4 ms·
Barney Frank: here's how to not waste your time pressuring lawmakers
- frgtpsswrdlame 10y agoNo one wants to be blasted with Barney's nosehairs as soon as they open a page, come on.
- dano 10y agotl;dr 1. Make sure you’re registered to vote — lawmakers check. 2. Lawmakers don’t care about people outside of their district. 3. Your signature — physical or electronic — on a mass petition will mean little. 4. The communication must be individual. Email, Letter, Phone call. 5. Know where your representative stands. 6. Communicate — even if you and your representative disagree. 7. Say “thank you" - to reinforce the behavior you want 8. Enlist the help of friends in other districts. - they write their own reps
- mercer 10y ago> 4. The communication must be individual. Email, Letter, Phone call. I've heard that calling is highly preferable to emails at least (and perhaps letters), because they have to answer calls but can do with automatic replies to emails (and relegate your message to 'cylindrical storage'). Can anyone confirm/deny that?
- tptacek 10y agoMy understanding, from a couple of different D staffers, one of which is "firsthand" (if Facebook threads count), is that email does not count even a little bit. I also don't believe voicemail counts, or if it does, it doesn't count consistently. The basic atom of political influence seems to be the live human phone call; anything less obnoxious is ignored.
- trendia 10y agoStrangely, he forgot to mention: 9. Donate lots of money. A study found members of Congress are way more likely to meet with you if you've paid them [0]. > "The offices who just thought they were being asked to meet with normal constituents, we almost never got a meeting with a member of Congress, or a chief of staff or a legislative director — the most powerful people in congressional offices," says Broockman. "On the other hand, when we reveal that the attendees were donors, they were more than three times as likely to get those meetings." [0] http://www.npr.org/2014/03/26/294361018/how-to-meet-your-congressman http://www.npr.org/2014/03/26/294361018/how-to-meet-your-con...
- wheelerwj 10y agoits really surprising that he forgot that because he nailed the other main ways to force change: Be thankful and only talk to people who represent you (no one).
- tptacek 10y agoI think point (1) is there not because it matters but because Barney Frank wants you to be registered to vote. Having made a _bunch_ of calls over the past few weeks, and having made some first- and second- hand contacts with staffers: I don't believe they really check anything at all, at least not on issues that lots of people are calling them about. The impression I have is that on big-ticket issues, they're just taking a yes/no tally of calls and letters, and that's it.
- Agustus 10y agoWhen you made your phone calls, did you call from a phone in the area code they represented? Did they ask for your zip code?
- tptacek 10y agoI called my IL reps/sens at their main DC office using my 312 cell phone. I suppose it's possible they look at caller ID, but it seems unlikely, since so many Chicago residents have non-Illinois numbers. Nobody ever asked for my zip code, although I introduced myself as a voter from Oak Park, so maybe that sufficed. I think there is literally no chance whatsoever that your reps are somehow checking whether you're registered to vote. They barely have time to make a tally mark for your position.
- fnord123 10y agoSurely they can't be stupid enough to look at the area code using caller ID. People living abroad are registered with the district where they last lived in the US so of course they will be calling from elsewhere. And many people work in a different county than they live.
- Agustus 10y agoI asked because I am trying to gauge the user experience that he/she had in calling their representatives versus mine. Mine spent a considerable amount of time with me and asked my zip code. For the representatives aide to not ask for any identifying information led to my asking the area code question, the person receiving the call may have used it as a crib to put them as within the representatives area.
- Agustus 10y ago#5 is great and should be amended to include understanding what interests the representative has in taking a particular stand. Barney Frank is the same guy who was actively fighting (1) against George W. Bush's initiative to tighten up lending requirements ahead of the Great Recession; Barney Frank was against it due in part to then boyfriend, who he helped get a job, being on the executive committee (2). Getting him to change his opinion would have been night impossible. 1. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=iW5qKYfqALE https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=iW5qKYfqALE 2. http://www.foxnews.com/politics/2011/05/26/rep-frank-admits-helping-ex-lover-land-job-fannie-mae.html http://www.foxnews.com/politics/2011/05/26/rep-frank-admits-... I know it is Fox News, but only quick-link I can find to support my claims.
- ndaiger 10y agoThat's a specious argument. You linked to short, mild a speech on the House floor from 2005 encouraging primary home-ownership as a means of investing, and a Fox News report about responding positively to a question about hiring a qualified ex-lover for an entry-level job 14 years prior to that speech. Neither has anything to do with the advice or article.
- masonic 10y agoIt wasn't just his boyfriend; it was a male prostitute operating from Frank's own house per the Washington Post[0]. [0] http://www.washingtonpost.com/wp-srv/politics/special/clinton/stories/frank121898.htm http://www.washingtonpost.com/wp-srv/politics/special/clinto...
- JSeymourATL 10y agoSome additional perspective from a Congressional Staffer > https://twitter.com/i/moments/798297193559904258?lang=en https://twitter.com/i/moments/798297193559904258?lang=en
- colinbartlett 10y agoThis is interesting content, but the format is atrocious. How is Twitter still relevant when posts like this must be made one sentence at a time?
- inetknght 10y agobecause teens and young adults these days don't care to read more than a few words and always want the tl;dr. If there's no tl;dr, they just ignore it and stay in their own precious ivory tower intellectual world where nothing goes wrong, people _always_ respect each other, and you definitely never have to worry about money
- LyalinDotCom 10y agoThanks for linking also a great read!
- coldcode 10y agoI wonder if this current environment is anything like a previous time regarding influence of a voter. For example the vote on Davos seems to have been more influenced by nearly $!M than any number of communications. For my own state Rubio got $100,000 in contributions to ignore what we in the state care about.
- sidlls 10y agoThe most important way to not waste time "pressuring" lawmakers is this: have money, connections, and influence over those connections. None of the items on that list comes even close to that one.
- mfringel 10y agoIt's true that money, connections, and influence will win against an unorganized electorate. The equation changes significantly if there's a coordinated effort by voters.
- sidlls 10y agoThat's a fairly broad statement and entirely dependent on the context. I'm struggling to think of an example in recent history where "a coordinated effort by voters" got some meaningful traction in the sense of this article. I'm far from omniscient, though, so this could very well be a huge blind spot in my own news information maintenance.