/nodes/share https://coin.dance/nodes/share All of that due to censorship in one subreddit, while there are multiple other forums that people talk in? I have to say, that's quite impressive.
- pmorici 10y agoThe censorship isn't just in /r/bitcoin it also happens on the dev mailing list, on the bitcoin.org website, and on the BitcoinTalk forum. BitcoinTalk, /r/bitcoin, and bitcoin.org are controlled by the same person.
- joshontheweb 10y agoCan you expound on why? I'm interested in hearing both sides of this.
- cloakandswagger 10y agoI've been an outside observer of the block size debate for a while now, so here is my naive take on it: The anti-block size increase camp says that increasing the block size is only a temporary fix, and that no blockchain can accommodate Visa levels of throughput. They also posit that any increase in the block size will make running a full node more difficult, meaning Bitcoin will become more and more centralized and consolidated around the big mining pools that have the hardware to handle bigger block sizes. However, many in the anti camp are pro segwit (segregated witness), a code change that does several things and is the first step to enabling off-chain networks like Lightning Network. These are basically pools of Bitcoins tracked by networks off the blockchain that would allow you to instantly exchange Bitcoins to anyone else in your network. This is a big problem for miners who have poured lots of money into their rigs, because now the blockchain would be little more than a settlement network. There would be far more transactions occurring off the network, meaning less money for miners. Again I'm no expert on this but this seems to be the crux of the debate. The Core developers seem to be OK with having the blockchain relegated to being a settlement network (similar to how Visa, your bank and merchants work together), but many people are opposed to this, partly because these off-chain networks would quickly form large central "hubs" which would obviate many of the benefits of Bitcoin (anonymity, privacy, security and decentralization).
- Laforet 10y agoI've also been keeping tabs on the debate and I agree with you except on one account: Not everyone want the Bitcoin to be the next Visa or Paypal, some are perfectly content with a 10 minute confirmation delay as long as the blockchain remains fully distributed and anonymous, whereas others see a business opportunity that could make themselves rich and influential down the line. The entire narrative about larger block making the network more centralised is a red herring. The network has been going in that direction for quite some time without a block size increase and in any case, going from 1MB to 2MB or even 16MB isn't going to change the economics of running a full node that much, which is to say there are no incentives for non-miners to host a full node at all, regardless of the alleged computing and network overhead (and worse, it can make you a more likely victim of DDoS attacks[0]). The entire point about keeping the 1MB limit (which was meant to be a temporary cap anyway) is to artificially create scarcity in transaction capacity and coerce people into accepting SegWit and eventually fully functional side chains. This is probably fine for those who believe that A. Bitcoin will become mainstream and B. the ends justify the means, but I find this to be a very unethical position to take. Disclaimer: I don't own a single cent in BTC, nor do I have association with anyone involved in the Bitcoin scene. [0]:http://www.financemagnates.com/cryptocurrency/news/the-latest-victims-of-ddos-attacks-banks-and-bitcoin-xt/ http://www.financemagnates.com/cryptocurrency/news/the-lates...
- steveklabnik 10y ago> Eeveyone else is shadow banned. On reddit, only admins can shadow ban, and they claimed that they stopped doing it over a year ago, in my understanding.
- slaveofallah93 10y agoSubs can do a pseudo-shadowban by setting up automoderator to delete any comment you make automatically without explicitly banning you.
- pmorici 10y agoNone of the comments I make in that sub seem to show up any more and the only reason I realized it is because I stopped getting any responses and checked from an incognito window. Sure enough nothing there. I know others who have experienced the same. Some people are outright banned as well.
- cloakandswagger 10y agoI don't even bother with r/bitcoin anymore. The level of groupthink is insufferable, but hard for me to say whether it formed naturally or via direct influence (considering it's Reddit, both are likely)
- pmorici 10y agoI agree. I think it is a natural consequence of the censorship. If you censor comments and ban users that dissent people take the hint pretty quick that diversity of opinion isn't welcome and look elsewhere. The one hope I have for this whole thing being resolved is that historically there are examples in Bitcoin of groups that were once very influential being superseded. Most notable is probably Ghash.io which had so much hash rate at the height of their power that people were afraid they could perform a 51% attack and that Bitcoin was doomed. Today they don't even register a percentage point.
- decker 10y agoFollow the money, it's not baffling at all.
- brokenmachine 10y agoCan you explain better? How does changing the blocksize affect the amount of money?
- nadaviv 10y agoI was sure you're talking about the chinese miners as I started reading your comment... The ones who oppose a block-size increase today are the miners and the anti-Core crowd. The rest of the bitcoin community, including its technical and business community, are pushing for an increase to 2MB blocks in the form of SegWit. And I think the "hostile comments" referred to by the OP are the non-stop personal attacks and toxicity that is happening on r/btc.
- pmorici 10y agoYour comment is a good example of the double speak and gas lighting I often see in /r/bitcoin
- nadaviv 10y ago> Your comment is a good example of the double speak and gas lighting I often see in /r/bitcoin It would be a lot easier if people responded to the actual arguments being made, instead of throwing general accusations at people who're trying to have a rational discussions.
- pmorici 10y agoI have responded to your actual arguments in other comments here. I just don't know where to start with this one. Your comment fundamentally misrepresents the position of what you term the "anti core crowd" and so it is hard to have a rational discussion when you can't even acknowledge the position of the other side of the argument. Miners want a hard fork block size increase. You claiming they don't is gas lighting. Core isn't providing it. Segwit is not a block size increase but it's supporters started branding it as one to better market it. That's the double speak part. It's false to call it a block size increase because it isn't. It isn't even guaranteed to increase transaction throughput which is the larger reason for wanting a block size increase. It actually encourages some types of large transaction by discounting the witness data.
- nadaviv 10y ago
- nadaviv 10y agoYou're painting a very unbalanced picture. > There is a small faction of the Bitcoin community working exceptionally hard to prevent any block size increase. This small faction is composed of nearly ~all the technical experts we have in the Bitcoin space, over 100 businesses and projects that support SegWit, the majority of bitcoin users that I'm personally familiar with, the majority of full-nodes on the network (~85%), and the vast majority by pretty much every metric you choose. https://bitcoincore.org/en/segwit_adoption/ https://bitcoincore.org/en/segwit_adoption/ https://bitcoincore.org/en/supporters/ https://bitcoincore.org/en/supporters/ https://coin.dance/nodes/share https://coin.dance/nodes/share https://bitcoin.org/en/bitcoin-core/capacity-increases https://bitcoin.org/en/bitcoin-core/capacity-increases > /r/bitcoin is now just an echo chamber where yes men regurgitate the agenda of a select few. r/bitcoin is the largest and most active bitcoin community by far. It had to start engaging in more heavy-handed moderation when the voting bots, sockpuppet accounts and other manipulation made it impossible to conduct productive discussions. Its sad, but I don't really see an alternative. https://www.reddit.com/r/Bitcoin/comments/4biob5/research_into_instantaneous_vote_behavior_in/ https://www.reddit.com/r/Bitcoin/comments/4biob5/research_in... https://bitcoinmagazine.com/articles/a-closer-look-at-reddit-vote-manipulation-about-bitcoin-1458682699/ https://bitcoinmagazine.com/articles/a-closer-look-at-reddit... https://www.reddit.com/r/Bitcoin/comments/3hf5z7/determining_manipulation_via_sock_puppet_accounts/ https://www.reddit.com/r/Bitcoin/comments/3hf5z7/determining... https://news.bitcoin.com/the-block-size-debate-and-sock-puppet/ https://news.bitcoin.com/the-block-size-debate-and-sock-pupp... https://www.reddit.com/r/btc/comments/5n3wsw/birds_by_bitcoincom_get_paid_to_retweet_the/ https://www.reddit.com/r/btc/comments/5n3wsw/birds_by_bitcoi...
- pmorici 10y agoYou don't deny that censorship is taking place you are just rationalizing it by calling it "moderation". Lets be clear what is going on there goes way beyond what is commonly understood as moderation. They are systematically silencing a large segment of the Bitcoin community. If your side really had the support you claim the censorship wouldn't be needed.
- nadaviv 10y ago
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- hnolable 10y agoIf Eric was serious about this he would have targeted this post at chinese miners who are stalling on activating segwit (which is a 2x blocksize increase and the foundation for instant & nearly free txs via the Lightning Network).
- mhluongo 10y agoErm, targeted at? You mean he would have, what, written it in Chinese? Note he said most businesses are looking for Segwit activation + a hard fork blocksize increase (ours included). The "Chinese miners" have expressed that desire as well. Segwit is stalling because it's not what the market is asking for.
- hnolable 10y agoSegwit requires 95% of miners to activate. Currently about 75% of hash power is controlled by a group of chinese miners/pools. This is about the % of hashing power that is missing for Segwit to activate.
- mhluongo 10y agoAware of how Segwit activation works, thanks. I'm speaking to the miners' motivations. They've been asking for a simple blocksize increase for quite some time. See the HK agreement if you don't get the politics.
- hnolable 10y agoYes that's the issue here, the miners are playing politics by trying to flex their power. But no one is willing to play petty games. There's an obvious win for everyone sitting on the table ready to go. Political games will be ignored.
- mhluongo 10y agoThe Core devs signed an agreement with these miners a year ago in Hong Kong, and the agreement was broken. Here are the consequences. Clearly, politics won't be ignored- or Segwit would be on track for activation.
- Proven 10y agoMost people are for larger blocks. But since last fall the real problem is few high profile reactionaries (and of course miners) working against SegWit adoption. Had SegWit been voted in we would already be discussing larger block size. Instead, there is nothing going on. I predict the larger block reactionaries will fold next month once they realize they need to vote for SegWit if they want to be taken seriously.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- mhluongo 10y agoAppreciate the pragmatic, user-focused view. There's rarely empathy for new users in this space, and it's refreshing.
- ac29 10y agoThis article completely ignores the block reward -- the real cost per transaction is more like $7 [0]. The blocksize really needs to change too, last time I did a bitcoin transaction, every recent block was 95%+ full. Its an arbitrary limit, but its contentious and political to change. It really made me want to avoid Bitcoin in the future. [0]https://blockchain.info/charts/cost-per-transaction https://blockchain.info/charts/cost-per-transaction
- pmorici 10y agoThe whole point of the block reward is to subsidize the network until transaction volume can grow to an equilibrium point where the network can be supported on fees alone. The fact that transaction volume is capped by the block size is troubling because it won't be able to grow to that equilibrium point.
- checksauce 10y agoAs the value of Bitcoin grows, transaction cost grows relative to other currencies. Really transaction costs in strictly btc/byte have decreased. Pretty much everyone agrees the block size will need to grow at some point, including core devs. It is the current proposed method of introducing this change (via hardfork) that is questioned and scrutinized.
- pmorici 10y agoThere is at least one prominent core dev that recently seriously proposed _decreasing_ the block size to 1/3rd of what it is currently. The problem is that the block size needed to be increased last year. Agreeing that it needs to be increased at some unspecified point in the future minus any specifics is just a stalling tactic.
- checksauce 10y agoYes some devs believe there is centralization pressure of mining blocks caused by the propogation delay of 1MB blocks. Further increasing the size of blocks would thus increase centralization pressure. Changing any number of variables leads to emergent properties which change mining behaviors. Game theory needs to be considered before tweaking the consensus protocols of Bitcoin. The open source nature of Bitcoin allows for many opinions and critisms and hopefully many more proposals for change in the future.
- danbruc 10y agoAnd if you look at hardware, energy and all the other costs, then you probably still end up in the $5 to $10 range as true costs per transaction. But this will not become fully visible until the block reward becomes negligible or the demand for new coins becomes essentially zero so that the deflation becomes visible.
- pmorici 10y agoIf what you say is true then that would imply that miners are losing money. I don't think that is the case. Total network hash rate has strong growth. People don't normally invest huge sums to turn a loss.
- danbruc 10y agoThey are not losing money, they get the block reward to sell. This in turn makes all Bitcoin users pay indirectly due to deflation but that is currently not visible because there is money flowing into the system. But you can just do the math for yourself - the network hash rate is currently 3,160 petahash per second, 300,000 transactions are processed per day, an AntMiner S9 - the most efficient currently available miner as far as I can tell - consumes 98 joules per terahash and you can buy electricity for 5 cents per kilowatt-hour. With this numbers you end up at 1.24 Dollar per transaction and that is as optimistic as it gets when looking at electricity costs. Then add costs for hardware, rent, cooling, labor, profits, ...
- pmorici 10y agoAh, you mean if you divide the block reward by transactions per block. Yeah in that case it's about $7 per transaction right now. That is why we need to increase on-chain transactions so that those fixed per block costs are amortized over a larger number of transactions.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- Animats 10y agoThat's just the transaction fee paid to miners. You also have to consider the currency conversion cost of getting into and out of Bitcoin. Most sellers use Coinbase to immediately get out of Bitcoin. There's also a volatility risk.
- crocodileJS 10y agoThe "average" cost of a Bitcoin transaction is just that, the average. It's not (part of) the true cost. The "true" cost is specific to the transaction. The last time I sent around some Bitcoin, it was around 20$ worth and the fee was whatever the client recommended me. It didn't amount to anything near the average. Why would I care about the average?
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- juskrey 10y agoPretty funny to see that SEPA money transfer from Kraken to EU bank account costs just €0.09 for any amount. Arrival is guaranteed (though can be late too of course). So the cheapness of bitcoin and high cost of modern fiat transactions are both overstated.
- Laforet 10y agoThe same way Uber was/is cheaper than Taxi, the cost is subsidised by someone else (Uber's investors, or in this case miners and speculators of Bitcoin)
- juskrey 10y agoI don't think physical automatic wire transaction cost is more expensive than SMS. High transfer/transaction fees in most banks are, on contrary, are subsidizing losses from other risky activities.
- mhluongo 10y agoIn eg the US, a domestic wire will cost you $30. In the US and EU I believe, credit card fees are much worse (1.5-3%). If paying internationally cross-currency, you'll often lose quite a bit in the exchange. Though I see that you said "modern fiat transactions", so maybe payments in the US don't count :)
- zump 10y agoWhat they did to Mike Hearn was a disgrace.
- SwellJoe 10y agoWho is "they" and what did they do to Mike Hearn? (I know Hearn left the Bitcoin community and pronounced it a failed experiment, and I know there was some harsh criticism for that assertion...but, did it go beyond that?)
- zump 10y agoBitcoin core team. Ostracized him for forking BitcoinXT, impugned his reputation, etc.
- sigi45 10y agoOne point which your post/this post is missing: Transaction fee = power consumption + profit. Bitcoin fee has to hit a fee amount which has less eco impact than a normal banking system.